11 ms·
Stack Overflow gets series E funding for $85M
- ghiculescu 6y ago> An Inflection Point to Accelerate the Realization of our Mission It makes me sad to think that someone wrote this headline and thought it really meant something. Congrats to the SO team, I guess.
- gameswithgo 6y agoI guess eventually you get to some substance. They are going to focus on "stack overflow for teams"
- Doctor_Fegg 6y ago"Slack Overflow"
- frandroid 6y agoThis name illustrates the limitations of this strategy. I like the idea of SO for Teams, but we already have Github Wikis, Github issues, and our team's slack instance.
- mattbee 6y agoWhich is, of course, to immanentize the eschaton.
- teh_klev 6y agoHail Eris!
- slim 6y agoyou mean that they should have ipo'd earlyer or that we should have an exclusive stock market for devs ?
- jdhawk 6y agoSomeone took their MBA vocabulary too seriously.
- draw_down 6y agoWell, I kinda doubt the person at Wal-Mart who tells me to have a nice day has sincere wishes about my day. You can just do a job. It is possible to just write copy. Not everyone is rube.
- falcor84 6y agoWell, assume you have a graph of progress over time, with 0 being just the mission plan and 1 being a full implemention. Then if your graph had a positive but declining slope, due to depleted funds, and now you get a cash injection, you'll hopefully see an inflection point marking a switch from negative to positive acceleration, towards realizing the mission.
- dude01 6y agoCongrats to them. Let's hope it doesn't destabilize the product too much.
- devmunchies 6y agoone the bright side, if it's destabilized enough then someone would be incentivized to build a better one.
- erikbye 6y agoHow do you make a better one? It's a human problem, a social interaction problem, not a tech one. Novices want to ask all the didn't-even-read-the-official-docs and don't-want-to-do-my-own-homework questions they want, and the more experienced users don't want to see those kinds of low-bar questions. In my not so humble opinion, the mods on SO gets a lot of shit, but I think they're not strict enough. SO is absolutely brimming with low-bar questions and answers. Best case that is all noise, worst case, the wrong and misinformed answers (by people portraying expertise) ends up in production code.
- devmunchies 6y agomuch like how there is a feature for linking to duplicates, there should be an official feature to link to a section in the official docs. It should even be in your face when answering a question. A culture of posting sources/references.
- mathattack 6y agoCongrats. Despite all the complaints about the nastiness of their mods, they’ve generated billions of dollars of programmer productivity to the world.
- capableweb 6y agoCould also be: "Despite all the nastiness of their mods, they’ve generated billions of dollars of programmer productivity to the world, but who knows how much it could have been if the moderation was done better?"
- wuliwong 6y agoThe original quote is "Despite all the complaints about the nastiness of their mods." The original was not granting as true the mods being nasty, just that the complaints were real.
- jasode 6y ago>complaints about the nastiness of their mods, I didn't downvote your comment but I think it would be better if we don't phrase it in a "us vs them" manner such as "their mods". The mods are _us_. The mods are mostly unpaid fellow users that passed a points threshold[1] to do certain admin tasks. E.g. 3000 points to cast "close votes" isn't that high. If we don't like what the "mods" are doing, maybe that old saying is relevant: "we've met the enemy and the enemy is us." [1] https://stackoverflow.com/help/privileges https://stackoverflow.com/help/privileges
- Quarrelsome 6y agoits mildly more complex. As someone that never enjoyed the moderation angle that SO took (forgoing community for correctness and generally tending towards librarian stuffiness), to me the mods are most certainly not "us".
- erikbye 6y agoIf the mods on SO were more lenient than they already are SO would be completely useless, as opposed to barely useful, as it stands today. So many of the low-effort questions and answers belong in forums or IRC channels, or just ask your colleague, FFS. Or, you know, read official documentation? Get an understanding of the subject before you start making posts and just wait around for an answer. But I guess people could actually learn something, then. Learning is not what many developers seem to use SO for, they just want a quick fix. Something to copy-paste. It leaves them with no understanding and increases the shittyness of code everywhere. We need a higher bar for programming. If you can't get your work done without SO, you should be fired.
