18 ms·
Americans are getting more nervous about what they say in public
- hyfgfh 6y agoI just express my option with a few people that I know will criticize me, but at the same time wont attack me.
- treeman79 6y agoPolitics are heading in dangerous direction. I take hydroxychloroquine to keep my autoimmune disease under control. It’s not a perfect drug, but it works great. It’s insane watching people being attacked over a 65 year old drug. There is the doctor video going around talking it, and people are being banned or given warnings for sharing it. Science is being tossed out the window in favor of hysteria. This is something that is cheap and could save hundreds of thousands of lives. But because of hatred towards an early supporter, we can’t even have a discussion on its effectiveness anymore. Related survey on people afraid to speak. https://www.cato.org/publications/survey-reports/poll-62-americans-say-they-have-political-views-theyre-afraid-share https://www.cato.org/publications/survey-reports/poll-62-ame...
- 52-6F-62 6y agoAs far as I understood, the distaste for the support of the drug in the context of Covid-19 was that it hasn’t been proven to be the “miracle cure” some people have touted it to be. Said touting was causing shortages at pharmacies where people like you who require the drug were not able to get access to it suddenly because of hordes of “supporters” buying up entire stocks. Not because of who pushes it. It’s the consequences of uninformed broadcasting like calling it a final cure that have people shook.
- treeman79 6y agoThat’s not what is going on. News broadcasters are denouncing it as dangerous, and we can’t talk about it. Social media is banning videos by actual doctors. A drug with a 10-50% success rate will still save a lot of lives. This drug already saves millions of lives. My life is much better on it then before. It’s already reached miracle cure status. Question is, will it do it again. Cases and deaths averted. It is estimated that a cumulative 1.2 billion fewer malaria cases and 6.2 million fewer malaria deaths occurred globally between 2001 and 2015 https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/200018/9789241565158_eng.pdf?sequence=1 https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/200018/9789...
- notacoward 6y ago> News broadcasters are denouncing it as dangerous It is dangerous. Proper dosage and monitoring are necessary to guard against risk of QT prolongation and retinopathy. It's possible for it to be true both that it saves millions of lives and that it's dangerous to take unsupervised. > A drug with a 10-50% success rate will still save a lot of lives. There is zero evidence that it has anywhere near that level of effectiveness, even when combined with zinc and azithromycin for the most favorable population and conditions. It might have some effect, but touting it as a miracle cure when other treatments are already known with greater effect and lower risk is irresponsible.
- DudeInBasement 6y agoGenius level here.... Drugs are dangerous. www.henryford.com/news/2020/07/hydro-treatment-study
- wlesieutre 6y agoSee also: https://www.statnews.com/2020/07/08/a-flawed-covid-19-study-gets-the-white-houses-attention-and-the-fda-may-pay-the-price/ https://www.statnews.com/2020/07/08/a-flawed-covid-19-study-... >The study that sparked the latest controversy was anything but randomized. Not only was it not randomized, outside experts noted, but patients who received hydroxychloroquine were also more likely to get steroids, which appear to help very sick patients with Covid-19. That is likely to have influenced the central finding of the Henry Ford study: that death rates were 50% lower among patients in hospitals treated with hydroxychloroquine. >One study, the RECOVERY study conducted in the U.K., compared 1,542 patients on a particularly high dose of the drug to 3,132 control patients and found no difference in how long patients lived. A second, conducted by the National Institutes of Health, also found no benefit from hydroxychloroquine at higher doses.
- salasrod 6y agoIt is dangerous, and the organization you linked to has been under heavy scrutiny for their so called "study". https://www.deadlinedetroit.com/articles/25726/controversial_detroit_study_helps_fuel_white_house_s_renewed_push_for_hydroxychloroquine https://www.deadlinedetroit.com/articles/25726/controversial...
- dragonwriter 6y ago> As far as I understood, the distaste for the support of the drug in the context of Covid-19 was that it hasn’t been proven to be the “miracle cure” some people have touted it to be. No, it's that in the various clinical trials, it keeps showing no improvement over existing treatments. It's not just not a miracle cure, the evidence is that it's not a useful treatment for COVID-19.
