13 ms·
How did anyone do math in Roman numerals? (2017)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dhosek 6y agoWhen I got my math teaching credential, there were bunches of interesting historical things we learned along the way including Egyptian Fractions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egyptian_fraction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egyptian_fraction Never actually used any of it so most of it has evaporated from my memory along with calculating square roots by hand, but it's nice to know at least enough to be able to look up the information if I want it.
- shagie 6y agoEgyptian fractions have an interesting property that may have been useful back then. Consider the problem "How do you divide five things for eight people?" Simple - cut everything into 1/8 and give each person five. But Egyptian fractions give an even easier way. 5/8ths is 1/2 + 1/8. Divide four wholes into halves - give each person a one half. Take the unit and divide it into eights and give each person one. The answer to this problem is the way you write the number itself. This makes division of the items easier and simpler.
- DNied 6y agoWell, thanks for repeating what Wikipedia says, down to the same example.
- jrootabega 6y agoThat's how I cut up bell peppers into the right sizes. They're either 4 loved or 3, so cutting them into 3 or 4 equal sized piles is a challenge
- msla 6y agoIs it blogspam when it's called syndication? Here's the "original" source of the column, which is on a less... determinedly fashionable website, so it might be friendlier to mobile users and people who dislike fixed headers: https://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/3330/how-did-anyone-do-math-in-roman-numerals/ https://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/3330/how-did-anyon... Also, previously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14818633 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14818633
- gowld 6y agoFixed headers are better than fixed autoplay ad videos.
- forinti 6y agoRoman numerals are very economical. The base with best radix economy (except for e) is 3. But roman numerals are better still. For representing 0-999, you would need 19 base-3 digits, but only 15 roman numerals (plus a symbol for zero).
- monadic2 6y ago...in terms of digits, which is a very odd quality to optimize for.
- gowld 6y ago...in terms of only the worst case numeral. Common numerals like II III VII VIII have worse length, while I IV VI are same, and V X IX are better. And factoring in per-digit cost, Roman numerals up to 999 have 5 distinct digits, 46% more cost per digit than base 3, making it worse than base 3 in almost every case, information theoretically. (You could win some back with a huffman encoding, though)
- monadic2 6y agoAhh, I see the error of my ways.
- forinti 6y agoSuppose there was a basketball game between Athens and Rome (go Athens!) and you have a 3 digit scoreboard. You would need 19 base 3 digits and only 15 roman numerals (plus N for zero) in order to represent every number. In base three, you sometimes have all three digits equal. With roman numerals, you can reuse the same digit in different positions.
- dmurray 6y agoI don't understand this. 999 is less than 3^7, so you can represent any number up to 999 with just seven base-3 digits. Where does the 19 come from?
- Animats 6y agoAdd and subtract on a good abacus (like a Japanese soroban) is quite fast. Multiply and divide are miserable, but in ordinary trade, it's mostly add and subtract with the occasional multiply. With a soroban, a slide rule, and a book of tables, you can do most classical engineering math. Slowly.
- dwheeler 6y agoIn general, with an abacus. Roman numerals for generally used for recording information, not for calculating with them. The article emphasizes how easy it is to add and subtract with Roman numeral notation, but everything else I've read emphasizes the Abacus even for that. After all, most people today calculate with calculators as well, and we have a snazzy Hindu-Arabic system for numbers.
- hencq 6y agoIt's actually somewhat surprising to me that the Romans didn't invent the concept of zero, when they used the abacus for daily calculations. With the benefit of 20:20 hindsight you'd think that the concept of zero would follow quite naturally from the concept of an empty column on the abacus.
- Sharlin 6y agoBut that's the thing about Roman numerals: you don't need a placeholder number to represent empty columns. And for "what is XVI subtracted from XVI" they could just use a word meaning "nothing", such as nihil or nihilum. The need for the concept of zero as we understand it really only arises together with a place-value system.
- crazygringo 6y agoThanks for explaining that clearly. I've always been so baffled by people who claim that some society didn't have a concept for zero, as if "inventing" zero marks some major advance in intelligence. Every culture has a concept of "nothing" which works for zero. The ancient Greeks debated over whether nothing was a number or not, but that's just a semantic splitting of hairs. At some point a symbol for nothing becomes useful so you invent a number-like notation for it. But that's just a matter of convenience. It's not some great conceptual leap.
