11 ms·
I'm going to have to disagree with the cover letter advice. I'm sure there are people out there who appreciate well written cover letters. They are a tiny mino
by BeetleB 6y ago
I'm going to have to disagree with the cover letter advice.
I'm sure there are people out there who appreciate well written cover letters. They are a tiny minority. How do I know this? Some years ago I started applying and would always type up a custom cover letter whenever a position allowed me to upload one.
Every time I got a call, I asked them if my cover letter played a role in their choosing to call me. The response was always "Oh you wrote a cover letter? Let me check it out."
Not one person had read it.
Not. One.
Those things take a while to write, and that time is better spent applying to more jobs. I quickly stopped writing them. Sorry, but unless you are getting a job via networking, it really is a numbers game.
If I were sending my resume to someone who I know is not a recruiter/HR, then I do take the time to write one. Otherwise, I don't.
- cm2012 6y agoMy experience is that small to medium size companies, where the person managing you is also screening resumes, pay much more attention to cover letters. I've had my cover letters explicitly mentioned by these companies when hiring. I've also hired based on cover letters at these companies. Big companies don't look at all. HR or recruiter finds you by keyword OR you get referred by a friend for the job. Then 5 people who don't care take 20 minutes of their day to interview you. There's no chance for the cover letter to come up in this scenario. When I worked at BigCo I interviewed a decent amount of people and HR never handed me a cover letter to look at.
- BeetleB 6y agoThe problem is I can't tell which companies will have an HR/recruiter vs a manager as the first filter. Almost all calls I've gotten from startups (most of which would be considered "small" companies) were via a recruiter. I guess if I apply to an established, small/medium company that is not a startup, it's more likely to be read by a manager.
- user5994461 6y agoWhen you say recruiter, do you mean HR from the company or an external recruiter?
- jlokier 6y agoIf they already know which company it is, they probably mean an internal recruiter. When going via external recruiters, you tend to know you're talking to a recruiter before you find out which company the job is with.
- sokoloff 6y agoI think a rule of thumb is "by the time a company is large enough to have someone in tech doing full-time management, your application is going to pass through someone else before getting to them for a second pass of filtering." Small, scrappy startups will have the decision-maker doing the first-pass filtering. None of those people will be called "manager".
- scarface74 6y agoIn 25 years, I’ve never randomly spammed applicant tracking systems. My first job was based on an internship and after that I used my network of former coworkers, managers, and local external recruiters.
- xmprt 6y agoMy rule of thumb is I don't write a cover letter unless I have a good reason to write one. For example, I found a mid size company through an interesting blog post and felt like that was something worth mentioning and that I thought the company seemed interesting too. It was probably as short as a tweet but I got an email and subsequently an offer very soon after. Generic cover letters are a waste of everyone's time.
- BeetleB 6y ago> Generic cover letters are a waste of everyone's time. "Generic cover letter" is an oxymoron. Cover letters are supposed to be individualized.
- another-dave 6y agoThe sample cover letter in the article is quite generic & doesn't seem much tailored to a particular job description.
- azangru 6y ago> The sample cover letter in the article is quite generic Yes, the first paragraph in the cover letter is almost identical to the opening paragraphs of numerous spam emails. "You're building a great feedback organization product I think has great potential". Really? Well, ta very much; now tell us something we don't know.
- ghaff 6y agoWhile I generally think a cover letter, even if mostly generic, is a good idea as a way of at least somewhat personalizing your application, there's a lot about that one that sort of turns me off. It would be a net negative for me.
- ciceryadam 6y agoYup, exactly. I'm in central Europe, I've never written one and no-one missed it. If a cover letter was mandatory I didn't apply. Same when I was at the other end of the hiring process, I never required a cover letter, good people are in high demand, so why make them jump through unnecessary hoops.
