16 ms·
A man who can read letters but not numbers exposes roots of consciousness
- unclesaamm 6y agoThe last paragraph surprised me even though it shouldn't have. It's shocking to have a clever scientific story suddenly grounded in the reality that this person is rapidly dying. In some sense he has donated his body to science even before he died.
- ketzo 6y agoIt was pretty jarring. You’re reading along, fascinated if you’re me, then jarringly reminded of the fact that this was a human being, not a Petri dish. Empathy’s gotta be one of the most important skills for an experimental social psychologist.
- chki 6y ago>Empathy’s gotta be one of the most important skills for an experimental social psychologist. Or maybe the exact opposite? I would find it very hard to do research and empathize with the subject of my research at the same time. This has also just made me realized that this problem with empathizing with my research is actually highly problematic when it comes to the research I am actually doing at the moment.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- correnos 6y agoAn EMT friend described her take as, you need empathy in order to help people, but you need to be able to switch it off because sometimes what you're about to do is going to hurt them. It's like any of our instinctual responses. Sometimes it helps, sometimes it's in the way.
- KozmoNau7 6y agoIt's not really switching it off as such, it's more that you have to "long-term empathize" with the person you're helping. Setting a broken bone or popping a joint back in to place will hurt right now, but the consequences of not doing it will hurt the person a lot more over time. So you do inflict pain on them right in the moment, which is certainly unpleasant to do, but in the hope that the overall pain and discomfort for them will be significantly lessened. At least that's how a friend of mine (former firefighter) put it.
- foxrider 6y agoI know it's most likely real, but I just can't imagine how this must've felt to have your "eyes" lie to you actively and deliberately. It just doesn't sit well with me.
- asab 6y agoI have also seen this example, where a man blinded by strokes still avoids obstacles and recognizes emotions, without any conscious awareness[1]. Is this the same phenomenon? [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/23/health/23blin.html https://www.nytimes.com/2008/12/23/health/23blin.html
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- namenotrequired 6y agoIt is the phenomenon called blindsight, mentioned in this article. (Edit: but not explained, so your question is reasonable)
- tyingq 6y agoFor reference, from the article: "Sara Ajina, a neuroscientist at the University of Oxford who studies visual awareness deficits such as blindsight—a residual, unconscious “sight” in people with damage to the brain’s visual system..."
- au8er 6y agoFrom what I recall in my neuroscience class, this is likely to be caused by damage to the visual cortex, which is used to consciously process visual information, but not the superior colliculi, which is used to unconsciously process peripheral vision. This is caused by damage to one of the visual processing regions but not others. From the article, it appears something similar has happened. Corticobasal syndrome potentially killed off some brain cells but not others, leading to damage at some areas but not others.
- nabla9 6y agoThat's called blindsight. In the published article they say that there is no evidence of blindsight. There is whole paragraph named: "No Evidence of Implicit Knowledge Found with Discrimination Tasks." >Furthermore, we showed that he exhibited chance-level accuracy on two-choice discrimination tasks for these distorted stimuli, suggesting that his deficit did not spare the sorts of implicit knowledge sometimes found in other deficits of visual awareness
- kebman 6y agoI think it was on this site that someone posted the very interesting perspectives on consciousness by Roger Penrose.[2] From that I found this video by Dr. Stuart Hameroff, M.D.: Microtubules & quantum consciousness.[1] Higly recommended. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R5DqX9vDcOM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R5DqX9vDcOM [2]:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hXgqik6HXc0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hXgqik6HXc0
- sangfroid_bio 6y agoA real life Flowers for Algernon :(.
- leonidasv 6y agoThis has some implications for artificial general intelligence. If consciousness does not automatically emerge from some sufficient high cognitive processing skills, those sci-fi super-human AI may never arrive. Anyway, I feel sorry for this patient. This must be a tough disease to die with.
