3 ms·
> EU regulators comb through documents looking for about 2,500 search phrases which include “big question”, “shut down” and “not good for us”, said a person fam
by SpicyLemonZest 6y ago
> EU regulators comb through documents looking for about 2,500 search phrases which include “big question”, “shut down” and “not good for us”, said a person familiar with the matter.
Is the text of the Commission's requests public? This paragraph seems to be implying that they're demanding every Facebook document containing any of these 2,500 phrases, which does seem pretty dumb if true.
- ggggtez 6y agoThis is how court orders work. See other lawsuits where company emails were obtained. This list of 2500 words is not random. https://www.huffpost.com/entry/gm-powerpoint_n_5340385 https://www.huffpost.com/entry/gm-powerpoint_n_5340385
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThanks for filling me in. I wasn't aware this was such a common practice.
- buran77 6y ago> which does seem pretty dumb if true Why is that? The alternative is to ask for everything and keep what's valuable, kind of how companies like Facebook do. What other options do you see?
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThe alternative is for regulators to issue narrow, targeted requests for the information they need to investigate specific issues. I don't think the government should be able to tell a company "alright, hand over all your documents so we can make sure there's no evidence of wrongdoing in them".
- buran77 6y ago> narrow, targeted requests The investigators should ask exactly for the smoking gun, but they need the smoking gun to know exactly what to ask for. Imagine if when asking for a warrant the Police would have to say "we are looking for a knife on the left side of a shoe box under the defendant's bed". Oh the knife is wrapped in some tax returns and blood work results... bummer. You don't need to go much farther than your average internet search to see that it's nigh impossible to search so narrowly that only the best result comes up from the first try and doesn't contain any irrelevant information. And that's before considering that unlike internet searches companies go through a lot of effort to intentionally poison the well and mix up the now known search words throughout a big volume of irrelevant information to prove their point. This is what this request is about, buying that time. As I already said, you can't not spot the irony when a company insists they need very broad access to your data to monetize it, but complain when regulators need access to their data as part as an official investigation.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoIn my area, that's indeed how police investigations work. They don't have to be quite that specific, but they do have to explain what specific things they're looking for and why they expect to find them. They couldn't say "well, it's possible you committed a murder, so we'll search your house to see if there's any murder evidence in it".
- ggggtez 6y agoLet's not pretend that Facebook isn't accused of a myriad of anti-competitive practices. Not even Facebook is claiming that the EU doesn't have grounds for a search. They are simply saying the search is overbroad.
- jariel 6y ago? The irony is the other way around. FB is free, users provide information, FB doesn't sell it or share it, they use it to place ads. The EU government is concerned about 'privacy' while asking a private, foreign company to hand over arbitrary private data. Imagine the police pulling you over and asking you to show any emails which included the terms 'deal' or 'partying' or 'the green stuff'. The investigators are probably barking up the wrong tree.
- jariel 6y ago"> which does seem pretty dumb if true Why is that? " Because governments have no right to ask private groups to hand over arbitrary, speculative bits of information. They can ask for specific things relating to specific matters with a court order, but broad searches for loose search terms is ridiculous and probably unconstitutional.
- oneplane 6y agoYes they do. Maybe you'd like government not to have that power, but the reality is that we elected officials that made this lawful.
- jariel 6y agoNo they absolutely don't and every modern nation has rules against arbitrary search and seizure. In fact, this looks pretty crazy upon first glance, these keyword searches are very arbitrary and broad, it wouldn't hold up in most other scenarios, FB is right to take this to court.
- petre 6y agoIt's not arbitrary search and seizure. It's a legitimate request for FB to produce documents because they're under suspicion of abusing their market position.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]