9 ms·
The battle to invent the automatic rice cooker
- graycat 6y agoDeleted. Mod, fix this attack on me.
- bemmu 6y agoWe often use the timer in our rice cooker such that when you come back home the rice is ready, and it also maintains the temperature after it's done. I wouldn't want to leave a stove at high heat while not at home.
- jagged-chisel 6y agoSo measure water and rice, monitor boiling status, modify cooking temperature... Yep, needs more automation and less human thought. We need single-serving-sized pouches of rice, and single-serving-sized bottles of water. Feeding four people? Use four packets and four bottles. The cooking device can monitor its own temperature and sing a ditty when it’s done.
- jrootabega 6y agoRicero!
- claudeganon 6y agoZoujirushi rice cookers already sing you a song when they’ve finished cooking: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=CMN0jAENzIg https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=CMN0jAENzIg
- damnyou 6y agoWhat you're describing is pretty close to a Zojirushi fuzzy logic cooker, which has a greater tolerance for mismatched rice/water ratios (and most importantly sings a tune when done!)
- sa1 6y agoAs the article states, the challenge is already lower for you because you can turn the heat to low, unlike the old days. Rice can vary, high starch to low starch, short-grain to long-grain, sticky, non-sticky, raw to parboiled. They're used as a base for other dishes including sushi, fried rice, pudding, biryani and porridge. All these require different amounts of consistency. While cooking at home, if you just mess it up a little bit, the dish will still serve its purpose. But that's not true if you're cooking an Asian dish with perfectly good rice used just as a base.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AmericanChopper 6y agoThe other factor that makes cooking rice today quite trivial (even without a rice cooker), is the quality of our rice. A typical bag of rice from the supermarket (even in most developing countries), will be of a much more consistent higher quality than you’d expect to have gotten 70 years ago.
- claudeganon 6y agoI’m not sure how you could read the article and miss the historical context. In postwar Japan, many women were not cooking with saucepans on gas or electric ranges with high-quality, industrially processed rice: >For centuries, most Japanese cooks made rice with a kamado, a box-shaped range topped with a heavy iron pot. It was painfully tricky. Cooking rice this way, says columnist and food writer Makiko Itoh, takes heat modulation: high heat until the water and rice boils, then low heat, then high heat again. “And that, with a wood-burning stove, is very difficult.” Each day, Japanese women rose at dawn and labored for several sweaty hours to make rice. The engineer who made the first, widely successful design relied on his wife’s expertise in this traditional cooking method to perfect it.
- mynameishere 6y agoIt was painfully tricky "Until now, this was the only way to get cooked rice from rice..." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=viejY6UZ5Bk&t=42s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=viejY6UZ5Bk&t=42s Okay, but in that case the best thing to invent would be a non-horrible stove. I've made rice, and even as an incompetent cook, it really is a non-issue.
- claudeganon 6y agoMost Japanese houses postwar were not equipped to have good gas ranges. The article highlights that widespread electrification had occurred, which favored rice cookers, especially because cooking food on electric ranges is anathema for huge swathes of Japanese cuisine. The standard to be measured against was also, again, Kamado rice, which most rice cookers today would struggle to meet and I guarantee few bachelors are measuring up to with their sauce pans.
- dec0dedab0de 6y agoJo Koy has a bit about cooking rice on his newest special that points out an even easier trick. Put as much rice as you want to cover the bottom of the pot, then put your index finger on the rice and fill the water up to the first knuckle. ...But for the next step I'm using my instapot while I do something else.
- imglorp 6y agoI was taught this method also, by a Japanese woman in the 80s. I think it works because the cooker cuts the heat exactly when it's all turned to steam, which is held at a minimum pressure by the lid. So the amount of water is very forgiving because there's those two automatic functions regulating the process.