- 52-6F-62 6y agoThanks. I was trying to be as diplomatic as possible because I didn't have all of the information on hand to get into a medical debate. It's outside my lane.
- mariodiana 6y agoSerious question: Who ever said it was a "miracle cure"? Going by memory, the most notorious kind words on the subject of hydroxychloroquine were: "It may be a game-changer. Or, maybe not." For some reason—I can't say what, exactly—that got spun by the media into something else entirely.
- fabian2k 6y agoThe data indicates that Hydroxychloroquine doesn't work for COVID19. It is by far the most studied existing drug for this purpose, and it didn't pan out. The study that indicates first that it was dangerous was retracted, that one was bad science and probably outright fraud. But several other studies later have shown that it does not work. This has nothing to do with Trump, though him pushing the drug without evidence is just fundamentally wrong. This is about the science, and that simply does not support using Hydroxychloroquine for COVID19. Here's one of the larger trials for hospital use of Hydroxychloroquine that didn't find any benefit: https://www.bmj.com/content/369/bmj.m2263?ijkey=355d5085a0aeed4493a778233d1ae2127edd2cc4&keytype2=tf_ipsecsha https://www.bmj.com/content/369/bmj.m2263?ijkey=355d5085a0ae...
- dariusj18 6y agoThe danger is that Trump will say whatever he wants, no matter how dangerous for short term gain, because nothing seem to stick to him long term. He can tell people that the moon is cheese, and there will be an overreaction of media "blasting" him, and a similar overreaction of his supporters defending him. But two weeks later he'll say something else, and the same people will react the same way. The insidiousness about his strategy is that one in a hundred times he guesses right, and then he gets all smug and his supporters feel like they have ammunition to use against those "elites" with their "being right all the time." (Not to mention all the times he just lies about what he was wrong about to frame it as if he was right all along.)
- CWuestefeld 6y agoThe data indicates that Hydroxychloroquine doesn't work for COVID19. That's not what the data says, and it's people who claim to be championing science but are actually regurgitating headlines that are causing this problem. "doesn't work for COVID-19" covers a lot of ground, and only some of it has actually been studied. I believe it's now been shown that it doesn't provide significant benefit for those already suffering from severe cases. However, I don't believe there's any real data on prophylactic use at all thus far, just some anecdotal stuff. Science is complicated, and doing it right requires a kind of finesse that just can't be captured in headlines - or apparently at all by our current media establishment.
- martythemaniak 6y agoSo you think that fighting medical quackery and disinformation is politics heading in the wrong direction? Isn't "politics heading in the wrong direction" the fact that some obscure drug was picked up randomly by a know nothing politician, baselessly sold as a miracle cure and had elaborate conspiracies formed around it, all so that said politician could pummel his political opponents and win reelection?
- ColanR 6y ago> fighting medical quackery and disinformation I would rather we fight the people who are preventing medical discussions from taking place. If you want to call the use of hydroxychloroquine "quackery" and "disinformation", then you should be able to definitively prove that it's completely ineffective. Because right now, there's indications that it can save lives, and the actual problem we're facing is that potentially life-saving information is being shut down.
- mcphage 6y ago> I take hydroxychloroquine to keep my autoimmune disease under control. > It’s not a perfect drug, but it works great. I'm genuinely glad it helps with your autoimmune disorder, but that really has nothing to do with Covid-19.
- mnm1 6y agoSo your argument is that because it works for your disease, it must work for covid. You provide zero evidence that it works at all for covid, zero evidence to counter the studies that show it doesn't. Then you claim some conspiracy that hcq is not being used because trump touted it. And this is supposed to be evidence of what, that society keeps you from sharing your stupid, idiotic opinions that have no basis in reality and can easily be disproved? If that's the case, good. Society is doing its job. You spoke stupidity and were shunned and unwelcomed. That's exactly how free speech is supposed to work when you say something this stupid.
