6 ms·
China made a big mistake in being too reliant on TSMC, etc. or maybe it did not have the capacity to go after too many targets. Or maybe it simply did not think
by mytailorisrich 6y ago
China made a big mistake in being too reliant on TSMC, etc. or maybe it did not have the capacity to go after too many targets. Or maybe it simply did not think it could be a problem.
They are quick to learn and adapt, though, not least when the Chinese state throws its whole weight behind something, so I'm thinking that after this initial shock, in a few years the result will be a decline of the relative importance of the Taiwanese semi industry because mainland China will have its own, with all the potential strategic consequences that this might mean.
- FooBarWidget 6y agoI don't think it's a mistake. It's more that they don't have a choice. There are very few (maybe even only one?) foundries in the world with advanced processes. Building a foundry is not trivial. For how long has Intel stuck with 14nm now? The Dutch ASML lithography machine is one of the most advanced machines in the world, and it's pretty much the only one of its kind. China has been investing heavily in domestic foundries for years now, but it takes time.
- samfisher83 6y agoThis is reason US needs to ensure that a US company can make the latest and greatest technology. You never know what geopolitical issue might cut your supply off.
- xster 6y agoI think it's just greed and poor risk management. Up until recently, china couldn't even manufacture ball point pens (which I think only 2 companies in the world produced). There's no money to be made at the bottom of the inverted tech pyramid. They rather put their energy in buying ball point pens and using those pens to write stuff that will in the short term make them more money on to of a foundation of sand. Similarly all of the investment from giants like Alibaba etc went into developing e-commerce on top of a tech foundation of sand
- ulfw 6y agoAnd who do you think the US of A is reliant on?
- mytailorisrich 6y agoThe US are also reliant on TSMC but since Taiwan is reliant on the US that's fine. As we can see the US can impose their will on them.
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoAnd will “will” is the US imposing on Taiwan? Keeping it from being annexed by China?
- FooBarWidget 6y agoWell for one, giving TSMC the ultimatum that either they stop doing business with Huawei, or stop doing business with the entirety of the US. This happened just a few months ago. And here I thought US would like to recognize Taiwan as an independent country. But then it goes ahead and tells a Taiwanese company that they can't make their own decisions on who to do business with?
- simonblack 6y agoAs we can see the US can impose their will on them. You can have all the will in the world, but that is not necessarily going to win out every time. "Oops, looks like there's a bad fire in that Taiwanese fab. Pity about that. They'll be out of production for years." By then of course, that fab would have been so obsolete that it's really not worth fixing.
- paulsutter 6y agoThis is super naive. China has a huge military, is much closer to RoC, and has absolute popular support that RoC is already a province of China. Whereas the US can barely muster popular support for wearing masks. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2020/08/06/china-deploys-amphibious-weapons-eastern-coast-tensions-taiwan/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2020/08/06/china-deploys-am...
- samfisher83 6y agoWhen you have a billion people + unlimited funds + some industrial espionage I am sure china will get their chip manufacturing industry built up quickly.
- parsimo2010 6y agoFor very technical things, having the information is not the same as having the ability to manufacture. Some industries don't lend themselves to catching up rapidly, you have to go through all the mistakes yourself. I think semiconductors is one of those industries. An example (unrelated to semiconductors) is China's failure to manufacture a decent jet engine even though they've been trying for 30 years. It turns out that the metallurgy required for a jet engine is more complicated than what is needed for household appliances. They aren't even dealing with incomplete stolen information, they have a license from Russia and the full technical information and still can't do it (although Russia isn't sharing their most modern designs, but China still struggles to make an engine with 1980's tech).
- mercer 6y agoI'd love to hear more elaboration on that, or a link to an article. As someone way out of my depth it seems almost silly that they wouldn't be able to figure that out through a combination of throwing expertise and money at it and spycraft.
- DiogenesKynikos 6y agoRelated: China can finally manufacture ballpoint pens. https://www.bbc.com/news/business-38566114 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-38566114
- bbarnett 6y agoIt really bothers me, how many (I assume) PRC loyalists are on here. This BBC article is valid, and on topic to this thread, and elaborates on how "just making stuff" isn't simple. Why else would this be a vote down, other than puppets of the PRC?
