5 ms·
One of the reasons this is important is that it's quite hard to get a visa for many EU Countries. If Germany opened a skilled\tech\finance visa program, you'd
by LatteLazy 6y ago
One of the reasons this is important is that it's quite hard to get a visa for many EU Countries. If Germany opened a skilled\tech\finance visa program, you'd easily see double the current number. I'm not sure whether they've held off because they don't want to do it or as a show of goodwill for the "negotiations" but they would be doing themselves and many decent people a favour if they pulled the trigger. Brexiteers won't be reasoned with and being reasonable is seen as weakness by them.
- bjornsing 6y ago> Brexiteers won't be reasoned with and being reasonable is seen as weakness by them. This “reasonableness is weakness” thing seems to be a more and more clear trend in western culture... It’s quite disturbing and seems very dangerous to me. Or is it something that’s been circulating for a long time, just that I haven’t noticed?
- Sambdala 6y agoIt's the 'movie' version of negotiating that plays to a populist crowd. It intersects with other 'tough guy' identity tropes that are being (successfully) used in domestic political battles to gain power, and then are repositioned to be used in foreign relations with predictably terrible outcomes. The problem is the audience of the negotiating stance isn't the counterparty, it's the domestic base who elected you because they were fed up with nuance and are suspicious of the counterparty. This isn't just a Brexit problem, but is much more widespread. I don't know how you'd be able to align incentives any worse.
- blaser-waffle 6y ago> It's the 'movie' version of negotiating that plays to a populist crowd. See also: "the art of the deal" > The problem is the audience of the negotiating stance isn't the counterparty, it's the domestic base who elected you because they were fed up with nuance and are suspicious of the counterparty. Not just the nuance, but the lack of dramatic change, a handful of examples of bad behavior by the party of nuance being equally corrupt or useless, and a constant stream of propaganda highlighting that.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoI don’t think people disagree more than they ever used to. I do think however that people are much more likely to judge those who disagree with them as simply being bad people, and are therefor willing to just dismiss their point of view entirely. Which is pretty much what the parent comment is doing. For anybody who’s legitimately curious about why Brexiteers so firmly won’t be reasoned with, I’d suggest you take a look at this survey that shows how much less likely remain voters are to understand the motives of leave voters, than leave voters are to understand the motives of remain voters. https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/brexit/2018/05/04/leavers-have-a-better-understanding-of-remainers-motivations-than-vice-versa/ https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/brexit/2018/05/04/leavers-have-a-bet... Really I think most people generally agree on what they want from society. Outside of the fringes, the primary points of contention revolve around how to prioritize issues over other issues, and the specifics of the approach to solving them.
- LatteLazy 6y agoRespectfully, I have talked to hundreds of brexiteers and looked at everything they claim. Then dismissed it. It's exposure, not a lack of exposure that makes me dismiss them. As far as I can tell (I am no social scientist) they'd be flat-earthers or anti-vaxers but they got got caught up in brexit first...
- AmericanChopper 6y agoIf only they were less unreasonable...
- LatteLazy 6y agoI think this whole thing has really taught me a lot. One aspect of that is that people are not rational by nature. Another is that we cannot change that about them and actually it's as much a force of nature as a hurricane or an earthquake. You cannot argue or reason with any of these forces. Our mistake has been failing to build quake proof cities, not failing to appreciate the earthquakes point of view...
- corty 6y agohttps://ec.europa.eu/immigration/blue-card_en https://ec.europa.eu/immigration/blue-card_en
- LatteLazy 6y agoThis is a really useful site, I looked at it when the Brexit vote happened but I was told I couldn't apply until the UK actually exited. Since we have now technically left the EU, but we haven't actually left it for any legal, economic or trade purposes, do you know if I can start applying? God this whole thing is a huge mess...
- csunbird 6y agoAt least in Germany, they give special residence permits right now for British citizens as a temporary solution. Edit: if you live in Berlin: https://service.berlin.de/dienstleistung/328595/ https://service.berlin.de/dienstleistung/328595/
- skissane 6y ago"Blue Card" is a directive. That means that the EU legislates the high-level principles, but implementation is up to each member state. So each member state's government and immigration authorities gets to fill in the missing details in the rules for themselves. Hence, the answer to your question is likely going to depend on which member state you are applying to. Not all EU member states have implemented Blue Card. Ireland and Denmark have an opt-out of EU immigration policy under the EU treaties. (So did the United Kingdom prior to Brexit.) All other member states are supposed to implement it, but the issue with directives is that member states often fail to do so at all, or fail to do so properly. The European Commission can prosecute them in the European Court of Justice for those failures, which can result in them being fined by the EU.
