4 ms·
> I want to pay a one off price for a stable and feature complete tool. I don’t want to fund a bunch of developers noodling around with new features I don’t wan
by taneq 6y ago
> I want to pay a one off price for a stable and feature complete tool. I don’t want to fund a bunch of developers noodling around with new features I don’t want, or fixing bugs they should be patching anyway, as part of the original price of the software.
Of course you do. So do I!
However, the bunch of developers wants you to fund them noodling around indefinitely, and sadly they're the ones that choose the business model.
If only FreeCAD had a UI as approachable as Fusion 360...
- david_draco 6y ago> If only FreeCAD had a UI as approachable as Fusion 360... You could pay a random professional software company to improve the FreeCAD UI.
- adventured 6y ago> You could pay a random professional software company to improve the FreeCAD UI. Software develoment is of course quite difficult. Good software development is that much harder. Sure, you could pay a company to try to improve the FreeCAD UI - you could pay a company a lot of money to botch the effort, deliver a mediocre outcome, take a zillion years to finish, go far over budget it while still getting a mediocre outcome, and so on. If it's anything other than a good outcome, most likely you just stole resources from the rest of your business and now you're worse off. The odds are against you. It's one of the many reasons people stick with their 75% or 85% good enough present solution. They're busy running their own business. Trying to manage a software development endeavor on the side is a huge tax (that much more so if you're not in the software business).
- taneq 6y ago> It's one of the many reasons people stick with their 75% or 85% good enough present solution. 100% this. That's one thing many people don't realise until they run a business - there are so many things which MUST be done, all the time, just to keep the lights on. When you do get a rare gap in those, you're better off developing and improving your core product than indulging yourself by spending resources on some unrelated nice-to-have.
- taneq 6y agoThis is true, but in a strange sort of tragedy of the commons, it's much cheaper for me personally to just fork out for Fusion and put up with their cloud shenanigans than it is to pay for improvements to FreeCAD. I'm edging closer to getting the source code and digging in in my spare time, though.
- snarfy 6y agoThe problem with FreeCAD, and open source CAD in general, is we have two choices: OpenCASCADE and CGAL. FreeCAD is based on OpenCASCADE. I've used both libraries and OpenCASCADE really left a bad taste in my mouth. It's not a project I'd want to contribute to due to the technology.
- shash 6y agoI share your frustration with OpenCASCADE. OCC has become marginally modernised with v7, abandoning that weird macro-template system and gaining support for real C++ smart pointers, etc. But it's still an early 90s framework with all the warts. Still it's like that Churchill quote about democracy being the worst form of government apart from all the other ones we've tried. I don't have all that much experience with ACIS, but I happened to look at the API once a few years back. OCC looks like heaven compared to that. I keep toying with the idea of writing a CAD library every few months or so. Sometimes I even write a bit of code. But OCC is always "good enough" for the task at hand, so I just bite the bullet, start typing BRepBuilderAPI_Make* and get on with life.
- shash 6y agoTo be fair, FreeCAD has been improving quite rapidly over the last few years. To the extent that I'm able to use it for the few small things I need to do.