11 ms·
TBH depending on circumstances, working five days a week at home also won't work for a lot of people this year. I have family trying to raise two kids during t
by shadowgovt 6y ago
TBH depending on circumstances, working five days a week at home also won't work for a lot of people this year.
I have family trying to raise two kids during this pandemic. Turns out, children aren't just little adults who will go off and do assigned tasks unsupervised; they require attention and crave personal feedback, and those aren't things they can get from either teachers or peers in a distance-learning configuration. Not in the quantities they get them in school. A lot of working parents are going to find they're splitting their time between their day jobs and keeping their children on their tasks, which will be a huge adjustment for a lot of families (especially families with two working parents who can remote-work).
I don't know that the US has a firm understanding of how much the babysitting aspect of regular primary (and in some cases, high school) education adds value, and the whole economy is in for a rude shock come Q42020 / Q12021 as everyone's projections get missed unless companies are writing down goal-hitting expectations right now.
- ryneandal 6y agoI haven't been this exhausted ever. Being productive at work and handling my children's needs throughout the day is unbelievably taxing, leading to Friday nights where I fall asleep with them ~730 and end up sleeping 12 hours. I hope this leads to realization of how important work/life balance is here in the States. This Protestant work ethic simply isn't necessary with today's productivity.
- gabaix 6y agoI am moving to my parents’ city for this exact reason. My wife and I are full time professionals, and we are failing at educating our children.
- ryneandal 6y agoThankfully we live in the same city my parents live in, and they're retired. They've been an absolute godsend.
- shadowgovt 6y agoThe (traditional) Protestant work ethic also assumed a Protestant community centered around a church as cultural / societal hub. Not even the PWE suggested people go all out all the time without community support.
- Consultant32452 6y agoTraditionally raising children was a multi-generational effort with grandparents often living under the same roof. Not to mention women were less likely to work outside the home back then. Modern society is highly efficient, but also highly susceptible to disruption. It'll be interesting to see how we figure out how to adapt.
- bobthepanda 6y agoElizabeth Warren actually has a book on this very topic: https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2019/1/23/18183091/two-income-trap-elizabeth-warren-book https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2019/1/23/18183091/t... >>> The “two-income trap,” described The “two-income trap,” as described by Warren, really consists of three partially separate phenomena that have arisen as families have come to rely on two working adults to make ends meet: The addition of a second earner means, in practice, a big increase in household fixed expenses for things like child care and commuting. Much of the money that American second earners bring in has been gobbled up, in practice, by zero-sum competition for educational opportunities expressed as either skyrocketed prices for houses in good school districts or escalating tuition at public universities. Last, while the addition of the second earner has not brought in much gain, it has created an increase in downside risk by eliminating an implicit insurance policy that families used to rely on. This last point is really the key to Warren’s specific argument about bankruptcy, though it’s the first two that would drive her larger interest in politics. Bad things have always happened to families from time to time. In a traditional two-parent, one-earner family, there was always the possibility that mom could step up and help out when trouble arose. “If her husband was laid off, fired, or otherwise left without a paycheck,” Warren and Tyagi write, “the stay-at-home mother didn’t simply stand helplessly on the sidelines as her family toppled off an economic cliff; she looked for a job to make up some of that lost income.” Similarly, if a family member got sick, mom was available as an unpaid caregiver. “A stay-at-home mother served as the family’s ultimate insurance against unemployment or disability — insurance that had a very real economic value even when it wasn’t drawn on.” A modern family where mom is already working has no “give” and is much more likely to be pushed into bankruptcy by job loss or family illness unless it builds up a big financial cushion.
- burlesona 6y agoThe “Protestant Work Ethic” was built around the notion of a two-parent household with the parents specialized such that one works outside the home while one works inside the home. It also assumes a significant social safety net in the form of family and close community support via churches, schools, etc. I understand the gist of what you mean, but I think you’re really pointing at the idea of the “nuclear family,” and the “two-income household,” both of which are post-war ideas. Specifically, Elizabeth Warren wrote an entire book about this “Two Income Trap,” how much more fragile it makes families, and why we should be working to get back to one-income being a reasonable option so that more people could choose it when their circumstances demanded it.