- jasode 6y ago>Cooking rice is difficult? Hmm .... I didn't downvote your comment but your dismissive snark seems out of place since the _history_ of "tricky/difficult/labored" was explained in the article: >It was painfully tricky. Cooking rice this way, says columnist and food writer Makiko Itoh, takes heat modulation: high heat until the water and rice boils, then low heat, then high heat again. “And that, with a wood-burning stove, is very difficult.” Each day, Japanese women rose at dawn and labored for several sweaty hours to make rice. (A contemporary restaurant in Nara, Japan, offers a kamado-cooking experience that starts with 15 minutes of pumping a bellows to fan the flames.)
- eternalban 6y agoThe article makes general statements about cooking rice, but it is really about cooking rice Japanese style. In some rice eating countries, automatic rice cookers never really took off because of the 'quality' of the product is obviously East Asia centric, which is considered 'mushy' rice in West Asia. With some rice cooking approaches, the amount of water makes no difference as whatever is left is drained after a fixed period of time, and then it's simmer time. "Burning" of the bottom is also locale dependent. In Persian Cuisine for example, the art of making 'Tah-Deeg' (lit. bottom of the pot) is one of the stepping stones of becoming a serious cook, and generally this is the bit of the rice that family fights over at the table. Bottom line, OP is correct, imho.
- cangencer 6y ago+1, in countries like Turkey, Persia, India, Pakistan rice cookers are pretty uncommon. In my home country of Turkey where rice is eaten very commonly, I've never heard of a single person use it. Further, rice is typically first washed several times, fried with a bit of oil and perhaps some spices before being simmered. I don't know if it's possible to do this with a Japanese style rice-cooker.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 6y ago
- bobcostas55 6y ago2:1?! That ratio is crazy and will certainly not produce good rice.
- Icathian 6y agoWhat do you personally recommend instead?
- pyk 6y ago1 cup rice 1.25 cups water is what I use as a ratio for short-to-medium grain white rice (I recommend kokuho rose extra fancy). That also is the one typically inscribed on the side of a rice cooker pot. You can go a little over water-wise for a mushier rice, or under for a chewier/drier rice - white rice is forgiving.
- riahi 6y agoThat's sort of a typical ratio for Basmati rice. Not good for East Asian varieties though.
- smichel17 6y agoI follow very similar steps. Two changes: - I turn the heat off (but do not open the lid) at 15 minutes - If I'm planning on making extra, sometimes I like to add some oil (usually coconut, sometimes olive or butter), which I find helps it keep better. Oil and rice added before water, to spread it evenly.
- ThePhysicist 6y agoFor people that regularly eat rice, buying a decent rice cooker is really a no-brainer. Cooking rice in a pan is possible and you can obtain good results if you're careful and turn the heat down at the right moment before the rice starts to stick to the bottom of the pan and burn, it's easy to miss though. A rice cooker makes this process so much easier though: Put in the rice, the adequate amount of water, press a button, wait, eat (usually) perfectly cooked rice. I started with a German brand a few years ago but finally mustered up the courage to buy a good Japanese one (Zojirushi seems to be the market leader these days). I imagine that it tastes a bit better now but honestly even most of the cheap rice cookers produce quite good results. Recently Xiaomi introduced a series of rice cookers which have really nice induction heating and a really heavy, solid cooking pan, unfortunately they have littered them with "smart" functionality, so it's nothing that I want in my kitchen.
- cycrutchfield 6y agoIMO the Korean brands are the market leaders. Check out Cuckoo
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- omilu 6y agoPanasonic makes good ones as well.
- 6y ago
- chris_st 6y agoNote to those who already have an Instant Pot: they make fantastic rice.
- travisjungroth 6y agoThe trick I found (maybe this is true of all rice cookers) is it's better if it has time to rest after cooking. I start the rice as the very first thing when cooking and it works well.
- throw0101a 6y ago> […] it's better if it has time to rest after cooking. This is true of a lot of foods. Not enough people let meat rest for long enough after removing it from the heat. * https://www.seriouseats.com/2009/12/how-to-have-juicy-meats-steaks-the-food-lab-the-importance-of-resting-grilling.html https://www.seriouseats.com/2009/12/how-to-have-juicy-meats-...
