8 ms·
Immunology Is Where Intuition Goes to Die
- sgdpk 6y agoThis is a nice summary of the basics of immunology and how it relates to SARS-CoV-2. It's good to see a piece that shows how complex the science behind COVID is, in the middle of so many contradictory or over-simplified news.
- schemy 6y ago>It's good to see a piece that shows how complex the science behind COVID is, in the middle of so many contradictory or over-simplified news. It's rather unfortunate how politicized the whole issue is. I got banned from reddit for pointing out that without knowing what the r0 was for asymptomatic patients any type of lock down tells you more about the psychology of the person for or against it than about its effectiveness.
- enkid 6y agoI mean, all you really have to know is that the r0 for asymptomatic patients is > 1 or that symptomatic patients aren't going to be perfect and are going to be going out when they are sick (or most likely a combination of the two). I think we've had enough evidence of that for a while now. The way you write your comment seems rather condescending and anti-lockdown when what we've seen is that "shutdowns" have saved lives.
- schemy 6y agoThe sheer hubris of your post is the problem I'm talking about. Banning cars saves lives. Forcing everyone to wear a helmet when walking saves lives. Banning sugar saves lives. The issue is how many lives and at what cost? I'll wait to see how many millions end up homeless before I say that the lock downs saved lives anywhere where they were implemented.
- nickthemagicman 6y agoThis so much. The economy IS lives! People putting food on the table. I feel like it's that train track problem where you have a train barreling at three people and we just pulled the lever and had it kill 40 people instead.
- schemy 6y agoYou are far too optimistic with how wrong things can go. The economy running smoothly is what keeps revolutions and wars from happening. The last time the wheels fell off as badly as they did over the last three months we had WWII happen within a decade. We are lucky that it is a sharp shock and it is probably recoverable, but the longer we keep this up the slower the recovery will be. And given how popular extremist ideas were even before a 25% unemployment wall it is not something I want to play with.
- nickthemagicman 6y agoHave had those same exact thoughts that poverty leads to war and other terrible stuff. The people supporting these extreme coronavirus measures have good intentions but don't seem to understand the law of unintended consequences.
- ghthor 6y agoYeah, it's a mess out there. One thing I've noticed is just how narrow people viewpoints are, if they could just take a step back and look at the whole picture they might start finding some common ground. The government is overstepping its responsibility rig but now, and far too many people are cheering it on, it's dangerous.
- bildung 6y agoOr just help those 40 people with federal funds, which is what every other rich country did, and _which worked_? The problem isn't the lockdown (the US didn't even have a proper lockdown, compared to European countries), the problem is lack of federal help to compensate the losses. The US GDP shrinkage in Q2 2020 was three times larger than that of e.g. Germany and France, despite these countries having harder lockdowns. Now those countries are mostly done with Covid, while the US still has over 1000 deaths a day _plus_ the economical costs of Covid.
- GlennS 6y agoAt this point (and for a few of months now), surely you don't need to know the R0 value? Why not just look at other countries, see which have had the best outcomes, and copy them?
- schemy 6y ago>Why not just look at other countries, see which have had the best outcomes, and copy them? Because if the R0 value for asymptomatic cases is high enough you will need 2 week quarantine for all travelers and fortress boarders until the virus is eradicated everywhere. Something New Zealand is currently doing after implementing the most draconian nation wide lock-down. Do you support a barb wire wall around both the Canadian and Mexican border with lethal force counter measures if anyone tries to pass and forced isolation of all travelers?
- GlennS 6y agoIf you think New Zealand's approach is infeasible, perhaps instead take inspiration from some of the countries with land borders that are doing well?
- nradov 6y agoAfter some initial problems, Sweden appears to be doing well for the past several weeks.
- bildung 6y agoI wouldn't say so. The economical costs are very similar to its neighbors Denmark and Norway (around -6% GDP growth projected for 2020), but the death rate is 10x higher in Sweden.
- dmitriid 6y ago> doing well for the past several weeks. How convenient of you to ignore all the weeks prior to "the past several" as in: significantly higher mortality rates than any of its neighbours. And the end result? Worst recession since WWII.
- doliveira 6y ago"No one knows everything" is much different from "No one knows anything so anyone can make anything up". We already know that it is bigger than 1. And you're mistaken if you think your comment has no political connotation.
- schemy 6y ago>We already know that it is bigger than 1. Do we? Do you have a study?
- doliveira 6y agoThere are quite a few studies showing that asymptomatic carry just as much viral load, and pre-symptomatic transmission is a thing as well. But I don't think you want to be convinced. Like you said, it has become politicized.
- schemy 6y agoPlease provide the doi.
- doliveira 6y agoThey're a Google search away. Are you aware that you're the one with the extraordinary claim?
- doliveira 6y agoBut anyway, I do regret entering this discussion. I hope I was not disrespectful.
