9 ms·
The site is beautiful and I couldn’t do it. But I’ll still be a bit judgemental. It breaks my first law of UX: don’t be self serving. The first screen is a lon
by Waterluvian 6y ago
The site is beautiful and I couldn’t do it. But I’ll still be a bit judgemental. It breaks my first law of UX: don’t be self serving.
The first screen is a long scroll of 20 elegant looking blocks and titles none of which mean anything on their own. I have to click on each and sit through some superfluous animation before I can even get access to the explanation.
Because of the animation, t he natural flow of swiping back on my phone results in a really janky transition.
I have to say, I love the style of these graphics. Minimalism I guess? Reminds me of the University of Waterloo during my childhood.
- amelius 6y ago> I have to say, I love the style of these graphics. Minimalism I guess? I'd say if you practice Minimalism, then also make sure it applies to the total amount of space you're using for it ;)
- Waterluvian 6y agoYeah I’m probably using the entirely wrong term. Whatever you call this style.
- smrk007 6y agoIt’s much better from desktop view, I found.
- joeyspn 6y ago> I love the style of these graphics. Minimalism I guess? It's a "Memphis style" variant. Pretty trendy these days. Now the industry is starting to move to "Neumorphism".
- Waterluvian 6y agoThanks. Two new terms to google.
- ardy42 6y ago> It's a "Memphis style" variant. Pretty trendy these days. Now the industry is starting to move to "Neumorphism". Really? I thought Memphis style was this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memphis_Group https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memphis_Group and this: https://www.megapixl.com/illustration-for-hipsters-memphis-style-illustration-67848727 https://www.megapixl.com/illustration-for-hipsters-memphis-s... (e.g. "80s style"). This website is not giving me that impression. If anything, it reminds me of a style I associate with the 60s or 70s (namely a sans serif font coupled with geometric graphics that use multiple shades of the same bright color). Edit: I think it's closer to the "Swiss/International Style": https://www.google.com/search?q=Swiss/International+Style+Graphic+Design https://www.google.com/search?q=Swiss/International+Style+Gr..., but I'm by no means an expert.
- minxomat 6y agoIt borrows from both Swiss style and constructivism.
- limograf 6y agoIt's ITS derived but the nearer referent is Material via Penguin Book covers from around 1960 to 1975, like the classic Hare Sitting Up: https://www.flickr.com/photos/joekral/231480092/in/album-72157594264351021/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/joekral/231480092/in/album-721...
- staplers 6y agoLol this is not Memphis, which is an art movement from the 80s. "Corporate Memphis" is new term to describe the over-the-top illustrated landing pages which are very common in modern web design. It seems you are conflating "Memphis" from modern web design. What we see on the Laws of UX cards is geometric abstraction.
- joeyspn 6y agoHmm are you sure? google "memphis style symbols" and let me know if you see any similarities. It's like saying Apple is not Bauhaus.
- tobr 6y agoGoogling “memphis style symbols” gives no useful results, just poorly made stock art. The design of the site is not at all akin to the Memphis Group, which is characterized by a sense of whimsy and lack of gravity, clashing colors and dazzling patterns. Regarding neumorphism, I’d bet that will be much like the “long shadow” trend of yore; an interesting style that is hyped until, a short time after, the appeal of the newness and uniqueness wears off completely.
- mushbino 6y agoDefinitely not Memphis, but I'd say it's in the Brutalist category.
- mortenjorck 6y agoI wouldn't call these Memphis at all, although Memphis certainly grew out of the same milieu. More than anything, these are referencing the look of Swiss style and mid-century modern book cover design, such as those by Rudolf de Harak.
- xingyzt 6y agoThe same style, logo and all, is used on Google’s site for material design. http://material.io/ http://material.io/
- ZephyrBlu 6y ago> Now the industry is starting to move to "Neumorphism" Really? Neumorphism is cool to look at occasionally, but I would hate it if everything started looking like that.
- mdoms 6y agoIt breaks my number one rule of UX for the web: don't fuck with scrolling. Native scrolling is one of the most natural interactions we have with our computers. Even a slight deviation is noticeable and annoying.
- harrisonjackson 6y agoIt is even Rule 5 - your site should work like every other site. I didn't notice any scrolling differences myself ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- KaoruAoiShiho 6y agoScrolling works fine here.
- dathinab 6y agoFor me to, maybe just (some) mobile browsers?
