21 ms·
Apple halved app store fee to get Amazon Prime video on devices
- LeoNatan25 6y agoTim Cook: "sAmE RuLeS ApPlY To eVeRyOnE"
- Godel_unicode 6y agoExcept in this case they do: https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2020/10661 https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2020/10661
- sdinsn 6y agoAnd Cook is being honest: everyone can negotiate with Apple about their fees. Don't be shocked if Apple doesn't budge, because you actually have to offer something to make it worthwhile.
- taylorhou 6y agointeresting how bigger players are able to negotiate discounts/preference when arguably they are more suited to not need the discount - whereas 15% could be the difference between bankruptcy and breakeven or ramen profitability for a small startup/business.
- BiteCode_dev 6y agoIn a system where money is power, and the economy encourages its concentration, you always end up with such unbalances. The invisible hand cannot help here: demand will ask for cheaper prices (the 99% have a big stack of cash as a group, but a small one individually, so they seek savings), which the economy of scale will only make happen for the bigger players. At some point, fair competition is not possible anymore. Not to mention the ability to negotiate is driven by who you can afford to hire, who you know, how sustainable you are, etc.
- Fiveplus 6y ago>ability to negotiate is driven by who you can afford to hire, who you know, how sustainable you are This is a good point, often subtly overlooked when discussing similar topics.
- WalterBright 6y agoYou mention economy of scale - that's why quantity discounts exist. It definitely is the invisible hand at work.
- acituan 6y ago> In a system where money is power, and the economy encourages its concentration, you always end up with such unbalances. Is money really the only power? For all I know these companies depend on consumers’ attention and consumption. Not only that, the people who run them depend on continuous growth of those to keep their positions. To the extent consumer interests can organize (which includes democratic, legal, informational organization and organizing consumption behavior) there are always ways out. > The invisible hand cannot help here Maybe invisible hand was never there to help. Maybe that is the origin of such a defeatist perspective. Companies are not gods, markets are not forces of nature. They are more like semi-useful entities and processes that can also parasitize our stone age psychology for their own ends. It is on to us to realize our own part in that equation.
- coldtea 6y ago>Is money really the only power? For all I know these companies depend on consumers’ attention and consumption. Which doesn't translate to any great power for smaller developers, who don't command much of consumers attention anyway. Try getting Amazon Prime, or Spotify out of the App Store and there will be a riot. Some smaller app few care about? Not so much... >Not only that, the people who run them depend on continuous growth of those to keep their positions. The people who run them will get their bonuses and golden parachutes even if they burn the companies to the ground. And after that they can retire or easily find other positions in different companies soon enough. It's lesser employees that depend on growth to keep their jobs...
- edoceo 6y agoThe ancient rule of "them that gots is them that gets".
- tinyhouse 6y agoThe worse case of this is with medical billing in the US. Health insurance companies get discounts while individuals do not...
- philwelch 6y agoSure they do. I’ve negotiated discounts on medical bills a few times.
- dazhbog 6y agoFrom 1000% markup to 500% markup?
- philwelch 6y agoI’ve gotten the exact same price the insurance company pays pretty consistently, and sometimes even less.
- ensignavenger 6y agoI've attempted to negotiate medical bills and gotten no where in the past, so that's another anecdote.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoIt’s not the same to discount a bill (that you legally owe) compared to an insurance company having pre negotiated prices. If a healthcare provider decides to lower the amount they claim you owe because they believe it will cost them more to pursue you more than they will receive, that’s different than agreeing to a price before the services or products are exchanged.
- philwelch 6y agoThe question is, what do you bring to the table? Maybe the App Store runs on AWS and Amazon gives Apple a discount on AWS so Apple reciprocates for Amazon’s apps. I don’t think their working relationship is all roses or anything—they were feuding a few years back—but agreements like this are negotiated because they leave everyone who agrees to them better off in some way. It could even be as simple as your app being so important that people won’t buy the phone if it can’t run it. Ultimately it doesn’t matter because for a new startup, you’re more focused on creating value from scratch than on optimizing your margins.
- penagwin 6y agoInterestingly you also can't purchase kindle ebooks on Apple devices at all, which I beleive is to skip the apple tax.