- roenxi 6y agohttps://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/332293/WHO-2019-nCov-IPC_Masks-2020.4-eng.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=yed=y https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/332293/WHO-... > Comprehensive studies on transmission from asymptomatic individuals are difficult to conduct, but the available evidence from contact tracing reported by Member States suggests that asymptomatically-infected individuals are much less likely to transmit the virus than those who develop symptoms. > The available data, to date, on onward infection from cases without symptoms comes from a limited number of studies with small samples that are subject to possible recall bias and for which fomite transmission cannot be ruled out. Go looking for evidence on the internet I suspect anything can be supported. I stopped trying to keep up with the evidence a few months ago; but certainly as of May I was infuriated by how little actual knowledge seemed to be disseminating about how, in detail, this thing spreads. There is a lot of 'common sense' out there that appears to be unsupported by attempts to gather and work to evidence. I havn't seen anything so far to suggest that asymptotic transmission is the problem. My theory is that people are ignoring quarantines if they have mild symptoms - but again, no evidence.
- monkeydreams 6y ago> I got banned from reddit for pointing out You got banned from reddit. As in the whole site? For merely pointing this out? I see a lot of users stake out similar positions all the time without ramification. Perhaps you were banned from a subreddit, or perhaps this isn't the full story. > without knowing what the r0 was for asymptomatic patients any type of lock down tells you more about the psychology of the person for or against it than about its effectiveness. Aaah, the old "I don't know 100% that this blotch on your face is a melanoma because I'm not an oncologist, therefore don't do anything about it" line of thinking. A few points: 1. We have a good history of containing pandemics, using simple processes and practices. We begin by following these. 2. We have a good handle on how to reduce and control the outbreak of COVID-19. This has demonstrated that total eradication of the disease is possible within certain populations (i.e. island populations, areas with strong border controls). This has also demonstrated that flattening the curve only works if you do not ease up on the curve-flattening practices (i.e. Japan, Korea, Singapore, Australia). 3. The impact on areas of high infection is not linear - due to the effectiveness of medical intervention when such intervention is not overwhelmed, flattening the curve significantly reduces overall deaths and allows for control of the disease even after it has reached relatively high saturation within the population. 4. Conversely, when medical capability is overwhelmed or absent, the death rate climbs significantly. (The US, UK and Iran demonstrate this). This is the "bulldozer mortuary" and "death panel triage" point in the pandemic. 5. The economic impact is not solely driven by lockdown. The US has limited lockdown, and they are being impacted severely because of lack of demand (people don't want goods at the price of their health). The government people seem to think the only driver of impact is Supply-side (i.e. shut down shops and the economy dies), and have completely underestimated people's willingness to sacrifice their health for the economy. 6. The biggest questions we don't know are the long term impacts of the virus on sufferers and the potential range of this impact does not extend into the positive. It appears to cause long-term damage to the cardiovascular system, and potentially the brain and other organs as well. We are seeing upswings in strokes, heart disease, and general mortality in sufferers and those who have recovered. To top it off, the potential lower end of this range appears extremely negative - with drastically lowered life expectancy in older patients and the potential for things such as a rise in dementia and significant cv illness as those who have recovered grow older. With all of this answers that we have, and identifying the questions yet to answer, the path is very fucking clear. Countries which do something appear to end up much better off. Those who do not, fare far worse. Pointing to an economic impact now, as people are doing with Sweden, is only part of the answer and is an indication of the best picture of Swedish public health - there is nothing which will improve and the picture will only grow worse as time passes. Whereas for NZ, Australia, etc, they have borne or are bearing the impact, and will have a healthier, fitter and less traumatised population to revive demand again when things improve.
- snowwrestler 6y agoR0 is an observed metric, not an inherent metric. That is, the R0 for asymptomatic patients depends on how those patients interact with other humans, not just on how the disease works. Reducing human interactions will reduce R0 for every communicable disease including COVID-19. This is highlighted on the Wikipedia page, for example: > R_{0} is not a biological constant for a pathogen as it is also affected by other factors such as environmental conditions and the behaviour of the infected population. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_reproduction_number https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_reproduction_number We don't need to know the R0 to know that COVID-19 causes abnormal impacts on society like increased hospitalizations and deaths; those abnormal impacts are how we discovered the disease in the first place. Those are the reason that affected societies are changing how they work temporarily to mitigate the impact of the disease.
- westoque 6y agomy takeaway from this is that the human body is actually really complex. even the immunologists quoted cannot say for sure about how the body responds to certain viruses. each one of us is unique and has different response levels. however, it's good to know that children have more a aggressive immune system response than older people and hopefully make their bodies somehow adapt to the Covid-19 virus.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoIt's two billion lines of spaghetti code created by iterative randomness and implementing its own compiler (and, as a side gig, perl) Parts of the code have evolved to code for two entirely different functional segments depending on the direction they are read in, while others have randomly duplicated and taken on entirely new functions over time. Energy has become the specialisation of a type of bacteria that at some point somehow avoided death after being eaten by a cell and instead founded its family of somewhat strange but super-efficient metabolisers. So yeah, it's complex.