- craftinator 6y agoOuch, interface should be consistent across platforms
- p1necone 6y agoI don't know about that. An interface for M+K on a 27 inch screen should be somewhat different from fat fingers on a 6 inch screen shouldn't it? "Don't fuck with scrolling" applies to both scenarios equally though.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- agumonkey 6y agorule 21: favorize balanced density of information rather than aesthetics ;)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dathinab 6y agoIt also brakes the rule that all text should be selectable (so that people can e.g. copy past it to an search engine). (The laws titles are not selectable on desktop/linux/firefox.) Furthermore the short description of the laws does sometimes subtle differ from the actual long descriptions in ways which make major differences about how "correct" that law is.
- thomasahle 6y agoThey are selectable on desktop/mac/firefox. However they are links, so you have to start dragging the cursor from next to the link.
- renewiltord 6y agoGood catch. I can verify this is also the behaviour on Linux.
- finger 6y agoOn Windows you can select text in hyperlinks if you hold down the alt key before you click and drag to select the text.
- jack1243star 6y agoLooks like I'm one of today's lucky 10000.
- dathinab 6y agoLet me rephrase: They are not easily selectable. I mean who expects the whole card to act as a link and as such need special handling wrt. selecting text? Especially if there is an explicit "link button" to navigate to the "more details view" just besides the card. The funny thing is that while for some users the whole card acting as a single hyperlink is intuitive (even through there is no indication that it does) for others it isn't intuitive at all and at most they would expect it to behave like a normal tile (it looks like a title) . The logo on the card being clickable and being a hyperlink on the other hand is probably expected by much more people.
- keithnz 6y agoThere's also some "dark patterns" like in the info section, if you click the twitter link, it trys to make you tweet the link to the webpage.
- renewiltord 6y agoFound the short summaries sufficient for everything except Law of Prägnanz, which I can't see how to apply. Much preferred the name+blurb style over a bigger description.
- paulie_a 6y agoThe site is completely broken on my mobile. Paulie law: make a website you would like to use The other 25 are irrelevant
- II2II 6y agoBeing judgmental about the UX is fair in this case since it is a site about UX. Quite frankly, it has a terrible UX. It took me three visits to understand what you meant by access to the explanation. I could only find a bunch of uninformative slides and a blurb promoting a book on the first visit two visits. On visit number three, I found the explanations. Why? I originally interpreted the scrolling indicator as an advance to next slide button. When I clicked on the button it presented the new slide and the advance button disappeared, so I further explored the site by clicking on the learn more button. That presented another uninformative slide so I ignored the advance button. After all, why would I want to repeat an action that failed to produce the desired result the last time I did it? Noticing the next link, I clicked on that in hopes that it would produce a more desirable result. Unfortunately, it produced the same sort of result as the advance button. At that point, I just gave up and clicked on the Info button and saw the blurb promoting the book. I tried clicking on the links to the left, saw the uninformative slides, and concluded that it was a gawd awful promotion for a book that included nothing but chapter headings. Those were my first two visits. On visit three, convinced that there must be something more, I actually tried the advance button on the right slide and discovered that it was a scroll indicator. By that point, I was already so frustrated with the experience that I just gave up on the site without seeing what the creator had to say. As for the graphics style, sure it's great. On the other hand, taking the minimalist presentation too far produced a site that was more difficult to interpret. Edit: trying to keep terminology consistent as my understanding of the site evolved.
- networkimprov 6y ago>> ... a long scroll of 20 ... blocks and titles none of which mean anything on their own > frankly, it has a terrible UX I don't follow these critiques. The content and navigation of the site is quite clear to me. The trackpad/wheel scrolling stutters very slightly in FireFox on Windows. EDIT: And hey, it's in Dark Mode!
- epse 6y agoI opened this site on mobile. The blocks are half as high as the titles, making them impossible to read. Clicking a block took me through soms slow animation, which always ended with some graphic growing into view, in the same colour as the text, overlapping with the first paragraph of text...
- mcbishop 6y agoIt seems the site is designed for someone that wants to take ample time to meditate on and memorize the "laws" (it's basically flash cards). So it's not designed for me — a person on lunch break, hoping to read at least 5 articles via Hacker News before my burrito is gone. While I was annoyed there, I still appreciate it. It's a free resource. It's pretty. I gleaned a few useful takeaways (especially the idea of putting more important things on the edges).
- ardy42 6y ago> The first screen is a long scroll of 20 elegant looking blocks and titles none of which mean anything on their own. I have to click on each and sit through some superfluous animation before I can even get access to the explanation. Bad user! You're not following the first law of UX: > Users often perceive aesthetically pleasing design as design that’s more usable. > Aesthetically pleasing design can make users more tolerant of minor usability issues. > Aesthetically pleasing design creates a positive response in people’s brains and leads them to believe the design actually works better. > Aesthetically pleasing design can mask usability problems and prevent issues from being discovered during usability testing. You're supposed to go "oh, pretty!" and forget how crappy it really is! /s Seriously now: the first law of UX should be that aesthetics are secondary to usability. If your focus is on making something "eye catching" or "beautiful" then you're doing bad UX. If designers followed that, we wouldn't have so many UX trainwreaks.
