22 ms·
Abolish the Police? Survivors of the Chaos in Seattle Aren’t So Sure
- collyw 6y agoWas anyone surprised by this? Defund / Abolish the police sound like the stupidest ideas ever.
- loopz 6y agoIt needs to be replaced with a credible alternative.
- sascha_sl 6y agoDefund is not actually a bad idea. The police are tasked with handling the fallout of failing or non-existent social systems and have been scaled respectively - in fact police funding is growing every year, and not insubstantially. If you work in tech you should know what happens if you transfer too many responsibilities to one bloated team. These funds would be better invested in actual support systems. Homeless shelters. Drug rehabilitation. Fixing subpar education funding in poor school districts.
- csilverman 6y agoYeah, but calling it "defund" sounds a lot like "no more police, anywhere". I think a lot of the insanity here could have been avoided if this was presented as what it was intended to be—a reallocation of resources based on a desire to more effectively address deep-seated problems that make society worse for everyone—and not as, you know, anarchy.
- sascha_sl 6y agoIf you were making that argument about "abolish", I'd agree, but defund? I guess you'd need to know the massive funding increases the police has gotten over the past 20 years. Even abolish acknowledges there needs to be some form of community policing, it's just that the current model is militaristic, has little accountability, incentivizes the wrong things (arrest quotas) and (re-)hires the wrong people. I don't think anarchy is what you think it is. It wrongfully has picked up the entire Mad Max vibe. Any Chomsky talk on anarchism or the book of the same name ("On Anarchism") are a bit more nuanced introductions. Anarchism and police are "natural enemies" because anarchists believe the power police hold right now is unproportionate and unjustifiable. See also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24025920 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24025920
- dorian-graph 6y ago> Abolish the police What does this mean to you?
- commandlinefan 6y agoWhat does "abolish" mean, you mean? The 13th amendment to the U.S. constitution "abolished" slavery. It means get rid of completely, and make sure it never comes back.
- royroyroys 6y agowhat about the exception for prison labor which many consider to be 'modern slavery'?
- csilverman 6y agoTough question actually, because I know what it is intended to mean, and I also know what a lot of its most passionate devotees want it to mean. I didn't disagree with any of the thinking behind it: shifting more funding and responsibility to social support/health professionals, and focusing more on the conditions that spawn crime rather than just stamping it out as it shows up. Seems like the difference between actually fixing the holes in your house vs. putting all your money into duct tape and basins. The first step towards fixing a broken system is identifying the root causes. But there's that, and there's the vast majority of people I know who say every cop is an evil fascist and society would be better with no law enforcement at all. Given how many people think—and want—"abolish the police" to mean abolition in the most literal sense, it is hard to look past that definition, even if it's not the intended one. It's simple: Radicalism breeds radicalism. I don't like those redneck survivalist guys with all the guns either, but it's getting a lot harder to tell them their doomsday fantasies are stupid when so many on the left sound like they consider CHOP to be a blueprint for a better society.
- loco5niner 6y agoIt doesn't matter what it means "to me". It matters what it means. Abolish: verb - formally put an end to (a system, practice, or institution).
- blueline 6y agoeverything must be so obvious when you’re super smart and have all the answers
- happytoexplain 6y agoI know you may be unwilling to entertain the opposite point of view, but it doesn't necessarily sound like a "stupid idea" to friends/families/cultures who have lost members to murder by police (at varying points on the scale from negligence to depraved heart to purposeful to premeditated), especially in the case for mere "defunding", which is thoughtless to call a "stupid idea" out of hand, since the argument that some police have too much firepower is one that can be formed reasonably, and not just a "stupid idea" to be dismissed without engaging. Also, most victims don't even go as far as literal and unqualified abolishment, and say they want complete reform. But even the ones desperate enough to call for abolishment, which I find hard to blame them for, are usually talking about specific extremely corrupt and violent jurisdictions, and further, they admit that something must come after - abolish "the current" police in "some" places, before they kill again, and replace them. And of course, I'm sure there are some who have been driven to want only to "abolish police" without further qualification, and you are encouraged to engage them respectfully and explain that it's unrealistic despite their emotional suffering and outrage, and engage them in the context of the more fleshed-out options I've listed above. Don't just call it a "stupid idea". That doesn't belong on HN.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throwaway29102 6y agoReforming policing and law enforcement is not a stupid idea, but the “Defund the police” messaging shuts down thoughtful conversation and alienates allies.