- throwaway45349 6y agoThe problem with going back to one income is cultural. Men want to be the breadwinner, so it's going to end up forcing women out of the workforce and back into the home. There's no way to have one income viable again without halving the supply of people in the workforce.
- ocdtrekkie 6y ago> Men want to be the breadwinner And there's the problem. I'd be totally comfortable if my future wife ended up being the financial supporter of the family. There's technical things I'd like to invest time and mental resources in that wouldn't necessarily make money, but would be fulfilling, and housework is already something I do a lot of and wouldn't mind being more responsible for if I wasn't spending 40+ at the office. I can't imagine dumping my career whilst I'm the higher earner, but if she ends up making more than me (kinda likely actually, given some time), it might be the most sensible solution. Marriage should be a team activity where either partner is willing to take on whatever role is best for the family.
- throwaway45349 6y agoBoth men and women usually prefer men to be the breadwinner though - this isn't just cultural - it has biological roots. Breaking away from that on a mass societal-wide scale will not be easy. Thankfully humans are one of the few animals who override their instincts so it's not impossible.
- stormdennis 6y agoProtestant work ethic. I used to believe in this but the hardest working people I spent time working with were actually Catholic.
- platetone 6y agoI'm still uncertain how I'm supposed to lead twins through online Kindergarten and write software all day. They can't even fucking use scissors without my help.
- jjeaff 6y agoAs someone with a young one at home and that works from home, you cannot without help. My advice is to not over-tax yourself trying to do two things at once. It is very tiring both mentally and physically to switch back and forth too frequently. Focus on your kids when they need your focus and reserve your strength for planned time that you can actually focus on work. Like during nap time or after bedtime.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoNo doubt. Like between teachers and other kids, young children have eight hours of constant stimulation and it's absolutely impossible for a parent to offer that. Work from home productivity will absolutely suffer because of it, but what else are employers going to do? Unlike providing on-site daycare, stay-at-home nanny services don't scale well. :/
- saagarjha 6y ago> between teachers and other kids, young children have eight hours of constant stimulation Not always eight hours, sometimes school can be boring ;)
- donalhunt 6y agoI ended up taking a 3 month leave of absence to take care of my 3 young kids (one of which has a disability). Ireland closed schools and universities on 13 March 2020 and we quickly realised that even with 2 parents at home full-time, we couldn't work and take care of our children. We found a good balance eventually but it was only possible through the circumstances of my wife's role and my ability to take leave. Many many people are not in a position (negotiating power, financially) to do that which makes this extremely tough mentally and physically. If you have the ability (time, money) to help friends, family, neighbours, please consider doing so (those that need it will very much appreciate it).
- _lacroix 6y agoObviously this isn't an ideal solution but I wonder if this might be an opportunity for the people with means to pay for a babysitter (but not necessarily a private teacher) to hire some of the 2020 college grads who aren't going to find a job any time soon as daily tutors/online school facilitators for their kids? There are going to be tons of educated young adults out of work in the coming year and given their lack of experience they'll be less expensive than hiring an actual teacher, but they may be able to provide enough feedback and structure to give the kids a better quality online education. I don't have kids though so I don't really have a dog in this fight, just an idea. I used to enjoy babysitting back in the day and I would have loved an "academic babysitting" job like this when I first graduated.
- sologoub 6y agoTurns out the age old adaptations of having proximity to relatives really do matter. US is doubly vulnerable here - people move around a lot and the infra for childcare is simply not there. This is being discussed from the well-off perspective of remote-capable jobs. The real pain is being felt by medical and other front-line workers. Gov. really need to look for options to support those in critical in-person jobs, starting with medical/fire/etc and then opening up to all essential jobs categories.