- ColanR 6y ago> So your argument is that because it works for your disease, it must work for covid. That's a strawman if I ever heard one.
- mnm1 6y agoHow is it a strawman? That's literally his argument. He writes: "This is something that is cheap and could save hundreds of thousands of lives." in the context of covid while providing nothing but his anecdotal experience with a different disease. How could I possibly interpret the argument any other way?
- atomi 6y ago> ... results are not statistically conclusive and for 4 or more days after exposure there is no statistical evidence that hydroxychloroquine is effective in reducing the appearance of symptoms. https://arxiv.org/abs/2007.09477 https://arxiv.org/abs/2007.09477
- perl4ever 6y ago>I take hydroxychloroquine to keep my autoimmune disease under control. What would you do if suddenly all the available drug is used for people who have or want to protect against COVID-19?
- helen___keller 6y agoI think people are finally starting to understand that public speech in the 21st century and public speech in the 20th century are not the same thing at all. Tweeting your opinion in 2020 is analogous to going on national television and airing your opinion in 1990. Would you feel comfortable airing a controversial opinion on national television? Would you feel comfortable that you still have your job and your reputation after going in front of the nation and saying "I think interracial marriages should be illegal"? No? Then don't tweet it because that's basically the same thing.
- rukittenme 6y ago> Would you feel comfortable that you still have your job and your reputation after going in front of the nation and saying "I think interracial marriages should be illegal"? Don't you think that's a bit disingenuous? People aren't being canceled for having overt racist beliefs. They're being canceled for having polite (but political) disagreements. The issue at play here is large-scale mob action. In the online space, it takes the form of bullying and cancel culture. Terry Crews, for example, is in trouble for using the word "coon". But Terry Crews didn't call anyone a coon. He was called coon and made up an acronym that he felt could empower himself and others. Whether Terry's career is destroyed or not, the attempt to bully him out of the public eye is there and it sends a message. > "Take what we give you." > "You won't be given a charitable reading of anything you say." > "Your beliefs will be stretched and twisted to the extreme." > "And if they can't be then we'll attack you for what you didn't say."
- helen___keller 6y ago> Don't you think that's a bit disingenuous? People aren't being canceled for having overt racist beliefs. They're being canceled for having polite (but political) disagreements. I picked a controversial opinion. Your beef seems to be that mundane political opinions shouldn't be controversial. I agree with you, but that's not really relevant to the point I'm trying to make. The point im trying to make is that some people treated Facebook or Twitter like a group of friends, when any digital post or recording can instantly become more like a nationally televised segment.
- blue52 6y agoAnd it's a damn shame. Dangerous as well.
- SaberTail 6y agoMaybe I missed it, but I didn't see if this was done before or after the pandemic lockdowns started. I've got a hypothesis that the Twitter (etc.) mobs are getting worse precisely because of the lockdowns. Locked down, with very little to do, people are desperate to feel like they're doing something useful. Joining in an online mob feels useful. It makes a person feel like they're doing good in the world. It gives them the rush of accomplishing something. It's an illusion, but there's a lot of feedback (upvotes, faves, retweets, etc.) that makes it feel real to people. I don't have any great ideas for how to improve it. I've been asking myself "will this actually do any material good?" before engaging, and I significantly cut back on social media. But good luck convincing everyone else to do that, too.
- gnusty_gnurc 6y ago> I've got a hypothesis that the Twitter (etc.) mobs are getting worse precisely because of the lockdowns. Any of the nonsense going on lately is pretty much a consequence of the lockdowns. People without jobs and tons of time on their hands, and social networks that amplify anything that crosses the minds of people confined to their house. It's a recipe for disaster. And precisely a reason you wouldn't want to embark on a lockdown strategy, ignoring the questionable efficacy.
- Theory5 6y agoThat's absolutely not true, lockdowns have been proven to help protect people and reduce the spread of the virus.
