8 ms·
Statement by Jeff Bezos to the U.S. House Committee on the Judiciary
- epberry 6y agoIf nothing else this is going to be a fun show. I have a feeling the House is overmatched.
- ponker 6y agoOvermatched in intellect but not in raw power. Bezos has managed to piss off Democrats and Trumpists so any anti-Amazon legislation is viable.
- zozin 6y agoLet's not pretend that Bezos spent much time on this statement. His lawyers and other employees wrote it for him.
- Invictus0 6y agoIf you have read Bezos' shareholder letters, you will recognize his writing style in this piece. I'm sure there is some text authorship software that you could use to verify this as well. I'll give that lawyers probably supplied the statistics used here; they are very misleading at times.
- p0rkbelly 6y agoI would think a smart, driven person who is passionate about the topic would be more than happy to write this and spend a lot of time on it. Seems like his writing style.
- missedthecue 6y agoI doubt it. This is his job, and it seems like something he'd want full oversight and control of. This isn't a press release about another warehouse opening
- ponker 6y agoNo, this is the kind of thing that CEOs take for themselves and cancel meetings that teams have spent 3 months preparing for. Of course he will have asked each team to deliver him draft language but I'm sure the final language is his.
- christophilus 6y agoI watched Barr’s hearing. It was mostly elected officials ranting and sermonizing. Barr came out of that looking like the only sane person in the room, and I say this as... not a Trump fan. It doesn’t take much to outmatch the House or the Senate these days. I expect this to be nothing but a bunch of virtue signaling. Nothing will come of it which is a real shame.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> the House is overmatched Booking all four on the same day was a genius move by some lobbyist. It dilutes the unique issues that each tech giant presents, and makes scrutiny look like sour grapes.
- epberry 6y agoI was wrong about this. Each of the 4 got hit pretty hard at times.
- supernova87a 6y agoI know that he (and others in positions like CEO in such industries) cannot say it, but I would be glad to hear him say: "Representatives, Amazon is a company focused on innovation, efficiency, and getting the best and most out of people, and giving the best and most to people, wherever it can. Tech allows us to tap into economies of scale, create new products and give consumers choices never seen before, squeeze out waste in ways that were not possible up to now, and create net benefit for people in this country. Each one of you can probably personally think of how Amazon technology has improved the lives of yourselves and people you know. We seek to do this as far as the law allows us to do, and other companies do that as well. We operate within the rules placed on us by the legislatures of this country and its states. As you know, sometimes even under fair laws, some people will lose out compared to others. Innovation comes with risk and change -- that's an unavoidable consequence of progress. And technology has been doing this for hundreds of years. But that's what laws are meant to set the boundaries of, based on people like you determining how best to create those rules. If this body is concerned with what we are doing within the laws, it should change those laws based on the best interests of this country and its people. And Amazon will follow those laws. We want that clarity, and want to follow our responsibilities under the law. It's your responsibility to set out those laws. Amazon welcomes performing our responsibilities to American consumers, and we invite you to do the same to the people you are responsible to."
- ceejayoz 6y ago> If this body is concerned with what we are doing within the laws, it should change those laws based on the best interests of this country and its people. And Amazon will follow those laws. Left unsaid here would be: "We will quietly but effectively work behind the scenes to prevent them from ever becoming laws."
- slg 6y agoIsn't it hypocritical to make a comment like this while also lobbying the government for laws that favor your business? "I'm just playing by the rules" shouldn't be a valid defense when you are actively taking a role in deciding those rules.
- shadowmore 6y agoYou know it's 2020 when a judiciary committee address begins with a billionaire attempting to cloak himself in a victim narrative. I can't wait for the world to go back to normal, so it once again becomes shameful to show any weakness and immorality, so we can deal with people's actions rather than their position on the victimhood totem pole.
- MONTREAL_TAYLOR 6y agoBezos is a victim of intrusive government.
- throwaway2048 6y agoand how mightily he suffers
- john-shaffer 6y agoWhat victim narrative? He didn't say anything about being a victim or try to make anyone feel sorry for him.
- Blastit 6y agoI hate to say it friend but 2016 was no black swan. This is the new normal. The tech landscape we built has completely destroyed a sense of shared narrative, at least in the US. With rhetoric being more effective for building political capital than sane policy, there is no one to call out the smarm.
- hannibalhorn 6y agoI really enjoyed the first bit about his background. I don't see it as "victimhood" as much as showing where he came from - inspirational, even.
- stevespang 6y agoLet's not forget that Bezos left behind several teenage children to shack up with this helicopter pilot . . . even Elon Musk has like 8 kids from a former marriage he probably rarely sees . . and now a new boy with his current "Baby Mama". Yet still the media dares not talk about these facts.
- m0zg 6y agoLays on the schmaltz pretty thick in the beginning. In fact I couldn't even get past all the schmaltz. Then I remembered he has warehouses where underpaid workers pass out from exhaustion and I stopped reading.