- closeparen 6y agoA lot of us were born in places that are no longer economically relevant. The retired are less geographically restrained - I wonder why they don’t more often follow their adult children. For example some of my Chinese coworkers don’t need to go back to China for childcare; their parents and in-laws rotate shifts here. Also keep in mind, if both generations have kids at 30 (or even younger in a more traditional setting), grandparents are also still working age when the child is born.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>I wonder why they don’t more often follow their adult children Because the cost of living where their adult children are reflects the incomes of their adult children.
- closeparen 6y agoThat's fair, but the way I've seen this done is with a 2-bedroom apartment. A young family will need that eventually anyway. The second bedroom can be the caregiver's until it becomes the child's.
- C1sc0cat 6y agoAlso remote education is much harder one of my friends who is a classics teacher at a public (private) school in the UK confirms that. And as its a public school these are small class sizes
- softawre 6y agoYou're right. I'm blessed to have my wife be a stay-at-home mom, and it means I can be much more productive during this time compared to people in dual income situations. At the same time, we've forgone extra income by having her stay at home, so there's that too..
- maest 6y agoWill childless employees receive raises or be rewarded in some other way?
- cyberlurker 6y agoNo. The reward is not having to do two jobs for the same compensation. If you’re childless, your reward is your freedom from this challenging time for working families. To get to the root of this...You are likely hinting that it is a choice to have kids. But it’s also necessary for society that people have children and take care of them. Disclaimer: I don’t have kids but might one day.
- maest 6y agoThe GP was suggesting that, due to having children at home, many people will slip on their deadlines. It's natural to ask what happens to people who do not have children. > You are likely hinting that it is a choice to have kids. I did not, and my view on having children is not relevant here.
- cyberlurker 6y agoThey might slip on their deadlines during a global crisis, or they might just work more than they usually do (childcare and regular work). Childless people will likely naturally move ahead in their careers.
- sukilot 6y agoUnless a social justice movement prevents it on equity/diversity/inclusion grounds, as has been mooted at my company.
- mac01021 6y agoIt depends a lot on the nature of your work. I have a young child and, over the last 4 months, have probably spent less time than ever doing work for my employer. At the same time, just by having the right idea/insight at the appropriate time, I've probably delivered more value to my employer in the last 2 months than ever before. I think and hope that the outcome of all this in terms of my career will be a net positive. But I guess time will tell.
- AsyncAwait 6y ago> TBH depending on circumstances, working five days a week at home also won't work I am aware that this is an extremely unpopular opinion, but in my opinion one shouldn't have kids unless they have the means to dedicate sufficient time and attention to them. That is maybe once you can take 2 days a week off as a parent, or there's UBI or something like that. Would avoid a lot of unhappy marriges, parents and children. Of course, most people seek to 'leave something behind', even at the cost of unhappiness for all involved. I am not sure exactly what a good solution would be, but maybe 40+ hours a week isn't a good deal anymore.
- foolfoolz 6y agolol this is retarded. who was having kids thinking they were going to stay home with them every day? the whole game has changed. anyone who had a well executed plan of taking care of work and kids has to re-think it all now. so many day cares have closed permanently. after school programs canceled. obviously schools closed. the basic building blocks of separating work and kids are all gone. you have no idea what you’re talking about.
- alach11 6y agoParents are spending more time with their kids today than was common in the past. There are huge economic/social upsides to having grandparents or schools cover more time.
- AsyncAwait 6y ago> Parents are spending more time with their kids today than was common in the past. And? How do we know it's enough? Based on the number of unhappy, abusive households, certainly doesn't seem so. My point is that parents should have the economic means to spend more time with their children if required, such as during a pandemic, while facing minimum stress and economic disruption. When parents have to work full time and often barely be able to take care of their children, it leads to stress at home and directly impact the child. Maybe working 40+ hours a week isn't a good deal anymore?
- 6y ago