6 ms·
I'm not quite sure where the assumption that Apple Sillicon instruction set will even be compatible with other ARM chips. Apple does add their own instructions.
by izacus 6y ago
I'm not quite sure where the assumption that Apple Sillicon instruction set will even be compatible with other ARM chips. Apple does add their own instructions.
- klelatti 6y agoCitation? Edit - I'm getting downvoted but if you're going to suggest that Apple are departing from the ARMv8 instruction set - which is a really important point if true and which I've not seen any evidence for - then you really need to supply a citiation.
- virtue3 6y agoApple is making a really strong push to differentiate it's chips from ARM. A few of the mac sites are claiming it's "Apple Silicon" and not "ARM". I believe the heart of it is that Apple has "followed the ARM spec" but did not use ARMs actual silicon designs. I don't really know what the backing of this is either. I'm sure they added a few of their own instructions. And I read that they single handedly pushed the ARM platform to 64bit (citation needed, definitely not sure if that's really true).
- saagarjha 6y agoIt’s easier to just tweak some system registers than to do that (and indeed this is how Apple implements their proprietary “in-silicon” features).
- Followerer 6y ago"Apple Silicon" is a literal truth. The silicon design, the microarchitecture, is theirs, not ARM's. The architecture, this includes the ISA but also many other things that have to be taken into consideration in CPU design (exception model, consistency, virtual memory, virtualization,...), is ARM's. They simply don't want to tie their brand to ARM's, which is fair enough, Apple's brand is much more valuable than ARM's. Regarding the push for a 64-bit chip, I've heard the exact opposite. Aarch64 (64-bit ARM) was an ARM design without a customer, Apple were the first to buy into it. I've heard that many said it was a premature jump, and there was a lot of scepticism within ARM that they'd be able to sell it (this happened when ARM was selling mobile designs exclusively, with no intentions of getting into servers). Still, they went ahead with it, and was an unexpected success.
- andai 6y agoHN seems to dislike too much conciseness -- I guess a single-word comment, even if it's a good reply, comes across as impolite or low effort (for the lack of tone in text).
- klelatti 6y agoThanks. (Please don't downvote me!)
- izacus 6y agoI'm digging through history to find an article about Apple's LLVM patches to add a custom instruction only present on A series chip. Due to Sillion announcement it's kinda hard to find - but they did add at least one instruction to ARM instruction set. From this, and from the very very strong marketing push to NOT use the name "ARM" from Apple, I have a suspicion that Apple Sillicon instruction set won't be a fully standard ARM holdings instruction set
- klelatti 6y agoThanks - I guess I would draw a big distinction between adding a new instruction as part of being first to a new version of ARMv8 - which then becomes part of the standard ISA, and adding a permanently Apple only instruction. Would be very disappointed if it's the latter. Agreed that the Apple Silicon branding was very strong but assumed that it was just to distinguish themselves with consumers from those who will also use ARM on the desktop.
- tyingq 6y agoThere are the AMX machine learning on-die accelerators. I assume there's some new instructions to talk to those.
- rrss 6y agoThey are probably just peripherals, like the GPU. I'd be very surprised if Apple strayed from the ARMv8 specification and added new instructions for those accelerators.
- tyingq 6y agoSee this post: https://www.realworldtech.com/forum/?threadid=187087&curpostid=187087 https://www.realworldtech.com/forum/?threadid=187087&curpost...
- rrss 6y agoThat whole thread is just speculation, same as what we are doing here. See this post: https://www.realworldtech.com/forum/?threadid=187087&curpostid=187119 https://www.realworldtech.com/forum/?threadid=187087&curpost...
- Symmetry 6y agoIf they want to keep their architectural license they have to have their designs pass certain compatibility benchmarks.
- regularfry 6y agoI wouldn't put it past them to have paid silly money for a bespoke license.
- rrss 6y agoApple does not have a license to add instructions to the ARMv8 ISA. ARMv8 processors designed by Apple must be fully compliant with the ARMv8 instruction set architecture - such are the terms of the license. ARM very recently started allowing licensees to add custom instructions, but only for Cortex-M (embedded).
- saagarjha 6y agoApple couldn’t care less; they are supposed to support 4K pages in hardware but they do not on recent chips.
- rrss 6y agoARMv8-A supports page sizes of 4k, 16k, and 64k. The specification permits implementations to choose which of these page sizes to implement. See the register ID_AA64MMFR0_EL1.
- saagarjha 6y agoI'm not an expert, but I believe 4K support is required? Apple doesn't do that; they just have 16K granules (which I forsee as being problematic with compatibility as they bring these over to macOS).
- rrss 6y ago> I believe 4K support is required? As I said, I don't think that's the case. ARMv8-A supports the 3 page sizes and has a register so that implementations can advertise which are supported. > Armv8-A supports three different granule sizes: 4KB, 16KB, and 64KB. > The granule sizes that a processor supports are IMPLEMENTATION DEFINED and are reported by ID_AA64MMFR0_EL1 https://developer.arm.com/architectures/learn-the-architecture/memory-management/translation-granule https://developer.arm.com/architectures/learn-the-architectu...
- saagarjha 6y ago