5 ms·
In fairness, if people drink this everyday, as some do, it's hardly Coca Cola's fault. It's quite obvious that obesity is caused by a bad diet. People should w
by mytailorisrich 6y ago
In fairness, if people drink this everyday, as some do, it's hardly Coca Cola's fault.
It's quite obvious that obesity is caused by a bad diet. People should watch their diet. The rest is just politics: politicians don't want to blame people and companies don't want to be used as scapegoats.
We also need to accept that the vast majority of people are neither victims nor stupid. People do make choices knowing that they are not good for their health. I think that at least some of the anti-experts trend we see is a reaction against being told what to do on the ground that people cannot decide for themselves.
- arvinsim 6y agoThere are general guidelines on what food is good for your but there is no universal “good” or “bad” diet. Before, fats were demonized. Now it’s carbs and sugars. Who knows what “good” diet will constitute in the future.
- WaxProlix 6y agoI don't think that's particularly fair, actually. When you're bombarded with images of attractive people doing a thing, your brain will naturally associate the two. And that's just the obvious ad tilting that anyone can see and everyone agrees with. You and I got educations (probably) and have spent time intentionally building up defenses to this sort of thing (also probably), but it's definitely on the companies for making what amounts to misleading propaganda. To some extent, at least.
- searchableguy 6y agoEven intelligent and self aware people will fall for this given a bad environment. You can be aware of how harmful something is while doing it yet won't stop because it feels better on short term. That's what addiction is and soft drinks definitely fall into that.
- james_s_tayler 6y agoNot to mention the trap that those who are addicted to it will often place others in situations where it's more present and can form or reinforce habits in others.
- imtringued 6y agoChildren sit at the same dining table as their parents. It's pretty much guaranteed that they will have the same diet.
- Spooky23 6y agoIt’s marketed like cigarettes. The number of activities associated with Coke is astounding.
- remarkEon 6y agoOne of the hard lessons I learned when I was younger was that some (or many, depending on the sample population we're talking about) don't actually have as much agency as you do, or as much agency as they like to pretend. It's a hard lesson, because it rubs up against many of the core values you grow up with in a country like the US - freedom of choice, personal responsibility, etc. So, yeah, people really should watch their diet, but that's only a part of the broader issue.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoGorging on soft drinks is a choice. Trying to pass off people as victims is counterproductive but the easy thing to do politically. Of course, 'some' people will always do something. This is not an argument because if we go that way we ought to ban everything.
- zepto 6y agoAre you suggesting that advertising doesn’t work?
- mytailorisrich 6y agoThat's not the problem. Ads may influence consumption but (over-)consumption is a choice. It's a fallacy to conflate both.
- zepto 6y agoIf ads increase consumption then they increase overconsumption too. Claiming otherwise would require an explanation.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Hnrobert42 6y agoThere is a middle ground. People are responsible for their actions, but so are corporations. If the conclusions in this article are correct, Coke deliberately misled people. So do we say to society, “Coke would have you believe it’s calories vs. calories out. Run a mile. Drink a Coke. It’s all good. The truth, though, is that it is mostly about diet. However, Coke can say whatever it wants. It’s a free country. If you can’t figure it out, if Coke fights to shape news, medical publications, educational material, and every other way you could find the truth, well, sucks to be you.”? Or do we say, “Coke misled you. They will be held responsible for their actions corporately and individually. Here is what literature not funded by motivated parties says. It says that if you drink a lot of Coke, whether you exercise or not, you will get fat. If you are ok with that, fine. If not, now you know.”?
- licebmi__at__ 6y agoIt's nor really about what people do. Is about what society can do. Society can and should impose costs and penalties for the behavior that is costing everyone. Coca cola is not lobbying for individuals not realizing sugar is bad and stop buying their products, they're lobbying against a sugar tax, or if you don't like taxes, against the insurance companies having justification to implement a coca cola clause.
- parineum 6y agoWithout public healthcare, I don't see a justification for taxes on things that cause poor health.