- dleslie 6y agoAs an outsider looking in, it seems to me like reducing the scope of responsibility , and increasing accountability, of your police forces would be a boon to public safety.
- andrew_ 6y agoIt really should. But in a highly polarized, incredibly litigious society like the US, that would likely lead to more trench-digging, and sadly the opposite of an increase to public safety.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoObviously the details would be contentions but I think reducing the scope of policing in abstract is widely supported across America. You'd be hard pressed to find someone who can't think of an entire category of behavior the government is currently in, and should not be, in the business of micromanaging with violence. But when people say "abolish the police" they do not come across as meaning "reduce the scope of policing in a careful manner" to a sizeable fraction of the other people in the country.
- happytoexplain 6y ago>But when people say "abolish the police" they do not come across as meaning "reduce the scope of policing". Some people, sure, but that's understandable given their extremely dire situation. Regardless, in my experience, most people do in fact flesh out reasonable ideas while using the phrase. Further, by far most "phrases" I've heard in person are of the "defund/reform" variety. But of course "abolishment" gets disproportionate attention, and there's always the trap of just listening to news sources and online forums where the phrase "abolish the police" is quoted with no chance given to the people for more context.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoI agree that the ideas put forth are generally reasonable but a national political slogan shouldn't require "but wait I don't mean that in the literal sense" explanation. You can't have a catch phrase and then complain when it's taken literally. A phrase like that was a marketing disaster waiting to happen.
- lostapathy 6y agoIt's mostly terrible messaging. Defund and Abolish are both absolute terms (i.e., people try to defund planned parenthood, and we abolished slavery) but, for the most part, what's being asked for is just to scale back the police and their funding.
- happytoexplain 6y agoI agree it's unfortunate. "Defund", though, I can defend as colloquially non-absolute. Literally it means "remove all funds", but people often use it to mean "reduce funds", I've found. Edit: Of course, that's not to say there are no people using it absolutely in this case.
- djaque 6y agoYou're falling for a strawman. Spend some time looking at the nuanced proposals for policing reform that go by the name "defund the police" and I am guessing that you agree with them a lot more than you think you do.
- collyw 6y agoHaving seen the bodycam footage from the police that has emerged recently, I think everyone supporting BLM have been falling for a strawman. George Floyd appears to be high as a kite, does practically nothing the police ask him to. The police appear to be pretty reasonable.
- djaque 6y agoEight minutes and fourty six seconds. There is no excuse for holding your knee on a person's neck for eight minutes and fourty six seconds. There is no excuse for doing it after he says that he can't breathe. There is no excuse for doing it after those around you tell you to cut it out. There is especially no excuse for continuing to do it for minutes after he became motionless. Honestly, I'm not sure how else to explain to you that you should care about other human lives even when those people are high or not in the best place in life. George Floyd was murdered by a police officer pinning him in a choke hold for eight minutes and fourty six seconds and "he did drugs" or "he didn't listen to the police" is not a sane explanation. I'm really not sure what else to tell you when you believe that it's "reasonable" for the police to choke a man to death for eight minutes and fourty six seconds because he was "high as a kite".
- spaetzleesser 6y agoI really hate that in typical US manner this issue gets pushed to the extreme so in the end a reasonable discussion can’t be had but it’s only a fight with everybody digging in and not listening to each other. Abolishing the police was always nonsense but there are plenty of areas where police is overused and too aggressive. In my view there shouldn’t be police in schools or hospitals. The drug war causes a lot of unnecessary arrests and aggravation with a lot of neighborhoods. Bad cops often stay in the force without consequences for clearly bad behavior. Cops don’t have enough training so they aren’t prepared for difficult situation . The list goes on and on. Addressing these issues would be good for cops, citizens and also public budgets. But instead the country chooses to have this stupid fight where the interested parties spend a lot of time distorting other views. Reminds me of the typical healthcare discussions. It’s very sad.
- mywittyname 6y agoIssues have to get pushed to the extreme because politicians drag their heels otherwise. Corruption is the best business to be in. Police departments have no interest in oversight, beyond the amount necessary for leadership to protect their positions of power. And Police Unions are generally very powerful and dominate local politics.
- moomin 6y agoI think the thing you're missing here is that the distortion (see the use of the word abolish here, the proposal is defunding) is completely deliberate. This divide didn't happen by accident, it's the product of decades of deliberate political choices.