- roganartu 6y agoI have found that the perfect amount of wait time is, conveniently, how long it takes for the natural pressure release to complete after cooking. Normally that's another 10-15 mins or so, but whenever the pressure lock drops so that you can open the lid the rice should be good. I always disable the Keep Warm setting though, not sure if that makes a difference.
- atombender 6y agoI tried cooking Indian basmati rice in mine. I followed a recipe exactly, and it came out mushy. Basmati is supposed to be fluffy, dry, and not sticky, with grains that tumble around if you fluff it with a fork. I decided one day to experiment until I got the water-to-rice-to-time ratio correct, and I just couldn't find the right combination. It always came out overcooked. I'd love to hear what the secret is.
- chris_st 6y agoStupid question, but did you try searching the internet for basmati rice recipes? Sometimes it seems like there's an infinite number of IP recipes out there :-)
- spaceflunky 6y agoThe science behind a rice cooker is fascinatingly clever, yet painfully simple. In short, boiling water temperature plateaus due to the latent heat of vaporization. When the water is gone the temperature of the pot starts to rise. The rice cooker uses this principle to control the switch. The switch is held by magnet. When the pot finishes boiling the heat rises and exceeds the curie point of the magnet, which means the magnet ceases to be magnetic, and the (no longer) magnetic switch is released turning the rice cooker off. Here’s a great video explaining how it works. https://youtu.be/RSTNhvDGbYI https://youtu.be/RSTNhvDGbYI
- jrimbault 6y agoIt's basically the same physics involved in this toaster https://youtu.be/1OfxlSG6q5Y https://youtu.be/1OfxlSG6q5Y same channel. Thing heats and deforms (change properties), when it reaches temperature n, thing deforms just a bit too much, cuts electrical contact.
- bch 6y agoThese are both clever, but different physics. The toaster uses metallic elasticity (and a subsequent distortion) due to heat, and the rice cooker uses the heat-induced disappearance of magnetism to disengage a switch. (I have one of those toasters, and they’re very pretty and charming to see work.)
- jrootabega 6y agoIt's not the magnet's curie point; it's the curie point of the metal the magnet sticks to. And I guess it's not really the curie point, just the point where the force becomes weaker than the spring
- throwaway_pdp09 6y agoThat sounds wrong. From wiki "In physics and materials science, the Curie temperature (TC), or Curie point, is the temperature above which certain materials lose their permanent magnetic properties". What you're saying is that metals stop being attracted to magnets above a certain, rather low temperature. Possible but very hard for me to imagine.
- konfusinomicon 6y agoTry making black garlic in one. Just do it outside if you can
- sorokod 6y agoWe have a rice cooker that we use at least once a week. It has a single lever/switch - when pushed it cooks. It is over a decade old and works perfectly. Do yourself a favor - don't buy smart appliances.
- colmvp 6y agoFWIW, I'm Asian and I just use a pot on stove.
- yomly 6y agoWhen I was a student the hobs were those ancient metal hotplates from the 70s/80s with nonexistent temperature control. I tried to cook rice in a hob and the surface was still raw but the bottom inch had burnt black to practically charcoal. I have never since tried to cook rice in a pan. And yet I cook risotto in a pan /shrug
- middleclick 6y agoI am of Indian descent and basmati has also always been cooked on a pot on a stove. And once you get the basic things right, it's actually not difficult. I am not downplaying the effectiveness of the rice cookers, just that it's possible to cook good rice without them.
- claudeganon 6y agoMost rice cookers are designed for East Asian rice and do middling with basmati. Some higher end models do have settings for it that work quite well though.
- pmoriarty 6y agoI cooked rice in a pot for decades, but eventually broke down and bought a rice cooker. I love not having to pay any attention to it and focus on other things instead of having to time it or keep an eye on it. When I eventually get around to checking on the rice, it's perfectly done. It's almost as good as having a personal cook make the rice for me. I'll never go back to a pot again, if I can help it.
- MAMAMassakali 6y agoWhy not just use pressure cooker? Cheap, easy to use, durable and versatile.