- philwelch 6y agoYeah, that’s one of the ways that it’s not all roses between them. Amazon has played hardball with Apple too, sometimes refusing to sell their products.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoI alone don't bring much to the table. But multiply it by thousands of developer and that "not much" starts to add up. Apple should want to encourage a vibrant app ecosystem, no? Who knows how many cool or useful apps just never get made because the developers can't deal with the App Store.
- philwelch 6y agoYeah, if it turns out that a standard rate of 25% would work out better for them than 30%, they should lower the rate to 25%. Is the current app ecosystem not vibrant enough? I think they’re doing fine as it is but it’s very literally not my business :)
- simonh 6y agoOh come on, the App Store is overflowing with Apps. The amount of options on there is overwhelming. If anything there’s too much competition and too many apps, driving down the prices companies can charge for premium products due to oversupply. And don’t tell me that’s Apples fault as well, because the 30% on low prices makes businesses unsustainable. Which is it, does the 30% discourage companies from participating, or does the App Store 30% and all enable too much competition for premium apps. It can’t be both.
- supernova87a 6y agoCelebrities get free gift bags full of stuff they could easily afford, in order to promote their brand. Frequent flier programs give out more bonuses to people who fly a lot and are probably rich, to incentivize them to fly more. Companies give price breaks to huge volume buyers. Is this behavior, in concept at least, not familiar?
- CubsFan1060 6y agoIsn't this pretty average business? Amazon (and the others) are bringing more business and get a discount. AWS does this. So does monoprice (volume pricing). My local landscaping place does this (contractors buying more tons of rock get a better price). Home depot has "contractor pricing" when you buy multiples of things.
- clusterfish 6y agoThe examples you give are driven by competition forcing the suppliers to share their economies of scale. Those deals are available to everyone and the pricing is also upfront. This Apple-Amazon situation on the other hand is a secret deal between two monopolistic powers, that's why it's coming up in hearings on anticompetitive behaviour. Such a deal is not available to everyone equally, it's not at all similar to Monoline / homedepot pricing.
- ryanisnan 6y agoI think it definitely is pretty standard. What's not standard is, when you are buying physical goods like that, you have competition. You can source better rates. With Apple, you have no competition. It is accept the pricing model, or leave.
- CubsFan1060 6y agoYou leave as in going to Lowes? Or going to Android?
- ryanisnan 6y agoTalking about mobile devices, you can't simply "go to Android". What you are purchasing when you pay Apple's fees are access to a userbase (among other things like the ecosystem). If you switch to Android, you are no longer buying the same product. Talking about things like bricks, it would be more like if Home Depot was the only brick seller, and if you didn't like their brick terms, you could leave and buy instead 2x4s elsewhere.
- amelius 6y agoIt's the economic version of "those who need love/affection the most are the least likely to receive it".
- wmf 6y agoBigger players don't necessarily have bigger margins.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoWould you give the same prices to someone who is buying a lot from you versus someone who is buying a little? I’ve never seen a seller (of product or services) not give volume discounts. If they didn’t, they would be out of businesses quickly, as I’m sure other sellers would be more than happy to discount.
- beervirus 6y agoWelcome to earth. You get what you can take, not what you "deserve."
- JeremyBanks 6y agoThe Amazon deal appears to buttress lawmakers’ claims that not all apps are treated equally, a contention Cook rejected during the hearing. “That is not correct,” Cook said when asked if some developers are treated differently. “We treat every developer the same.”
- gotostatement 6y ago"We treat everyone the same. Everyone is equally allowed to use their position as a trillion dollar business to negotiate a deal."
- ryanisnan 6y agoI think this is in essence the problem. Well put.
- Spivak 6y agoI mean you don't have to be a trillion dollar business. Your ability to negotiate a deal is mostly how valuable you are to Apple, or at least how valuable you're perceived. If Apple doesn't need your business you're gonna be stuck paying full price.
- ByteJockey 6y agoIsn't the old line that you deserve whatever you can convince people to give you?
- WalterBright 6y agoQuantity discounts are normal. The reason is pretty simple - your costs to deliver a quantity product is lower than an individual one.
- readams 6y agoFor content distributors whose margins are far less than 15%, it's a death sentence that means only Apple is allowed to distribute content.
- scarface74 6y agoThere is an existence proof that isn’t true. All of the streaming providers have apps for the AppleTV - even those that don’t allow in app subscriptions.
