2 ms·
Who has ever been a part of a mass lawsuit for making a copy of a DVD and giving it to a friend?
by jrockway 16y ago
Who has ever been a part of a mass lawsuit for making a copy of a DVD and giving it to a friend?
- tzs 16y agoProbably no one, since people copying DVDs offline generally only give them to a handful of friends, tops. Try making many thousands of physical copies of DVDs and handing them out to random strangers, and I'll bet you'd get sued--and almost no one would be outraged that you got sued. Do it on the internet, and suddenly people think you are a victim. The same thing happens with defamation, too. If I printed out a bunch of flyers accusing you of something horrible and not true, and posted them around your town, very few people would have a problem with you suing me, and with me losing. However, if instead I post the same things about you on an online forum, and you sue, then to a lot of people will think you are the bad guy trying to stop free speech. The general principle in the article, that law should really be the same online and offline, is a good one. After all, law is mostly about how people interact. The medium should not matter. All the internet really changes is that our actions can have a wider impact, and that some things are a lot easier to do on the internet.
- spullara 16y agoI think the big difference here is that in the physical world all that work that lead up to distributing 1000s of DVDs carries much more weight to the person making the copies. With Napster it was literally just start the program and point it at your music folder. People don't see it as "fair" that you can click twice and be doing the same crime as someone who methodically collected all the DVD copying hardware, bought disks, made the copies, found distributors and systematically created a business whose purpose and intent was completely clear. I think the same logic for people applies to people posting in forum. Computers have drastically increased the productivity of everything, including breaking the law, to the point where it was so easy there was no time to think about what they were doing.
- jrockway 16y agoPeople online don't make thousands of copies. The most I have ever made is about 5. The most most people make is around 1 or 2. I have never seen a non-seeder with a ratio of 1000. (To upload 1000 copies of a DVD on 768kbps DSL would take over a year!) In addition, the lawsuits are based on sending a few bytes of the file to someone who has a legal right to those bytes (the company that released the movie). Bittorrent is like making a copy of a DVD, smashing it into a thousand pieces, and giving each pies to a random passerby. When you get sued, it's because one of those passerbys is a laweyer for the company that released the movie. And the reason you are being sued for $millions is because he now has that shattered fragment of a DVD. Pretty shaky.
- tzs 16y ago> In addition, the lawsuits are based on sending a few bytes of the file to someone who has a legal right to those bytes (the company that released the movie). The lawsuits are based on unauthorized creation and distribution of copies of copyrighted material. What you describe is part of the evidence used to prove that. If the defendant wishes to argue that they normally ran their P2P software in a mode that did not actually share anything, and it was only some weird glitch that one time when the movie company happened to be sniffing that led to an accidental release of bits, they are free to try it, and the jury is free to decide its probative value. > Bittorrent is like making a copy of a DVD, smashing it into a thousand pieces, and giving each pies to a random passerby. If you did that, you would no longer have the pieces that you distributed, which breaks the analogy.
- Dylan16807 16y agoRead that again. The copies are given away. It's a perfectly good analogy, and if you want to get really picky it's also accurate on a technical level. An ephemeral copy in memory and TCP is made, given away, and lost.
- tzs 16y agoOK, I did misread it. It's still not a good analogy, though, because if you made a physical copy of a DVD and smashed it and gave the pieces to random people, they would be useless. Even if a large number of people were doing the same thing, it would be very hard to reassemble the pieces. With bittorrent, the pieces are all carefully constructed so that they will be easy to put back together, and everyone doing it is "smashing" their DVD the same way, so you can put together pieces from different people.