- pmoriarty 6y agoI've read too many horror stories of pressure cookers accidentally exploding.
- Kiro 6y agoI just use boil-in-bag. Can't taste the difference from rice done in a rice cooker.
- ngcc_hk 6y agoTo this days national rice cooker is still confuse me. Is it Panasonic?
- tradewarsonlyn 6y agoBeen cooking rice in a microwave for years now. Jasmine, Thai or Himalayan. Use any rice. Seems to cone out pretty well every single time.
- pmoriarty 6y agoWhat container, rice and water quantities, lids, and timings do you use? Do you have any tips for microwaving rice?
- grenoire 6y agoI don't quite get why people think that pot rice on the stove is somehow difficult. Measure your rice and water, and set up a timer. That's it. We've been cooking rice for millennia in this way, a rice cooker is just plastic waste in the end.
- jasonwatkinspdx 6y agoIt's about convenience and freeing up a burner on the cook top. I love the hold warm feature on mine in particular. It'a a zojirushi that's pushing 12 years now, and I've never had a single issue with it. It's far from being plastic waste for me, and I wouldn't be surprised if it lasts another decade.
- brudgers 6y agoFor a long time, I would have said something similar. For me, the big advantage of a rice cooker is timing. I can start it before the rest of the dish and no matter how long it takes to cook up everything else, the rice is ready to go. And it is ready to go if someone else in the household eats an hour or two later. And when I go to put leftover rice in the fridge, it's still palatable, so when it comes out of the fridge it's also palatable if properly stored.
- slfnflctd 6y agoIt's a simple robot. Allows you to delegate and time-shift a set of tasks so you don't have to be interrupted while focusing on something else. For many of us, that is more than worth a bit of 'wasteful' product design, and can lead directly to increased productivity in several ways.
- zeroimpl 6y ago100%. The proper measuring of ingredients and timing is all that's required. Take a look at the first line of the article: Cooking rice on a stovetop can be fraught. Add too much water and you end up with porridge. Then take a look at this line shortly afterwards: These devices can seem all-knowing. So long as you add water and rice in the right proportions, it’s nearly impossible to mess up So in other words, the device doesn't actually solve the most important problem... The timing isn't particularly important, as long as you remember to turn down the heat as soon as it starts boiling.
- throw0101a 6y agoBegin Japanology has an episode on rice cookers (of course): * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=teCnG2ZVAxU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=teCnG2ZVAxU * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I00uy0ssPP0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I00uy0ssPP0 [Hello, I'm Peter Barakan.]
- blntechie 6y agoElectric rice cookers are pretty uncommon in South Asian countries. Reasons could have been due to the electricity availability and affordability initially. But it has not caught on even now. I have seen electric rice cookers in minuscule number of households. Based on interactions, it’s more to do with people not liking the taste of the cooked rice. I always found this funny as older generation used to complain about the same about pressure cooked and stove top cooked rice instead of the wood fired stove cooked rice but everyone have accepted it now.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- unmole 6y agoThey are fairly common in urban South India.
- skinkestek 6y agoThis is just a story I heard when I was a kid, but I think HN might either like it or have some more details about it : There's a marketing story about a western company that tried to introduce their product to the Japanese market with the slogan: "as easy as cooking rice" - which, according to the story managed to insult every Japanese woman as cooking rice was - according to the story - considered more or less an art form in Japan at the time. Anyone has details about this story?
- odomojuli 6y agoI vaguely recall this story as well, all I've been able to find so far is an excerpt in International Business that doesn't go too far into detail.