- readams 6y agoAnd that seems like an equal competitive footing to you?
- scarface74 6y agoWhat other competition do you want? Any app gets a placement on the AppleTV once it is installed and any app can but is not required to integrate with the TV app. Netflix doesn’t integrate with the TV app completely (Netflix’s choice) but when you search for a TV show or movie, if the app is installed , Apple tells you when it’s available for free with one of your third party subscriptions instead of steering you to buy it from them. I can say “watch DareDevil on Netflix” from the AppleTV and it launches Netflix. If I do it on my phone there is an “open in” button and it lets me choose Netflix.
- learnstats2 6y agoIt's monopolistic behaviour on both sides. Apple gets away with charging a flat rate of 30% on the App Store because there are no reasonable alternatives (Apple has worked hard to ensure that there are none) Amazon gets away with negotiating this down because there is no reasonable alternative. In my opinion this provides evidence that the App Store cut should be regulated.
- hardtke 6y agoThis could be the nail in the coffin for Apple with regards to Spotify's antitrust complaint in Europe.
- scarface74 6y agoSpotify reportedly got the same deal. Spotify hasn’t allowed in app purchases for years. Spotify’s complaint was that Apple gave Apple Music special treatment when it came to its platform like how Siri integrates with it and how it was Spotify couldn’t stream directly over the Apple Watch. Apple opened up both to third parties over a year ago - and Spotify supports neither.
- CubsFan1060 6y agoSpotify supports siri. "Play AC/DC on Spotify" works just fine.
- pornel 6y agoThat's very new. Until recently all you got was an excuse that it doesn't work and a suggestion to use Apple Music instead. It doesn't work on my HomePod yet.
- scarface74 6y agoHomePod support for third party music services was just announced this year.
- scarface74 6y agoThat’s very recent...and still no standalone Watch support at least as of April. https://community.spotify.com/t5/iOS-iPhone-iPad/Apple-Watch-offline-usage/td-p/4922721 https://community.spotify.com/t5/iOS-iPhone-iPad/Apple-Watch...
- sercand 6y agoSpotify’s Apple Watch app terrible because Spotify wants it’s that way. Other music streaming apps did build really good Apple Watch apps already[1]. I believe that Spotify just don’t want to integrate well with the system so that they can use it as a leverage. [1]: https://9to5mac.com/2020/04/29/pandora-shows-spotify-how-to-make-a-proper-apple-watch-app/ https://9to5mac.com/2020/04/29/pandora-shows-spotify-how-to-...
- dannyw 6y agoThis is really, really bad for Apple.
- xilni 6y agoHow is this different than volume discounts for anything else?
- tehwebguy 6y agoIt's not, it's just how negotiating works!
- rurp 6y agoGiving a discount to a big spender is normal, but lying about it to Congress and elsewhere is not.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoLying to Congress is (I assume) illegal. But when it's done by a powerful entity, is there really much practical risk to the liar? Perhaps I'm being overly cynical, but my impression was that high-profile Congressional hearings are mostly a form of political theater.
- rurp 6y agoI'm pretty sure these hearing are almost entirely theater and there's basically no chance Tim Cook gets personally charged with a crime. But, these statements can have large second and third order effects. The worse the tech CEOs and their companies look, the more political will there will be for passing significant legislation that affects them.
- b4ke 6y agoThey are under oath with the potential for a perjury charge if they are caught knowingly misleading the lawmakers asking them questions.... The only reason that people such as those who were speaking yesterday would ever "correct" themselves.
- scarface74 6y agoIt’s an open secret that they did the same for Netflix, Hulu and Spotify.
- philwelch 6y agoAnd Amazon, I’m pretty sure, gives AWS discounts to Netflix despite directly competing with them. And Apple gives a lot of these companies discounts to buy Macs for their employees.
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoSomething I'd like to know about antitrust laws around the world: Suppose two major companies work together, such that their collaborative effort is monopolistic. Is such a collaboration subject to antitrust intervention?
- gpm 6y agoThat would typically be known as a cartel and would typically be illegal. Typically.