- rsj_hn 6y agoI think this is correct. Be mindful of how HR is likely to work at the place that hires you. Big Co: there is some HR screener looking for keywords who hands a stack of resumes -- maybe a hundred -- to a hiring manager who has to quickly go through them and pick maybe 5-10 who will get a screen. If the screen goes well, it may go to a second screen or a full panel. The thing to keep in mind is that interviewing bears substantial costs for the firm. You are yanking 5-6 senior people out of usually an overloaded sprint to spend an hour and then more time writing up a form, so basically 1 day of work. But you may have 300 people applying. That means if everyone got a full panel, it would take 1 year of labor to fill 1 position. Obviously that's not possible, so the end result is going to be capricious for the person going through the process -- there's no way around that, as you can only have resources to do an indepth look at 5 out of those 300. So yes, interviewing sucks and you will often get unfairly ruled out for stupid stuff. We get it, but that's how it has to be and will continue to be as long as applying for a job is costless and open to everyone who can upload a pdf. It's just a bad equilibrium -- the more people apply per position, the more arbitrary the process becomes, which encourages more people to apply to many different positions to hedge their bets, which creates more resumes per position, etc. For really famous firms like Microsoft or Google, they may get 1000-3000 applications per positions. Even if most of these applicants are unsuitable, they still gum up the works and add more randomness to the process. OTOH, if it's a smaller company you don't get so many applying and they can afford to give a better look per resume, but then again it's going to depend on the job market situation. Still your odds are better. Strangely, it's rare for the candidate to actually think about what it's like on the other side of this and take steps that make it easier to process their resume. Stuff like: keep it to a single page, read the requirements in the job posting and include relevant experience/skills rather than a full dump of everything you did, etc. And never, ever, lie about a skill or experience. Try to make the resume easy to read for someone who has to read 100 of them per hour.
- jon-wood 6y agoAs someone on the other side of the table now I’m almost at the point where I’ll bring anyone who provides a single page CV in for interview, just because they’ve clearly put some thought into it. I’m so sick of trawling through five page CVs which contain absolutely everything apart from a reason to hire you.
- caro_douglos 6y agoIn the past when applying for many gigs (and writing cover letters) I used the opportunity to gauge how much I wanted to work at the company. If they didn’t read it or respond to it iiwii. - Sincerely the guy who spells the company name wrong in his cover letters
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoA cover letter is a way to keep you out for not following the instruction of send your cv and a cover letter, nobody is going to read it. I have a cover letter template I rewrite for each company.
- BeetleB 6y ago> A cover letter is a way to keep you out for not following the instruction of send your cv and a cover letter, nobody is going to read it. The fact that you say CV makes me thing that either: 1. You're in academia or some kind of research discipline. 2. You are not in the US (we distinguish between resumes and CVs, and CVs are almost unheard of in the engineering sphere here). My comment about cover letters is US specific. Academic/research jobs should have a cover letter - I agree. Most engineering positions I apply for do not require a cover letter - it is optional. If it is required, I do write one - but that is extremely rare. And I often do get calls from companies that allowed me to upload one (optionally) - even though I never upload one. My guess is that the majority of companies that optionally allow you to upload one will never notice if you do. My guess is that most likely the reason you can upload a cover letter (optionally) is that whoever designed the site is using a generic template - not because they actually want one.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoNot in U.S
- BossingAround 6y agoTo a lot of people, CV and resume are synonyms.
- t_von_doom 6y agoHere in the UK (at least in my experience) we use CV and resume interchangeably
- plopilop 6y agoNot American, what is the difference between CV and resume? I always assumed they were synonyms.
- iandanforth 6y ago"Allowed me to upload one" is the red flag there. If you're dealing with a company that is asking you to use a system to upload a resume rather than communicating directly with a recruiter and hiring manager then yeah it's going to get ignored.
- hrktb 6y agoIf you’re applying by yourself, directly to the company, isn’t that your only way to push your resume ? Or do you go out of your way to find recruiting team’s email/phone number to hit them out of the system ?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Lammy 6y agoKids These Days just need to learn to pound the e-pavement, have a firm e-handshake, and really show that they are the best ${entity} for the job.
- kjeetgill 6y agoJoking aside, yea 90% of my job hunt tends to be recruiters on LinkedIn, resume in an email, straight to calls. For Software in the bay. I'm sure this varies a ton by industry and role.
- teetertater 6y agoThe latter is the only way that works for me. In one case, I found a job posting with an online form that had the name of the recruiter on the website. I dug up the recruiter's email and sent an email intro + my resume. From there she said "thanks, let me put you into the system". So double win for me because my application was acknowledged and I didn't have to fill out their custom form! (Made it to the last round). Hitting out of the system makes you stand out and they're forced to consider you
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Daub 6y agoBeing an academic in a design school, my experience with interviews is different. When reviewing applicants for a job, the cover letter is the only means I have to know if they have researched the particular requirements of the university I work for. We are a western university located in an non-western nation. I need to know that they have considered what this means, especially if they are Weston. It much harder that you might assume to move to a new continent.
