9 ms·
Single income household with three relatively recent babies here. That doesn't make me an expert, just someone on the front lines of this. The article makes me
by tomrod 6y ago
Single income household with three relatively recent babies here. That doesn't make me an expert, just someone on the front lines of this.
The article makes me say "no duh". The economic tradeoff of kids versus no kids is crazy in most places in the US. If we hadn't been stuck in a cult earlier in life we probably would have waited to start having kids.
In order to keep up you basically have to have two income streams or a solid business.
- Ericson2314 6y agoAmazing answer
- uptown 6y ago"If we hadn't been stuck in a cult earlier in life we probably would have waited to start having kids." Literally or figuratively?
- tomrod 6y agoWe were stuck by choice, until we both gained a sense of rationality and started to understand logic. Left soon after.
- enthdegree 6y agotwo by twos?
- tomrod 6y agoI don't know what this is (name? movement?) so I'm going to say probably not.
- FillardMillmore 6y agoWait - can you explain what you mean by this a little more? Stuck in a cult "by choice"? What cult? How were you stuck "by choice" if you weren't rational?
- mac01021 6y agoThey were convinced to be cult members, as consenting adults, rather than having it imposed on them as minors by a parent, is my reading. Later, they gained some perspective and realized it was not in their interest to stay.
- tomrod 6y agoI should be clear, we were both raised in it as children. That made leaving much harder. Our families are still in.
- doytch 6y agoNot OP but one common example of this is staying where you live. Sure you /technically/ could move to a different country but there are a truckload of social and economic factors that keep you "stuck" in your current country. So you're stuck by choice.
- watwut 6y agoThere is no contradiction between "choice" and "not rational". Choices are often emotional, irrational, fear based, inertia based or result of perceived lack of choices.
- baq 6y agopeople are only rational if they stop and think real hard and also are able to invalidate their assumptions. this is difficult if your assumptions are your identity, see flat earthers.
- war1025 6y agoLooking back through his comment history, the "cult" he is referring to is the Mormon church.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoWe only had two kids because we’re mostly financial independent in our 30s from choices I made in my 20s. Had we not been well off, I would’ve gotten snipped before the first kid. $500 versus hundreds of thousands of dollars per kid is a no brainer (sidenote: cryopreserve some tissue before you do this, it’s only $1500-$2000 and gives you options in the future). America is designed for extraction, not nurturing the future. We’re bouncing to Oceania (AUS and Taz specifically) in the future (universal healthcare). TLDR Don’t have kids unless you’re rich or you can live somewhere that values you having them, or just values people in general.
- tomrod 6y agoWe would love Oceania or Scandinavia/Iceland. How do you get started doing something like this?
- toomuchtodo 6y agohttps://immi.homeaffairs.gov.au/visas/permanent-resident/visa-options https://immi.homeaffairs.gov.au/visas/permanent-resident/vis...
- kspacewalk2 6y agoThe solution is clear - cults.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoAnyone look at the Mormon and Catholic fertility rates lately? I haven’t, but it seems even those cults can’t keep the baby rate up anymore.
- war1025 6y agoThe only Mormon that I know reasonably well has five kids, so they're at least doing their part. The main thing I've noticed among my peer group is that the more "career-oriented" you are, the fewer kids you're going to have. For those people it seems to come down to a decision that the expenses of kids outweigh any benefits. Whereas the less well off people I know tend to have larger families because you're never going to have enough extra money for it to matter anyway, so why not have more kids and enjoy them.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoLooks like Mormon and Catholic fertility rates are declining also (just not as fast as the population at large). https://religionnews.com/2019/06/15/the-incredible-shrinking-mormon-american-family/ https://religionnews.com/2019/06/15/the-incredible-shrinking... https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/empty-cradle-empty-pews-what-the-low-birth-rate-means-for-catholics-15832 https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/empty-cradle-empty-p...
- codysc 6y agoVery true and covid has made this so much worse. Distance learning is manageable for my kids as they're a little older and I can work from home. But families with younger kids where both parents have to go out to work and can't possibly afford childcare are getting hammered. As always, the poor get the worse of the effects, and children are really compounding that right now.
