7 ms·
But the virus hadn’t wrecked Dowd’s lungs. In fact, she had only mild pneumonia. Instead, SARS-CoV-2 had ruptured her heart. A lot of the early part of the art
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
But the virus hadn’t wrecked Dowd’s lungs. In fact, she had only mild pneumonia. Instead, SARS-CoV-2 had ruptured her heart.
A lot of the early part of the article rehashes basics, like how viruses replicate. If you have basic knowledge of that sort, you can kind of skim until the mid point, where we find the above factoid.
I have been reading less about the virus of late, but this fits with everything I know. It causes blood clots. Ventilators aren't really fixing it. The lack of oxygen is probably more about what it does to the blood (than what it does to the lungs).
Later in the article, it talks about impacts on the feet suspected to be a side effect. Feet issues are commonly associated with blood/circulation issues. This is why diabetes can lead to feet being amputated.
The blood issues are well established and this has been known for some time. I'm somewhat aghast to see this article talking like we don't already know that detail.
- simonh 6y agoThis is the feature article in a special series of articles on combating the virus. As such it's presenting a summary of what we know about it so far, and references a lot of sources, some going back several months. Given that context I think that's exactly what I'd expect it to do. Not everyone has done as much research as you, and the public perception and debate is still awash with "just a bad flu" disinformation, so its really important a clearer and more accurate picture is put out as widely as possible.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThank you. The stuff about blood clots began coming out about the time I concluded I probably had it and had been mostly asymptomatic and about that same time I ran into a researcher on HN who said something about the blood that I didn't follow and I asked questions and that went weird places and then they said something else about zinc. And that led to an epiphany for me and I turned to my son and kind or recounted the exchange with the researcher and then I said "We've been eating a lot of zinc-rich foods. I am going to go get a cheese pizza because cheese has zinc." So I got a pizza and then he felt vastly better. So the whole blood angle is cemented in my mind like "Clearly, this is a hard fact and everyone knows it." But it's probably just me in my little bubble and that's it. I'm still aghast. But what you say makes sense.
- corin_ 6y agoIt's worth remembering that just because you have a bubble of belief/knowledge it doesn't automatically make it scientific fact rather than anecdotally coinciding with some science. For example, yes there is some research suggesting zinc (and related, vitamin D) may be very relevant with covid-19, but there isn't yet definitive understanding among experts yet alone us HN commenters. Anecdotally: I often feel better after eating a pizza, dating back to before covid-19 existed, and despite my zinc levels being fine. I just really fucking love pizza. All of us, whether we are trying to read every research paper released or not following anything except newspaper headlines, need to keep reminding ourselves that just as the experts will keep revising their beliefs to fit new findings, we need to keep checking if our own knowledge is correct, or if it might be either outdated and/or based on cognitive biases. Personally I'm recommending friends/family to make sure that they are getting enough of various vitamins/minerals, while being very clear that my suggestion is a "can't do any harm to have the right levels of whatever" rather than "I'm sure this will help with covid".
- DoreenMichele 6y agoIt's worth remembering that just because you have a bubble of belief/knowledge it doesn't automatically make it scientific fact rather than anecdotally coinciding with some science. I'm well aware of that. I'm just trying to say that it made an especially big impression on me because of my personal experience, not that my anecdote makes it scientific fact. I'm still appalled that they know it causes blood issues and are not connecting the dots between that and the feet issues. The article doesn't explicitly say that feet issues of that sort are consistent with blood issues, though that is an extremely well-established scientific fact. I paid accident claims for five years. As part of that job, I read medical records all day. I paid for foot amputations and we had to sometimes try to decide "Was this really an accident? Or was this really a complication of diabetes?" So I'm not just talking out my ass here. I completed a Certified Life and Health Insurance Specialist certificate. I also just do a lot of reading of medical stuff because of my own health issues. I'm pretty confident the blood issues are very well established at this point and have been for some time.
- credit_guy 6y agoIf I get Covid19, my plan is to take aspirin wile at home. If I need to go the Emergency Room, then I'll leave it to the doctors to decide what I should get, but before I need urgent care, I'll use aspirin.
- JanSt 6y agoAny scientific backing for this?
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThe Cleveland Clinic recommends against it: https://www.cleveland.com/coronavirus/2020/05/taking-daily-aspirin-to-prevent-blood-clots-in-case-you-get-coronavirus-is-dangerous-idea-doctors-say.html https://www.cleveland.com/coronavirus/2020/05/taking-daily-a...
- credit_guy 6y agoThey have no choice but to say that. Just like in criminal justice one is assumed innocent until proven guilty (beyond any reasonable doubt), in the medical field a drug is assumed harmful until proven beneficial (beyond a certain p-value). As long as the proof of the benefit is not out there (and peer-reviewed), a medical professional needs to give more weight to the known risks vs the unproven potential benefits. They might lose their license if they do otherwise. But while they may need to think about their license, I need to think about my survival. And here I'm talking about my own survival. I'm not advising anyone else to do the same. I'm not a doctor, and even if I claimed I were one, nobody should just take a random guy's advice over the internet. That said, my thought process is this: it is aspirin we are talking about, not cyanide. I have taken aspirin many times in my life, including several times recently. The benefit is not proven because doing medical trials is expensive. But the benefit is plausible enough that someone started just such a trial [1]. Separately, the benefits of other blood thinners are considered so great that they are part of the standard of care for Covid19 patients in some hospitals, such as MassGeneral [2]. So, my own assessment of that taking aspirin has for me a higher potential benefit than the potential risk. But again, this is just for me, not offering advice to other people. [1] https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT04365309 https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT04365309 [2] https://www.massgeneral.org/assets/MGH/pdf/news/coronavirus/mass-general-covid-19-anticoagulation-algorithm.pdf https://www.massgeneral.org/assets/MGH/pdf/news/coronavirus/...