- andrepd 6y agoOh my god, this is exactly how I feel about most modern software UI. It seems like it's optimised to look pretty on screenshots, rather than to actually be usable!
- userbinator 6y ago...and "pretty" is highly subjective. I find the current "sea of white/blackspace with almost no affordances" and "hide everything that could possibly be useful" trend rather repugnant --- but perhaps that's because it almost always comes with a lack of usability.
- CoryAlexMartin 6y agoYes, the "hide everything" trend is really annoying. An egregious example of this is how iTunes hides the track number and/or duration when you hover over or have a track selected: https://i.imgur.com/IhwHnfO.png https://i.imgur.com/IhwHnfO.png
- Shared404 6y ago
- pbreit 6y agoFirst law quite ironic.
- alangpierce 6y agoIn case others are also confused by: > The first screen is a long scroll of 20 elegant looking blocks and titles none of which mean anything on their own. The page behaves differently on mobile vs desktop, and that quote is a description of the mobile experience. On desktop, it also includes a one-sentence explanation of each law without needing to click through.
- romanows 6y agoJust the first screen and then not the subsequent screens depending on where you click. I clicked around trying to figure out what to do and got to what looked like presentation slides with a prev/next links. I just saw text ("Doherty Threshold") and a meaningless graphic. Clicking on the screen does nothing. I didn't realize you were supposed to scroll down for more text, I just didn't see the scrollbar and I guess I wasn't looking for it because the page looked like slides.
- northwest65 6y agoWait, there's animation?
- Drdrdrq 6y agoJust stuttering for me (ff mobile).
- andai 6y agoYeah, the site breaks the fifth rule, Jakob’s Law: > Users spend most of their time on other sites. This means that users prefer your site to work the same way as all the other sites they already know. Side note, this text was hard to copy because the site changes the text highlight color to black, the same as the background.
- sjwright 6y agoThough to be fair, on desktop at least, I don't think the site breaks modern web conventions in any egregious way which compromise UX. In most critical respects it works like any other website: it scrolls normally, it has headings and subheadings, it links off to pages located at different URLs, and those inner pages have reasonably conventional layouts. I agree that the mobile experience is broken. They should rethink the layout to add the summaries back onto the main page. If I was offering advice to the designers, I would suggest they abandon the obsession with 100vh layouts and always have a little bit of scrollable content peeking in from the bottom. 100vh layouts evokes the slideshow metaphor, which changes how people expect interaction to function. I would also restyle the "LEARN MORE" buttons to make them clearer. My brain somehow completely ignored them on first viewing. I saw them on subsequent viewings but the low contrast makes them not seem very clickable, I think they could be easily misinterpreted as shortcuts to the next content "slide".
- cosmotic 6y agoHaha, I didn't even realize you could click to get more info until you said something.
- galaxyLogic 6y agoIronically the first law says "Users perceive aesthetically pleasing design as design that's more usable". So now you say "I love the style of these graphics". So if the 1st law is correct it means you perceive this design as usable. Then here's the irony: Just because you PERCEIVE it as more usable does not necessarily mean it is more usable. Which seems to be the case as per your experience. But so what is the point about trying to make users PERCEIVE a design as usable? Shouldn't the goal be to make it actually usable whether users perceive it as such or not?
- hinkley 6y agoBit low on contrast and flirting with over-saturation.
- sfifs 6y agoThe irony is this designer made an excellent demonstration of poor design :-) i agree none of the graphics use actually seem to mean anything intuitively to me. Looks like just pretty placeholder pictures. Also if one find oneself writing down 20 general rules for anything, it's an excellent indication one may not have actually grokked the topic because it's very very unlikely you'll apply 20 rules at the same time. It's likely in some situations, 3-4 are important and in other situations, some others are more important and this ability to classify and recognise what applies where is an indication of knowledge and pedagogical strength.
- shrimpx 6y agoI found the organization to be great, and there’s a “next” button at the bottom of every page so you can consume the whole thing linearly.
- valuearb 6y agoNever saw it. But did see all the pretty images.
- bensfrankl 6y ago> The first screen is a long scroll of 20 elegant looking blocks and titles none of which mean anything on their own. The index page is even worse. It sits under the burger/help menu. Non of the titles make sense, you'll have to click each and read to have a clue.