5 ms·
Seeing these studies and NYTimes talk about the widespread use of masks in 1918 makes me angry that in 2020 public health officials thought it was a good idea t
by dmix 6y ago
Seeing these studies and NYTimes talk about the widespread use of masks in 1918 makes me angry that in 2020 public health officials thought it was a good idea to lie to the public for months with vague dismissals of the benefits of masks - merely to protect supply chains for doctors (both Dr Fauci and officials here in Canada have admitted they purposefully kept it vague for the benefit of health care workers).
It set back a really important protocol in western countries that asian countries had already adopted and clearly had success with. By the time they switched on the masks-everywhere messaging we were well into the mass spread of COVID.
This sort of "protecting people" through deception or indirection is the sort of thing I despise from governments.
The side-effects of not immediately stating their usefulness to the public - while no doctor would go near a COVID-19 patient without a full face + eye mask - is still being felt today.
- PaulKeeble 6y agoThere will be lasting consequences of that lie for the rest of the pandemic probably for decades to come. There is a sizeable anti mask movement that gained significant ground because authorities told people masks didn't work despite the science saying the opposite, they even fabricated it as a scientific position further hurting belief in science itself. Many governments of the world created an anti vaxxer like movement around masks just to protect supplies. They had to do so because they failed to act early enough and to follow their own recommendations for stockpiles of protective equipment. The consequences of those lies will be here for a long time.
- jdoliner 6y agoThis is particularly damning given that we're also now being told that a bandanna or any piece of cloth is a suitable replacement for a mask. Assuming that's true, it's pretty hard to justify lying to people about mask efficacy for the first several months of the pandemic. Would people have listened if they were told: masks work, but are in limited supply so use a bandanna and save the mask supply for front-line doctors? Probably not completely, I'm sure many people would still have gone out and bought masks impacting the total supply. Would it have been worth it, looking ahead, to not lie to people and degrade their trust in medical professionals, so that in the future when you decide to reveal the truth to people that masks actually do work they'll believe you? I think it probably was, but who knows.
- newacct583 6y ago> we're also now being told that a bandanna or any piece of cloth is a suitable replacement for a mask. We are not. But we are being told it's better than no face covering, which is true. You are, personally, wearing a mask though, right?
- toxik 6y agoIt isn’t established that mandatory face masks is a worthwhile policy decision. I refer to the Swedish health authority for analysis of the current findings. Ah downvoted without rebuttal, how cowardly.
- wolco 6y agoI didn't downvote. I'll offer this. This (the quote is from the Swedish health authority) was proven wrong yesterday. People touch their face less with a masks. Based on cctv studies in England. "a face mask which is itchy and falls below the nose contributes to your hands often touching the mouth, eyes and nose which can increase the risk of infection"
- toxik 6y agoThe question is not simply “do masks have any benefit”, it’s “do masks have enough benefit to be worthwhile mandatory policy”. There are many ways to deal with this pandemic, and it’s getting more and more “with us or against us”. This censoring that Twitter et al now engage in is very, very troubling.
- neom 6y agoSouth Korea did an amazing job, as outlined in this NYT article [1]. The thing I liked the most is my Korean map app had a new tab, showing me all the official mask distribution locations, and their real time quantities on hand. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/01/opinion/covid-face-mask-shortage.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/01/opinion/covid-face-mask-s...
- newacct583 6y ago> public health officials thought it was a good idea to lie to the public for months with vague dismissals of the benefits of masks - merely to protect supply chains for doctors It was weeks, not months. By mid-march, conventional wisdom had shifted, as had most of the official rhetoric. This was before or simultaneous with most of the early lockdowns. And it was wrong. But the real harm was caused much later when political actors started arguing not based on this early advice that masks were ineffective/harmful/tyrannical, or (even worse) that the expert advice now was not to be trusted because the experts then got it wrong. Basically: the people who refuse to wear a mask aren't the ones slavishly honoring the whims of the WHO or Fauci, so I don't understand your point.
- javert 6y agoAbsolutely. This was a disinformation tactic adopted from the modern Republican playbook. Don't lie to people and then blame Republicans for lying to people. Reality matters. Intellectual hygiene matters.
- Someone1234 6y agoIt is very easy to politicize this, but it wasn't just the party in power: Supposedly independent healthcare organizations in the US gave outright and easily disprovable safety information for at least two months. We had studies about similar airborne illnesses that showed mask's effectiveness, and while I am sympathetic to protecting key medical supply lines, they have done long term harm to public trust and mask adoption. The anti-maskers we're seeing today are directly their fault. Even now, we're still seeing misinformation about the difference between cloth and N95 effectiveness, particularly as the US has failed to ramp up N95 production after months of seeming inaction. Even healthcare providers are still struggling with PPE, let alone the general public or educators with the upcoming school re-openings.
- ericb 6y agoWhile I agree with your point, there were also anti-maskers during the Spanish Flu, so these anti maskers aren't entirely the fault of the deception. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Mask_League_of_San_Francisco https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Mask_League_of_San_Franci...
- Someone1234 6y agoI agree that we'd always have some anti-maskers. But the level of it (seemingly mainstream) has been quite problematic (although the tide does seem to be slowly turning).
- javert 6y ago> It is very easy to politicize this, but it wasn't just the party in power That's what I'm saying. Non-Trump people took a move out of Trump's playbook. That's vicious. > The anti-maskers we're seeing today are directly their fault. I wouldn't go that far. Anybody who is still anti-mask at this point is just an anti-reality nihilist.
- snowwrestler 6y agoThis is not exactly what happened. U.S. medical authorities really did not believe that basic masks, like fabric or paper surgical, offered significant protection. Thus they believed it was N95 or nothing, and they (correctly) wanted to save N95s for medical professionals. They were wrong about basic masks, which is what we're all using now.
- Demonsult 6y agoThe virus had not been well characterized at all, yet they were very certain of the opinions they expressed to the public. I can't forgive this.
- tombert 6y agoIt wasn't like they just guessed or anything. IIRC they had a test where people coughed into a petri dish with and without masks. The initial results showed that there was coronavirus on the outside of the mask, leading them to conclude that the virus is able to get through the mask. They weren't able to realize they were incorrect on their conclusion until they looked at the cultures a few weeks later and measure the amount of coronavirus in them. I could be wrong on that, if someone is better-informed please correct me, but that's what I read somewhere. EDIT: Just to clarify before I'm downvoted, I do actually agree they were a bit too hasty to tell people not to buy masks. Having the surgeon general tweet out saying "Seriously people, DO NOT BUY MASKS" was definitely premature and obviously led to a lot of the problems we're having here now. I just wanted to point out that it wasn't a completely unfounded take, just premature to make huge decisions like that.
- snowwrestler 6y agoI don't think this is fair; in real time you have to either go with what you think you know, or do nothing at all. If they'd done nothing at all, I think they would still be getting at least as much criticism now.
- Demonsult 6y agoWhy not advise to err on the side of caution until a meaningful quantity of knowledge is available?
- mike503 6y agoI will say - I do understand why they did it, because nobody told anyone toilet paper was useful or important with the virus and look at how that went out of control. Just think if they suggested masks or even “face coverings” - people would definitely have saturated the market. However it did suck as that helped cement some anti-masker excuses early on. Hard to tell if there is any winning in that situation. :(