5 ms·
This article is more than three years old, but the story hasn't changed much. VC Summer was abandoned, leaving utility customers with massive bills. Vogtle so
by epistasis 6y ago
This article is more than three years old, but the story hasn't changed much. VC Summer was abandoned, leaving utility customers with massive bills. Vogtle soldiers on, but seems to be unlikely to finish.
Nucleae's problems are not the politics, the problem is that basic competency in design and construction logistics have been lost. Plans get delivered to construction that are "unconstructable," but construction soldiers on and wings it. Then it al has to go through design review again. And maybe redone. Delays delays delays. Incompetence abounds.
All the partners are planning from the beginning for a massive lawsuit at the end, and work harder to limit their liability (or create liability for others?) than to make the project work.
Executives lie about the progress, there are guilty pleas to fraud:
https://www.postandcourier.com/business/former-scana-executive-pleads-guilty-to-fraud-charges-tied-to-failed-sc-nuclear-project/article_26e23ca8-c50b-11ea-8377-e7b39854212b.html https://www.postandcourier.com/business/former-scana-executi...
20 years ago, I though nuclear was essential to fighting climate change. Today, I don't see how nuclear can ever help. We can't build it before it's too late, and by the time we build anything other technology has completely leapfrogged it.
We started these two AP-1000 reactors in 2008! A dozen years later we have nothing to show for it except for bankruptcy, plea deals, billions of dollars that would have been more effectively spent on solar and storage.
- CydeWeys 6y agoYup. For all the people boosting nuclear power, the reality on the ground seems to be that it just does not work anymore. It's way too expensive and never gets done, and this problem is global, not just in the US; see e.g. https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/energy/a33499619/france-nuclear-reactor-epr-expensive-mess/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/energy/a33499619/fr... At some point the results have to speak for themselves, and solar/wind plus battery storage is actually working and being built. That seems a more realistic path forward than nuclear power, which is demonstrably failing over and over.
- api 6y agoNuclear is superior in some ways, but battery and renewable is small, can be incrementally built, simple, safe, and is experiencing exponential cost reductions due to mass production scaling. It reminds me of TSMC leapfrogging Intel because of mobile volume or PCs vs custom Unix workstations.
- magicsmoke 6y agoThe incremental build is probably a big part of it. More volume and minor failures = more practice time and experience. How does someone "practice" building a nuclear power plant when failure can be so catastrophic?
- api 6y agoOh yeah... it's hard to get industrial scaling of expertise, production tech, and hands on experience when you're building a few monuments. If we do make nuclear fission work it will be with modular reactors and standardized fuel form factors, etc. Fusion won't fly even if we get over unity fusion unless we adopt a similar approach. Fusion reactors like to be big, but I can see them being composed of mass producible smaller modules and parts. Settling on a standard design that can be mass produced could make it work. Thing is: as the nuclear people work to try to make anything above a reality, we are experiencing iterative rapid development in solar, wind, and batteries, with all of these getting geometrically cheaper until they approach the naked cost of the materials and the energy required to refine them... and the latter cost (energy) will drop as we get better at making these things. In the long term I would not be surprised if Earth is almost 100% solar/wind/hydro/geothermal powered. You might see nuclear used in niche markets that combine high population density with low insolation and insufficient other resources and where geopolitical concerns make reliance on long distance power transport problematic. Earth is pretty close to a giant free fusion reactor that we don't need to worry about maintaining for at least two billion years. Nuclear power will be for space settlements further from the sun and deep space travel. I could see Mars eventually relying on fusion in the far future. Mars is further from the sun, and most people who talk about settling there drastically underestimate the massive amounts of energy that will be needed to refine and purify literally every single material all the way down to the air and the water. The total energy footprint of your average Martian will be at least 10-20X your average Texan with a giant raised pickup and a 4000 square foot house.
- kurthr 6y agoYes, but what will we do if/when wind and solar just "doesn't work anymore". In the US trains "don't work anymore"... but they do in other countries. This gradual erosion of technical capability is a generic problem the US needs to solve. Nuclear is a case study of what is wrong and where the problems are (political, business, education).