- dcminter 6y agoUnder the withdrawal agreement you don't need a visa to move to or work in an EU country until the end of the withdrawal agreement. If you do so, get a job there, and register that you have done so (details depend on country), then you can stay there after the end of December. What you won't then be able to do is move freely to another EU country, and it does potentially get tricky if you lose your job. So if you seriously plan to move, now is a very good time to do it. Lots of info here: https://britishineurope.org/ https://britishineurope.org/
- Proven 6y ago> quite hard to get a visa for many EU Countries. It’s much easier to illegally immigrate. I don’t get it - why would a Brit want to go to the EU. Those who are already stuck in there, fine. I bet in 1-2 years net balance will be in favor of the UK. Even now, if we accounted for those EU people who will attempt to stay in the U.K., I doubt there will be any brain drain. The EU is done.
- monoclechris 6y ago> Brexiteers won't be reasoned with and being reasonable is seen as weakness by them. Theresa May's deal was remain in all but name and there was multiple opportunities to vote in favour of it over a period of years. The only compromise willing to be accepted by the remain camp was complete capitulation.
- uzakov 6y agoIt's also quite hard to get a work visa for UK. Also, Germany already has a skilled\tech\finance program for non-EU citizens
- LatteLazy 6y agoThis is the problem for Brits looking to leave: We weren't eligible for many visas because we were part of the EU so we didn't need them. Now we are leaving but no one has setup visas on either side since there is ongoing negotiations and other issues to contend with. So now we've "fallen between two stools". >It's also quite hard to get a work visa for UK The UK has had enough of experts...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- uzakov 6y agoIn the worst case scenario British citizens will have to apply for work visas like non-EU citizens? Ie skilled workers will apply for skilled workers visa and compete against non-EU citizens? > The UK has had enough of experts... What do you mean?
- rawbot 6y agoThere is already a very good skilled/tech visa for all of EU, including Germany. It's called the EU Blue Card (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Card_%28European_Union%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Card_%28European_Union%29). It's an amazing way to move to the EU, and in Germany it's a really easy way to get Permanent Residence (you can do it in 21 months, if you learn German up to B1, or 36 otherwise). It also guarantees a high enough salary (55k minimum).
- dogma1138 6y agoBlue cards are extremely hard to get and most EU member states don’t issue them (they haven’t passed the legislation to support it). There are far far easier way and often under much better terms to get a work visa in virtually any EU member state as both skilled and unskilled workers.
- realityking 6y agoWorking for a mid-sized Berlin startup, most of my coworkers who are not EU citizens and don't yet have permanent residency are working here on a Blue card. Especially for folks from the US, Canada and Australia it seems really easy to get - you can even apply for it in-country.
- dogma1138 6y agoYou could only apply in country from a specific set of countries, it's easy to get if you have a recognized higher education degree and a job offer of over 55K (45K in Tech).
- csunbird 6y agoThey are really not hard to get, especially in Germany. Obtaining the visa to enter the country and starting the work, took only a day (plus another day for the consulate to ship my passport) and the card was issued within 6 weeks after my appointment with foreigners office. Although, getting the appointment with foreigners office took 5 months (after my first entry to the country), because of the high number of applicants, but they have a legislation that automatically extends your visa if you have an appointment for a long term residence permit.
- goatinaboat 6y agoBrexiteers won't be reasoned with and being reasonable is seen as weakness by them. But that's not true at all. If you asked a Brexiteer, they would say Article 50 could have been invoked the day after the referendum, and instead they spent 2 whole years trying to find an accommodation that would satisfy Remainers too, you can't ask for any more "reasoning with" than that. But Remainers wouldn't budge from the position of ignoring the referendum result completely, they had no regard whatsoever for the wishes of Brexiteers. None at all. We could have had such a soft Brexit that it would have been indistinguishable from remaining, but hardline Remainers made that all but impossible with their intransigence. Eventually the entire country grew tired of those antics and delivered Boris an 80-seat majority on his single mantra of "get Brexit done". I know this is off-narrative but the Brexiteers bent over backwards to be reasonable.
- jjgreen 6y agoI think you will find that that is Cummings's mantra; credit where it's due.
- pjc50 6y agoNo, it was the insistence on avoiding ECJ jurisdiction and ending free movement that caused hard Brexit. Nothing more. There was no support from conservatives for the softer "indicative votes".