- 3pt14159 6y agoIt's just a shame that programmers like myself can't invest randomly in the tools we love. GitHub, StackOverflow, and DigitalOcean all would have had at least $10k from me years ago. I get the reasons why, it's just frustrating to see obviously good companies grow just like you expect them to and 100x their valuation over a decade.
- DSingularity 6y agoHow will the rich and powerful grow if programmers like you are allowed to invest like you describe?
- AbrahamParangi 6y agoIf you believe this then write to your congressional representative and tell them to repeal accredited investor rules.
- TomMarius 6y agoWhat if they are one of the people that lost? Not every person gets a representative, only the bigger (but potentially small) portion of voters gets.
- icedchai 6y agoMost engineers can clear the accredited investor rules in their 30's. A million isn't what it used to be in the 80's.
- boring_twenties 6y agoImagine thinking this is even close to accurate
- icedchai 6y agoSorry, but it is accurate with many engineers I know. Most have pretty fat 401Ks by mid to late 30's. 401K millionaires are not uncommon. Also, many west coast folks or those in high cost of living areas can clear the accredited investor rule based on income alone. ($200K income for 2 years in a row.)
- bgorman 6y agoThis concerns me. I doubt the product will actually become better with more VC money thrown at it. We will probably see things like premium content now.
- the_jeremy 6y agoAs a pretty avid answerer on SO (>5k rep, >100 answers), it's surprising how much money people are willing to throw at this. The staff's apparent inability to interact positively with the community is a huge red flag[0], especially as the primary value they have as a brand is the size and quality of the community. I would switch sites easily if there was a compelling alternative, but I haven't heard of one. 0: https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/333965/firing-mods-and-forced-relicensing-is-stack-exchange-still-interested-in-cooper https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/333965/firing-mods-...
- PaywallBuster 6y agoI'd say most people come to SO from Google searches and are not following any of those politics.
- the_jeremy 6y agoMost users, sure. I think most of the regular answerers are aware of this, and they are the main value of SO.
- felipellrocha 6y agoThe thing is that you eventually get a good answer, and I don't know who, but someone does eventually go back around and delete all the bad answers. I checked all my previous questions. I remember being met with people cursing me out for not already knowing the answer (why would I be even asking in the first place?), and after a few months, when I go back for reference, it all looks peachy. You're left with a golden nugget of interaction with most answers, and that builds up over time. I would switch too, but they do provide value as of today, even while your first few interactions might be more unsavory, because at the end of the day, as far as I can see, the people giving terrible first answers are regular people, and if so, the value they're providing is finding the good answer in a sea of awful people.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rubber_duck 6y agoI can't pinpoint the exact moment but I noticed I've been finding more and more answers in the official documentation, GitHub issues and project source code. Maybe Google got better at indexing docs or people started writing higher quality documentation but where I used to land on SO multiple times a day I will now visit it a few times a week at most. Also when the mentioned sources hit a search result it's almost always better quality (SO has gems for sure, but I often encounter outdated, incorrect or half solution answers and the format is not structured so that you can share your process which makes it hard to examine how someone got to that point and where to take it from there - unlike say GitHub issue thread).
- wastedhours 6y agoDocumentation as a sales and SEO tactic has been undervalued for so long that it's surprising it's taken this long for projects to clock onto the fact. It's definitely a great trend for questions to be answered by the right communities up front rather than endless SO questions asking slightly different variants of the same thing. (And if you run a project and aren't thinking about your documentation in that way, do start!)
