6 ms·
It's not even so much about protecting the secret sauce as protecting user data. Every tool interfacing to the Google backend is a potential attack vector. When
by shadowgovt 6y ago
It's not even so much about protecting the secret sauce as protecting user data. Every tool interfacing to the Google backend is a potential attack vector. When the time comes that nobody's willing to bear the cost to keep it updated as the core infrastructure changes, the product dies.
In a world where Google is split up, that'll still be true; it'll look more like "Google CoreCloud has just changed API foo to protect against backflooper attacks; all users must change by Q4 2022." And spin-offs that can't afford the change will kill features or products.
In fact, in a world where individual pieces of Alphabet are required to sink or swim based on their own profitability, I expect more products dead, not fewer. Ads pays for search. Who pays for search in a world where the government has stepped in and divested ads and search from each other?
- Retric 6y agoPresumably spinoffs would end up with their own copy of all software infrastructure, which would evolve independently at that point.
- shadowgovt 6y agoI'm not sure that's presumable. It sounds like a better way to do things in the short run (in the long run, there's a net loss from the loss of the cross-pollination benefits of security and best-practice on the backend that Google enjoys now).
- Nasrudith 6y agoIt depends on how stupid the regulators are - the one with the google name will win. Seriously people - domain names and awareness matter ans you can't just partition websites to regions with an international web.
- scarface74 6y agoWe already know how incapable the regulators are. 20 years after they went after MS for their dominance in personal computer operating systems, productivity software and browsers, MS is still dominant in two and the third doesn’t matter to anyone except for Google. MS had the highest market cap in the US in 2000. As of today it is #3. The government had a monopoly suit against IBM in 1969 and finally withdrew it in 1983 and nothing came of it. People in tech have been wanting the government to go after Big Tech for years. Four of the CEOs show up for Congressional hearings and then the government goes after...TikTok and WeChat instead.
- dylan604 6y ago>People in tech have been wanting the government to go after Big Tech for years. Four of the CEOs show up for Congressional hearings and then the government goes after...TikTok and WeChat instead. The Big4 are US based companies. WeChat & TikTok are foreign owned companies, and that country is currently a safe play to bash. The gov't can go after the low hanging fruit so they can have something point at to say they are doing something about evil tech.
- int_19h 6y agoA big part of it is that trust busting in US is just not what it used to be, since getting borked back in late 1970s: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Antitrust_Paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Antitrust_Paradox
- derefr 6y ago> Who pays for search in a world where the government has stepped in and divested ads and search from each other? Since most of the revenue from Google's ads are from ads on search, presumably the broken-up ads company would be buying the ad space on the broken-up search company's SERPs. All the search company's revenue would still come from the ads company.
- shadowgovt 6y agoIs most of Google's ad revenue from ads on search? They have a huge display ads business also.
- kube-system 6y agoIt's clearly enough revenue to support the existence of search today.
- jefftk 6y agohttps://abc.xyz/investor/static/pdf/2020Q2_alphabet_earnings_release.pdf https://abc.xyz/investor/static/pdf/2020Q2_alphabet_earnings... breaks advertising into: "Google Search & other", "YouTube ads", and "Google Network Members' properties". My understanding is the latter is the display ads business, and you can see that it is pretty small, relatively. (Disclosure: I work in Google's display ads business)
- johannes1234321 6y agoI guess the first category is maps and Gmail and other such offerings. (Still plausible to me that search is the primary driver there)
- jacquesm 6y agoThat's why we originally had an IETF and RFC's were publicly commented on and why standards are supposed to be company agnostic. The whole proprietary-APIs-over-HTTP was a giant step back. Before we did that interop between internet based applications was far more common and supported. Now every company treats 'their users' as their own private little walled garden when before 'your users' were not so much cows to milk as they were users you exposed services to at the protocol level. We have been able to move very fast and very far because of this shortcut but the price is a very high one and I'm not so sure if in the longer term we will end up with an advantage.
- shadowgovt 6y agoI'm not convinced, though there are, obviously, advantages to RFCs and IETF. The primary disadvantage is speed. A private corporation innovating on its full stack can come up with a faster and more secure HTTP alternative for their use case in the time it takes the RFC process to get up in the morning and find its shoes. Google has a streamed cloud gaming service running in its web browser right now; how long would it take the RFC process to kick out the protocols necessary to enable that?
- nitrogen 6y agoThere are already RFCs for realtime streaming of data. Also IIUC the RFC process often starts with a draft based on am existing implementation.
- owowow 6y agoOnLive was streaming games years before Google entered the space, there isn't much novelty in what Stadia has done.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoThe novelty will be if it's profitable / something people want.
- cat199 6y ago
- pdonis 6y ago> Who pays for search If search is of value to you, the user, wouldn't you, the user, be willing to pay for it?
- sukilot 6y agoI'm willing to pay $5/mo Much of India will pay $1/mo Most people will pay $.1/month What will the price be?
- sz4kerto 6y agoPricing would be based on value. Someone who's willing to pay X is more valuable than someone who's only willing to pay 0.1X, so naturally the former should pay more.
- pdonis 6y ago> What will the price be? If you allow Google/Alphabet to practice price discrimination, it will charge customers in richer countries more. You and I would pay $5/month, much of India would pay $1/month, and people who can only afford $.1/month would pay that. If you insist that the price be uniform over all users, then it has to be $.1/month, or whatever the lowest common denominator is. Of course in that scenario it's much harder to get to a revenue number that is anywhere close to Alphabet's current revenue.
- jonas21 6y agoThe problem is that even if every Google user on the planet paid $5/month, it would maybe just barely match their current revenue.
- pdonis 6y agoYou'd need something over 3 billion users at that rate to match Google's current revenue (about $16 billion a month). Google currently has about 2 billion. However, Google's current revenue pays for a lot more than just search. It doesn't seem unreasonable to me that search could pay for itself with revenue from users instead of ads.
- cat199 6y ago> Who pays for search who says that 'search' has to be a consolidated system that needs to be paid for?
- shadowgovt 6y agoIt's a hell of a lot more convenient as one. Not really thrilled about going back to the days of a fragmented web where webcrawler would give you some results, lycos some others, altavista yet a third batch...
- gvjddbnvdrbv 6y agoSounds great. These days we only get the Google or the MS batches of results.
- shadowgovt 6y ago... which cover five nines of use case. A fragmented ecosystem would give us three to five sites to search that still cover only five nines of the use case, based on past experience.
- withinboredom 6y agoOh but the things you discover! I didn’t learn BASIC by searching for it. I learned it because someone stuck a manual in the young adult section at my library by accident and I was curious...