- missosoup 6y agoIt's complex and beautiful. "We are all just a somewhat interesting random arrangement of photons"
- kazagistar 6y agoIts a nice sentiment but inaccurate. If you wanted a fundamental particle that we are mostly made of, gluons would be a better boson to pick, since they make up the majority of the mass/energy of subatomic particles in matter. Why would you say photons?
- doliveira 6y agoOur biological processes are caused by the electromagnetic force, which is mediated by photons.
- medymed 6y agoIntuition can die often, but on the other hand many individual processes within immunology are somewhat well characterized as far as biology goes, and are amazing. The VDJ recombination process for B and T cell development is a stochastic-engineering-like feat of self-driven mutation (not just slight code changes but actually chopping up parts of our DNA and rearranging their order) and is occurring constantly in huge numbers of developing lymphocytes to generate structurally new proteins under very close scrutiny, allowing our immune system to adapt to previously unseen infections. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/V(D)J_recombination https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/V(D)J_recombination
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bionhoward 6y agoIt’s amazing to watch folks deny evolution while their bodies evolve new immunity in real time
- Terr_ 6y agoThe Long-Term E-Coli Experiment [0] is also pretty awesome, because not only is is evolution seen directly in the lab, but frozen samples can reveal exactly what steps turned out to be important. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E._coli_long-term_evolution_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E._coli_long-term_evolution_ex...
- pas 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yybsSqcB7mE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yybsSqcB7mE (Harvard Mega-Dish antibiotic experiment)
- kevinmchugh 6y agoThe most sophisticated arguers of that group would draw a distinction between short-term evolution and long-term. This was normally a response to the peppered moth observations. That's short-term evolution, which doesn't explain ball and socket joints, or eyes. Or, this was the explanation on blogs 10-15 years ago. A very strange time that was.
- hirundo 6y agoWhere intuition can't be relied on we must resort to experimentation. Animal and virtual models can tell us a lot, but because immunology is so contingent on the details, they can't make strong predictions about human responses. Human testing is needed for that, and even then reactions over the population can differ wildly. But we've locked ourselves out of timely human testing. We are protective of subjects to the point that even a global pandemic can't overcome long deadly delays in testing vaccines. So what's the alternative, Dr. Mengele? One simple word that Mengele didn't bother with: consent. We should create a category of fully informed, fully consenting adults that are willing to subject themselves to human experimentation, even before lengthy animal testing. Give them sufficient education, training and evaluation to determine that they consent by strict criteria. Test them on their knowledge, let them decide over months. And then let the scientists administrate the test substance or placebo. With conditions monitored by a research oversight committee. Even if it were a risky and painful process that didn't make a subject any richer, I predict that there would be hundreds of sincere volunteers. Both fools and heroes. We should let them. It could defer large numbers of deaths.
- ineedasername 6y agoThose fully informed and consenting adults may very well have significant selection bias and not represent the population very well. Meaning results obtained from them would not be generalizable and could run the gamut from ineffective treatment to dangerous or fatal when tried in the broader population.
- op03 6y agoHow do the randomly located specialist T-Cells that "clone into a battalion" after the messenger cell show up know where to go in the body? Do they just fan out in all directions? Or is there some spl navigation mechanism? Any good book reco's for the layman?
- anotherboffin 6y agoWell a lot of the T cells will enter the bloodstream in order to spread through the body. My knowledge of this is fairly limited but chemokines serve as the navigation instruments in many cases: a site of inflammation or infection will have immune cells expressing these signaling molecules that will slowly diffuse and create a gradient. T cells (for example) will follow this gradient to get to the site of interest (the process is called chemotaxis). No book recommendations off the top of my head, but I’ll post back if something comes up.
- yread 6y agoWe don't really have good explanations on "how does anything know where to go" in biology except "brownian motion" everything goes everywhere and if the association is strong enough it sticks
- nickthemagicman 6y agoThis is such poor sensationalized fear-based reporting. There are extremely well enumerated principles in immunology. There's always exceptions in any sort of molecular biology and this article makes them sound like they are the rule or the standard. Covid is extremely tame compared to other pathogenic viruses. You want a scary virus, look at ebola which destroys epithelial cells and has 90% fatality rate , look at HIV which integrates into your genome. The article implies that Covid is special in some regard in how it attacks the body. It's a standard virus. Every virus on the planet has people that are susceptible to it and it kills them. Every virus on the planet can cause you damage via immune system over response. That's how influenza kills and its way better at it. The entire human physiology and biology in general is crazy with exceptions to every rule and millions of years of evolution makes it hard for us to understand why. All of biology is crazy and unintuitive from the tree of life down to proteomics. But to say it so unpredictable is just false.
- klodolph 6y agoIf you want a cartoon explaining some parts of the immune response in the article--try Cells at Work! It's on Netflix, last time I checked. It is surprisingly technical.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gverrilla 6y agoWe are still in Middle Ages