- dwohnitmok 6y agoI think that for the majority of people throughout history, numbers were inseparable from numerals, i.e. notation for numbers. This would explain why people are far more comfortable with the notion of real numbers (which despite their name are very very strange in a lot of ways) than imaginary and complex numbers. Even their names betray the difference. However, one has a common notation that everyone has learned whereas the other has a more confusing and less well-known notation. Therefore I think ancient arguments over whether 0 is a number (and acceptance thereof) are representative of a greater paradigmatic shift, similar in essence to the arguments over whether the square root of -1 is truly a "number." Viewed that way 0 is the first step in a journey of an understanding of numbers from purely counting discrete entities, to abstract parts of computation. So basically I would posit that it is in fact a great conceptual leap (just as the negative numbers are) that only seems like an obvious fluke of notation when every schoolchild has learned it.
- andrewl 6y agoIn An Introduction to Mathematics (1911) Alfred North Whitehead wrote: By relieving the brain of all unnecessary work, a good notation sets it free to concentrate on more advanced problems, and, in effect, increases the mental power of the race. Before the introduction of the Arabic notation, multiplication was difficult, and the division even of integers called into play the highest mathematical faculties. Probably nothing in the modern world would have more astonished a Greek mathematician than to learn that ... a large proportion of the population of Western Europe could perform the operation of division for the largest numbers. This fact would have seemed to him a sheer impossibility ... Our modern power of easy reckoning with decimal fractions is the almost miraculous result of the gradual discovery of a perfect notation. [...] By the aid of symbolism, we can make transitions in reasoning almost mechanically, by the eye, which otherwise would call into play the higher faculties of the brain. [...] It is a profoundly erroneous truism, repeated by all copy-books and by eminent people when they are making speeches, that we should cultivate the habit of thinking of what we are doing. The precise opposite is the case. Civilisation advances by extending the number of important operations which we can perform without thinking about them. Operations of thought are like cavalry charges in a battle—they are strictly limited in number, they require fresh horses, and must only be made at decisive moments. John Allen Paulos discusses the power of notation in his book Beyond Numeracy: A German merchant of the fifteenth century asked an eminent professor where he should send his son for a good business education. The professor responded that German universities would be sufficient to teach the boy addition and subtraction but he would have to go to Italy to learn multiplication and division. Before you smile indulgently, try multiplying or even just adding the Roman numerals CCLXIV, MDCCCIX, DCL, ANDMLXXXI without first translating them. Numbers may be eternal and invariant, but numerals, the symbols used to represent numbers, are not, and the above anecdote illustrates how easy it is to take for granted the Hindu-Arabic numerals we use today. The history of numeration systems is a long one extending from prehistoric times to the adoption in the Renaissance of our present system. The heroes of the story are the nameless scribes, accountants, priests, and astronomers who discovered the principles of representing numbers systematically.
- bhntr3 6y agoThank you for the quotes. I think this essentially answers (or at least provides a hypothesis for) the question I posted about how the numerical system influenced their math.
- bhntr3 6y agoI feel like the article misses the most interesting question about Roman numerals and Roman (Greek really) math. How did the numerical system influence the math that they developed and used? The Greeks were really into geometry using the compass and straight edge so they actually did a lot of math without really needing numbers at all. They viewed calculation as less worthy of mathematicians and my understanding is that we don't have a lot of evidence for how merchants and engineers did basic calculations since most of the great Greek math texts ignored it. Algorithms and algebra probably existed in some informal way but they weren't really formalized until the Arabs did it with the help of Arabic numerals. So, while you can do some calculations in roman numerals or using an abacus, the interesting question to me is: Did the Greeks (and the Romans) not develop algebra or use Arabic numerals because they weren't that into numbers as compared to geometry? Or was it the other way around? Did the clumsiness of doing calculations in Roman numerals keep them from developing more complex systems of numerical calculation? I'm not an expert on the subject at all but it's always interested me. It makes me think of Bret Victor's Media for Thinking the Unthinkable (http://worrydream.com/MediaForThinkingTheUnthinkable/ http://worrydream.com/MediaForThinkingTheUnthinkable/)
- k__ 6y ago"Did the clumsiness of doing calculations in Roman numerals keep them from developing more complex systems of numerical calculation?" Probably? I mean, look what the world achieved after it left roman numerals behind.