- vwcx 6y agoI’ve often wondered about the ‘herd immunity’ that forms as a result of widespread cancel culture. Initially I assumed that prolific canceling would lead to a general societal understanding of the unsustainability of the cultural. The idea that in Presidential elections in 2059, every candidate would have so much ‘dirt’ against them that it might level the field a bit. But as this article suggests, another alternative might just be a deadly-to-democracy silence.
- luckylion 6y agoAll experiments with ideologically driven cancel-culture we've had in the time since WW2 point to silence being the answer. You might be able to open up in a very private setting, but East Germany showed enough evidence that there will be spies even in your closest circle who will report on you. If you need to tell somebody how you really feel, write a letter to yourself and then burn it. Otherwise, just smile, repeat the party line, and carry on.
- teachrdan 6y agoAre you actually comparing "cancel culture" to being imprisoned by the Stasi? The most powerful person in the country regularly tweets opinions that cancel culture supposedly makes impossible to say. There are those who make cancel culture out to be an all-powerful entity. But the evidence suggests it's just a right wing boogie man in all but the most extreme cases. And sometimes not even then!
- tenebrisalietum 6y agoPrinciples, such as "free market" and "free speech" in strictest forms, are immaterial below a certain economic threshold. Survival itself, or relief from the drudgery of survival becomes paramount. A homeless person living on the street already has just about the freest speech you could want in the freest market for ideas possible--his economic situation can't really be altered further by anything he says politically. Does anyone want to live like that? Principles are going to take a back seat while housing costs and a bunch of other things are the way they are.
- RhysU 6y agoA homeless person on the street gets the best value for his/her minimal dollars when buying goods produced by a free market. A homeless person living on the street can rant about whatever government conspiracy he/she chooses without being imprisoned because of free speech. These rights do matter, even to those with practically nothing.
- tenebrisalietum 6y agoLet's say the homeless person was presented with this deal: "You can have free housing, but you can't rant about government conspiracies. If you do, you get imprisoned." I'd say most homeless people would take the deal. It would be interesting to actually conduct a study and find this out, though.
- non-entity 6y agoThat couldnt possibly be legally upheld though?
- RhysU 6y agoAnytime the government wants to void the deal all they have to do is to accuse the person of ranting. It is an ephemeral offer.
- DaniloDias 6y agoI’m not nervous. I’m saddened by the lack of courage, lack of independent thought and this common belief that it is healthy and worthwhile to try and control how other people perceive you.
- mattgreenrocks 6y agoThere's a perceptible slide towards culture telling people they need to worry more and more about extrinsic measures of value (e.g. what others think) in lieu of teaching them how to assess things for their intrinsic values, and weigh those along with external perceptions. It's no wonder we can feel like we have little agency at times: we've used outside sources for validation instead of building resilience. I used to be big into IRC, or in smaller channels. Eventually I noticed a certain persona was overrepresented on IRC: a sort of cynical, sarcastic type that could probably use a bit less time on IRC, but couldn't muster up the will to change. I see the same thing with social media, and, worse, we've normalized the addictive behavior, and made it easier to stay connected away from computers. I don't want to be that person.
- paul7986 6y agoThe US news media (left, right and upside down) is sensationalized trash. Fueling hate (stereotypes), outrage and inducing fear..all for profit! I've tuned it all out minus some pertinent local news.
- pmb 6y agoPeople are getting kidnapped off the street by unspecified federal agencies. It's a pretty sensible time to be nervous about what you publicly broadcast.
- stolenmerch 6y agoAt the same time, there is no evidence that this kind of illegal "kidnapping" has really happened. To even push back slightly on this narrative it to "support fascism" in some circles, which is a pretty dangerous position. Yep, pretty sensible to be nervous all around right now. https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/feds-unmarked-vans-portland/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/feds-unmarked-vans-portlan...
- pmb 6y agoYour link marks the claim as "mixed truth", which is different from the "no evidence" in your comment text.
- stolenmerch 6y agoI commented on the claim there were illegal kidnappings, which is the part there is no evidence of. What is true, according to the link, is that LE used unmarked vehicles.