- Mindwipe 6y agoI think the more worrying thing is what happens to the West if, when it has built it's own fab capacity (which is much easier said than done, but China will throw enormous resource at it because it has to), China decides to destabilise Taiwan's semiconductor industry. Western nations would be smart to try and decentralise some of that production capacity (also easier said than done) before that could come to be, but does anyone think the Western nations current or foreseeable leadership really have the strategic foresight to do so?
- mytailorisrich 6y agoYes, that's what I meant by 'strategic consequences', including in case of a cross-straight conflict. At the moment it is in everyone's interest that Taiwan's foundries stay up and running. But in the future, in case of a hypothetical conflict it might even be in the mainland's interest to bomb them and create havoc for Western companies.
- Mindwipe 6y agoIt might. I suspect we'll see a large amount of soft power disruptions first which would still make Taiwan's life fairly miserable.
- mschuster91 6y ago> Western nations would be smart to try and decentralise some of that production capacity (also easier said than done) before that could come to be, but does anyone think the Western nations current or foreseeable leadership really have the strategic foresight to do so? TSMC actually plans to set up shop in Arizona: https://www.tsmc.com/tsmcdotcom/PRListingNewsArchivesAction.do?action=detail&newsid=THGOANPGTH&language=E https://www.tsmc.com/tsmcdotcom/PRListingNewsArchivesAction....
- FooBarWidget 6y agoOnly time will tell whether that shop is valuable. The only reason they started doing that was because the US pressured them into it — it wasn't for economic reasons.
- fakeslimshady 6y agoThe world is reliant on TSMC even Intel is capitulating and going to use TSMC
- Steltek 6y agoThe West has been unwilling to use its economic levers to preserve competition and a healthy market. China has no problem using state control and doesn't care much for fair competition either. The West isn't doomed but we're not in a very defensible position either.
- shankysingh 6y agoI don't have enough knowledge of chip's logistics so my less informed 2 cents would be, thinking from a business perspective, if eventual dominance of chip supply-chain was in cards, Chinese businesses would have had done it regardless of ban existed or not. So, this ban gives Taiwan and US businesses some breathing space to keep that lead. How its leveraged, is upto the governments and business's .
- mytailorisrich 6y agoThis ban does not help Taiwanese businesses. Quite the opposite.
- londons_explore 6y agoI'm sure they were given a decent financial incentive to go along with this ban. Taiwan is an ally after all, if you annoy their companies with far overreaching targeted international rules, and don't compensate them, there are going to be political costs. I would guess the new TSMC facility in the US is part of this compensation - they'll probably be receiving very favourable tax treatment for everything manufactured there.
- coreblocks 6y agoWell the reason TSMC gave up Huawei so easily was because they knew they would have no trouble filling orders from AMD, NVIDIA, Xilinx and now Intel apparently.
- dirtyid 6y agoLook up Fujian Jinhua plant 2018. Truth is US has been sanctioning and using CFIUS to undermine Chinese IC for a while now. Many blocked acquisitions under Obama. Relationship was just less acrimonious and less public. I suspect even Nvidia's ARM ambitions is part of plan to undermine Chinese IC efforts. Like how William Barr floated idea to get CISCO to buy controlling share in SE or Nokia to rival Huawei 5G. That said, TSMC is too successful for it's own good. Once their Arizona plant opens on US tax dime, Taiwan will loose security guarantor. I suspect they'll delay for as long as they can. SMIC is basically sufficient to make IC for Chinese military use in any case. The main, and huge problem, is being commercially competitive.
- Steltek 6y agoInteresting theory re Arizona meaning Taiwan loses its advantage. Although no one can ascribe too much (or really any) foresight to the current US admin, I have to imagine there's a domino theory w.r.t. to Taiwan and the SCS region. Ceding China's control (military, economic, or otherwise) of Taiwan would panic every other independent nation in the region into striking a good deal with China to hopefully maintain their autonomy. Ugh. The West has had the tail wagging the dog for so long. Arrogant transnational corporations and the rich think they can control China like everything else. It's the same arrogance on display with coronavirus: they play by very different rules and don't care who you are.