- axlee 6y ago> people started writing higher quality documentation I think that's certainly the case. We went from raw, technical-specs style documentations revolving around feature description towards a more usage-based documentation style, which is far more effective at answering the most common questions when approaching a new software: "How can I do X using this software? What if Y happen when trying to do X?" Also, projects like Django and companies like Stripe provided great examples to follow when writing solid documentations for respectively frameworks and APIs and led the way to an overall higher quality of docs, by mimetism. It also doesn't hurt that a well-documented product sells better and has easier adoption: maybe the popular software/frameworks/languages/APIs of today are not exactly the "best" of yesterday, but people naturally gravitated towards the better documented ones.
- seventh-chord 6y agoIve experienced the same thing, but have attributed it to gaining more experience. I feel like the questions answered on stack overflow usually are ones that one can trivially solve by knowing where to find documentation, and the questions I end up wanting help with are too specific to bring up sensible search results. Maybe I'm just bad at using search engines though...
- schwinn140 6y agoCongrats to the SO team. That said, I'm struggling to understand how/why a they could possibly need to raise now a total of $153MM. All the content is community generated so there's no costs there. The core Exchange product is extremely templatized and I would assume be quite scale-able to spin-up as they need additional ones. I don't believe they have much in the form of paid outbound marketing initiatives. I'm assuming that I'm completely missing something here. Educate me. ;)
- coliveira 6y agoThey are certainly trying to move the company in other directions that will require a lot of funding and uncertain returns. Otherwise, investors wouldn't even look at it.
- mikestew 6y agoThat said, I'm struggling to understand how/why a they could possibly need to raise now a total of $153MM. Gotta make the work of those digital sharecroppers pay off somehow: https://blog.codinghorror.com/are-you-a-digital-sharecropper/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/are-you-a-digital-sharecropper... No, the fact that the blog post was written by a SO founder is not lost on me.
- tghw 6y ago> This is a topic that I've spent a great deal of time thinking about, because we happen to run a site chock full of user generated questions and answers. The last thing I want to do is exploit Stack Overflow users for corporate gain, even accidentally. That's horrible. Yikes. Right on the nose...
- schwinn140 6y agoYikes is right. Seems like they said the quiet part out loud.
- JeremyBanks 6y ago
- dvh 6y agoI thought it was bought by Microsoft but I guess it's just Mandela effect playing trick with my mind.
- quaintdev 6y agoHow difficult it would be to build a decentralised SO? I know it's the valuable knowledge base and contributing users that will be missing in our new service but we gotta start somewhere. I guess it would be easier to onboard Software developers on a decentralised service than general public. Some ideas for this service: 1. Users can choose to keep knowledge base locally for topic of their interests 2. A terminal based interface for quick answers
- dusted 6y agoI guess the difficult part is not the technology, it's not like SO is doing anything too fancy on that front. But the community, growing and getting people to answer questions, that's something we'd have expected FSF to grow, but somehow that community couldn't.
- dehrmann 6y agoI agree that building a community is very hard, but at least there are success stories to look at. I can't name any successful, Google-accessible decentralized system.
- zozbot234 6y ago> How difficult it would be to build a decentralised SO? Q&A platforms are widely available, and they could easily support federated/decentralized use cases via ActivityPub. So building a decentralized platform is mostly about creating these communities and enabling them to federate with one another.
- shagie 6y agoIn reading another current HN post I was reminded that for a long time, this was known as USENET.
- frandroid 6y agoEvery time I search for an answer to a technical question, and I end up on a mailing list post, I get the old great/damn response: Great, that's my question! Damn, will it actually be accompanied by an answer??
- dusted 6y ago"The next generation of digital applications" buzzbingo!
- eric4smith 6y agoWhat’s the endgame with SO here? A series F investment? Going public? Selling to Microsoft? I would assume selling to Microsoft would be the thing to do. But whoever buys it has no revenue model so that’s tricky. Unless they’re doing it for altruistic purposes. Don’t get it twisted I love SO.