- Someone 6y agoThat’s called a cartel. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cartel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cartel: “Most jurisdictions consider it anti-competitive behavior”
- mrkurt 6y agoMost antitrust laws are binary "is it or isn't it a monopoly". They're usually concerned with abuse of market power. In the US, we have much more stringent antitrust laws than actually get enforced by the DOJ. So the answer is, yes they're subject to antitrust intervention, but only if the people responsible for antitrust intervention choose to intervene.
- AnonC 6y agoThat act (verb/adjective) would be “collusion”, “fixing” (like prices), etc., and the companies called a cartel (noun). It is anti-competitive behavior because it reduces or eliminates free market competition, and is illegal (or at least subject to government scrutiny) in most countries.
- jowiar 6y agoAbsolutely. The Apple-Google-Intel-Adobe collusion to keep salaries down was an example of this.
- tptacek 6y agoYou are describing a trust.
- ziddoap 6y agoEdit: Users below have helped provide context, thanks. Maybe I'm missing the news here -- I'd be happy if someone could correct me or point out what I'm missing for why this is a big headline. If you replace the company names with "Ma & Pa's Pizza" making a deal with "Dad & Sons Grocery", but keep the article the same (Ma & Pa pay 50% less of a fee for shelf space, Dad & Sons Grocery benefits from the great pizza Ma & Pa make), I don't see it being a Bloomberg story. My analogy might not quite line up (I have 0 clue how grocery shelf space is allocated), but the sentiment remains. Two companies negotiated, they had things to offer in lieu of the standard monetary compensation, and they came to an agreement. If I am able to leverage assets other than money (intangibles like reach, brand, etc.) to lower the cost of something I am purchasing/becoming involved with, and the other company agrees to lower their cost because they will reap the benefits of the intangibles I offer, why is that wrong? Is it because of the scale involved here? Two companies negotiated fees. What am I missing here?
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoThat yesterday Tim Cook stated a bunch of times under oath that they treat every company the same with regards to App Store policy and fees. Except Jeff Bezos got a special deal directly from Tim Cook. So this is potentially evidence of perjury.
- ziddoap 6y agoThat's fair, he probably shouldn't lie under oath I agree. The article has a very small paragraph about that, and the remaining 95% was just discussing that a deal was made. I guess since Bloomberg gave much more weight to the fact a deal was struck (rather than weighting the fact that Cook potentially lied under oath), I was focusing on the wrong thing.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoIt's pretty risky for a news organization to directly accuse one of the most powerful men in America of a crime. It's much easier for them to present facts and let people read that out of it. (And I nearly guarantee you the Congresspeople who spoke with him yesterday will see this article.)
- rydre 6y agoContext for those who missed yesterday's anti-trust hearings: Tim Cook, the CEO of Apple said that Apple treats developers equally - under oath. The problem is that Amazon got a special deal. Baidu (the Chinese Google) got a special deal where Apple fast tracks App Store approval for them and have special assigned Apple employees for their app(s). This might be one of the evidence that Apple's CEO lied under oath.
- ghshephard 6y agoDoes Apple treat other video streamers differently than Amazon?
- rydre 6y ago> Does Apple treat other video streamers differently than Amazon? Apple changed it's rules for everyone in this category to get Amazon onboard with their video service. Why should it take another Amazon in another industry to change rules for that industry? Why did Apple change it's rules in an entire category so that they can get Amazon onboard? Because Amazon is too big and has leverage over Apple? Isn't it? Well this is precisely why good democracies and competitive countries have anti trust laws. This also shows that for some arbitrary categories to please companies that have leverage over Apple, Apple will change rules at whim. This also indirectly indicates that Apple does not treat all developers equally - if you look at this in good faith.
- tptacek 6y agoProbably because there are other, more popular app stores. You can draw a line around anything --- the icon that appears when you boot a Macbook, for instance --- and claim that Apple has a "monopoly" over it. You have to persuasively connect it to harm to consumers, which is difficult given the vibrancy of competition in mobile apps.
- modeless 6y agoHave they publicly announced the availability of the special deal Amazon got, and the criteria for qualifying for it? Are they proactively notifying everyone who might qualify for it? Are the rules written broadly enough that a wide variety of smaller developers might easily qualify, rather than just the behemoths? If not, then these secret negotiations are not treating all developers equally.
- wy35 6y agoFor people running into a paywall: https://web.archive.org/web/20200730155558/https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-07-29/apple-considered-taking-40-cut-from-subscriptions-emails-show https://web.archive.org/web/20200730155558/https://www.bloom...