- idclip 6y agoThe academy is different. We tend to grow into s job, but a field of study does require more digging into motive beyond „i need money“, where „i need money“ is the main reason most of us look for jobs. After my toxic 3 years at a job to whom i did send a cover letter they liked (i liked the company before finding out one guy in the department im in had seniority and was doing dodgy stuff to maintain power) ... i quit and eventually I got my job via connecting with people, and i think thats the best way one could get hired.
- MattGaiser 6y agoI usually dump the cover letter in the same file as the resume to make sure that it gets read. Worst case, there are a bundle more keywords for the ATS.
- hinkley 6y agoThat explains some interactions where they sort of vaguely wonder why I think I’m right for the job given my resume. Well, I told you why in the cover letter. Years ago I started keeping a full version of my resume with everywhere I ever worked (sometimes it helps, like for the background check I had to do once), maybe I should be keeping long form discussions of what I worked on, and Then cherry pick the bits that are specific to each position I apply to...
- deepaksurti 6y agoReferrals are the best form of cover letter!
- bananaface 6y agoThe mythos around cover letters seems totally wrong to me. You're telling me that when presented with two candidates, companies routinely pick the less qualified one because... The cover letter was more personalised? They put more custom messages in there? Come on. They're going to turn down a better CV for an interview because the cover letter was copy-pasted? Come on. Companies like the best candidate they can get for the price, I honestly don't think much else matters.
- IneffablePigeon 6y agoAs someone who screens a bunch of applications, absolutely I'll factor in a cover letter. For me, the presence of a cover letter with half an attempt at customisation to the company and job ad demonstrates they actually care at least a little about this role at this company. And if it's well written then that demonstrates communication skills which I value highly in my colleagues. It's really not often clear cut which one of two CVs is the "best qualified". The cover letter is just a bit more signal that will often swing my decision towards "let's take a punt".
- bananaface 6y agoSo in other words: if they have a good CV, they'll get through to the next stage regardless, but if they're a punt candidate then the cover letter might make a difference, maybe? I would then ask: if I'm a punt candidate to begin with, the number of interviews I get is primarily a factor of how many applications I fire off into the crapshoot, right? What's the increase in success rate for applications with cover letters? Is it enough to outweigh the reduction in applications I can send from hand-crafting each of them?
- hackinthebochs 6y ago>demonstrates they actually care at least a little about this role at this company But why does that matter to you other than ego? Barring some exceptionally unique work your company does, we know that the applicant wants to work there because you offer money for their particular skills. Why perpetuate a culture of bullshitting?
- 6y ago
- yibg 6y agoI've been a hiring manager for 5 years and otherwise doing candidate screening for 10+ years. Looking back I don't think a cover letter has played a positive role in getting a candidate through, but probably has played a negative role a few times due to typos etc.
- Dahoon 6y agoLuckily not everyone is living in a place where you apply to a ton of jobs at the same time. Seems very American. I would only apply to a single job that I found exciting. Can't see how sending out many applications could possibly mean applying to good jobs. More like a lottery. Guess it is the difference between there being a good social security net to catch people and not.
- another-dave 6y agoThink it's normal to give yourself multiple options — if you're broadly happy in your current job but come across a job ad that's more exciting you may just apply for it on its own, as your options are to stay put or accept the new role. Staying put would be your 2nd choice. But if you're unhappy in your current place, you're more likely to apply to multiple places at the same time — if you find 2-3 jobs ads that are all better prospects, staying put may now be 4th choice. Plus you may want a contingency if you don't get an offer from choice #1/#2.
- oblio 6y agoIf you're really looking for a job you won't be fussy. Anywhere in the world.
- apeescape 6y agoWhere are you based?
- mehrdadn 6y agoAny chance someone different might've done filtering with cover letters than the person who would call you?
- hrktb 6y agoAnother issue I have is that any pre-written material is a very poor indicator, in particular when candidates are handled to us by a recruiting agent. Their resume is sometimes doctored up to a point it half of it doesn’t make sense, or at least is inflating a lot their role and what they actually did. Reading a cover letter in that light is only indicative of someone who can write cover letters. I never got to hire someone for that skill, so the value is through the floor to me.