- dencodev 6y agoThis is basically just highly polished PR. I'm sure bezos took acting classes and consulted with psychologists for just this purpose.
- mft_ 6y agoI’d you’d continued lower down, you’d have read: > Amazon employees make a minimum of $15 an hour, more than double the federal minimum wage (which we have urged Congress to increase). We’ve challenged other large retailers to match our $15 minimum wage. Target did so recently, and just last week so did Best Buy. We welcome them, and they remain the only ones to have done so. We do not skimp on benefits, either. Our full-time hourly employees receive the same benefits as our salaried headquarters employees, including comprehensive health insurance starting on the first day of employment, a 401(k) retirement plan, and parental leave, including 20 weeks of paid maternity leave. I encourage you to benchmark our pay and benefits against any of our retail competitors. They might still be ‘underpaid’, but maybe they’re less underpaid than other similar businesses? Could it be true to say that all entry-level jobs suck, but maybe working for Amazon sucks slightly less than some others?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- numakerg 6y ago> I founded Amazon 26 years ago with the long-term mission of making it Earth’s most customer-centric company I wonder if he still thinks that's the case.
- dencodev 6y agoI feel like customer centric is just another way of saying money centric. Big difference between customer-centric and people-centric
- umvi 6y ago> It’s not a coincidence that Amazon was born in this country. More than any other place on Earth, new companies can start, grow, and thrive here in the U.S. Our country embraces resourcefulness and self-reliance, and it embraces builders who start from scratch. We nurture entrepreneurs and start-ups with stable rule of law, the finest university system in the world, the freedom of democracy, and a deeply accepted culture of risk-taking I don't disagree, but in my opinion, many of these things are actively under attack. We used to have stable rule of law, but since the protests I'm not so sure now. We used to value self-reliance and risk taking, but a growing chunk of America now wants a more risk-averse government-reliant (in the form of guaranteed pensions, etc) European style society.
- rayiner 6y ago> We used to value self-reliance and risk taking, but a growing chunk of America now wants a more risk-averse government-reliant (in the form of guaranteed pensions, etc) European style society. I’d be happy if that’s all they wanted. Some people want to “dismantl[e] White Supremacy, Patriarchy, Capitalism, Imperialism and the role the state plays in supporting them.” And instead of saying “hey, one of those things is not like the other” I now drive past a street in DC every day named after an organization that has this quote on their DC chapter’s front page. (Technically, it’s an honorary name, but DC streets have proper street signs for those.) Meanwhile, the Smithsonian is publishing materials condemning “objective, rational linear thinking” and “progress” and “competition.” I get that these are fringe academic ideas that fringe people have injected into an otherwise really important conversation. But I’m pretty alarmed about the degree to which mainstream sources are implicitly sanctioning these kinds of assertions. Silicon Valley as we know it can’t exist within this intellectual framework.
- tehjoker 6y agoThey're all deeply interconnected. Read a book. All of those systems involve hierarchies that are more or less flexible. Capitalism has been highly productive as an economic system, but it still is deeply undemocratic and could safely be called tyrannical as it has few if any democratic features below the level of the wealthy shareholders. EDIT: In the case of many of our tech giant friends, the trend in the mid-2000s to late 2010s was to create different tiers of stock so that the founders would have near absolute authority over the company. This is like a private monarchy and is even more authoritarian than the previous generation of companies. EDIT2: The funny thing is, because we distrusted the financial system so thoroughly in the early 2000s, cutting out the influence of institutional finance was seen as liberating while in actuality we were merely constructing an even more hierarchical and conservative system.
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoThe statement is a work of art, and should be read, perhaps even studied. It's perfect. Jeff is a master at doing PR. Learn from him. The big question for him and Amazon should be: why does Amazon paid an average of 8% tax rate [0], when average people pay much more? [0]: https://www.wsj.com/articles/does-amazon-really-pay-no-taxes-heres-the-complicated-answer-11560504602 https://www.wsj.com/articles/does-amazon-really-pay-no-taxes...
- supernova87a 6y agoIt pays 8% because US tax law is set up to allow that to happen. Perhaps, even incentivize that. And maybe that's not a good thing. But there are well defined ways to change that. If we can't, then there is something else wrong.
- spectramax 6y agoYes and the whole multi million/billion dollar law business exists around it. Tax law and tax attorneys. Their job is to find legal loopholes.
- darkerside 6y agoIt's hard to penalize them for that without also meriting them for the benefits directly related to the actions they took to achieve those deductions and credits. Paywall, but I didn't see any of those mentioned in the summary, which makes me question the balance of the article. Also, any single out Amazon here? The entire corporate tax rate in the US is extremely low. It's part of what makes it a business friendly country.
- thecleaner 6y agoAm I the only one who thinks that Bezos gives the same generic statements everywhere. I have heard all of these before in an interview with David Rubinstein and other interviews before that.