- shadowfiend 6y agoBloomberg itself reported in 2016 that fees were halved for all video streaming services: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-17/apple-is-said-to-cut-fees-video-services-will-pay-for-app-store https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-11-17/apple-is-... . You could take this to mean that rather than negotiate a special rate for Amazon, they changed App Store rules for a whole category on the store, informed by discussions with Amazon. Hard to know if that's actually how it went down based on the info that's out there right now though.
- Despegar 6y agoIt might not have been Amazon but HBO. This story related to the Apple TV was in 2015. https://www.vox.com/2015/4/13/11561392/how-to-beat-apples-30-percent-subscription-fee-sell-your-stuff-on https://www.vox.com/2015/4/13/11561392/how-to-beat-apples-30...
- shadowfiend 6y agoMy reading of the Vox story you linked is that Apple started Apple TV apps off at 15%, then the 2016 change standardized this rate to all video streaming apps (which makes it seem like it could have been a simplification of the rules overall, though that's not clear from either story).
- patrik11 6y agosadasd
- patrik11 6y agoqewwqeqwe
- wlesieutre 6y agoA more recent change (April 2020) is that Amazon lets you buy/rent movies in their apps, and if you have billing info set up through Amazon it goes through that instead of Apple, presumably bypassing Apple's cut. If you don't, payment goes through Apple's system, probably at the reduced 15% cut. Apple commented to 9to5mac that this is part of a "program for premium subscription video entertainment providers," and it has some strings attached - integration with the TV app, AirPlay 2, universal search and single sign-on integration. https://9to5mac.com/2020/04/01/purchases-amazon-prime-video/ https://9to5mac.com/2020/04/01/purchases-amazon-prime-video/ From a business perspective I can see why they'd offer this, integration with the TV app and universal search means that users access content through that, so you're putting in extra work in order to mix your content in with everyone else's and give up the chance to upsell whatever else is on offer through your own app. When they first launched the new Apple TV system with its TV app, streaming providers didn't seem very keen on the idea of integrating. Cutting to 15% in exchange lets the providers keep more of their revenue, and lets Apple create the integrated experience that they want to offer.
- blinding-streak 6y agoIn my mind, this is basically a form of network peering, but on a biz-dev level. These two tech giants are peers in many ways, such as customer reach, developer footprint, company size, global stature, etc. Amazon wasn't able to get a zero-fee arrangement, but half off is pretty good.
- hinkley 6y agoI wonder if that was before or after they banned AppleTVs from amazon.com
- ViViDboarder 6y ago“... there are many rivals trying to woo mobile developers and consumers.” Wow. Many? There are only two platforms, Android and iOS. Android barely has any competition with Play and iOS has no competition for the App Store. So who are the rivals? The Play Store and the App Store do not compete as they cater to distinct audiences.
- evilantnie 6y agoApple's market share when it comes to streaming video is not as dominant as it is for mobile apps. Samsung, Android, and WebOS platforms out-share them by quite a bit, Amazon had already established their app in those markets, along with the success of the firestick. This was all about subscriptions, and the customers weren't watching or had stopped watching on apple devices in 2016/17, so Apple was willing to concede the rev share % to retain subscriptions that started on their platform. Now Apple gets to count those numbers as subs, even if they aren't watching on Apple devices anymore.
- baddox 6y agoI think in practice the web provides the biggest competition to any native app development, but of course that’s not really a commercial entity trying to “woo” developers.
- noarchy 6y agoIn this case, Amazon does run its own app store. And as far as streaming platforms go, it sells its own devices (that use Amazon's app store).
- nend 6y agoCook said this defensively in regards to a question during the anti trust hearings. The context makes it even worse, because his additional examples were the play station and Xbox platforms, which obviously aren't mobile app competitors. It was a prepared canned response that barely addressed the question, but since each rep only gets 5 minutes to ask questions, Cook (and others) could basically answer however they wanted because there's no time for follow up. The anti trust laws were designed to prevent exactly this type of action the article is talking about, but we've given big business so much political sway I don't have much faith the laws are enforceable at this point.