- pmb 6y agoAnd (truth value unknown by Snopes because proving a negative is impossible, but it corresponds with the videos) failed to wear identification or do or say anything that would allow the person being taken by unknown people into an unmarked car to distinguish those people from one of the paramilitary alt-right militias that populates Oregon.
- stolenmerch 6y agoLike you said, proving a negative is impossible, so we just don't know if they wore ID or not.
- auganov 6y agoWhat many are missing is our ability to have a voice has also grown tremendously over the years with social media. Just over a decade ago far fewer people could get to a point where their speech could be censored/sanctioned. It's not necessarily that you could say more back in the day, but the fact that fewer people would hear it.
- bovermyer 6y agoI absolutely do not publicly state my beliefs, or even state them in writing anywhere that could conceivably be accessed publicly. This is for two reasons: one, I doubt anyone cares to hear yet another voice in the cacophony; and two, there is plenty of prior precedent for someone saying something online and a digital mob descending on them and making their lives hell. That doesn't even consider government surveillance, which adds a whole 'nother angle. So, there's no incentive for me to share, and a strong disincentive.
- Balgair 6y agoBut you share your opinions here. Your comment history has opinions in it, however niche. And your profile links to your personal website. What am I missing?
- bovermyer 6y agoLet me add additional context - my controversial political opinions have never made it out of verbal conversations and into writing. Better?
- Frondo 6y agoI also don't say controversial things online or over the phone -- secured channels okay still -- but not because I give a shit about "digital mob" (give me a break!); What worries me is how the three-letter agencies vacuum it all up and have now started disappearing people, literally, under the guise of "stopping riots".
- gowld 6y agoWho has been disappeared? Is there a known name of someone reported missing? Being arrested and released within hours is not "disappeared", at least not more than has always been happening.
- froasty 6y agoThe incentive for you to share your beliefs is that if you will not lead, someone else, invariably less discerning, less principled, and less honest will. This used to be considered a fundamental precept of Western civilization and its legislators, popularly stated as "[t]hose who are too smart to engage in politics are punished by being governed by those who aren't." The historiography of this period, if humans remain extant, will discover the causal link between the rise of New Atheism and the rise of intellectual cowardice that by necessity emerged shortly after the implicit social norms of Christianity were intentionally jettisoned. Being willing to sacrifice, not to inflict violence but to actively suffer, for the truth that one witnesses is a fundamental predicate of Western civilization. Even the Christian heretics of the middle ages, willfully executed for their idiosyncratic beliefs, viewed this as a sacrosanct duty as a human being. If a polity actively consents to the silencing of the individual's ability to testify to their truth for the sake of Mammon, state persecution, the possibility of being stoned by a crowd of True Believers, or any other exercise of temporal power, civilization, that is the ability of a group of diverse individuals to exist for a future commonweal, is impossible to maintain. The honest and earnest among this and past generations have voluntarily silenced and removed themselves from the possibility of being spiritual and intellectual leaders. The only result that can come of this abdication of responsibility is not their own safety but the endangerment of everyone within that society. If you will not lead, you will be led by those that aren't so fearful, so future-minded, or scrupulous. If you would pretend to be blind, you will be led by the blind. And if the blind lead the blind, both shall fall into the ditch.
- notmyfriend 6y agoThe most important thing to take away from this is that It's likely all political polls are complete garbage due to this.
- notacoward 6y agoConservatives have long felt nervous about sharing their opinions because they know they're in the minority (and for issues such as race/immigration/LGBTQ+ some at least suspect they're on the wrong side of history as well). The new trend has been liberals feeling nervous because the minority is in power and we now have our own government's paramilitary goons doing what such goons do in broad daylight. I have to admit that I've considered the possibility of my own words earning me a red triangle[1] if we don't manage to turn this around in November. When there's constant news of real violence against people exercising their first amendment rights, it's no wonder they feel nervous. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazi_concentration_camp_badge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazi_concentration_camp_badge
- spaginal 6y agoMost Americans feel nervous about sharing opinions because of the increase in doxxing, and cancel culture that results in physical harm and job loss. Has nothing to do with feelings of wrongness or being on the wrong side of history. We just don’t want our lives that we’ve worked hard to build, destroyed.