- spaetzleesser 6y agoTotally that this is manufactured and a lot of people see problems only as something that’s related to winning an election. Still a sad state of affairs.
- bobbygoodlatte 6y agoSocial media algorithms amplify the most engaging content, and extreme versions of political statements are very engaging. I don't think it takes deliberate messaging tactics by one side or another for our current political climate to emerge.
- dorian-graph 6y ago> “Seattle’s unprecedented decision to abandon and close off an entire city neighborhood, leaving it unchecked by the police, unserved by fire and emergency health services, and inaccessible to the public” Is this what people advocating for abolish the police are advocating for? Removal of health services? Isn't it literally the opposite, to have more and more varied health (and social) services, that people are advocating for? "Abolish the police" is a scale where there is an extreme end where they may call for completely removing police from across the USA. From what I've seen, that isn't what the majority who are calling for abolishment are aiming for. Maybe "abolish" was a poor choice of a word. The more common level I've seen is advocating for replacing parts of policing for more appropriate systems and services. I'd call this article a straw-man argument, but there are those on the extreme end of the scale, apparently.
- hartator 6y ago> “Abolish the police” is a scale Words have meaning though. No one on the political board is against reforms but “abolish”, “defund”, or “shut down” mean what it means.
- dorian-graph 6y agoWell, yes, duh? In what movements are there not scales attached to pithy lines? I even said: > Maybe "abolish" was a poor choice of a word.
- DHPersonal 6y agoI don’t think it necessarily is a bad choice for some: many people who do use that word want what we call “policing” to be abandoned completely and replaced with something far less punitive in its reactions to emergencies.
- capableweb 6y agoSure, and sometimes different people have different understandings of the meaning of a particular word. Someone can say "abolish the police" and mean that there should be no one with monopoly on violence. Another one can say "abolish the police" and refer the to current state/situation with the police in the US, and simply want the police to stop shooting people at sight and instead act like police in other countries, where they try to de-escalate instead of using their guns. So while it's easy to try to put everyone in one bucket, it's hardy useful to do so in reality.
- PedroBatista 6y agoHuman ego seems to be the most powerful thing in the Universe. Whole communities commit "suicide" just to fuel the delusions of a handful and the self-preservation of another handful. How many injustices have been perpetrated in the name of justice? No one comes out of this looking good, certainly not the police too.
- 1312 6y agoA reminder that police "do not owe a specific duty to provide police services to citizens based on the public duty doctrine." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warren_v._District_of_Columbia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warren_v._District_of_Columbia
- elil17 6y ago“Business owners describe a harrowing experience of calling for help and being left all alone.” No one advocating defunding the police was saying it would be good for business owners. The point of the whole movement is that police protect the rich and powerful at the expense of everyone else.
- thatsfine 6y agoThen the businesses will leave and the local economy will suffer. Those with little will have less. Those with enough to start over elsewhere will leave. This phenomenon is called "blight". Good luck Seattle.
- shadowgovt 6y agoAs long as Amazon and MSFT are mixed into the economy, Seattle barely needs luck. Not when it has that much tech cash blowing through it.
- donkey-hotei 6y agoThat this article is written by someone who isn't from Seattle, and posted by someone on hacker news who isn't from Seattle, really amuses some of us who live on the hill.
- iron0013 6y agoHere in Minneapolis the feeling is similar. Suburban and rural folks seem awfully concerned about crime in the city, while those of us who actually live in the city just want the cops’ boots off our damn necks.
- leetcrew 6y agoI don't think the owner of an independent coffee shop qualifies as "rich and powerful".
- andrew_ 6y agoI would argue that small business owners with few employees would hardly meet the generalized popular definition of "rich," and that their inability to operate would directly harm those employees who are also not "rich." This country runs on small business owners, and it's baffling that there are those who exclude that fact from their worldview.
- jkingsbery 6y ago"Aren't so sure" from reading the article seems like an understatement. Many of the people featured in this article are suing the city for not doing it's responsibility. I get that police treatment is often inequitable, but I think we've had some experiments this summer showing that some of the radical changes being proposed have their own problems.
- adjkant 6y ago> the radical changes being proposed have their own problems I'd like to point out that none of said changes have been implemented anywhere in the US in any meaningful way. Save some minor defunding, I know of no locale who has transferred any responsibility away from the police, which is one of the main roads to abolition. As another poster said, this is a very clear straw man. CHAZ was a result of protesting and an incredibly aggressive Seattle PD, not an ideal people are looking to recreate everywhere.