- CydeWeys 6y agoIt's a good point, but I think we can fix trains more easily than nuclear power plants, because as you point out at least the trains are a solved problem in many other countries that would simply just emulate. And passenger trains have serviceable enough fallbacks (planes, Megabus, etc.), like solar/wind are proving to be fallbacks for nuclear.
- coredog64 6y agoThis is a mischaracterization of the state of US rail. The US has prioritized freight rail over passenger rail. That’s not a terrible choice given the long distances and the lower sensitivity to slower, more efficient speeds.
- manicdee 6y agoThe way the US chose to address accidents in rail was to armour plate their rail cars. In Europe they worked on better processes to ensure trains don’t run into each other in the first place. The erosion of technical capability in rail is driven by the legislature. You have many states that will need to work together to completely abandon the US regulations on rail, adopt European regulations, and replace every piece of rolling stock to comply with the new regulations. That’s quite the undertaking, but achievable since the required expertise still exists outside the USA. The erosion of technical capability in nuclear power is likely unsolvable. There is no brains trust outside the USA from which to borrow the knowledge of metallurgy, concrete, site preparation, building design, or even design for manufacture. This is rebooting the entire industry from scratch to produce an unprofitable product.
- bobthepanda 6y ago
- enaaem 6y agoPeople have been saying for 30 years that solar/wind are going to take off and that we don't need nuclear. We are now in a climate crisis, and solar/wind is still a fraction of the energy portfolio. We als can't build nuclear anymore, because we have lost decades of experience. I really hope you are correct this time.
- ldiracdelta 6y agoThe economics are changing though. An idealized stock market return is (used to be) 11.8%/year. This interest, compounded, doubles your position every 7 years. Once solar has a break even period of less than 7 years, the investment in solar beats a rosy, idealized stock market. When the payoff period drops to 4 years, you'd be an idiot _not_to do solar, because you're looking at an investment returning numbers in the credit card interest rate range. I bought my current system for $45k four years ago. I only did it because the investment math worked in my case. (Yes, yes yes. It was for sure subsidized and the investment math _didn't_ work without the subsidies.) Now, however, that same system would cost me ~$20k. I checked when my coworker was looking into solar and wanted to run the numbers. The economics of solar are approaching beat-the-[idealized]-stock market investment. 4 years is a rule-of-thumb number for many businesses for investing in capital. That is, if a capital investment breaks even in 4 years, you pull the trigger. Once the economics hits 4 years for break even, you'll see a lot of CFO's start pulling the trigger, not to mention the encouragement from the marketing department for the optics. Anyways, I think it is coming and for many of us, it is already here.
- zackees 6y agoI love how people here are trying to say that technology simply does not progress forward for nuclear, as it does for every other technolgy.
- CydeWeys 6y agoIt's a factual, descriptive argument. Nuclear takes so long to build and is so expensive that it's not really being built anymore, and thus the progress isn't happening.
- manigandham 6y agoIt's expensive because it includes much more of the externalities in the price with much longer time-frames for ROI, as compared to other sources like coal or natural gas. Nuclear as a power source is fantastic. One of the biggest operators is the US Navy which has been running reactors in military vessels for decades without incident. The problem is politics, ignorance and lack of will to actually see it through, not fundamental science or tech.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> One of the biggest operators is the US Navy which has been running reactors in military vessels for decades without incident. AFAICT, none publicly acknowledged since a bunch in the 1970s, but that may mean less than it seems since the US government has a history of covering up nuclear incidents for decades (like a whole slew at the Hanford site from the 1940s-1980s that weren't acknowledged until the 1980s.)
- manigandham 6y agoHanford was for nuclear production, not power generation, and was created during the early days of nuclear weapons research. Modern reactors are in an entirely different league with an incredible safety record. [1] Considering how easy it is to detect nuclear failures and the consequences in a tightly-enclosed ship, it's unlikely that there are any serious incidents. It's clear that they're experience and technology is continuing to get better every year though. 1. https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2019/12/23/americas-nuclear-navy-still-the-masters-of-nuclear-power/#5ee0d3466bcd https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2019/12/23/americas-...
