3 ms·
This is a great clarification. It's a shame that Wikipedia is such a bad reference for learning maths. I think it is a result of most maths articles being edite
by IshKebab 6y ago
This is a great clarification. It's a shame that Wikipedia is such a bad reference for learning maths. I think it is a result of most maths articles being edited by people who just learnt something and therefore don't understand it enough to explain it well, and also want to show off their knowledge rather than actually explain things.
Mathworld is much much better in general.
(Somebody's probably going to reply "Wikipedia is an encyclopaedia not a tutorial".)
- nl 6y agoThis is absolutely correct. Wikipdia math pages (and for some sciences too) are correct in the details and yet provide no insight. It's almost backwards what you want from an encyclopedia, which should be an overview with references to more details.
- ducttapecrown 6y agoWell, the insight each person needs varies.
- edflsafoiewq 6y agoThe matrix article is really unusually bad. One of the problems, I think, is that there are competing "views" of linear algebra. Mathematics students are taught a different class than everyone else where vector spaces and linear functions are brought to the fore. Everyone else seems to get a more computation-focused course. So there's a tension there where if you write a math-style article about matrices where this fact about the columns would probably be the definition of a matrix, everyone else might not even recognize what's going on. There's also the issue that the current article is so sprawling that refactoring it to subject it to a unifying plan would require a large rewrite, and that's hard in an environment like Wikipedia.
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoWikipedia is great when you already know a math topic and just need to look something up, but is terrible at teaching math. Generally the level of abstraction is too high and too general for a first introduction to a topic.
- swimfar 6y agoI find that sometimes even when I'm familiar with a topic, it ends up being a bad reference. This is especially true when they start introducing variables and constants that haven't even been defined.
- benrbray 6y agoFor what it's worth, I find that Wikipedia is a great place to learn about more advanced topics in abstract algebra / analysis / category theory. For example, the representation theory [1] page gives some pretty good context for how it relates to other fields. It's not the same as a textbook, but generally, after reading the Wikipedia page, I know enough new terminology to intelligently Google for more complete resources like lecture notes, papers, etc.. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Representation_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Representation_theory