- perl4ever 6y agoIt's increasingly looking like there are deep biological reasons for expressions like "gut instinct". There are a lot of neurons in the digestive system. A recent paper[2] appeared to show that the fundamental purpose of sleep is to regulate reactive molecules in the digestive system. Another item I saw in quanta, [or somewhere else][0], described how gut bacteria have a direct link to the vertebrate brain and immune system. So my modest proposal is that if we want AGI, we need to figure out how to implement a digestive system in silico. [0] https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2018/09/your-gut-directly-connected-your-brain-newly-discovered-neuron-circuit https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2018/09/your-gut-directly-co... [1]https://www.quantamagazine.org/how-microbiomes-affect-fear-20191204/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/how-microbiomes-affect-fear-2... [2]https://www.quantamagazine.org/why-sleep-deprivation-kills-20200604/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/why-sleep-deprivation-kills-2...
- hackinthebochs 6y ago>So my modest proposal is that if we want AGI, we need to figure out how to implement a digestive system in silico. The problem is that whatever function digestion provides to the mind must do so through modulating neural signals. That is, its influence is purely functional in nature. Thus we can replicate its influence without replicating digestion, e.g. simulate the dynamics of the vagus nerve. There is nothing essential about digestion to consciousness.
- perl4ever 6y agoThe last sentence is a bit facetious.
- maxkwallace 6y agohttps://www.livescience.com/nueroscience-patient-who-can-not-see-numbers.html https://www.livescience.com/nueroscience-patient-who-can-not... ^ This article (reporting on the same research) seems to be a bit better.
- andai 6y agoMaybe so, but the ads were so annoying I couldn't keep reading. It was almost comical how they kept popping up every few seconds, like some kind of parody. Fortunately, https://outline.com/5nJgjL https://outline.com/5nJgjL Curiously this article presents a different hypothesis about why he is able to read 0 and 1: > It's also "surprising" that his brain doesn't have problems with "0" and "1," McCloskey added. It's not clear why, but those two numbers might look similar to letters like "O" or "lowercase l," he said. Or those two numbers might be processed differently than other numbers in the brain, as "zero wasn't invented for quite a long time after the other digits were," he said.
- Camillo 6y ago> Or those two numbers might be processed differently than other numbers in the brain, as "zero wasn't invented for quite a long time after the other digits were," he said. Come on, that's just silly. What are they even suggesting here? Zero is encoded in a different area of RMS's brain because he learned it as an adult, after its invention under the Nixon administration? Also from that page: "The group of researchers created new digits for RFS which they called "surrogate digits" so that he could use them in daily life." That's just not some sort of new jargon, it's what the word surrogate means! How does someone end up writing for a living without learning how to use a dictionary?
- TwoBit 6y agoI knew an older woman who had a hard time remembering freeways by their numbers but could remember them all by their names (e.g. "Santa Ana" freeway instead of "5"). That seemed odd because to me the number was the name, so why be any different?
- bitbckt 6y agoThey weren’t always numbered. Up north, there are still people who refer to Highway 40 as Lincoln Highway. I’ve heard a couple of LA natives say that’s an explanation for SoCal’s affinity for calling them “the 5”: they switched from “the Santa Ana”.
- war1025 6y ago> there are still people who refer to Highway 40 as Lincoln Highway This is interesting to me because here in Iowa, the Lincoln Highway is "old Highway 30". In the 60s they rerouted Hwy30 about a mile south of the existing Lincoln Way so they could make it 4 lane and avoid towns.
- war1025 6y agoIn case it wasn't obvious from my post above, the Lincoln Highway referred to in both my post and the parent post is the same highway [1]. The part I thought was interesting is I assumed it would have the same number designation across the entire nation, but that doesn't appear to be the case. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lincoln_Highway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lincoln_Highway
- Xenograph 6y ago> In contrast, when shown numbers with embedded faces, the number’s effect apparently swamped that of the face: RFS reported seeing neither; everything looked like spaghetti. Yet an EEG still showed the characteristic N170 spike for registering faces. Somehow, his brain was still processing and identifying a face—a fairly high-level skill—even though his conscious mind was oblivious. This deficit shows high-level cognitive processing and consciousness are distinct, Koch says. “You can get one without the other.” I think this misses another possibility besides "cognitive processing and consciousness are distinct". Namely, "the part of them that is conscious of the cognitive processing is not well-connected to the part of them that is generating speech and controlling their motor systems."