- odomojuli 6y agoI grew up cooking rice on the stove. My mother preferred it this way because she liked crisping the bottom. It's definitely an art. Even picking what kind of rice you want is an art. Even slight variations in your technique can yield wildly different results. How much you rinse the rice changes the gluten content and stickiness, how long you let it soak changes the texture and size. Things like water quality, pot material and heat source make a big difference for smaller amounts. Being a minute late is too much sometimes. I used to have to "learn" how to cook a new bag because the grains are different sizes, sometimes it's not really brown or white but white-brown or brown-white. The best Japanese rice is in my opinion, from California. I like Koda Farms, their brown rice is just about as close as you can get to the flavor of white rice while having a decent amount of nutrition. Fun fact, the "flower name" for America is 米国. Means rice country. Nowadays people just say Amerika in Katakana which technically has a kanji representation as 亜米利加 but even that has the word rice in it. China calls us 美利坚合众国, which means beautiful country. It's not difficult to eyeball what it takes to make good rice. Quick and dirty rule is having just enough water to cover the rice. I just stick my pinky in and measure up to the second phalange. You basically just heat until it boils, quickly escape the air, release to mid heat and then keep an eye on it for about 10-15 minutes without opening the lid. If your technique is good, you can kind of estimate how long it takes on a linear scale for cups to cooking time. A clear lid helps, it'll just look right. Key thing to do is take your rice spatula and just carve out the edges when it's done so you're getting a more consistent mix. Later in life, I got the 1.8L Neuro Fuzzy Rice Cooker by Zojirushi. I fell in love with the name, which is apparently from artificial intelligence. Not sure how they come up with that. Here's the thing: sure, it's easy to make one kind of rice and costs almost nothing to do. With a dedicated rice cooker though, I can make any kind of rice, in any amount, without having to think about it. The inside of the pot has markers for your rice quantity and water volume for each type. I have the larger cooker, so it kind of takes longer (it consistently takes one hour to cook about 3-4 cups, which is simple to plan around). There's a quick cook setting which makes no discernible difference in consistency. Every time I turn it on, it sings a cute little song and then sings another one when it's done. I find it utterly delightful. Here's why you get a rice cooker. Sure, you can make rice in like 15 minutes on the stove. But then what do you do if you have leftovers? Put them in the fridge where it gets stale? With a rice cooker, I make 5-6 cups at the beginning of the week, and I can leave it there for at least 72 hours and it stays incredibly fresh. I wouldn't recommend it, but I've left it in there for 4 days. Constant heat kills any bacteria or mold that might take. I don't have to worry about my rice technique. I don't have to worry about storing and heating leftovers. I can make as much rice as I want and save myself time and effort throughout the week. If I wanted to be even more efficient, I could let the rice soak overnight, and set a timer for it to start cooking right before I wake up. It's one less thing to worry about, and I can time all of my meals around it so that everything's ready at the same time. You can also make other things besides rice such as pancakes or pasta in it. Pasta's a bit more difficult, but I've made perfect pancakes in this thing. Highly recommend Zojirushi for their excellent insulation products.
- apalmblad 6y agoA good discussion of rice cookers, in my opinion, needs a link to Roger Ebert's (yes, of film fans) article on The Pot: https://www.rogerebert.com/roger-ebert/the-pot-and-how-to-use-it https://www.rogerebert.com/roger-ebert/the-pot-and-how-to-us...
- pmoriarty 6y agoJust a warning about cheap rice cookers... About six months ago I bought a tiny $20 model Dash[1]. I've often heard people say that cheap rice cookers are just as good as expensive ones, and since I'm poor, live alone, and this was my first rice cooker, I thought it would be enough. It turns out this rice cooker had a number of problems. First, the screw that held in the pot lid on this rice cooker wasn't made of stainless steel, so it quickly rusted. I could have gone to the trouble of going to the hardware store and picking out a perfectly matching stainless steel screw (if they had one), but I never bothered, so to this day I still lift the pot lid with a paperclip that I insert in to the hole where the pot lid used to be each time I want to lift out the lid. It's a little annoying, but I can live with it. I'm sure for some people not dealing with this annoyance would be worth paying more for a decently made rice cooker. The second issue is that this ultra cheap rice cooker only makes enough rice for me to eat at a single sitting. As a single person that only very rarely has people over, this is enough.. or so I thought until I found that I'd rather cook extra rice ahead of time that I could eat throughout the week (or at least one day in advance), so I don't have to even bother with the rice cooker ever day. As simple as the rice cooker is, it's still a bit of a hassle to rinse the rice out, and fill the cooker with rice and water. I'd rather just microwave leftover rice, which is a bit simpler. Third, the markings for the water level and the instructions for this model are just plain wrong and take experimenting to get the optimal levels. After some months of experimentation, I managed to perfect my technique, but it would have still been a lot less hassle to just have the thing make perfect rice from the beginning rather than having to fiddle with it so much. So, because of these issues, in retrospect I wish I'd gone for a larger, inevitably more expensive rice cooker... and hopefully it would have been less annoying and fiddly from the start. [1] - https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07CHZP91L/ https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07CHZP91L/
- genocidicbunny 6y agoI think the actual message of 'Get a simple rice cooker' often gets heard as 'Get a cheap rice cooker' which is not quite correct. You don't need a rice cooker that has two dozen different functions and some 'Neuro Fuzzy Logic' crap. But you do want a well-built rice cooker that wont break down and rust on you. Your best bet for a decent cheap rice cooker is your local asian market. The bigger ones will likely have quite a selection, but even your dinky little chinatown grocery store will probably have something quite usable.
