4 ms·
In the past we had some candidates complain about take-home problems. The primary complaint was that candidates weren't interested in dedicating 4-5 hours of th
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
In the past we had some candidates complain about take-home problems. The primary complaint was that candidates weren't interested in dedicating 4-5 hours of their own time unless they felt that someone from the company was putting in an equal amount of their own time. Some candidates also had suspicions that we were trying to use them for free labor (Not true, we used the same toy problem for every candidate). One candidate even thought they should be able to bill us for their time spent applying (We passed).
Eventually I changed the strategy and offered candidates the choice of the take-home problem or an on-site whiteboard style interview where they solved a subset of the problem in pair-programming fashion with us. Zero people chose the on-site interview. Everyone chose the take-home problem.
No one complained any more after we reframed the take-home problem as the candidate's choice rather than the company's.
- an_opabinia 6y ago> offered candidates the choice > reframed Aren't meaningless shenanigans generally associated with meaningless things? Do you have any evidence that either strategy really matters? Does it boil down to, "We choose an interviewing strategy that selects for people who look like programmers."
- jmchuster 6y agoSo instead of doing a 4-hour on-site interview, you make a hiring decision based on a 4-hour take-home problem?
- cutemonster 6y agoSeems you think that 4h test was all, wondering how you got that idea
- jmchuster 6y agoSo candidates actively chose to add a 4h project on top of a 4h in-person interview?
- cutemonster 6y agoThere's probably a one or two hours soft skills interview and more that they didn't mention.
- justinclift 6y ago> One candidate even thought they should be able to bill us for their time spent applying ... Are you meaning they wanted your company to pay for the time used to solve the take-home problem? If so, isn't it normally done that way in order to prevent companies potentially exploiting free labour?
- TooCleverByHalf 6y ago> One candidate even thought they should be able to bill us for their time spent applying (We passed) Ironically, you passed on the smartest applicant of the bunch.
- tjpnz 6y agoHow do you stop people from "getting help" on the take home problems.
- asdff 6y agoWhy would you penalize an employee for getting help on a problem? Stack overflow away. Troubleshooting is an essential skill.
- cutemonster 6y agoI think s/he meant letting a friend do the whole assignment
- tjpnz 6y agoPrecisely and I've heard of people landing gigs at some well known companies who did just that. Without any followup questions.
- dennisgorelik 6y ago> an on-site whiteboard style interview where they solved a subset of the problem in pair-programming fashion with us Do you offer candidates a remote pair-programming interview? E.g. screen-sharing session over Skype/Zoom?