- jkingsbery 6y agoFair point - you're right that the suggested policies have not been implemented in a meaningful way. My point was that some relatively minor changes (de facto abandoning neighborhoods as in CHAZ, changes to bail laws in NY being two examples) have led to some pretty drastic (negative) changes to safety.
- adjkant 6y agoWhere have bail laws caused any issue in NY? As a resident I haven't encountered any such issues. I wouldn't call "abandoning a neighborhood" a minor change either. It seems clear to me it's very much a calculated political move to do that so people can do exactly what you did - point and say "well we need police, look what happened without them". This should have no bearing on reform laws and abolition steps.
- NovemberWhiskey 6y agoThe article below provides a summary of the discussion on the NY bail law impact: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/04/nyregion/crime-stats-nyc-bail-reform.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/04/nyregion/crime-stats-nyc-...
- azangru 6y agoI thought well over half of the US population "aren't so sure", not just "survivors of the chaos in Seattle".
- Threeve303 6y agoAbolishing the police combined with the protests (or riots) and the move against the NRA creates a very uncomfortable environment for probably half of the United States. All in an election year no less. Does no one remember 2000,2004 and 2016? Perhaps the DNC could write a book called “How to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory”
- shadowgovt 6y agoBut it's an uncomfortable environment happening on the incumbent's watch. That doesn't say much positive about the incumbent's ability to lead, and suggests new leadership is in order.
- ghthor 6y agoYes, we need some strong Republican for the people mayors and governors to replace these weak democratic wannabe leaders.
- justSayin000001 6y agoMore people have died from the weak and careless inaction of our president and his sycophant governors because of covid.
- kbutler 6y agoTrump's sycophantic governors with the most deaths: New York 32,817 Andrew Cuomo (D) New Jersey 15,924 Phil Murphy (D) California 10,083 Gavin Newsom (D) 58,824 of 160,976 of the US total https://covid19info.live/us/ https://covid19info.live/us/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_current_United_States_governors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_current_United_States_... The next few (Texas 8,817, Massachusetts 8,709, Florida 8,051) are Republican, then Democratic governors of Illinois 7,822, Pennsylvania 7,364, and Michigan 6,524 put it over 50% of US deaths so far, and then some more Democrats, then more Republicans. Plenty of blame to go around.
- noarchy 6y agoPeople want security. That means different things to different people. Law enforcement is not necessarily the same thing as security. Law enforcement means just that, and the laws themselves may not be what many would consider just. The laws are likely to reflect the prejudices of those in power, which may lend itself to why we're seeing the clashes we're seeing in the US right now. Those with the resources to do so have on-site security. This ranges from gated communities, to some condo/apartment buildings, and even shopping malls. Even this isn't necessarily free of problems, but it needs to be seen as something fundamentally different from law enforcement. So when we talk about "abolishing" the police, we have to ask what we really want in its stead.
- shadowgovt 6y ago> Law enforcement is not necessarily the same thing as security I'm having difficulty finding my source right now, but it appears that in cases of homicide by someone unknown to the victim, a police officer is the perpetrator in between 1 in 3 and 1 in 4 incidents. These statistics don't consider whether the killing is justified; they just observe that if people know of someone who was killed by a stranger, there's a 1-in-3 or 1-in-4 chance that stranger has a uniform. And as we know, people's perceptions of safety are more important than actual statistics. We rewrote the nature of air travel in response to 9/11.
- victoro0 6y agoHow would that imply lack of security? Wouldn't it be perfect if every single homicide by a stranger was by a cop? It would mean that a cop was there every time to stop the criminal before they hurt someone.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThat's assuming that the only people cops shoot are criminals. in point of fact, legally, almost everyone the cops shoot are innocent people in the eyes of the law.
- 6y ago
- cyberdrunk 6y agoAm I the only one under impression that the article is chaotic and it's hard to tell from it what is the extend of the damage done and who and to what degree contributed to it?
- shadowgovt 6y agoIf I understand correctly, the main call is for defunding the police, not abolishing them.
- miles7 6y agoI think for most people defund sounds like “take away all funding for” which would be tantamount to abolishing.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThat's not what it means when we do it to schools.