- latk 6y agoAt this valuation an acquisition is less likely. I would have rather expected an acquisition by Microsoft than a series E, but I guess it's too late now. That would leave an eventual IPO as the only way out, but they'd need to break even first (or at least have a very compelling vision to break even soon). I don't see that happening with their current Teams product, which is an uncompelling entry in a crowded market. Also, whether Teams eventually succeeds is largely unrelated to SO's unique value: the community. Teams is not valuable because of the community, it's just a spin-off from their public platform. They really need to find a better path to success, because wasting $85M on the status quo is not going to get them there. Their Careers product was more interesting in this respect, but it seems they failed to achieve sufficient scale there.
- corobo 6y ago> has no revenue model Half the smartest people in the world are working on the revenue model Ads. Ads everywhere.
- matsemann 6y agoThe internal SO offering (SO for teams or what it's called) works reasonably well for huge orgs.
- Slartie 6y agoThey're secretly waiting for GPT-4 to be finished, which will be trained on the whole SO question/answer corpus and can then be sold to big corporations desperate to scale up their teams of monkeys copy-pasting code from SO...sorry, I meant to say "engineers writing enterprise grade software".
- turnerc 6y ago> This is an exciting inflection point in our company’s history as we accelerate the realization of our mission If your first line of a financing announcement is this, then I do wonder if SO has lost touch with who their target audience is. I also struggle to see where the value actually comes from, if tomorrow all of the top 1% of posters stopped then their leverage to promote other lineups is dead. It's a shame to say it but its another case of VC overvaluation
- thrownaway954 6y agoremember that the database to SO is released under CC. https://www.brentozar.com/archive/2015/10/how-to-download-the-stack-overflow-database-via-bittorrent/ https://www.brentozar.com/archive/2015/10/how-to-download-th...
- dyeje 6y agoBit concerning they haven't been able to build a sustainable business off a website that has become more or less a canonical resource for software engineers by now.
- deedubaya 6y agoI've stopped contributing to SO. SO is simply going the same route as Experts Exchange (if you're old enough to remember it). It has amassed a significant amount of knowledge (for free!) that they'll some day hide behind a paywall and sell to desperate seekers of that information.
- erikbye 6y agoDoubtful, in the case of Stack Overflow, I think "free" and ads provide a hell of a lot more users and revenue than paywall.
- coronadisaster 6y agoEE used to be the top search result for a long time... Hope SO don't go out in the same way.
- knowhy 6y agoLooking at the answer-rate-over-time[0] SO benefits from the Corona pandemic. 0: https://data.stackexchange.com/stackoverflow/query/303570/answer-rate-over-time#graph https://data.stackexchange.com/stackoverflow/query/303570/an...
- Flenser 6y agowow, it looks like the answer rate is going down significantly. It looks like it slipped a bit in 2014/2015 but there's a big decrease in 2019 around the time of the Monica Cellio incident.
- jypepin 6y agoSO is over 10 years old now and hasn't changed much - I'm wondering what makes the investors think that profits will come and now is a good time to invest more money.
- jiofih 6y agoHaven’t used SO at all for over five years now. Eventually I’ll look up some weird edge case answers, but the trust I had on the site and it’s content is long gone. This smells like a corporate move to get more money on executive’s pockets, nothing more. A shame that SO was allowed to get to this state.
- ram_rar 6y agoSO is an amazing product. I learnt a lot from it. But in the last few years, I have been directed more towards Github, whenever I face issues with a particular library or tech stack. I see those questions already being asked/answered via github Issue. I am not sure, what is the endgame for SO. But, Github could become a strong competitor in this space. Its become lot more easier to copy paste troublesome code/error and see resolution in github.
- Vysero 6y agoI prefer using forums. They feel more personal, inviting, and calm. My bookmarks include top forums for every language I use. I would rather wait a few hours for an answer than bother with SO when I have questions that don't seem to have been asked before. SO is hostile even after years, and years of use I still always feel as though I am walking on eggshells when I post questions to SO. That's not okay.