- andai 6y agoSometimes I read about split-brain experiments and wonder, if my brain were to split, which side I'd end up on?
- all_blue_chucks 6y agoBoth.
- komali2 6y agoWhat even is I though?
- mojuba 6y ago"I" is something that knows its place in space and time, the here-and-now, but also has a memory of here-and-now moments of the past. As such "I" is an illusion. If a quantum clone of you is created both I's will have the same memory of the past here-and-now moments, so both will be you at the same. So probbaly something similar happens if a brain is split.
- apoorvkumar 6y agoAbout your analogy - quantum cloning may not be allowed by laws of nature. That would make any consciousness unique at any point in time. Also I feel the experiment suggests split brains would most likely become 2 very different (new?) entities with different behavior after losing integrity.
- kovac 6y agoI don't understand how these experiments lead to the conclusion separates higher cognitive functions from consciousness. I fact I don't see anything that necessarily she'd any light into the roots of consciousness here. Can someone explain how the results of the experiment lead to that conclusion? This looks to me like, if it were a computer program, encoding/decoding of the symbols seems to be messed up for a largely contiguous block of symbols. Like you get jumbled up weird shapes when you feed the wrong encoding to a program.
- randcraw 6y agoI think RFS' loss is a little deeper than ablation of a contiguous block of symbols, since characters and numerals aren't likely to be represented sequentially in the brain they way they are on keyboards or ASCII. I agree with your conclusion otherwise. I see no connection to cognition in what the scientists explored. Specifically, RFS' loss was specific to both encoding (recognition) and decoding (writing) of only those numerals that have no analogs among letters (not 0 or 1) had failed in RFS. Presumably this implies that the neurons that map the visual coding for numerals 2-9 in the cortex to and from their underlying concepts were lost. However the concept of each numeral persisted, so RFS could learn replacement glyphs and map them to the concepts, thereby using them as equivalents to numerals 2-9. So I agree with you, this seems like only selective damage to the V2 or V3 portions of the visual cortex used strictly to encode/decode numerals 2-9. I too see nothing related to higher cognition or consciousness, at least in the early stage of RFS' disease mentioned here. Methinks the author at Science Mag who summarized the work got a bit carried away in seeking cosmic revelations therein.
- sinuhe69 6y agoMy understanding is he could see the numbers but failed to recognize or make sense of these pictures.He wasn’t aware of the letter pictures anymore and could not associate them with the “numerical symbols” stored in his memory (if our brains do it this way). But with the stored symbols he still can do mental math so his higher cognitive function must be at least partly intact. Using the computer program metaphor we can say his input routine for numbers is scrambled but the other calculation routines remained intact. My guest is because we do math, our brain create the association for not only the numbers but also what we do with these numbers (maths routines). And because we don’t work with numbers all the time (we also can do symbolic maths), it’s necessary to separate the numbers with its meaning to accomplish these feats. If I would “program” our brain, it’ll be much more efficient to separate the recognition routines with the higher-function routines because we need to adjust the recognition routines all the time due the (slightly) different fonts and hand scripts of all the people.
- djhaskin987 6y ago> That he could still interpret letters, Schubert says, lends support to the idea that the brain has a specialized module for processing numbers. This makes a lot of sense to me. I have almost no trouble at all remembering long strings of numbers, but I have the opposite problem with names. I cannot remember names to save my life unless I use them on a daily basis. I feel like this is a flip-flop from how most people process information. It seems to me that lots of people are very very good at remembering names and have a hard time remembering numbers. some people look at me offended when I forget their name as if the only reason I would ever forget their name was because I didn't like them. It's very embarrassing. When I show I can remember numbers or lines of code just by looking at them once, people are amazed but then move on.
- randcraw 6y agoI too. If a name is unfamiliar to me, even if it's no more than 5-6 letters long, I can't for the life of me recall it. But I can remember random sequences of numerals up to length 12. Why? I wonder if there's some term for this malady, like 'literophasia' or 'numeraphilia'? I wonder too if it occurs equally as often in both genders. I would guess not.