- notacoward 6y ago> We just don’t want our lives that we’ve worked hard to build, destroyed. Who's "we" in that sentence? The people most in danger of actually having their lives destroyed right now are those whose opinions conflict with those being enforced by men in camo. How many supporters of the government have been sent to the hospital or disappeared into vans lately?
- spaginal 6y agoWe as in every American. Categorically though, you are conflating two issues. Any violent riot (yes, that is what it is) will end up in hospitalizations and arrests. Spinning it as a secret state action against people just doing their thing is not genuine. Imagine a scenario where 2A supporters violently protested outside of the ATF headquarters in Washington DC, brandishing firearms and attempting to attack the building and people in it. Imagine yourself as you are now with your present opinion, would you be supportive of or against the protesters? I’m speaking more generally in the benign everyday sharing of innocuous opinions online that spiral wildly out of control.
- roenxi 6y agoThe partisan split here is fascinating. This implies that a possible situation we are in is that most Democrats aren't saying what they think. That bodes badly for them long-term. Speaking practically, that seems like a nasty defect in their ability to communicate an honest vision. Hopefully the things they can't saying are only on unimportant issues. I suspect that is not the case though.
- insickness 6y ago46% of Democrats and 73% of Republicans said they can't say what they think.
- maxk42 6y agoThat was in 2017. The 2020 numbers are 52% and 77% respectively.
- Jotra7 6y agoOh no, people can't be racist, sexist, or any spew other anti-social beliefs without social consequences. Whatever shall we do?
- ckdarby 6y agoDavid Shor probably got fired because they did not have a disclaimer on their account expressing these are just their opinions. I once had an employer come after me when I posted a Medium article because of this. Medium appends your bio at the bottom which said, "Working at X, top 25 largest bandwidth consumer." Employer argued that I was representing the company's opinion and had breached a clause in my employer contract.
- amvalo 6y agoHe does have the disclaimer
- ckdarby 6y agoDid he have that disclaimer before and did he have the disclaimer on all places he might have posted or shared the link from? Easy example would have been Linkedin if it was shared there, his title probably would have said he worked there but not had a disclaimer description on his Linkedin profile.
- zzzeek 6y agoSo there are no barriers to free speech, no laws to be enforced against people saying pretty much anything, but polling indicates people "feel" they "cannot" express their true beliefs. I'm pretty sure the first amendment has nothing to say about feelings.
- katktv 6y agoYeah, especially when the first amendment gets violated on the streets of America, today, as the journalists get beaten by the government goons in direct violation of free speech and freedom of the press.
- zzzeek 6y agoSure, law enforcement having gone corrupt in a more obvious way is a huge problem. I live in a small town and I'm absolutely careful what I post on local Facebook groups because our neighbor across the street is a cop with radically conservative viewpoints, and I don't want to get targeted. So the idea that there's some kind of left wing "cancellation" system is just ever more BS as the state is currently favoring fascist speech, not antiracist/feminist speech.
- perl4ever 6y ago>So the idea that there's some kind of left wing "cancellation" system is just ever more BS Alternatively, you might consider that it could be real but a bipartisan thing, despite the term being used (and I assume coined) as though it's just the left wing. Someone put together a long list of people Trump has tried to get cancelled, that seem to fit squarely within the usual connotations. https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/07/politics/fact-check-trump-cancel-culture-boycotts-firings/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/07/politics/fact-check-trump-can...
- titzer 6y agoThe issue seems more complicated than just the first amendment, which only proscribes the restrictions of your free speech. In general I think the underlying dynamic is that culture itself has become a hostile battleground and expressing an opinion is likely to get people riled up and breathing down your neck. In short, people are flat-out shitty to each other these days. It sucks. No one wants to speak up in that environment. But even then I'd challenge your first couple of statements. There are whole lot of consequences for defying the political leadership these days, especially when you bring evidence that they might have committed crimes. It's a nightmare right now.