- keiferski 6y agoThe reform movements of the last ~15 years have consistently failed to learn one lesson: pick a simple, easy to understand slogan that leads to simple, actionable goals. Occupy had the exact same problem and ultimately accomplished nothing. Obama and Trump both understood this and both chose slogans that virtually no one can disagree with (“Change / Yes We Can” and “Make America Great Again.”) Pretty easy to understand. “Abolish the police” seems almost designed to fail as a slogan right from the beginning.
- Kednicma 6y agoThe NYT is bootlicking with this article; they entirely left out that Seattle did defund their police, cutting their budget by about half. So did Portland. But NYT would rather focus on how scared business owners feel, because that's their target audience.
- pseudalopex 6y agoPortland cut 3%.[1] Seattle is going to vote on 2%.[2] [1] https://www.portlandmercury.com/blogtown/2020/06/17/28550006/portland-city-council-approves-3-reduction-in-police-budget https://www.portlandmercury.com/blogtown/2020/06/17/28550006... [2] https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/seattle-city-council-takes-a-swing-at-the-police-and-mostly-misses/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/seattle-c...
- AngrySeattleite 6y agoSo far the suggested policy has been to: - abolish the police [1] - banning crowd control munitions on peaceful protesters [2] who peacefully throw bombs of peace [3] and start fires of peace [4] - prosecute those who attempt to defend themselves from said peaceful protesters [5] - selectively fire white cops, civil rights laws be damned [6] I'm tired of this. [1] https://www.wbur.org/hereandnow/2020/07/17/black-lives-matter-activist https://www.wbur.org/hereandnow/2020/07/17/black-lives-matte... [2] https://komonews.com/news/local/seattle-police-deployed-crowd-control-methods https://komonews.com/news/local/seattle-police-deployed-crow... [3] https://www.q13fox.com/news/seattle-police-declare-riot-after-20-plus-officers-injured-explosive-fires-set-in-capitol-hill https://www.q13fox.com/news/seattle-police-declare-riot-afte... [4] https://www.capitolhillseattle.com/2020/07/groups-smash-glass-set-fires-across-capitol-hill-in-burst-of-protest-mayhem/ https://www.capitolhillseattle.com/2020/07/groups-smash-glas... [5] https://www.stltoday.com/news/local/crime-and-courts/mccloskeys-charged-with-felonies-for-waving-guns-during-protests/article_73bfcc8c-6828-5b77-8a58-37cd10d97f4c.html https://www.stltoday.com/news/local/crime-and-courts/mcclosk... [6] https://www.kiro7.com/news/local/seattle-police-chief-fires-back-suggestion-lay-off-officers-out-order/VLMWOYSO4JH7DPBPTS7UU3YZUM/ https://www.kiro7.com/news/local/seattle-police-chief-fires-...
- hevelvarik 6y agoThis is rich. The comments are largely in favor of diminishing police funding presumably to protect black people whereas black people want nothing of the sort https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.newsweek.com/81-black-americans-dont-want-less-police-presence-despite-protestssome-want-more-cops-poll-1523093%3famp=1 https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.newsweek.com/81-black-ameri... Truly bizarre
- john-shaffer 6y agoJust FYI, you're likely to get downvoted for posting an AMP link. It's generally best to link directly to the source.
- leetcrew 6y agoas always, be careful what conclusions you draw from polls. here's an article discussing that poll and some others from previous years: https://www.vox.com/2020/6/17/21292046/black-people-abolish-defund-dismantle-police-george-floyd-breonna-taylor-black-lives-matter-protest https://www.vox.com/2020/6/17/21292046/black-people-abolish-... I'm not even sure you're wrong; I just think you can't conclusively say how black people feel about an issue.
- adjkant 6y agoRemember back when people had such issue with the language and phrasing of "Black Lives Matter" until people (over 50%, according to recent polls) finally came around after George Floyd? "Abolish the police" is going to be the same scenario in time. Please, do your research on what abolition actually looks like. This article does not describe abolition, it describes a PR tactic the Seattle PD decided to pull as punishment to protestors. Linked below is one with actual interest and nuance. https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2020/6/12/21283813/george-floyd-blm-abolish-the-police-8cantwait-minneapolis https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2020/6/12/21283813/g... If you look around and see incredible injustice, great. Don't spend your time policing the language and methodology the oppressed use to argue for their rights, go do things and help them be more effective. This is a classic white liberal issue of "I support the ideas but not the way to them" that has been around for centuries. https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2020/01/17/martin-luther-king-polite-racism-white-liberals/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2020/01/17/martin-luth... "We do not need allies who are more devoted to order than to justice" - MLK
- CapricornNoble 6y ago>>>This is a classic white liberal issue of "I support the ideas but not the way to them" that has been around for centuries. "The white liberal is the worst enemy to America, and the worst enemy to the black man....The white liberal aren’t white people who are for independence, who are moral and ethical in their thinking. They are just a faction of white people that are jockeying for power. The same as the white conservative is a faction of white people that are jockeying for power. They are fighting each other for power and prestige, and the one that is the football in the game is the Negro..." - Malcom X https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/8869214-the-white-liberal-is-the-worst-enemy-to-america-and https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/8869214-the-white-liberal-i...