- djhaskin987 6y agoTo add some color to this, if it's a common name it's really hard to remember but if it's a foreign name to me or something I've never heard of, it's as if my brain thinks it's a random sequence of sounds and I'll remember it forever. Indian names, native Hawaiian names, no problem, but forget about it if your name is George. It's just the common names I'm used to that I have a hard time with.
- isoprophlex 6y agoSecond that, i have that with organic chemicals. Diazabicycloundecene, sure, used it once, will remember it forever. Oh nice to meet you George, what was your name again?!
- copperx 6y ago
- Camillo 6y agoIf he had simply lost the ability to recognize the glyphs for 2-9, he would have still seen their shapes, and he could have learned them again, just as he learned new glyphs for them. What seems to be happening here is a sort of crosstalk or feedback. His brain is still recognizing the glyphs, but those neurons are sending unwanted signals elsewhere in his visual cortex which scramble the perceived image. My interpretation of this case is that the image we perceive consciously is a combination of the raw visual data and various recognition modules, so that we don't just perceive "a curved line crossing back on itself in the lower right of the image" plus "the abstract notion of the number 8", but we see the number 8 localized where the line forming it is. Same with any other symbols, objects, faces etc. Because of this, the neurons that represent the conscious perception of a certain section of the visual field must receive both "low-level" information (the curves forming the digit, their color, the color of the background), but also "mid-level" recognition output ("the digit 8"). So if the neuron(s) recognizing the 8 act up and send scrambled signals, they can scramble the whole conscious perception of the corresponding area of the visual field. The fact that it also disrupts his conscious perception of faces overlying the digit confirms this.
- jamiek88 6y agoInteresting. The way we can do captchas suggests you may be on to something there.
- whoisjuan 6y ago> 0 and 1 looked normal—perhaps because those digits resemble letters Or perhaps this is proof that we live in a simulation that is written in binary.
- neom 6y agoAs someone with really bad dyslexia and dyscalculia I can't say I'm particularly surprised. I've done a lot of research on what neurologic differences are present and they're fairly interesting: http://www.neuroanatomy.wisc.edu/selflearn/Dyslexia.htm http://www.neuroanatomy.wisc.edu/selflearn/Dyslexia.htm https://www.brainfacts.org/archives/2011/dyslexia-and-the-brain-today https://www.brainfacts.org/archives/2011/dyslexia-and-the-br...
- joshspankit 6y agoWould you be interested in adding what you’ve learned to the discussion here: https://www.kialo.com/our-perception-as-humans-is-not-necessarily-the-same-as-any-other-human-30317?path=30317.0~30317.1 https://www.kialo.com/our-perception-as-humans-is-not-necess... ?
- Marsymars 6y agoReading is weird. I've never had migraines, but a few years ago suddenly, and briefly, lost the ability to read and write. After a number of doctors and tests ruling out a TIA, best guess is one-time transient aphasia from a migraine aura.
- outerouterspace 6y agoSame thing happened to me in college, although I never went to the doctor about it. I thought it was a drug flashback at first, and was terrified it was permanent, but it went away after about two hours.
- stordoff 6y agoMigraines in general are weird. It's rare[1], but I can occasionally tell when a severe migraine is about to occur because rooms feel too big. I walked into my bathroom a few days ago (which is about 2mx2m/6'x6'), and each wall seemed about 2 feet longer than it should, and the far corner looked about 3 feet too far away (it was more a feeling than a visual disturbance - it's hard to describe). I felt _small_, which is a really odd feeling when it comes on suddenly. About an hour later, I had a severe migraine. I'm assuming it's a subtle form of Alice in Wonderland syndrome[2]. [1] I get regular migraines, but I can only remember this happening a few times, possibly because it's fairly subtle [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_in_Wonderland_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_in_Wonderland_syndrome
- jimmaswell 6y agoI've never had a migraine but I've definitely had that feeling like the room was too big. I think it only happened once or twice as a kid from a fever or something.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoI had that as a kid for a while; when it reached its peak, I ended up in hospital with meningitis. From that period, I distinctively remember feeling small and the room walls and ceiling receding somewhat, and also some weird stuff with colors - I could focus on the visual noise I saw (kind of like the noise you get in a digital camera in low-light condition), and focusing on that would trigger the feeling of the world expanding / me shrinking. All of this only happened at night.