- RobPfeifer 6y agoPro-tip: put something actually interesting about you personally on the resume. Literally the first thing I look at after scanning background and making an immediate decision. I think it’s literally the only thing to jar people out of their auto decision (especially with zoom interviews). The one exception is take homes exercises - sometimes I’m surprised but still that doesn’t usually flip the bit
- nullify88 6y agoI believe Denmark takes coverletters seriously. They also want photo of yourself on the CV which is uncommon and often frowned upon in other countries. They want to know a bit more besides your skills and abilities.
- iso947 6y agoPhoto opens the door to early discrimination. What next, marital status?!
- nullify88 6y agoMaybe I'm not thinking about it properly, but if they would discriminate based on my photo, they'll probably do so once they see me in the flesh and give me some excuse to not hire me. I'd rather not go through the wasted effort of making it to a interview and they instead ghost me so I can focus on an employer that does want me.
- iso947 6y agoYou are susceptible to bias at every stage. Maybe your application is filtered by a biased AI, maybe it’s a person, but you are giving more reasons to reject you before reaching the actual recruiters. It’s far easier for a recruiter to discard a resume because of unconscious bias than the allow it to interfere at the interview level
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoInterestingly, it should be 'What before, marital status?!'. Check out the early Bill Gates resume from the 90s, he listed his weight and marital status and apparently that was like totally normal.
- ghaff 6y ago90s seems late for that sort of thing in the US. But it definitely used to be pretty common.
- amf12 6y ago> Every time I got a call, I asked them if my cover letter played a role in their choosing to call me. The response was always "Oh you wrote a cover letter? Let me check it out." > Not one person had read it. This is probably true. But one advantage I see of cover letter is to include more keywords in your application and keep the resume clean and focused. It could potentially get you through keyword filters or boost your ranking in keyword searches.
- jlokier 6y agoThat's an insightful and interesting idea. The need to stuff keywords while also providing a clean and small resume that actually says something interesting other than the keywords, is a difficult tension. Do you have any evidence that the keywords present in a cover letter are taken into account though?
- donkeyd 6y agoThis is also my experience, however, during my most recent interview, my cover letter was actually in front of the interviewer. That was a new experience for me.
- surfsvammel 6y agoI hire people and I read cover letters... if they are short. They are supposed to be cover letters, not essays. Edit: Another tip. If you are sending your CV in an email directly to the company, no need for cover letter. Your email is the cover letter.
- raverbashing 6y agoCover Letter -> body of the email you're sending with your attached CV But that exaggerated importance that some say is recruiter FUD
- rv-de 6y agoWhen I was responsible for hiring I always checked and often read cover letters. Cover letters are an opportunity for the applicant to put her CV coherently into perspective. Because a complete application comes with several documents and lists. The CL is supposed to highlight some of the relevant parts.
- PopeDotNinja 6y agoFor what it’s worth, just because the frontline person doesn’t read your CV, someone else still might. If you’re a solid applicant who interviews almost well enough & the company is fishing for an excuse to give you a shot, a solid cover letter demonstrating interest can mean the difference between getting hired and not. A cover letter doesn’t have to be epic. It can be short and to the point, which bucks the trend of “I didn’t have time to write you a short cover letter, so I wrote you a long one.” Something like... “Hi Company X! I was scooping out your web page and found a blog article on how y’all invest a bunch of time in your security audits. I’ve been reading up a lot in security myself lately, and I’m quite interested in a company that takes that seriously. My personal approach to crafting software tends towards secure by design. I’d love to work in a place that philosophy would be appreciated :) Cheers, PopeDotNinja” Try this... list three to five things you are good at and like. Stalk a company a bit to find something mildly related in their social media, website, or blog. Connect thing you found to thing you like. It take a little work, but not that much work.
- watwut 6y agoI think that if this cover letter changes anything on the hiring process, the hiring process is odd.
- PopeDotNinja 6y agoThe point I'm attempting to communicate is that a little effort can go a long way to show your interest in a position. Many people write long & unpersonalized copy/pasta that says nothing about the job to which they are applying.
- paulcole 6y agoThe only feedback I’d give is: > My personal approach to crafting software tends towards secure by design Whatever you put in your cover letter, try imagining another candidate saying the opposite in their cover letter: > My personal approach to crafting software tends towards insecure by design Nobody would say this right? So your original statement adds nothing. You need to get more specific and direct. Same goes for “reading up a lot in security.” What is 1 thing you were reading and why should whoever’s reading this email care? Other than that not a bad start. You’re on the right track to keep it short and (hopefully) leave them wanting to learn more. Also it’s scoping not scooping.
