5 ms·
Ancient microbial arms race sharpened our immune system but left us vulnerable
- riksucks 6y agoNice read
- dvh 6y ago> The influenza A virus, shown in a stylized scanning electron microscopic image That's a cg render with ultra shallow depth of field like in typical optical microscope. Scanning electron microscopes have depth of field in order of few feet. How can I take rest of the article seriously?
- ceejayoz 6y agoHaving worked at a newspaper, someone in web production was likely asked to search a stock image site for "influenza virus" to illustrate the article, and the caption is copied directly from there. In this case, it looks like you can blame the folks at https://www.sciencesource.com/ https://www.sciencesource.com/. It'll be someone entirely separate from the folks who wrote the text.
- seesawtron 6y agoIt's hard to convince folks to read your article without the introductory image (even if it is irrelevant or out right misleading). Sad but not totally unexpected given our short span to focus on anythin in the ocean of "information". Here you can find the "non stylised" Electron Microscope image from another paper: https://jvi.asm.org/content/93/19/e00644-19/figures-only https://jvi.asm.org/content/93/19/e00644-19/figures-only
- feralimal 6y agoDo you think the stylised imagery has any correlation to the electron microscope image? Which image do you think the stylised one is based on?
- buran77 6y agoThis is how the original [0] is described so they probably just went with that and a bit of editing for effect. [0] https://www.mediabakery.com/MRF0009873-a-stylized-scanning-electron-microscopic-image-of-the-influenza-virus.html https://www.mediabakery.com/MRF0009873-a-stylized-scanning-e...
- seesawtron 6y agoTLDR: The human and primate outer cell membrane is covered by a sugar coating (sialic acids) which protects the cells from foreign microbial invasion. Human cells are coated with one type of sialic acid, N-acetylneuraminic acid (Neu5Ac). But apes and most other mammals also carry a different one, N-glycolylneuraminic acid (Neu5Gc). 2 million years ago a mutation in a certain gene led to overproduction in one type while dicontinuing production of the other type. This abundance of one type of silaic acid sharpened our immune system to specific microbes but since we discarded the other type or silaic acid, left us also vulnerable to certain microbes.
- rpiguy 6y agoThank you
- partyboat1586 6y agoAutoimmune diseases are becoming more common[0] and so we will need to better understand them to maintain the health of the population. If the evolution of these Siglecs could be better understood perhaps that would provide an insight into what causes them to go haywire and target our own tissues. I wonder what environmental factors could be at play given that the rise in autoimmune disease is so recent and sharp. Do we for example ever see autoimmune disease in our animal relatives with similar immune systems, e.g new world monkeys? [0]https://www.technologynetworks.com/immunology/news/amp/autoimmune-conditions-are-on-the-rise-333244 https://www.technologynetworks.com/immunology/news/amp/autoi...
- salawat 6y agoLikely, we're living much longer, and most other things we'd die from before an ill-tuned immune system due to post-sexual maturity thymus atrophy became a problem aren't killing us as often anymore. That at least explains the prevalence of old-age related autoimmune problems. Not so up to date with regards to the younger folks or genetics linked ones though.
- ccffpphh 6y agoThe rise in autoimmune diseases is probably due to higher inflammation levels due to the trend of steadily increasing levels of sugar consumption and seed oils amongst western societies - same reason heart disease continues to be a killer.
- wobbly_bush 6y ago> probably due to higher inflammation levels due to the trend of steadily increasing levels of sugar consumption and seed oils Any resources where I can read up more about this?
- partyboat1586 6y agoI've got one for the seed oils http://raypeat.com/articles/articles/unsaturated-oils.shtml http://raypeat.com/articles/articles/unsaturated-oils.shtml Afaik sugar is not inflammatory though.
- SubiculumCode 6y agoFrom the article: "If a woman with only Neu5Ac sialic acids mated with a man who still expressed Neu5Gc, her immune system may have rejected that man’s sperm or the fetus that developed from it. This fertility barrier might have helped divide Homo populations into different species more than 2 million years ago, the researchers speculated." If it was a single mutation with such a drastic effect on breed ability, how could the mutation have had a chance to spread?
- BoiledCabbage 6y agoMaybe it beat out its ancestors that had 4 variants instead.
- SubiculumCode 6y agoSeems more likely, I suppose. But it would seem hard to maintain a coexisting, yet reproductively incompatible variants.
- labawi 6y agoI'd guess intoleration of Neu5Gc only came in later generations. Article says there were intense adjustments to the immune system after dropping Neu5Gc.
- hirenj 6y agoSialic acids are super interesting, and the biosynthesis of sugars with them on is controlled by a small group of enzymes (20-ish). These enzymes have different tissues and cell type expression profiles, and can catalyse linkage of sialic acids in one of three conformations (linkages on carbons 3,6 and 8). They’re in every cell, and the biosynthesis pathway limits how many different combinations of linkages you can make. So how exactly is it that these pathogens have often such amazing specificity for particular cellular receptors, if we know they bind sialic acids? The answer lies in higher order assemblies called clustered saccharide patches, proposed by Varki a few decades ago. This is when the proteins (or lipids) that the sugars are found on have a particular shape, which enhances the binding by the pathogen (or Siglec). They were theoretical for a long time, but right now we have the tools to be able to dissect this, and our lab has had some success finding evidence for this, and we’re using our capabilities to dissect Siglec specificites too.
- hirenj 6y agoAlso, I find it is massively unsatisfying that SARS-CoV 1/2 don’t use Sialic acids to recognise our cells, when it’s more likely than not to find a virus that binds sialic acids.