- aaron-santos 6y ago> eventually mastered an entirely new digit system (where ⌊ stood for 2, ⌈ for 8, etc.) Why invent a specialized number system? How difficult would it have been to teach him Chinese numerals for example. Also very curious on his perception of Roman numerals.
- henriquemaia 6y agoBrilliant. Roman numerals are, after all, just letters. The "why haven't they used them?" becomes pretty jarring once you think about it.
- rocqua 6y agoRoman numerals are a lot harder to do arithmetic with.
- henriquemaia 6y agoTrue. Maybe that's the reason why they chose that new system.
- Sharlin 6y agoRoman numerals are not a place-value system and you can’t make a computer use Roman numerals just by switching to a custom font.
- scatters 6y agoOpenType font shaping is shockingly powerful ([e.g.](https://blog.janestreet.com/commas-in-big-numbers-everywhere/) https://blog.janestreet.com/commas-in-big-numbers-everywhere...), so I'd be surprised if someone hasn't made a Roman numeral font already.
- Sharlin 6y agoHeh, I knew I should have said something about OpenType shenanigans :)
- sradman 6y agoThe original paper Lack of awareness despite complex visual processing: Evidence from event-related potentials in a case of selective metamorphopsia [1] is not as Freudian as the article about “consciousness”: > How does the neural activity evoked by visual stimuli support visual awareness? In this paper we report on an individual with a rare type of neural degeneration as a window into the neural responses underlying visual awareness. When presented with stimuli containing faces and target words—regardless of whether the patient was aware of their presence—the neuro-physiological responses were indistinguishable. These data support the possibility that extensive visual processing, up to and including activation of identity, can occur without resulting in visual awareness of the stimuli. [1] https://www.pnas.org/content/117/27/16055 https://www.pnas.org/content/117/27/16055
- surround 6y agoThis reminds me of two mind-boggling discoveries I’ve had about the human mind. The first is that the two halves of your brain act somewhat independently. And in rare cases, people’s left and right halves are “split” apart, and they act entirely independently - e.g. their left and their right hands will act separately, or even argue with each other. CGP Grey made a great video about this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wfYbgdo8e-8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wfYbgdo8e-8 The other is that most people have a “voice” inside their head - e.g. when they read, they hear their own voice inside their head reading; their thoughts are like sentences they “hear;” they could look in the mirror have a conversation with themselves. Some ~10% of people do not have this internal monologue. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22193451 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22193451 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11162927 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11162927
- henriquemaia 6y ago> Somehow, his brain was still processing and identifying a face—a fairly high-level skill—even though his conscious mind was oblivious. I'm maybe wrong about this, but isn't the ability to recognize faces a fairly low-level skill? Case is point being other social animals having it, like apes, monkeys, or even sheep [1] (who can even recognize human faces [2]). So maybe they're here referring to the ability of seeing representations of faces (little faces on the letters). Or is this just a blunder of the person who wrote the sciencemag article? [^1] http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/1641463.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/1641463.stm [^2] https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-41905652 https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-41905652
- sradman 6y agoThe paper describes “event-related potential (ERP)” [1] measured via EEG. “The N170 is a component of the event-related potential (ERP) that reflects the neural processing of faces, familiar objects or words.” [2] They also measured the inverse of recognition “...improbable events will elicit a P3b, and the less probable the event, the larger the P3b.” [3] [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Event-related_potential https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Event-related_potential [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/N170 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/N170 [3] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/P3b https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/P3b
- macleginn 6y agoThere is a difference between “low level” and “human specific”. Faces are highly complex geometrically, while numbers, such as 8, are simple. Animals sure can recognise simple shapes (https://docsmith.co/2007/01/can-animals-recognize-shapes/ https://docsmith.co/2007/01/can-animals-recognize-shapes/), but they cannot endow them with abstract meanings, such as "number 8". The person in the article lost the basic ability of recognising very simple shapes while still being able to recognise more complex shapes, like faces, and to operate with abstract concepts.