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Hanford was for nuclear production, not power generation, and was created during the early days of nuclear weapons research. I'm not saying that Hanford has the same risk profile as Naval reactors, I’m saying that it demonstrates that the US government has a propensity for covering up nuclear incidents that it can get away with covering up (note that it also acknowledged other incidents at Hanford in the decades it was concealing many of them), so the fact that it hasn't acknowledged any related to naval power generation since a bunch in the 1970s is absence of evidence of such incidents, but not reliable evidence of absence of such incidents.
- pstuart 6y agoI'm pro renewables but Asimov made an impact on how nuclear is the power of the future and it would be nice to have it in our portfolio. The only likelihood of nuclear power succeeding would be to containerize the reactors to ensure build quality, keep costs down, and to address scaling. A quick search hit this company that appears to be promoting this very thing: http://www.holosgen.com/ http://www.holosgen.com/
- toomuchtodo 6y agoNuclear is the future of power on Mars (containerized and launched on reliable person rated launch vehicles). It's clear we're not going to build it successfully on Earth, and that's okay. Renewables and batteries are faster and cheaper to build on Earth.
- epistasis 6y agoI think you are right, that the power of science fiction has clouded people's judgement of what the future will really be like. Today, I don't think we can consider nuclear a good or modern energy system when compared to something like solar or wind. Nuclear is used as a heat source to boil water and power a turbine, and throws away half of its thermal energy as waste. disposing of that waste heat is becoming so difficult that reactors in France power down in hot days. This is not some sort of super futuristic power source!! While small modular reactors are the only near term hope for nuclear, I think that fission is not a good fit for terrestrial power. And fusion is no better until we have direct conversion or some other massive tech leap.
- CydeWeys 6y agoGood point about heat waste disposal. That's why you almost always see nuclear reactors along lakes/rivers/oceans, which is bad for other reasons as we saw with Fukushima, and all of that hot water being released wreaks havoc with riparian/marine ecosystems. Nuclear has downsides beyond the most obvious one, that of the risk of fallout. > I think that fission is not a good fit for terrestrial power. Heh, it's even worse off-planet. If you think dumping the waste heat is hard when you have access to an atmosphere/large bodies of water, wait until you try it when you don't!! ;)
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoAnd the root of this is essentially politics keeping competent people from getting interested in nuclear. We can't do nuclear properly because society tells all the smart engineers and financiers that they should be doing other things. A lot of "boring things" suffer from this problem.
- epistasis 6y agoI don't think that's true. We had the same construction problems in the 70s when we wouldn't have had such a shortage. There are tons of super smart people working on nuclear startups right now, with big funding. It's all bad management, bad execution, and bad promises. And since few of any around the world have been able to keep construction promises recently, it may just be part of the natural variability of the construction process. And 2-3x variability is not a desirable trait for $10B projects, where most of the lifetime cost is in the upfront construction.
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoYeah, you are right. The part that causes these projects to fail isn't the nuclear part. It's the construction part. You can't just take a construction crew that's used to building highways or skyscrapers and expect them to build a nuclear complex properly. This was the exact problem they had in the 70s, the contractors didn't understand why things had to be done a certain way, so they did it the way they thought it should be done. Then it turned out that the problems that many of the safety and operational issues that occurred later were due to not doing it properly in the first place. Nuclear is sexy, construction isn't. There is a great book on the history of the US nuclear power industry that goes into this called Beyond Engineering: How Technology Shapes Society. The technical issues were only a small part of why nuclear power is not more widely used. Countries like France that standardized on reactor design and had enough projects that construction crews could gain experience with the different processes and requirements involved were much more successful in deploying nuclear power.