- brianwawok 6y agoHiring for a few devs right now. Read cover letters. That said if you have never worked a programmer job in your life, a cover letter won’t land you a senior web-dev role.
- thedufer 6y agoI don't think your evidence has much bearing on the point you're trying to make. In my experience from the other side of the table, it's quite common to not talk to the person who picked your resume. I make these introductory phone calls often, and while I have a copy of your application I don't see it until after someone else has decided we should talk to you.
- renewiltord 6y agoI've never read a cover letter. Never planning on it. I have spoken to a few hundred people.
- CalRobert 6y agoI work in a fully remote organization. I _always_ read cover letters. I have wasted too many years of my life trying to decipher some ungodly pile of crap somebody thought was a question (much less a spec!) and a cover letter can be an indication of a candidate's writing ability. Poor writing leads to wasted hours, wasted sprints, and frustration. Good writing shines a light on incomplete reasoning and logical inconsistencies. A person who takes the time to write a decent spec is the person who has considered "what, exactly, do I want?" in detail. Too often people try to paper over their complete inability to write a paragraph by saying "let's get on Zoom" and spewing out nonsense verbally, because this is somehow better than putting nonsense in writing. Unfortunately, if the person reviewing your application is a terrible writer - and most are - it's unlikely your cover letter will be read.
- brown9-2 6y agoIt seems like it would be so much more productive to give the candidate a writing prompt where they can show their skills, instead of such a poor and generic exercise of “tell me who you are and why you want this job even though you’ve spoken to no one at the company yet”. If you value good spec writing then give them a spec-writing exercise.
- lighthazard 6y agoWhat's a nice way of saying, "I want to be paid to work." ?
- gru 6y agoCan you share advice or recommend any resources on how to improve one's writing? Especially with regards to technical writing and communication in remote organizations.
- ghaff 6y agoYou mostly get better at writing by doing it. There are a fair number of online publications that have editors and are always looking for writers. (Not paid but this is a case where it really is good exposure and a way to build skills.) Opensource.com is one I write for fairly frequently.
- Jare 6y agoI inevitably read CVs with a cover letter before those without (unless the cover letter looks like a wall of text). All I ask of a cover letter is that it reminds me to think of you as a human, nothing more; reading lists of projects, employers or education achievements is very dry and mechanical otherwise. A bad cover letter is going to be worse than none, but it really takes very little effort to have something decent and reusable. Many modern CV forms include a small space for it, that's less than ideal but still ok.
- partyboat1586 6y agoJust summarise the best bits of your CV at the top of the CV. That will be read every time.
- AdrianB1 6y agoAs an interviewer for more than 20 years I am never looking for cover letters, but I am trying to read it if they exist. I don't remember to have ever seen a cover letter than made any difference for the process or end result and I had over 1000 interviews (hard to count the exact number, too many years).
- mettamage 6y agoI always write a cover letter. Sometimes they read it. But I time box them to an hour. For me, the cover letter is an exercise in reflection on how much I want to work there. If I feel really enthusiastic then my cover letter just flows. At other times they are more formal. It teaches me a lot about myself.
- thepratt 6y agoIn that small/medium sized company space there are those that publicize nothing about themselves and have such a poorly written JD that tells you nothing about why they exist, their goals, or anything more than possibly irrelevant keywords, then have the requirement for a cover letter. In this instance, they haven't provided a shred of evidence for why someone would want to work with them. I normally see this when non-technical people attempt to hire technical people, they just lack understanding for what is important and are sometimes fresh to hiring in general; less so when technical try to hire technical (but still appears). I'd rather have a conversation with someone who isn't HR, cover letters are mostly wasted effort.
- gpm 6y agoIf you don't have an appropriate contact, sending a good cover letter and acceptable resume to someone who isn't HR is the first step in getting that conversation in my experience.
- jon-wood 6y agoCover letters reduce in value as the size of the organisation increases. When applying for large companies with HR departments I’ve found they don’t really get read because piles of CVs are what gets passed around, but I know for a fact my cover letter is what got me into the interview for both the early stage startups I’ve worked for - when you’re starting as developer number 1 or 2 founders really care about who they’re hiring, and a good cover letter is what allows you to frame the CV in light of the company. For example my current job is with a company that does IoT based home security - a skim of my CV at the time would have been completely unimpressive in that context, but the cover letter allowed me to go into some detail about the fact I’ve been done home automation and electronics as a hobby since before I even had a job.