- moralestapia 6y agoOh boy, Series E. If you raise Series E it means either you are doing extremely well or your business is drowning and you need a lifesaver. A business that is doing really well typically raises much more than 85M, so I'm going to go with the latter option. In which case, also, an 85M lifeline at this stage means you are not worth that much alive ... IMO I can see in a very clear way the downfall of SO happened, they undermined the community that made them rise in the first place. Their most valuable asset IS the community, way more than the knowledge base they have accrued. People no longer feel comfortable going there. I wouldn't be surprised if their MAU is going down. Too bad for Atwood which I think is responsible for the culture that SO initially had, and which lured many of us to contribute. Since he left, it's hard to put it in words but something changed. I don't think he's happy with how the site turned out to be down the road. tl;dr; what this series E means is that SO will become the new experts-exchange sooner than later.
- bobobob420 6y agoStack Overflow is the greatest programming resource ever made and the people who answer questions in a manner that helps also teach the OP are the true heroes.
- bawana 6y agoWhat about all the other stack exchange sites? Are they separate and not deserving of support because they are not about software? Is it because software makes money so a public support group for software is monetizable? I miss usenet.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- easton 6y agoI wonder if they have received any buyout offers lately. Their business model doesn't seem to be as successful as it should be (given how much their site is used), but it seems like they'd be an ideal candidate for a company that wanted to make inroads with developers, like Microsoft. And the site does already run on IIS. Perhaps I should start a Bureau of the Atomic Scientists-esque doomsday clock[0] for the minutes until Microsoft buys Canonical and Stack Overflow and completes their trifecta of modern dev tooling companies with GitHub. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_Clock https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doomsday_Clock
- shagie 6y agoI want to say "with the direction that SO Teams took - no." Its not that SO Teams is a bad thing, just that it isn't the thing that the other companies want to buy. Look at Microsoft - its got a large work productivity suite (MS Teams, Office, Sharepoint) - all of which are more more mature than Stack Overflow in terms of developer experience. And then there's GitHub and its got GitHub Discussions ( https://github.com/github/roadmap/issues/104 https://github.com/github/roadmap/issues/104 ) on its roadmap for the near future. SO would be conflicting with that... and then there's the rest of the SE network that has nothing that a hypothetical MS buyer would want. And SO Jobs competes with LinkedIn. At best it would be an accuhire... but a lot of the developer knowledge has either left or been fired. Google is the other option. But then... Google is trying to do its own venture into worker productivity. SO (and the SE Network) would kind of help that and making it searchable... but its really not that interesting of a target beyond all that content (and Google doesn't really like managing content of their own). And elsewhere on HN today you can see what Google thinks of maintaining information... why would they want to buy it when they can get search clicks for free? Google has no need to buy SO as an accuhire... and again, most of what is there seems to be sales rather than engineering (look at job postings https://stackoverflow.com/company/work-here#positions https://stackoverflow.com/company/work-here#positions ) The blog post seems to suggest that SO wants to go up head to head with Zoom, Atlassian, Slack and Microsoft for the team productivity area. That feels like a "too little, too late" for the direction that they're looking at. As an aside - look at the benefits on https://stackoverflow.com/jobs/companies/stack-overflow https://stackoverflow.com/jobs/companies/stack-overflow - the free lunch from in house chef and proclaiming great chairs feels (at least to me) more of a startup that is spending money because it got it.
- ykevinator 6y agoI hate so, I love the info, I hate the moderators, I hate flagging. All that aside, I can't believe they still can't make money.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 6y agoTo me the problem with stackoverflow is the same. It's a useful place to find examples and simple answers to almost-documentation kind of thing, but all the hard questions without a clear possibile answer is not allowed. This made the website less and less useful over time.
- user00012-ab 6y agoA dystopian science fiction story where Yahoo buys Stack Overflow, destroys it like all their other products, and in the doing so, no one knows how to program anymore and society collapses.