- patrik11 6y agosdad
- patrik11 6y agoasdasd
- gpapilion 6y agoI wonder how much of this is the mode being based around low value one time purchases, that have now been replaced with subscription models. .30 cents on a single purchase makes sense from a marketing cost perspective, it just seems like apple isn’t bringing enough to the table to justify the 30% cut after the initial sign up.
- WalterBright 6y agoAmazon could say 30% commission on selling all Apple products on Amazon! Or reduce the app store cut.
- simonh 6y agoApple don’t sell their products on Amazon. Third party distributors do, but Apple couldn’t care two hoots about that. Chances are it would hit Amazon’s revenue more than Apple’s.
- sdinsn 6y agoBut they didn't say that. I don't understand why you are making up fantasies.
- WalterBright 6y agoI said "could say" not "did say".
- mxd3 6y agoThe takeaway for me was this: "The deal, announced in December 2017, also allowed Amazon’s video service to integrate with Apple’s voice-activated digital assistant, Siri, and the iPhone maker’s TV app, which launched in 2016." To me this means that development for Siri is partly bound to whoever's willing to pay Apple enough money. This is really disappointing from the accessibility side.
- readams 6y agoIt's the other way around. Amazon didn't want to be integrated since that means you're just in a bucket of content that Apple controls and Amazon has no opportunity to control the user experience or offer additional upsells. Part of the deal for the reduced cut was that Amazon _had to_ do these integrations, not that they were allowed to.
- scarface74 6y agoAmazon didn’t have to. Netflix doesn’t. Apple is a lot more lenient about which apps can get on the AppleTV than Roku. Roku wants a cut of ad revenue and forces each provider to make special deals.
- readams 6y agoAmazon agreed to do it in in exchange for a lower revenue share with Apple. This is in the article. All I did was summarize what was said in the emails.
- scarface74 6y agoIt was a mutual deal. Netflix chose not to. Other streaming providers choose not to have in app purchases at all and still integrate. Either way it’s the provider’s choice. Apple really wanted Prime so it made a deal.
- scarface74 6y agoApple has publicly available intents that any developer can take advantage of.
- monadic2 6y agoWow so all I need to do to make the app store viable is have a brand worth more than anything else on the app store.
- jb775 6y agoThe crazy thing is that Apple not only gets a 30% cut of app revenue, but the development work comes at essentially no cost to them. Would be interesting if a bunch of powerful app makers banded together and threatened to pull their apps. If there's a way to impact iPhone sales, which is typically the entry point to buying other Apple products and services), maybe Apple would lower fees.
- nerpderp82 6y agoClones would immediately take their place. If done publicly, Apple would not capitulate. iOS users are still the premium ARPUs
- pluc 6y agoWhy is everyone acting like Apple's App Store is this democratic place that should abide by some arbitrary rule of equality? They own the thing _and_ they make the rules that govern it. They can do whatever they like and really don't have to answer to anyone.
- damnyou 6y agoIt isn't, but it should be more democratic.
- shados 6y agoBecause antitrust laws are a thing. If you make a new phone OS tomorrow and lock it down to a single store with a 99.99% cut, no one cares and it's not illegal. You don't have oligopoly. When Apple or Google get a little too strict with their app stores, things get a lot more ambiguous.
- ryanseys 6y agoBut the 30% cut by Apple has been standard from the beginning. Why does that suddenly come into question once they have been successful? Serious question, I'm not an expert in antitrust laws.
- inopinatus 6y agoIt isn't the size of the cut that's the problem. Focusing on that is misdirection. The problem is that Apple require vendors not to advertise, link to, or even mention that other payment methods are available outside of the walled garden. That's the stunning uppercut. The size of the fee is merely a follow-up kick to the nuts. No doubt Apple's PR team have been feeding Bloomberg background that pulls them towards only thinking about percentages, because "high prices bad" is an much easier story for lazy hacks to write than "Apple's T&Cs are distorting a marketplace and forcing vendors to mislead consumers", and much easier for Apple to leak about and subsequently respond to without addressing the core problem, especially when they're eventually forced to sit down and haggle with consumer/anti-trust regulators.
- 6y ago
- WalterBright 6y agoEffectively competing against Amazon: https://www.inc.com/justin-bariso/amazon-almost-killed-best-buy-then-best-buy-did-something-completely-brilliant.html https://www.inc.com/justin-bariso/amazon-almost-killed-best-...