- mantap 6y agoBabies can recognise faces so I would definitely class it as low-level. Anything you can do as a baby is low-level. High-level are things like reading and writing that are learned rather than evolved.
- dreamcompiler 6y agoThe SF novel Blindsight by Peter Watts explores the idea of aliens that are cognizant but not conscious. Fascinating book. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blindsight_(Watts_novel) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blindsight_(Watts_novel)
- Symmetry 6y agoBlindsight was a well crafted book but it sort of underplayed the benefits that consciousness gives us. We're bombarded by a huge number of sensory impressions at any given time. The unconscious parts of our brain do a huge amount of work in processing it and figuring out which bits are important. But without consciousness to synchronize, serialize, and persist it then all that information will just fade away within a few seconds. To remember something, or talk about it, or engage in multi-step planning regarding it you need to be consciously and not subliminally aware of it.
- rini17 6y agoPerhaps the coherently serialized stream of qualia isn't the only possible way to intelligence?
- Symmetry 6y agoOh clearly not, GPT-3 clearly produces fairly intelligent responses but by the mechanisms that in a human would be pure reflex. And your unconscious reflexes can produce responses that can be relatively intelligent at times. It's just that creates with brains that evolved on Earth need consciousness to remember anything more than a couple of seconds. Also, who knows how qualia fit into this, if they exist they might very well exist for subliminal stimuli too. In the scientific study of consciousness qualia aren't a part of the paradigm really. And in philosophical investigations of consciousness don't have subliminal stimuli as part of their paradigm.
- rini17 6y agoAnd how do you call the stuff which gets filtered by consciousness so that it can remember more than a couple of seconds? That's what I meant by the qualia. As an example what I mean and it was recently on HN, too: apparently the perception of "now" is a hack supported by delays so that input from various senses is perceived as synchronized even if it does not arrive synchronized to the brain, plus compensating the temporary blindness while doing saccades. Aliens could have different "hack" there, resulting in profoundly different perception of time.
- pulkitsh1234 6y agoSomehow this is not surprising for me, I have heard about experiments related to free-will wherein the brain already made a decision even before the conscious mind became aware of it. Thus putting doubts on our conscious experience of free-will. Also, in terms of problem solving, there are experiments which show that the brain calculates the answers and "presents" the answers later on to the consciousness. It's not like the problems were solved within the scope of consciousness, which is of course contradictory to what we experience. We feel the contradictions because we experience everything through consciousness, i.e. we can't experience things which happen outside realm of consciousness. The brain scans prove in a sense that there is a disconnect (For instance in this article the brain scans showed signals related to seeing faces in the numbers, but the conscious experience was not seeing them). The link between what the brain does, and what we experience (consciousness) is indeed the hard problem of consciousness.
- pulkitsh1234 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroscience_of_free_will#Libet_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroscience_of_free_will#Libe... For more context.
- akiselev 6y agoAll of the research you describe can be safely bundled into the same category as "dead salmon shows brain activity on an fMRI if you squint hard enough." It's phrenology for the 21st century, except with dyes and MRIs instead of head shaped calipers. The second you say the words "conscious mind", you leave the realm of science. At best, "consciousness" is an abstraction used by psychiatrists and laypeople over much deeper, more complex, and less understood concepts in neuroscience. The field has yet to differentiate the roles neural plasticity plays between newborns, the average college student, and brain trauma victims - let alone grapple with the implication that our brains are the result of a billion years of evolution. The nature of human intelligence is far wilder than you or I can imagine, Horatio, but publish-or-perish cannon fodder is clearly not the answer.
- corin_ 6y ago
- seemslegit 6y agoSomething that is (crucially) missing from the article but appears in the paper: his ability to read words describing numbers like "five" remains in tact, and so is his ability to read Roman numerals.
- stormdennis 6y agoWhen they gave him the foam 8 he didn't recognize it and they speculated it was because the brain prioritised sight over the sense of touch. Surely they tried the same experiment after asking him to close his eyes first?