- dirtyid 6y agoAt least with semi there's continuity. And some of the China-hawks in the admin, though cray cray and warmongering, are also pragmatic. i.e. I think Trump banned TikTok out of spite, but probably Pompeo banned WeChat... as if Trump knows what WeChat is. And probably other hawks pushed for TikTok acquisition, and Trump poison pilled with with extortion to US treasury. A lot of the escalations are... unprecedented, kind of insane, but also calibrated enough that China can tit-for-tat. Whereas Trump would just be insane. By all accounts TSMC didn't want to open plant in US. They were denying it for months / weeks / days before. And TSMC has invested so much capex in new Taiwan plants that it makes no fiscal sense for them to open low capacity plant in US unless heavily subsidized, and US wouldn't subsidize unless it was for MIC. As for Taiwan's future, really depends on how election goes. I'm skeptical China will allow TSMC / Taiwan to cooperate with US unfettered in semi. Right now there's mediatek buffering Huawei. And other Chinese brands can still sell phones with qualcomm. But if US manage to coerce all Taiwanese semi from working with China... well glitter bombs are going to blow up in Taiwanese fabs before real bombs. I think it's semi is a much more dangerous situation than most people realize. If Trumps over November, there's a few years before Arizonal TSMC comes online to form a useful Chinese semi containment strategy. Or TSMC will delay the play until after Trump term 2. Otherwise, stock up on graphics cards now.
- chvid 6y agoIt has been a potential threat to China for a decade and they have invested massively to counter it.
- chlee 6y agoThe chinese govt is indeed throwing their weight behind developing a local semiconductor industry capable of rivaling TSMC. They are making heavy investment in SMIC for example. However, at the same time, unfortunately the Chinese government doesn't play fair, and they are ramping up state sponsored industry espionage and hacking of American and Taiwanese semi-conductor firms to speed up the process. This best describes China's perspective towards "technology acquisition" “They want technology by hook or by crook. They want it now. The spy game has always been a gentleman’s game, but China has taken the gloves off,” said John Bennett, the special agent in charge of the FBI’s San Francisco office, which battles economic spies targeting Silicon Valley. “They don’t care if they get caught or if people go to jail. As long as it justifies their ends, they are not going to stop.” See: https://www.wired.com/story/chinese-hackers-taiwan-semiconductor-industry-skeleton-key/ https://www.wired.com/story/chinese-hackers-taiwan-semicondu... https://www.reuters.com/article/us-basf-espionage/basf-workers-in-taiwan-suspected-of-leaking-company-secrets-idUSKCN1P10WO https://www.reuters.com/article/us-basf-espionage/basf-worke... https://www.wsj.com/articles/taiwans-technology-secrets-come-under-assault-from-china-1530468440 https://www.wsj.com/articles/taiwans-technology-secrets-come... https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2019/08/inside-us-china-espionage-war/595747/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2019/08/inside-... https://www.latimes.com/politics/la-na-pol-china-economic-espionage-20181116-story.html https://www.latimes.com/politics/la-na-pol-china-economic-es... https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/prc-state-owned-company-taiwan-company-and-three-individuals-charged-economic-espionage https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/prc-state-owned-company-taiwa...
- greatjack613 6y ago+1 to this, China has never made anything real themselves. It is all stolen property from countries who actually play fair. Until the general U.S population realizes that china's end goal is to eat them alive and unanimously supports putting china in its place, nothing will change and by then I fear it will be to late.
- beagle3 6y agoThe assumption that any country, especially the successful ones, plays “fair” is ludicrous. IIRC the CIA (or was it NSA?) was giving state-gathered intel to American arms And aerospace manufacturers in the 1980s so that they could outbid European rivals. The Chinese might be playing by different rules than those “established” over the last few decades by the west; but no one is playing “fair”.
- Nokinside 6y agoHuawei will replace Kirin with other chips manufactured in TSMC fabs (MediaTek for example). Huawei is forbidden using their own chip designs if there is come US based IP components, not from buying TSMC manufactured chips.