- huffmsa 6y agoCoronaviruses in cats primarily attack the blood. Has been speculated on since as early as March (that I've seen) with more evidence in support since then that this strain of human coronavirus is behaving like that. Explains the majority of symptoms. Low pulse ox, feet, brain, lung, kidney, etc etc.
- coldtea 6y ago>I'm somewhat aghast to see this article talking like we don't already know that detail. It's an article, not a news story or a scientific paper. So it's neither about breaking news nor innovative research results. So, they don't presume what the public knows at any substantial level (heck, many still don't know/believe the virus is not real). I, on the other hand, am more aghast for the use of the word aghast for such a trivial matter :-)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jfoster 6y agoMainstream (and that includes many politicians) still think of it as respiratory. All the other effects are not yet mainstream knowledge.
- newacct583 6y ago> Ventilators aren't really fixing it. The lack of oxygen is probably more about what it does to the blood (than what it does to the lungs). That's not right. It causes cytokine storms just like any other major repiratory virus. Ventilators do help, lots of people survive on them. They are a critically important piece of the treatment puzzle. I don't think statements like that are very helpful. It's on the spectrum toward conspiracy nonsense. > I'm somewhat aghast to see this article talking like we don't already know that detail. It's not a scientific study, it's a review piece for general readers.
- titzer 6y ago> If you have basic knowledge of that sort, you can kind of skim until the mid point, where we find the above factoid. Well maybe you skimmed a little too much, because the article clearly talks about the negative effects of an overactive immune system response being characteristic in some patients, and there was plenty of evidence of that in some people's wrecked lungs. Part of the therapy is to guide and even suppress the complex immune system response to keep people's bodies from destroying themselves. Your comment didn't mention any of that and might be read by some as a "move along, nothing to see here." I think this is definitely not the case and people would be better served to read the article itself instead of your comment dismissing it and instructing them to skip over the section about immune system response.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI wasn't instructing anyone to do any such thing. Another way to frame my point: If the start of the article bores you to tears, hang in there. It gets meatier.
- titzer 6y agoI can only go by what you wrote. > If you have basic knowledge of that sort, you can kind of skim until the mid point, where we find the above factoid. I replied to your comment because I read the article first and actually did learn this bit about the immune system response which is in the first half. If I had read your comment first I would likely would have skimmed the article (or even skipped it altogether) and missed it. In that situation your comment would have directed me away from learning something new. I'll continue to try to read articles before comments in the future.
- danesparza 6y agoBlood clots might be caused by a change in angiogenesis that appears to be correlated with COVID-19. I found this autopsy analysis by an MD to be very enlightening: https://youtu.be/1HTionnTT9I https://youtu.be/1HTionnTT9I
- hartator 6y agoYes, COVID-19 is a bad one but it’s just another virus at the end of the day. I feel they act as we rediscovering everything about viruses for sensationalism.
- mohamedattahri 6y agoYes, but downplaying the fact that it’s new and that there’s a lot of unknown unknowns about it and its effects mid/long term is dangerous. Not all viruses are the same, and it takes time to observe and study them. This is IMO the other important reason why it’s important to stop the spread, besides overloading hospitals.
- jmcqk6 6y agoAnother way to look at it is that many people who were previously ignorant regarding most things we know about viruses are learning quickly and because they are novel to them, they find them sensationable.
- Balgair 6y agoNasim Taleb had a good point on the most recent EconTalk [0] about covid: We kinda know what the morality rate is, but we have no idea what the morbidity of covid looks like. All the co-morbidities are essentially unknown and are likely to stay that way for a while. These side effects take time to suss out; more than the nine months we've had with covid. With the unknown and potentially unbounded risks we are staring at, Taleb says that over-reaction is the best strategy. He and Russ Roberts go on to talk about the basic issues with statistics in these cases, a good trip back to the first week of any stats course that everyone promptly ignores. [0] https://www.econtalk.org/nassim-nicholas-taleb-on-the-pandemic/ https://www.econtalk.org/nassim-nicholas-taleb-on-the-pandem...
- giardini 6y agoBalgair says: >"We kinda know what the morality rate is, but ..."< "Morality rate", hmmm...I like it, but maybe for another article!8-))
- specialist 6y agoI'd previously read that COVID-19 might be a cardiovascular disease, which would account for the blood clots and heart stuff. From the OC: Marcus plans to also start collecting data from wearable devices, including Fitbits and Zio patches, which wirelessly monitor heart rhythms. “There may be large numbers of people who are suffering from cardiovascular effects of COVID-19 in the absence of other symptoms,” Marcus says. “I’m worried we’re missing those cases.” I have no idea what it means to regard COVID-19 in cardiovascular vs respiratory terms. I'm just repeating what I think I've read. I really don't understand this stuff.