- katktv 6y agoYeah, conservatives can get less afraid of pushing their malarkey when they stop spreading it. I do not care if they and their libertarian friends get "cancelled" because after four years of Trump they've truly shown their colors as the vile politicians they are. The real issues today are all the civil riots occuring on the streets of America, the government violating the civil rights of its own people, and the media turning the blind eye on it because all of it is inherently biased. "Cancel culture" is a bunch of dead air.
- qzx_pierri 6y agoYou're only one slip up or bad tweet away from being thrown under the bus like those people you mentioned. And before you argue that context matters, take a look at some of the other replies in this thread. I guess you don't have to worry if you're on the winning team, but others who just happen to have different beliefs aren't so lucky. Try to remain objective and really consider the other side of things. Or not. But remember that no one is safe if/when the tables turn - including you.
- katktv 6y agoTo put it in abstract, the "other side of things" currently wants me, as a part of the minority group, either dead or without my rights, while its representatives in the big politics are currently busy defending the police force which actively discriminates against ethnic minorities and commits literal crimes on the streets while violating the first amendment conservatives supposedly uphold. With that in mind, a bunch of conservatives being afraid according to a report by the Koch-funded organisation is not my problem.
- perl4ever 6y agoIsn't it plausible that fear of cancel culture is a large part of the re-election strategy for the President? I read that it was part of his speech at Mt. Rushmore. It doesn't make sense to say a bunch of conservatives being afraid is not your problem if you're an American who cares about November. But of course, maybe that's an incorrect assumption. I'm paranoid enough to speculate that the election manipulation involves shills hammering both sides of this debate that is contrived to help the POTUS' re-election campaign.
- scottlocklin 6y agoIt's pretty obvious America is heading towards some sort of filthy low level civil war like 1973-1976 in Argentina[0]. For those of you unfamiliar with this period of time: this was the three years preceding Operation Condor and the Junta throwing people out of helicopters. A shitty period of chaos where opposing political groupings kidnapped, assassinated and otherwise destroyed each other in the streets. Cancel culture is just one aspect of it. Riots, mass shootings (hey, anyone remember Stephen Paddock shooting 500 people in Vegas? kinda reminds me of the mass murder[1] of the Montoneros at the Peron rally[2] except worse, and with a media blackout), tent cities, complete distrust of the mass media, political polarization over .... covid treatment and mitigation, clownish conspiracy theories touted on the mass media, actual conspiracies (dude totally didn't kill himself) in plain sight, people baying for blood on social media, and threatening to murder their political enemies. The classical liberal ideal of a marketplace of ideas and of coexistance with political rivals is dead and gone, and the virtues needed to sustain it basically don't exist in the population under the age of 40; aka the people who fight in violent civil wars. At some point, someone's going to go apeshit and go after the leader of the mob that canceled him. I'd say the main thing preventing it now is companies actually pay out decent settlements for firing people for political statements -leftovers from when labor unions had juice; remember labor protections, alleged lefties? The whole thing is idiotic and sad, and America will end up the totalitarian shit hole it seems to want to be. Junta Argentina without the nice climate and good looking people. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Juan_Per%C3%B3n#Third_term_(1973%E2%80%931974) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Juan_Per%C3%B3n#Third_term_(19... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ezeiza_massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ezeiza_massacre [2]https://www.britannica.com/topic/Montonero https://www.britannica.com/topic/Montonero
- luckylion 6y ago> At some point, someone's going to go apeshit and go after the leader of the mob that canceled him. I believe it's a testament for how anti-violence everyone in our societies are. People being publicly hunted down in witch trials rather kill themselves than turn on those who seek to destroy them. I'm similarly surprised that all those pyramid scheme people live peacefully after their schemes blow up and thousands or millions are left holding the bag, while they made off with millions and might possibly face a year or three in a luxurious prison. When you consider how many people wish them death online and nothing happens, death threats to random Twitter users can probably be ignored in general: if people aren't going after those that defrauded them and took their life savings, they're not going to come after you because you disagree on politics.