- ben_w 6y agoThat’s not what it looked like from the outside. From the outside, Leavers ran the government. Leavers insisted that May was a great negotiator by holding her cards close to her chest (and then fired her ASAP when they saw her cards). From the outside, Leavers openly told Remainers that Leavers had no reason to compromise with anyone — not the EU, not Remainers, and not each other. Every time I discussed anything with a Leaver, my concerns were always and without fail dismissed as “Project Fear” — the other party would even say that about the possibility of no deal while saying no deal was their negotiating tactic. Now, I don’t doubt that you’ve seen some idiots promoting Remain just as I’ve seen idiots promoting Leave — but can you give any example of Leave trying to compromise with Remain? Not with each other (basically everyone hates what May came up with, Remain and Leave alike), not with the EU, but with Remain?
- DrBazza 6y agoGermany, in particular is one of the worst places for tech start ups isn't it? https://startups.co.uk/best-european-cities-for-startups/ https://startups.co.uk/best-european-cities-for-startups/
- sgift 6y agoAccording to some very weird methodology which looks like they decided beforehand which cities they want to have on top and then build a methodology to ensure it happens.
- DrBazza 6y agoI'd read somewhere else that start-up costs in Germany are prohibitive vs. just about anywhere else in Europe, but I can't find that article. Personal experience trumps that of a journalist though.
- LatteLazy 6y agoIt's probably a matter of personal opinion and choice and opportunity. Berlin has a tech startup sector (supposedly) almost as big as London. So whether it's a good place to start a company may not matter: if it is where all the jobs are, and I need a job then I'm there. I do Fintech, so I'm looking at a niche of startups. That pushes me to Berlin, Frankfurt, Paris and Zurich as those are the (non London) finance hubs in the EU. But if I saw a job where I could work remotely or where they were based elsewhere, I'd go elsewhere. I actually just started working remotely for a company technically incorporated in London. So once I pass probation etc, I may go to Germany to master my German. But as you indicate, I'd find a place with good work life balance and low costs and opportunities that suit me. Not just blindly walk to Berlin. :)
- Nursie 6y ago> Brexiteers won't be reasoned with and being reasonable is seen as weakness by them. Respectfully, neither will many 'remainers'. There are many who refuse to even consider reasons people may have had for wanting to leave, and insist on viewing everything through a lens of presumed racism. I voted to remain, but not through any great conviction. I don't believe that any sort of responsive democracy is really possible at the scale of the EU, and I do believe that the democratic institutions of the EU are lacking. We know that comparatively not all that many British people make much use of freedom of movement. I also don't believe that all concerns about the volume and speed of immigration to the UK should be brushed off as mere xenophobia or racism, in light of housing shortages. That's not to say that these necessarily add up to a leave vote, they didn't in my case, nor that leaving the EU will fix anything. But to view the entirety of 17 million leave voters as unreasonable by definition, well that's pretty unreasonable itself.
- moystard 6y agoThe vote was a close one; it should have been taken into account to come up with a compromise. I think remainers were ready to accept a soft Brexit and everyone would have moved on. It would have represented a loss of influence for the UK (it's going to happen anyway), but it would not have been the shit show that we have seen since then. The soft Brexit proposition exploded right after the vote, and Brexiters started pushing for a very hard Brexit. I disagree with your statement on the democracy not working at the scale of the EU. The EU is a democratic institution, with limited responsibilities (the UK famously fought back against tighter integration). Recent history in the EU has shown that people are ready for more integration now that the UK is (unfortunately) gone (as seen 2 weeks ago with the common debt).
- Nursie 6y ago> I think remainers were ready to accept a soft Brexit and everyone would have moved on. > The soft Brexit proposition exploded right after the vote, I've not seen much evidence of this particularly, our parliament spent a long time arguing over exactly what flavour of soft brexit might be acceptable while both hard brexiter and hard remainer minorities postured and shouted and in some cases started legal proceedings. Eventually the different groups blocked and barracked each other so much the whole thing fell apart. Outside of parliament there were plenty of cheerleaders for just leaving, absent any ongoing agreement, but also plenty for finding methods to overturn the entire thing. > I disagree with your statement on the democracy not working at the scale of the EU. But you understand that I have an opinion based on looking at the EU and at other large democracies (like the US), observing how their political classes are remote from the public and relatively unaccountable, and how hard it seems to be for citizens to affect change? As compared to somewhere like Iceland, where a small movement can have a big effect? And you grant that it is a reasonable opinion to hold even if you yourself don't hold it and disagree with it being important? That's my point here really, we don't have to agree, but casting everyone that disagrees you as unreasonable and unwilling to listen to reason is not a good thing. Though it does seem to happen in a lot of public discourse these days.
- tormeh 6y agoIt's not that hard for Germany. The problem is more that there are multiple competing schemes, and it's kind of a mess. Make-it-in-germany.com should be a good guide