7 ms·
Prevent person-to-person transmission of SARS-CoV-2
- blakesterz 6y agoLooks like what we've been hearing is backed up by this study: "Interpretation The findings of this systematic review and meta-analysis support physical distancing of 1 m or more and provide quantitative estimates for models and contact tracing to inform policy. Optimum use of face masks, respirators, and eye protection in public and health-care settings should be informed by these findings and contextual factors. Robust randomised trials are needed to better inform the evidence for these interventions, but this systematic appraisal of currently best available evidence might inform interim guidance." I've not seen any recommendations for public use of eye protection, is that being done anywhere? Are some places recommending wearing some type of goggles or something?
- mgkimsal 6y agoIIRC, some news reports stated Fauci mentioned something about eye-protection last week. Haven't heard anything more concrete than that. It makes sense, but... I doubt most people will do it. I wear glasses half the time, which... I dunno - may be slightly useful?
- skybrian 6y agoTransparent face shields might actually be nicer to wear than masks, if that's all you needed, because you can still see each other. I saw someone on the street using one once. Unfortunately, they haven't been studied much, and I've seen a couple reports that face shields alone are not enough and they are best combined with masks. Still, a face shield alone would probably be better than nothing.
- mistersquid 6y ago> Transparent face shields might actually be nicer to wear than masks, if that's all you needed, because you can still see each other. Alone, face shields do little to nothing to protect people from the wearer.
- johnchristopher 6y agoFWIW, as far as I am concerned, I would wear goggles if made mandatory or highly recommended (as long as the kind of recommended googles are sufficiently well described). On that note I don't see anyone left wearing surgical or latex gloves outside now (Western Europe).
- thisisnico 6y agoBecause the gloves are mostly pointless, if not making the problem worse. It's better to not touch your face and sanitize your hands. All the cashiers here don't use gloves. They sanitize their hands after every transaction, they wear face masks, plexiglass shield around their station, and there is a limited number of people allowed in the store, with a 1m physical distance between customers enforced. This is the requirement in South-Western Ontario. So far it's working fantastic over here. All decisions have been informed by scientists and experts in their fields.
- wolco 6y ago"They sanitize their hands after every transaction" They use soap and water? Handwipes? That must be killing any skin they have left. Gloves make so much sense for them. They make sense for everyone.
- thisisnico 6y agoThey use hand sanitizer. It contains moisturizer as well. Gloves are scientifically proven not to work unless you replace them after every transaction, additionally most people do not know how to properly remove surgical gloves without contamination.
- wolco 6y agoThat makes sense overall. But they work for the worker who wears them (just not the public). Longer term healthy workers won't be sick and spread as much. Taking off gloves shouldn't be an issue. I would think after a 4 hour shift you would take them off and wash hands because they would be sweaty anyhow and you would smell of rubber.
- cma 6y agoMost footage during the Wuhan lockdown had a near majority wearing goggles in places like grocery stores.
- jansan 6y agoYeah, they were wearing swim goggles, like this Irish badass in Wuhan at the end of January: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=luztqxUBvZo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=luztqxUBvZo
- 762236 6y agoDo glasses help, or do you need goggles?
- verroq 6y agoGlasses obviously help and is better than nothing, it is a screen in front of your eyes.
- irq11 6y agoThat’s because this isn’t a “study”, it’s a review. A review introduces no new information - it summarizes the existing literature. This is the meta-review commissioned by the WHO to investigate the value of PPE, and it is notable because it aggregates a number of low-quality studies and attempts to statistically re-weight their data to arrive at a broader conclusion. It’s notable for face masks, in particular, because it mixes data from hospital settings with community settings, along with respirators and surgical masks, source control and PPE, and attempts to draw a conclusion about “protectiveness” overall.
- tux1968 6y agoMy dentist wore a full-face clear plastic shield yesterday, which obviously provides eye protection and let him work while staying protected. I wouldn't be surprised if this becomes standard practice ever more.
- azinman2 6y agoThat’s not true if the particles are aerosolized (why dentistry is so high risk) and simply go around the face shield into the eye. Eye googles would be far more effective.
- xenonite 6y agoRegarding aerosols, the authors write that it is not possible to draw conclusions yet, because they could not find enough supportive data on aerosol transmission. Please note that they only consider sources before May 3, 2020.