- sushshshsh 6y agoWhy would I want to work for a company that has 1 year of runway and pays below market rate? If the chance of making millions was 1/100, maybe I would try it. But it seems the real chance is 1/1000? Possibly even 1/5000?
- ghaff 6y agoMaybe because they think the company is doing something really interesting? It's not just about making the most money.
- sushshshsh 6y agoThat's a reason, for sure. But I would say that I have become very cynical about this type of reasoning for the following reasons: 1) If you are interested in working on interesting technology, and the idea is that a traditional corporation provides only soul crushing but possibly more stable/well paying work, then I would simply say its better to have a side project instead of working at a startup, because they are unstable. 2) If you are interested in doing work that will change the world, be aware that if you aren't the boss of the startup, then you can be gone in a second because of profit reasons. Better to start your own non profit like Watsi
- mattoxic 6y agoI would prefer to see a cover letter in applications. It shows effort and that's important. Also, you only have to write one.
- ghaff 6y agoOr at least you can have 3 generic bullets and one that's more specific to a position/company. To be honest, I probably haven't really written one for a long time. But that's because my jobs for the past 20 years or so have come through sending emails to people I knew well.
- chiefalchemist 6y agoThey might not have read it but providing it - when others do not - is a signal. Then there's excessive noise such things might help. The CL + resume isn't to get a job. It's to get an interview. They might not read the CL but it can still help.
- joshuanapoli 6y agoA thoughtful cover letter is very helpful for getting an interview at my company.
- mandeepj 6y agoFor the same reason, I stopped writing a cover letter. I used to write a custom one for each job that I'm applying to. And, of course, it takes time. My take is - if my resume can't convince you to hire me then nothing else will, including a cover letter.
- darkerside 6y agoNo offense, but this is difficult to assign any meaning without more details. Zero is one data point, but what's the denominator? Zero out of 3 vs 30 vs 300 are qualitatively different pieces of information. Also, another common denominator is you. Just because you haven't had success with cover letters doesn't mean others can't or won't. Perhaps, to be blunt, your cover letters weren't very good. Finally, just because the person who called you back didn't read it doesn't mean others didn't. These things end up in systems with lots of eyes on them. That said, I don't disagree with your statement, just the certainty with which it's stated. I agree on balance people should generally play the numbers game, not the custom cover letter game. But, if there's a particular job you really want, it might help.
- ghaff 6y ago>I agree on balance people should generally play the numbers game, not the custom cover letter game. But, if there's a particular job you really want, it might help. If there's some job or some company that you're really interested in and especially if you have some network there that might give you an "unfair" advantage, by all means go above and beyond to maximize your chances at that one company. But I agree in general that, for most people--especially more junior people--it's really a numbers game. That's not to say you shouldn't do little things that might make you stand out a bit for a given employer, but you should mostly be casting a wide net.
- jeffrallen 6y agoI just recruited in Swiss academia, and I read every word of the cover letters, and they played a significant role in selecting the final 3 for interviews. In French it in is called a "letter of motivation" and it should explain why you are more motivated to take and do the job well than all the other candidates. A serious and motivated candidate shows in their letter.
- icedistilled 6y agoIf European academia is similar to American, the application process is quite distinct from the industry job application process. Similarly, as many have said, for an industry job, it depends on whether the company is small, medium or large.
- mindhash 6y agoI write cover letters to highlight specific experience which is in line with the work that company is into. This is just to help the decision maker. I don't care if he or she doesn't read. I would want to take every chance of getting through screening
- JamesBarney 6y ago100% this. When I was interviewing I almost never got the cover letters from HR. When I did glance over them every time it was obviously a form cover letter that they spent 15-30 minutes customizing for our company. If you have something incredibly unique to tell the company like "I want to work for this pharmaceutical company because your newest chemotherapy drug saved my wife's life" I'd sneak it into the resume. Proving to the interviewer that you can write three sentences of generic fluff based on a cursory glance of my company's website doesn't tell me anything about your abilities, just how much you value your time.
- t-vi 6y agoI'm not a HR person but would get applications as local team lead for an actuarial consultancy. I would expect "insurance" and "consultancy" to be related to in the cover letter and invite precisely the people who either do both or have something really interesting somewhere else. A well-written cover letter would also start the conversation in the interview. But I'm based in Germany, not the US.