- jeffrallen 6y agoAlton Brown taught me: No single taskers in the kitchen, except for the fire extinguisher. I don't see what's so hard: put in rice, wash it, fill cold water to one finger joint above the rice, boil, cook slow 7 mins, turn off leaving covered, wait at least 5 more mins while finishing sauce (but up to 15!), fluff, serve. Pots are for cooking. Machines are for other stuff.
- oehtXRwMkIs 6y agoMany believe the rice cooker to be an exception to this, especially when you're cooking rice for your family every single day. It's just easier, and when you do something constantly, even minor improvements help save time and effort. I think you have to follow the no unitasker rule in moderation. If you eat salad every day for example, I don't think it's a bad idea to have a salad spinner, when you can "easily" rinse and drain by hand.
- twic 6y agoI have a multi-cooker which is basically a rice cooker with a microchip. I regularly cook rice, lentils, and stews in it, and have cooked bread and cakes in it in the past, although mostly as a stunt.
- genocidicbunny 6y agoEffectively, your basic rice cooker is a metal pot on a hot plate with a clever thermal control to turn off the hot plate. That's a pretty versatile piece of kitchen equipment -- no more single-use than your stovetop is.
- enjeyw 6y agoGrowing up I always assumed a rice cooker was one of those things I'd never be able to live without - for years my family used one almost every day. When I moved out of home, I didn't buy a rice cooker initially, because you don't strictly need one to make rice. I was amazed at how convenient making decent quality rice on the stove was! It cooks faster, and there's less cleaning up afterwards. Many years have past and I still don't own a rice cooker. I'm not sure I'll ever own one gain.
- summitsummit 6y agoI've had the exact same experience.
- arh68 6y agoI am amazed how well my Zojirushis make rice. One can make the same rice two different ways, consistently (white, umami). No burnt layer, no undercooked rice. I think the pressure/induction makes slightly better rice than the standard fuzzy logic; there's no restaurant near me whose rice I'd prefer over my p/i Zoji.
- inakarmacoma 6y agoWhat about the size of the hand being used?
- samus 6y agoFinger length doesn't vary that strongly as the palm size. Any actual differences in output because of millimeters difference in water level could also due to eyeballing it in the first place.
- julianlam 6y agoOwning and using a rice cooker is such a time saver that I am often surprised that it's not a staple in other peoples' houses (though much of that is a cultural thing,I eat rice basically every single day) It's like Americans and not owning a kettle. Boggles the mind, but I suppose they don't drink as much tea as I do ... On the topic of _which_ rice cooker to buy, the answer is simple: the rice cooker was perfected years ago, with its double pot single button (on-off switch) operation. Anything else is a gimmick and not worth paying extra for.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoOn the other hand rice is so trivial to cook on the hob why bother with a rice cooker?
- karmakaze 6y agoAs mentioned in other comments. The 'keep warm' function is also key. It allows for having cooked rice 24x7 and is as important a feature as the auto-shutoff cooker for a daily consumption household.