- andy_adams 6y agoThis does not match my experience. I live in an average cost-of-living area and know lots of large families (3+ kids) living off a single income, sometimes in the $12-15/hour range. Life is challenging for them but not impossible. What does "In order to keep up" mean, exactly?
- IanDrake 6y agoAndy - your experience doesn't matter for several reasons. 1st - It doesn't fit with what the majority here believe. 2nd - It dangerous to spread the idea that people aren't victims and they're just experiencing the effects of their own choice to live in an expensive city.
- dvdhnt 6y ago> It dangerous to spread the idea that people aren't victims and they're just experiencing the effects of their own choice to live in an expensive city. Mobility is much more elusive than HN, or the middle and upper classes, would have you believe. Also, that doesn't account for the fact people do not choose where they are born.
- IanDrake 6y agoI'm listening... Why is it more difficult? For every corporate executive position there are thousands of low level jobs. These low level jobs are practically everywhere. Internet is free at the free library. Go there, Google cheep places to live, pick one, look for a job, rent a moving van, rent an apartment. It's not rocket science.
- mac01021 6y agoIanDrake: I upvoted you here to offset some of the downvoting. While your posts here arguable lack a little tact, I think this discussion would be improved if people who strongly disagree would respond with substantive, logical argument. I don't think you're really wrong here, but some things are worth noting: - People are generally not rational beings who examine their lives and try to live them better. So it's not reasonable to expect a large majority of people to take the kind of initiative you're describing - There are only so many jobs in Billings, MT. So it's not like all the struggling families in San Fransisco can move there and all expect to do better. They need to all move to 10000 different parts of the country. - Most kinds of working class jobs do not typically interview candidates from around the whole country so it gets tricky to first find a job and then relocate. And uprooting your family and moving 1000 miles to then look for a job seems risky.
- mindvirus 6y agoIt's nuts. Living in a big US city, with two young kids, daycare alone for them is $5k/month - so that's about $100k of pre-tax income, not to mention probably $2k/month extra spent on a larger apartment than we'd otherwise need. We can afford it, but think of what this does to the income gap and GDP. If either of us made less than $100k/year, it'd make sense for one of us to stop working for a while to look after the kids. This means that already well off people have a big advantage of being able to have a double income, while that's denied to everyone else. It feels like COVID makes this even worse - at least daycare is only a few years before public school takes its place. With that gone, kids need full time care for longer. Does this mean we'll see people dropping out of the workforce in big numbers? What does that mean for recovery? How do other places and countries manage it?
- ilstormcloud 6y agoThird world resident here. $5k a month income would get you living like a king here (with in house nanny) so to hear you have to spend that on daycare alone is insane. If i may ask, What is it about daycare that makes it this expensive? It seems demand is high and the business is profitable if they can charge that much so why isn't competition driving price to be affordable?
- jimbokun 6y agoI'm not who you asked, but will add my thoughts anyway. Fundamentally, it is a business that does not scale, as you need a set number of providers per n children, and low values for n are probably going to be associated as better value. There's really no way to get efficiencies or scale, as the personal interaction and attention is what parents are really paying for. So it come down to a question of local real estate prices and prevailing wages for the area, so I'm assuming mindvirus lives in a city with a very high cost of living and real estate costs.
- ilstormcloud 6y agoMakes perfect sense when you put it like that. I didn't realize x kids per carer would mean it can't scale. Thank you.
- war1025 6y agoSingle income household with three relatively recent babies here as well (4, 2, 2). To me, the thing that strangles young families financially is child care. We've been able to sidestep that by having my wife stay home. The current response to single income households is "think how oppressed the homemaker is!", so they aren't really in vogue right now. Yea, my wife doesn't have a career. The truth is she wasn't on track to have one anyway. She was managing a coffee shop before we had our first. That's not a "climb the corporate ladder" situation.