- brandmeyer 6y ago> the problem is that basic competency in design and construction logistics have been lost I don't think this is just a nuclear problem. This is a civil engineering problem more broadly. IMO, the exact same forces which make nuclear impractical now are also responsible for the horrific budget explosions and overruns in big projects all over the US.
- epistasis 6y agoYes, I think you are right, and it's a damn shame because there are so many infrastructure projects that we desperately need: high speed rail, commuter trains, subways, inexpensive housing builds with high du/acre and walkable designs... My guess is that by the time we have regained any such capacity, renewable and storage will be cheaper than the thermodynamic process of harvesting heat and turning it into electricity; a process that has been hyper optimized for a century without much progress, and which has hit the wall of thermodynamics in efficiency. The only way to improve its cost would be far cheaper materials, a revolution which might happen with 3D printing, but which is super speculative today.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoWhile I think we need efficient housing designs, I don't think we need high speed rail and commuter trains in the US. As much of that functionality as possible should be replaced with internet connectivity. There is no reason to be spending enormous sums per mile when we can find ways to destroy demand for moving atoms instead of bits. The cheapest mile of high speed or commuter rails it the mile you didn't build. Efficient homes, renewables, ubiquitous internet connectivity, and electric vehicles are going to be your targets as people spend more time at their homes and the trips they make can be electrified. (the above comment is predicated on developing countries aging rapidly causing workers to leave the workforce, the quick uptake of remote work due to the pandemic forcing employers to learn how to support it, and data showing people fleeing cities for the suburbs and lower density living arrangements in general)
- ramshanker 6y agoI believe civil engineering part of nuclear reactor is it's easiest parts.
- zackees 6y agoWait until this guy finds out France is nearly all nuclear and did it at 1/10th the cost of solar and wind. Are people not able to do an internet search for this stuff? All this data is right out there in the open.
- dv_dt 6y agohttps://www.popularmechanics.com/science/energy/a33499619/france-nuclear-reactor-epr-expensive-mess/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/energy/a33499619/fr... France is going to retire end of life nuclear reactors and replace them with renewables, while their new generation reactors have had all the same cost and schedule overruns as elsewhere. Including BTW, China, which did all the construction expertise management for nuclear that the experts recommend - e.g. using the same crews the build multiple reactors, moving them from project to project. China too stopped building new reactors in favor of more renewables.
- wahern 6y ago> while their new generation reactors have had all the same cost and schedule overruns as elsewhere Reactor, singular. They've only tried to build one new reactor this century, Flamanville #3. Civaux reactors were finished in 1997. As in the U.S., it's clear the cost issue is primarily related to public sentiment, not fundamentals. France's existing nuclear energy infrastructure was built at a time when France was very pro-nuclear, and nuclear was a matter of national pride, thus the gall to sink the Rainbow Warrior. Times have changed, for better (less investment in nuclear weapons, appetite for murdering civilians) and worse (less support for nuclear energy). > China too stopped building new reactors in favor of more renewables. "China will build six to eight nuclear reactors a year between 2020 and 2025 and raise total capacity to 70 gigawatts (GW), up 43.5% compared to the end of May, the official China Daily said on Thursday, citing the country’s nuclear association." https://in.reuters.com/article/china-nuclearpower/china-to-build-6-8-nuclear-reactors-a-year-from-2020-2025-report-idINKBN24A0DL https://in.reuters.com/article/china-nuclearpower/china-to-b... Since 2011, over 30 reactors have come online, 3 of which began construction after Fukushima: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_reactors#China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_reactors#China
- ericcumbee 6y agoI live with in about 40 miles of Plant Vogtle and thats not really an accurate assessment. They have had to reshuffle some of the work due to COVID-19. but last I saw all of the major construction milestones on unit 3 are complete. its just down to ancillaries. Cold Hydro testing is slated to be conducted this fall and initial fuel loading by end of year. They are still on track for production to start Nov 2021 and 2022 for unit 4. https://allongeorgia.com/georgia-business/georgia-power-announces-resequencing-of-vogtle-units-3-4-planned-activities/ https://allongeorgia.com/georgia-business/georgia-power-anno...