- ketzo 6y agoOh man, I wonder what he pictured in his head if he tried to picture an 8 instead of read one? Nothing? Squiggles? Headache? Honestly, I could ask a billion more questions about this situation. So fascinating.
- punnerud 6y agoLike the Google Translate app that live translates from camera, there could be developed googles for him that translate everything that looks like 2..9 into his new representation of numbers.
- Razengan 6y ago“Intelligence” is a 100 different little daemons running in tandem. I’m surprised at how this analogy almost never comes up in a community of programmers.
- Symmetry 6y agoIf you're interested in learning more about how sensory impressions go on to become conscious awareness, at least so far as we knew 5 years ago, I'd highly recommend the book Consciousness and the Brain.
- badrabbit 6y agoSilly question: how do they know he isn't lying?
- chiefalchemist 6y agoJust to clarify a bit, it's possible he can't communicate thoughts about numbers. That's a different perspective than can't read them. I say this because my father had a stroke ~3 years ago. It compromised him significantly. He definitely can communicate the way he used to. But one of the patterns we've seen is he can have a thought, but he can't communicate it. He tries but it doesn't come out. I haven't recognized it's specific like the man in the article. But I wanted to mention that processing and communication are two seperate steps.
- whearyou 6y agoI hate to say this, but could he just be lying? That’s what I worry about when we try to learn a lot about human minds from a case.
- luizfzs 6y agoThe post only mentions recognizing letters and digits, but no mention of the subject actually writing them. Since the subject was an engineer, maybe writing numbers would be a sort of mechanical thing, that could bypass that limitation? That would've been a nice addition to this study.
- dandare 6y agoAs a software developer I imagine the brain not as some separated layers but as a huge collection of routines/procedures, for this or that (including procedure for understanding numbers), interconnected with a spaghetti code of links. Many of these processes specialise in making decisions and calling other processes. One specialised procedure is called the consciousness, it is blind to the rest of the processes and it is tricked into believing that it does all the calculations while it merely reads the results from other processes. Also, I highly recommend the book The Language Instinct by Steven Pinker.
- pessimizer 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epiphenomenalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epiphenomenalism Read Patricia Churchland instead:)
- Lambdanaut 6y agoThe consciousness procedure also has links out to the other procedures. It calls them with inputs based on what they send it. It' a co-recursive system.
- alanbernstein 6y agoI like to think of it as not even a collection of procedures, but just a giant jumble of self-modifying spaghetti code.
- hrgiger 6y agoCan you relate this with color blindless? Most of time I could swear I could see that green,orange and red different but somehow my brain refuses to identify them.
- hnarn 6y agoI might be wrong but my understanding was that the cause of color blindness is an abnormality in the retina, not a neurological condition.
- hackinthebochs 6y agoThere are definitely cases where color-blindness is caused by a neurological issues. Strokes can cause temporary or permanent colorblindness, for example.
- eivarv 6y agoHow is "cognition != consciousness" surprising, especially given the (now old) fMRI studies complicating (our experience of) free will? Why would one assume awareness and processing abilities to be related, if there is no evidence for it?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lisper 6y agoI call shenanigans. There is nothing inherently different about numbers and letters. They are all just abstract shapes. There is no possible way that evolution could have produced a mechanism that could distinguish between the two without training.
- whatshisface 6y agoIf evolution was responsible for character recognition, reading would not be taught in schools...
- lisper 6y agoYes, that was kind of my point.
- Nasrudith 6y agoCouldn't the brain damage have essentially caused the state from the training process for those specific glyphs to fail with "garbage" associations? Thus he gets disoroentating confusion and reinforced revulsion when he tries to understand interfering with any occupational therapy to retrain it such that arbitrary glyphs lacking such associations didn't have those issues.
- lisper 6y agoYes, that's possible. (I actually missed the bit about the brain damage. I somehow got the impression that article said that he was born with this. I guess I skimmed too fast.)
- peter303 6y agoLetters are phonograms with strong clues about pronunciation. Numerals are pure ideograms with no clue about pronunciation. Modern English is a mix of phonograms and ideograms, with more of the former. Its very likely they trigger different subsystems of the brain. And in this case the ideogram subsystem was defective.