- adjkant 6y agoWas looking for this when I was typing that post up! Should have known it would be Malcom X. There's another great quote along the lines of "those concerned with how something is said than what is said" that I can't seem to remember the source on either that is very relevant here too.
- Tycho 6y agoWe can split hairs about 'defunding' vs 'abolishing', but I just get the distinct impression that many people have got no real idea about the threat that crime poses to the prosperity of a community (or city or state), and the effort that is required to keep it in check. The occasional misbehaviour of police officers is a small price to pay compared to the oppression and privation wrought by widespread crime.
- happytoexplain 6y agoMost of the examples that spurred this movement are killings that are disproportionately either negligent or depraved heart at the very least (let's pretend we can't form an argument that any of them were purposeful murders that were not necessary to save the officer). Even given this benefit of the doubt, it is still reasonable for independent citizens of a free nation to fight tooth and nail against such an assault on a tenant of civilization: That the state never kills you in the streets, if they can at all help it. Further, I can't see from any angle how allowing these instances to continue is a necessary price for preventing widespread crime. >I just get the distinct impression that many people have got no real idea about the threat that crime poses to the prosperity of a community I can't disagree more strongly. >... and the effort that is required to keep it in check This I agree with. But this is a weak argument against people who live with a constant background, and sometimes foreground, fear for their lives from their own government.
- Tycho 6y agoYou have to consider the stochastic nature of crime and policing. The size of the population, the size of the force, behaviour altered by substance abuse, the prevalence of deadly weapons, the mental toll of dealing with criminals every day, the presence of organised crime, the antagonism, the heat of the moment, the type of personality needed to want to do the job: of course you are going to end up with some bad encounters. That is the price of having police. The price of not having police is the constant and imminent danger and cost of crime. We all have to avoid certain parts of our cities. Women can’t walk safely at night even in the “safe” parts. Children can’t be left unattended. Public goods are ruined by vandalism. The stabilising effect of family households is lost as many flee to safer locations. Property values languish. Nobody can invest in the area, lenders and insurers aren’t interested. Innocent people are brutalised and they can’t rely on the police to protect them. Violent criminals operate with impunity. These aren’t isolated incidents, this is a trend of misery. And this will be the legacy of many of these BLM protests/riots. More misery heaped on the poorest communities. That’s why I say that many people seem to have no real idea about the trade-off.
- dragonwriter 6y ago“Abolish the police” isn't “abolish law enforcement”. It's “abolish the centralized, generalist paramilitary model of local law enforcement.” The ability of a blanket law enforcement withdrawal from selected neighborhoods, is largely a product of, and historically has been applied as a negotiating tactic by, exactly the model of law enforcement targeted for abolition by people who Say “Abolish the police”.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoAll right, but then comes the question: Replace it with what?
- dragonwriter 6y agoAmong the alternatives: dividing law enforcement among domain-specific agencies that that have law enforcement within their domain as part, but not usually all, of their remit. You might have relatively pure enforcement in a central criminal investigation service, traffic enforcement enforcement within the agency responsible for roads and transit; truancy and school resources officers organizationally within the education office rather than assigned to them by a separate law enforcement agency, etc.
- rayhendricks 6y agoCutting the Seattle police departments budget by 50% would be the perfect way to provide an argument for Trump Republicans that the alt-left/Antifa are out to get you . This combined with the portland protests will get Trump re-elected and keep the GOP majority in the senate. This is what you call a diversion from the real issue which is COVID, that republicans have not managed well at all. The CHOP was a nightmare that was not shut down soon enough. There were armed gangs patrolling the entire thing who would try and make you delete cellphone footage. There was also rape/Iv drug usage/trash all over. I was literally there back in June. That is NOT what I want to deal with on a daily basis. We need to hire more police and private security to stop the crazies, make cal Anderson a gun free Zone and stop the chaos.