- qzx_pierri 6y agoThis is even more annoying if you're a person of color. Mostly because a lot of the "PC Culture" zealots are middle class white people who are virtue signaling and using these far left ideologies to gain social acceptance - They're literally shooting fish in a barrel when they decide what to say vs. what they can say AND get 'credit' for. Speaking your opinion and being called a racist on Twitter by white people is beyond infuriating when you're a black man who has actually experienced it. Twitter is a cancer to society, and I really hope this "cancel culture" dies out soon. Most times when things like this happen, someone could have easily sent the person in question a DM, explained why they thought the tweet might have been badly timed, and that would have been all - No scandal. But you don't get "credit" for that. You have to pretend to be angry, make a tweet with some ALL CAPS thrown in, and get someone fired. I hope people find another way to feel good about themselves soon, because throwing people under the bus is destroying any hope of free speech in the near future. Sorry about the long rant. Hopefully I don't catch any heat for this on HN shrug
- espCrunch 6y agoIt’s not going anywhere and your employer will be hearing from me soon.
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/jm0qr https://archive.is/jm0qr
- throwaway29102 6y agoIt’s almost as if Americans have realized that speech, like all other actions, has consequences.
- commandlinefan 6y agoActually, we realized it shouldn't 244 years ago but forgot in the past year.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoYou are suggesting that a person should be able to say anything, and nobody who hears it can react in any way? That would certainly be a minority opinion. Or perhaps you are defining "speech" and "consequences" differently?
- perl4ever 6y agoI'm not sure what side you're on, but the US wouldn't be what it is but for founders who manipulated public opinion by publishing under a pseudonym about their vision of an ideal government. While owning slaves. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Federalist_Papers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Federalist_Papers
- throwaway29102 6y agoI'm an arsonist, not a partisan.
- BooneJS 6y agoMy village’s Facebook page offers a counter-example to this article. When it comes to wearing masks or virtual/in-person school, there’s no amount of vitriol the most vocal won’t say.
- johnny22 6y agodo the comments on these posts every go anywhere? I might be wrong, but it seems like folks just start from zero every time. I have my own views on the subject, but am willing to change my mind. The arguments however don't seem to be compelling. It'd be nice if we could stop starting from scratch as if this was the first time the subject was discussed.
- krapp 6y agoNo. Most of these threads wind up being so similar you could write a bot to fill them out.
- nobletrunk 6y agoYou’re a lunatic. You should be on antipsychotics as well.
- nobletrunk 6y agoPlease take a huge dose of hydroxy and remove yourself from the gene pool.
- c7________- 6y agoIf you express conservative viewpoints then people will physically assault you. Andy Ngo has been physically assaulted multiple times and recently was brazenly lased in the eyes. Liberal activists have taken to lasing the eyes of their political opponents as well as federal officers standing in front of a federal courthouse. These lasers will cause eye damage simply by looking at their spot on a wall. The fact that people in general are not upset by this baffles me. Personally, after the lasing started, I totally lost any desire to publicly convey any kind of even positive sentiment for conservative or even moderate ideas. That’s how toxic it has become: moderates are now villainized by at least a large chunk of the left.
- testfluke 6y agoGood! Andy Ngo is human scum; so are the agents in Portland and so are all conservatives in the broadest sense. I’m excited by where this is going.
- c7________- 6y agoWhat did he do? Oh and congratulations, you won. You literally terrorized people into silence.
- testfluke2 6y agoHis whole shtick is to drum up violence against people on the left. Turnabout is fair play. And thank you, it is unironically really satisfying.
- c7________- 6y agoI’m not going to rebut. But my point could not have been proven any more thoroughly... I even wonder if you are a conservative pretending to be a liberal just to try and help my comment...
- turnsnake55 6y ago