- DNied 6y ago> look what the world achieved after it left roman numerals behind. Look what the world achieved after we started wearing button shirts.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoPerhaps it would be expressed better as Look at what mathematics achieved after it left Roman numerals behind.
- Grustaf 6y agoWhy would it be significantly harder than using some other system of numerals?
- shultays 6y agoThey probably had algorithms for it, but even then it sounds challenging. Addition sounds easy and works mostly like how we do base 10 addition. I imagine they would first go for sub 5 part which is a bit exceptional and had to be manually. And then start grouping letters together like we do and create carries if they reach the next letter. Subtraction sounds harder. It sounds close enough to our base 10 system but borrowing from next digit is much more complicated. Like subtracting D-I (500-1). The answer is CDXCIX but I am not sure how I can go there. And now imagine this with more complex numbers But multiplication and division? in that weird base format? I won't even try Keep in the mind that they don't convert or even think numbers in base 10 system like we do.
- Grustaf 6y agoHow numbers are written down does not necessarily correspond to how you do calculations. Given that 499 was called 499 I’m pretty sure they thought in base 10, so subtracting 1 from 500 would be trivial. Writing it down took a few more symbols but so what?
- shultays 6y agoHmm, I was assuming they didn't have a concept of base 10. If they do have it I wonder how they couldn't make the connection and write stuff in base 10 as well instead of a mixed base with weird rules Then I guess the real challenge is converting numbers around?
- Sharlin 6y agoDid you read the friendly article?
- kccqzy 6y agoWhen I was learning programming, one of the beginner's exercises was to implement addition, subtraction, and multiplication of natural numbers "by hand" (division wasn't covered). There you learn to formalize the grade school algorithms you know by heart into concrete code, a necessary mental process for beginning programmers. At the end of the session, the teacher asked us to try the same with Roman numerals. That was when I knew it's significantly harder.
- dan-robertson 6y agoI am very wary of just about anything published on the history of science or mathematics. Much of it tends to be very low quality full of just-so stories, or at best whiggishness. Unfortunately much of the work by academics on the subject is not much better as the field is full of former mathematicians or scientists with an interest in history rather than lots of historians with an interest in mathematics or science.
- phonon 6y agoRomans essentially used the same binary arithmetic computers use today for multiplication; doubling and halving. http://www.phy6.org/outreach/edu/roman.htm http://www.phy6.org/outreach/edu/roman.htm
- MayeulC 6y agoYeah, this was discussed previously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13636277 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13636277 And division basically works the same. Discussed article is https://thonyc.wordpress.com/2017/02/10/the-widespread-and-persistent-myth-that-it-is-easier-to-multiply-and-divide-with-hindu-arabic-numerals-than-with-roman-ones/ https://thonyc.wordpress.com/2017/02/10/the-widespread-and-p... Nowhere as complex as it's made out to be.
- frandroid 6y ago> The IIII-for-4 notation survives today on the faces of clocks. What? On which clocks?
- paragraft 6y agoWhen I search for "clock with Roman numerals" on Google images I see about 50% use IIII.
- gerikson 6y agoOn this new Omega Constellation, just as a random example https://www.omegawatches.com/watch-omega-constellation-omega-co-axial-master-chronometer-41-mm-13133412106001 https://www.omegawatches.com/watch-omega-constellation-omega...
- oblio 6y agoI was as baffled as you when I first saw IIII instead of IV...
- sn41 6y agoIt is well-known that the place-value system introduced into Europe from India via the Arabs played an invaluable role in modern arithmetic. But, if you read the "Sand Reckoner" by Archimedes, what he lays out are the rudiments of a place-value system. He essentially describes the modern notation, but not rules for addition, subtraction, multiplication and division using this notation. Another tidbit: if you see the recent movie about Shannon "The Bit Keeper", he shows the journalist a mechanical device (he designed?) which can do calculations using Roman numerals.