- pmarreck 6y agoSomething I see not often mentioned (as a long-sufferer of both of them) is that since COVID is much more highly contagious than either the standard set of flu virii OR the standard set of rhinovirii (common cold) (what I've read, IIRC, is that COVID is 3x more contagious than those: the median R0 for COVID is 5.7 https://www.healthline.com/health/r-nought-reproduction-number#covid-19-r-0 https://www.healthline.com/health/r-nought-reproduction-numb... and the flu has an R0 of 1.3 https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/world/asia/china-coronavirus-contain.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/world/asia/china-co... and the cold, 1.5 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.02.04.20020404v1.full.pdf https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.02.04.20020404v..., see table 1), all the work we're doing to stop COVID transmission may be having an even greater effect on flu and cold transmission. I talked to a biologist friend about the possibility of those being eradicated as an unintended positive side effect of our anti-COVID efforts, and he suggested that the animal kingdom unfortunately can serve as a zoological reservoir of some of these viruses and could potentially retransmit them back to humans, so it probably wouldn't entirely eradicate them, but it might certainly drastically hamper them for years. I for one will be happy to take "will not experience a cold or flu for the next... who knows how many years" as a 2020 consolation prize. Things I did not know while researching this comment: The common cold costs the US economy $40 billion a year, and Amazon is secretly working on a cure: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/06/amazon-is-secretly-working-on-a-cure-for-the-common-cold.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/06/amazon-is-secretly-working-o... The 2018 flu season cost businesses an estimated $15.4 billion https://money.cnn.com/2018/02/02/news/flu-season-business-cost/index.html https://money.cnn.com/2018/02/02/news/flu-season-business-co... and sufferers $10.4 billion in hospitalizations and outpatient expenses https://www.cdc.gov/flu/pdf/business/Toolkit_Seasonal_Flu_for_Businesses_and_employers.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/flu/pdf/business/Toolkit_Seasonal_Flu_fo... That seems to imply that the combined economic benefit of nearly eradicating both could result in an economic boon of $65 BILLION a year, and that's just in the United States! Not to mention all the people who won't die of the flu, etc...
- skuhn 6y agoI hope that even if this situation doesn't eradicate other diseases, it at least pushes us to take more care with infectious disease in general. Since I've been exposed over the last few months to roughly a million people claiming that COVID19 is no worse than the flu, it prompted me to look up just how many people die or are hospitalized from the flu every year. US avg annual deaths (prev 9 years): 37,000 US avg annual hospitalizations (prev 9 years): 446,000 Clearly COVID19 is worse than this already (160k deaths, 317k hospitalizations, and more every day). But put aside the COVID19 comparison, and that is still a lot of people who suffer or die from something that we have tools to prevent. How much of that could be avoided with better flu vaccine uptake, policies that support staying at home when you're sick, and the normalization of wearing masks in public? Why weren't we already doing all of those things? I only did one of those things, and that feels kind of dumb now.
- 2rF7OoC47 6y agoFrom the study abstract: "Our search identified 172 observational studies across 16 countries and six continents, with no randomised controlled trials" Don't have a chance to read the full article until later. Does anyone know if they are controlling for confounding factors (e.g. urban/rural, public/private settings)?
- irq11 6y agoThey are not. They freely mix studies from different circumstances. For example, the “mask” section mixes data for respirators and surgical masks, and does not differentiate between hospital or community use, source control or PPE, when they make their top-line conclusions. If you look at the breakouts, you’ll note that most of the data showing effectiveness for masks is for respirator use in hospitals.
- dmix 6y agoSeeing these studies and NYTimes talk about the widespread use of masks in 1918 makes me angry that in 2020 public health officials thought it was a good idea to lie to the public for months with vague dismissals of the benefits of masks - merely to protect supply chains for doctors (both Dr Fauci and officials here in Canada have admitted they purposefully kept it vague for the benefit of health care workers). It set back a really important protocol in western countries that asian countries had already adopted and clearly had success with. By the time they switched on the masks-everywhere messaging we were well into the mass spread of COVID. This sort of "protecting people" through deception or indirection is the sort of thing I despise from governments. The side-effects of not immediately stating their usefulness to the public - while no doctor would go near a COVID-19 patient without a full face + eye mask - is still being felt today.
- PaulKeeble 6y agoThere will be lasting consequences of that lie for the rest of the pandemic probably for decades to come. There is a sizeable anti mask movement that gained significant ground because authorities told people masks didn't work despite the science saying the opposite, they even fabricated it as a scientific position further hurting belief in science itself. Many governments of the world created an anti vaxxer like movement around masks just to protect supplies. They had to do so because they failed to act early enough and to follow their own recommendations for stockpiles of protective equipment. The consequences of those lies will be here for a long time.