- mac01021 6y agoThe thing is, depending on the power dynamics in your family, she might or might not lose a lot by not having a job. If she's a homemaker, you have the ability, if not the desire, to hold all of the purse strings and possibly, in effect, monopolize all of the power to make decisions for the family - where to live, what to buy, where and when to travel.... If she works, even only earning $12k, her position in the family (when you're a controlling husband) is greatly strengthened. To be clear, I'm sure YOUR actual relationship with your specific wife is much more egalitarian, so being a homemaker probably works well for her.
- Press2forEN 6y ago> "think how oppressed the homemaker is!" Associating homemaking and raising children with oppression is probably part of the reason why modern society is not reproducing. You may receive a comment soon regarding the opportunity cost of your wife staying home. As if she is an object of economic activity who is unfashionably compelled to pause her value generation in order to raise kids.
- watwut 6y agoIt is not just irrational association. When the relationship goes bad, being homemaker is massive disadvantage. It is not just money lost by staying at home, it is making it super hard to find any job after being at home for long (and plus having kids dependent on you). Even when they stay together in mutually resentful relationship, it quickly becomes his money that she is wasting rather then our money. Plus, men die. And if he dies and she did not had a job for years, it gets pretty bad. The domestic violence rates go up with female earning power and down with female unemployment. It is opposite for males relative earnings. Partly it shifts power in the family and partly it simply allows her to leave. That is not even speaking about male resentment from having to work while she is chilling at home. Because not every male is winning in a job that he loves, plenty of them are working jobs they dislike for sociopaths bosses. The single income arrangement does not have to turn badly. But when it turns badly, it is very bad. And the guys who are intentionally looking to make someone dependent on them so that they can have upper hand are favoring this arrangement - making it more vulnerable situation then it would if only honest guys would be interested in that.
- econcon 6y agoI was discussing it with a friend who is pretty wealthy and entirely self made and I learned that... The reason my friend is not having kid has nothing to do with economics of having kid. He has plenty of money to support 10 or even 15kids based on the numbers some people posted on this thread. Reasons why he does not want to have kids: 1. He dated like 5 different women, most of them confessed their love to him. But they were always busy at education/career, he lost interest in them and decided to shift focus to his career. After years, he found himself to be alone but successful. 2. After having achieved success, he didn't want to take deals where he could lose half of my income like alimony. It took a decade to build this much wealth, why risk losing it with marriage. 3. He needed love/support/care the most when he was younger. Now that he is much older, what's the purpose of all of that even if it comes to him now? 4. He told me that all the women who rejected him when he was young are now confessing that they always were interested in him. He told me that what people are attracted to do doesn't change, later in life they start supressing what they are truly attracted to for things that they logically want from others. Not sure how many people can relate to it.
- apta 6y ago> It took a decade to build this much wealth, why risk losing it with marriage. Nothing to do with marriage per se, but more about how it's implemented in the US.
- watwut 6y agoSo basically, he wants a woman that does not have career or education, focuses everything on him, but like, he does not want to pay alimony of it fails after years of her not having career. As young, he also wanted the kind of support he was not and is not willing to provide. So, like, yeah. Him being single is good outcome. From all the choices, he wants the good selfish stuff and don't want the tradeoff.
- Konohamaru 6y ago> If we hadn't been stuck in a cult earlier in life we probably would have waited to start having kids. You weren't stuck in a cult. Consensus figurehead reality (CFR) was vying for your attention and you were looking for an escape. Judging by the fact that it helped you defy CFR on the most important life decision (reproduction), you chose wisely. Also the ruling class discourages reproduction due to the tactic of Parasitic Castration. Raising kids takes money--money that could have been diverted to the ruling class.
- Balgair 6y agoI'll echo this as well and add in that Women's healthcare is just a circus. It's crazy dependent on the provider, the hyper-specifics of the mother, and the peculiarities of the MD/RN. It's as if they all got together to make it so that no single person could ever be billed the same (to paraphrase Voltaire's quip on Ancien Régime France). The bills, months and years after, are insane. I would not be surprised if the children had children of their own, and yet still you'd get bills for pre-natal care. Then you throw in the near pervasive distrust in the medical community of women's pain and knowledge of their own bodies. Like, you're an OB-GYN, you deal with women all day, how are you thicker than concrete about this. GAH!