- jbit 6y agoI'd never heard of this documentary, so I took a look. I assume you meant "The Bit Player"? ( https://www.imdb.com/title/tt5015534/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt5015534/ ). It looks interesting, and it's on Amazon prime video so I'll give it a watch. Thanks!
- sn41 6y agoSorry, you are right.
- reidacdc 6y agoI have read that the uptake of Arabic numerals was actually fairly slow and fraught in Europe, but of course can't put my hands on any references. There's a reddit thread [0] that might be some of what I saw, and my wife does paleography work where she runs across books of accounts that are rendered in Roman numerals, because that's how formal accounts were prepared, even if the actual accounting was done by other means. That same reddit thread has link to an "algorists vs abacists " article [1] which purports to back this up, but I can't confirm because the article is paywalled for me. Edit: Moved/fixed links. [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/12m0vp/how_and_when_did_the_arabic_numbers_took_over_the/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/12m0vp/how_a... [1] https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/2686479.pdf?seq=1 https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/2686479.pdf?seq=1
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- siraben 6y agoContrast Roman numerals with the rod calculus[0] invented in Ancient China. Wikipedia has a list of algorithms for calculating with rods, from the usual arithmetic operations to fractions, division, square and cube roots, Gaussian elimination, and solving polynomials. It would seem that such tasks would be extremely difficult for someone working with the Roman numerals. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rod_calculus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rod_calculus
- zapzupnz 6y agoNot really related to the article per se but I always find it interesting how one may become tempted to say "this alternative to a thing I already know makes so much sense, why don't we always use it?" I felt the same way when encountering Chinese numbers via Japanese. If 二 is two, 十 is ten, 四 is four, and twenty-four is 二十四, that's so clear! Two tens and four! I quickly decided that this number system, though something I'd obviously need to learn and become acquainted with if my Japanese learning were ever to progress, wasn't necessarily as easy as I initially imagined. Yes, there are no places, but numbers in this system are grouped at different boundaries — not every thousand but every ten-thousand. So 六十七億八千三百一万五千四百二十一 breaks up as sixty-seven hundred-thousands eight-thousand-three-hundred-and-one ten-thousands five-thousand-four-hundred and two-tens-and-one — and obviously, that's not quite how we would represent six-(billion/thousand-million) seven-hundred-and-eighty-three-million fifteen-thousand-four-hundred-and-twenty-one, or rather 6,783,015,421. I post this not to discuss the positives or negatives on the Chinese number system compared to the Arabic one or vice-versa. Rather, just how one's imagination can be so easily captured by the apparent simplicity of an alternative to that with which one is familiar, almost to the point of wanting to adopt it altogether. The realisation of where things get tricky for oneself, often not coming until quite a bit later, sometimes doesn't come until later. For myself, I tried using roman numerals for my own math for a long time but stopped when I found division too brain-breaking!
- earthboundkid 6y agoLiving in Japan, I became accustomed to using numbers for up to around 10,000 yen ($100USD) due to interactions at the stores and around town, but when I would hear the price of a car (1,000,000+ yen or 100 myriad yen) or a house, it would just confuse me and not register at all. It’s all just based on your personal experience, I think.
- pjmlp 6y agoI have the same experience with German reversed way of speaking numerals, yet I speak the language fluently, including a good understanding of Swiss German as well. But reversing back the numbers into my Portuguese brain, just doesn't work after a certain size.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoI'd previously read that Fibonacci had helped popularize the hindu-arabic notation in Europe. Wikipedia says "In 1202, he completed the Liber Abaci (Book of Abacus or The Book of Calculation)," which included lessons and examples. Interestingly, he grew up with a merchant father based in Northern Africa and had internalized it.
- jankotek 6y agoMost merchants at Roman times used Greek nimeral, it has much easier algebra comparable to arabic.
- nprateem 6y agoOr feet and inches. I've been watching videos online of people making things with the added challenge of using imperial measurements. 7 29/32 less a margin of 5 3/8 plus a 1/16 offset... Is metric too easy for Americans?
- scott31 6y agoA millenia later, humans will look back and wonder the same about how we did math on decimal system, while binary is far superior. I expect they will even genetically remove one finger from each hand so they can do binary math better with their fingers