- jdoliner 6y agoThis is particularly damning given that we're also now being told that a bandanna or any piece of cloth is a suitable replacement for a mask. Assuming that's true, it's pretty hard to justify lying to people about mask efficacy for the first several months of the pandemic. Would people have listened if they were told: masks work, but are in limited supply so use a bandanna and save the mask supply for front-line doctors? Probably not completely, I'm sure many people would still have gone out and bought masks impacting the total supply. Would it have been worth it, looking ahead, to not lie to people and degrade their trust in medical professionals, so that in the future when you decide to reveal the truth to people that masks actually do work they'll believe you? I think it probably was, but who knows.
- jcoq 6y agoThis study talks about 12-16 layer cotton masks as being the most effective. They say this offhand, as if that's a thing. However, it's very difficult to find anything with more than 3 layers. None of the citations to that claim give any hints about how to find 12-16 layer cotton masks (in fact, one of the citations to that claim is a paper that couldn't determine the efficacy of one mask-type over another).
- DeRock 6y agoI think you interpreted this wrong. N95 were associated with higher reduction in transmission than others (eg. the 12-16 layer cotton masks you mention).
- jcoq 6y agoYes, that's true, but the 12-16 layer masks were ostensibly superior to single layer masks. The authors seem to treat "12-16 layer" masks as somewhat equivalent to surgical masks throughout the article, which might answer my original question. "For the general public, evidence shows that physical distancing of more than 1 m is highly effective and that face masks are associated with protection, even in non-health-care settings, with either disposable surgical masks or reusable 12–16-layer cotton ones, although much of this evidence was on mask use within households and among contacts of cases." In another part, they compare 12-16 layer/surgical masks to single-layered masks, ranking the single-layered as less effective.
- Nuzzerino 6y agoI see on page 3 of the paper it says 118 studies were excluded for "Wrong Outcomes" but I couldn't find any elaboration on what was meant by this. Were papers tossed out based on arbitrary criteria? This would suggest a bias, no?
- Sebguer 6y agoOutcomes in research papers refer to the specific values that were being measured. In this case, "wrong outcomes" means that the studies that were discarded were not measuring FOR the values that they're comparing across. "Outcomes of interest were risk of transmission (ie, WHOdefined confirmed or probable COVID-19, SARS, or MERS) to people in health-care or non-health-care settings by those infected; hospitalisation; intensive care unit admission; death; time to recovery; adverse effects of interventions; and contextual factors such as acceptability, feasibility, effect on equity, and resource considerations related to the interventions of interest. However, data were only available to analyse intervention effects for transmission and contextual factors. Consistent with WHO, studies generally defined confirmed cases with laboratory confirmation (with or without symptoms) and probable cases with clinical evidence of the respective infection (ie, suspected to be infected) but for whom confirmatory testing either had not yet been done for any reason or was inconclusive."
- marcell 6y agoI dug through to find a few of the underlying studies on the topic of masks, which is a controversial topic. I looked at three of the studies they cited that had high N numbers for enrolled patients: [1] https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.04.20.20064899v1 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.04.20.20064899v... [2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12737864/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12737864/ [3] https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.04.20.20064899v1 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.04.20.20064899v... These studies all are focused on the protective aspect of masks: does a mask prevent you from getting various coronaviruses? Also, they are all focused on health care workers who interact with sick patients. The studies find that wearing masks and taking other protective steps reduces the danger to health care workers. There is big a leap though, from the conclusions of these studies to global mask mandates. Some reasons: (1) If masks protect the individual, then individuals can make their own decisions about mask use. If you are more concerned about getting covid, you wear a mask to protect yourself. (2) Health care workers interact with a lot more sick patients than the typical person. If interact zero or just a handful of sick patients a day, your risk calculation is a lot different than if you interact with a dozen sick people each day. (3) I haven't seen any studies that look at the benefit of wearing a mask all the time as oppose to wearing a mask when you have symptoms. This would be very interesting and relevant, since it's likely that the most contagious period is when you are sick (coughing, sneezing, sinus congestion) In all, digging into the data doesn't really support global, 100% mask mandates. It does support masks to protect yourself, and mask wearing in certain situations (hospitals, for example).