- ssijak 6y agoThere is also a problem of marketing junk to kids, and parents buying that junk for their kids who cant know better.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoI have children. When they see some ad and ask me to buy something, if I think it's not a good idea I just say 'no'. That's a parent's job to do so. Marketing does not cause bad parenting. But, again, politicians find it less risky to tell people (electors...) "Oh poor you, you're doing all you can and you're doing a great job but those companies undermine you with all those ads" rather than "You're a parent, take your responsibilities and do your job". And unfortunately some people buy that because it's also more comfortable than facing the music.
- rbecker 6y agoCoca-Cola just engineers the environment to maximally exploit human weaknesses. But it is ultimately the people's fault for not being iron-willed über-mensch and resisting temptation. Whatever the people do to fight this, they should do it individually, and not consider any pesky freedom-infringing legislation (such as banning vending machines in schools, or soft drinks in school cafeterias, or a tax on soft drinks). Act alone - there's one of you, and one Coca-Cola. One versus one - fair, right?
- hegtor 6y agoOne versus one? When comparing a single person and a massive corporation? Or I might be missing the sarcasm there maybe
- Hnrobert42 6y agoYou are missing it. ;-)
- p1necone 6y agoPersonal responsibility doesn't work in aggregate.
- hegtor 6y agoIt is possible to tax unhealthy products to compensate for the toll they create on people health and subsequent costs to society. Tobacco is heavily taxed, and so is alcohol. While buying coke is close to the price of mineral water.
- tiew9Vii 6y agoIt's Coca-Cola's fault paying scientists to downplay how sweet drinks are related to obesity. It's Coca-Cola's fault not using morbidly obese people in their marketing campaigns and instead choosing physically fit, attractive people, those who realistically will not be drinking much Coca-Cola to get their gym bods because of the sugar it has. A 375ml can of coke is 161 calories / 40g of sugar. Two 375ml cans a day is the equivalent of a small meal calorie wise with no nutritional benefit, only 80g of sugar. People are essentially having multiple meals a day on top of their solid food by drinking soft drinks and unknowingly or through ignorance are in massive calorie surplus. Anyone who goes to a gym and in good shape knows it's 80% food 20% time working out. Your food is more important than the workout. It's not in Coca-Cola's interest to educate people advertising CocalCola as a very poor liquid meal consisting of only sugar.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoPeople know that their diet is what make them obese. People know how much sugar there is in Coke and soft drinks. It is frankly ridiculous to claim that in 2020 people are ignorant or misled.
- ageitgey 6y agoThere's a big difference between what you know as an abstract fact vs. what seems normal in your society. By definition, normal people do what is normal in their society. I've lived in the southeastern US, various places in California, China and Europe. The type of consumption that is considered normal is so vastly different in all those places. In the southeastern US, your whole environment is telling you that eating enormous meals, drinking sugary drinks, etc, is totally normal. If you are responsible, maybe you could cut back a little to "watch your health". But you are starting from an unhealthy default setting and you have to dig yourself out of a pit to get back to 'healthy'. This includes Atlanta, the home of Coke (where I went to college and lived several years). In southern California or even more so in Europe, the norms are vastly different. Meals are much smaller and sugary drinks aren't assumed. Healthier options are available nearly everywhere. But in Europe, things go much further than even the healthiest parts of the US. The very composition of basic foods is different - brand name foods are less sugary and contain less preservatives than the same brands in the US, staple foods like bread are less shelf stable but contain less additives, and so on. Things like Kraft Mac & Cheese, Snickers bars and Doritos chips are literally illegal in Europe with their original US formulations and are produced with tweaked ingredients. It's in the very DNA of society to default to a more healthy lifestyle. Sure, it's possible to be unhealthy but the default setting of your environment is much healthier so more people are healthy. The point is that people operate at a default setting that seems normal for their society. Some will be healthy minded and will outperform the norm for their area, but not everyone will. If you want a healthy population, you need a healthy norm and no amount of telling people to take responsibility is going to fix a society if literally every food easily available is bad for you. There is just a mountain of public health evidence that shows this to be true.
- imtringued 6y agoThere is quite a large difference between a handful of individuals becoming more obese and everyone becoming more obese. > In fairness, if people drink this everyday, as some do, it's hardly Coca Cola's fault. It's hardly coca cola's fault that they paid scientists to lie? This article is not about individual behavior. >It's quite obvious that obesity is caused by a bad diet. It's less obvious when a company uses its market power to distort science and encourage bad diets.