15 ms·
Afghan opium growers have switched to solar power
- danbruc 6y agoIs there a real risk of depleting groundwater reservoirs making this non-sustainable?
- LeanderK 6y agoat the end of the article: > So much water is now being used that ground water levels in Helmand are estimated to be falling by 3m a year. The fear is that pretty soon the water will simply run out. "Maybe this boom will not last longer than 10 years," says Orzala Nemat, who runs the Afghanistan Research and Evaluation Unit, the country's biggest think tank.
- posterboy 6y agothis rate factors in growth. it says nothing about the rate once market settles. The fear, i guess, must be that a lot of the water doesn't come back to the aquifier.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mschuster91 6y agoOf course it is, and not just in Afghanistan. The US is at risk (https://www.nationalgeographic.com/news/2014/8/140819-groundwater-california-drought-aquifers-hidden-crisis/ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/news/2014/8/140819-ground...), and even Europe is not safe (https://eos.org/articles/southern-europes-groundwater-use-will-become-unsustainable https://eos.org/articles/southern-europes-groundwater-use-wi...). To make it worse: when groundwater gets depleted, there is a very real risk that the soil on top collapses/compresses, so even if there were enough rain the aquifers would physically be unable to retain the water (https://www.usgs.gov/special-topic/water-science-school/science/groundwater-decline-and-depletion https://www.usgs.gov/special-topic/water-science-school/scie....
- rob74 6y agoThat was my first thought too: at least by using solar power the opium farmers are not polluting the environment and generating CO2, but that benefit is tiny compared to the damage done by depleting the groundwater. And that in turn pales in comparison to the corruption and political instability caused by the drug industry and what that means for the country.
- curiousllama 6y agoSuper cool, but not going to solve the question of renewable energy at scale. Farmers have been doing things like this for generations. American Homesteaders - settlers of the sometimes-rather-arid Great Plains in the US - used windmills for exactly this purpose in the 1800s. We know renewable energy is super useful under specific circumstances (remote/underdeveloped electrical grid, low power, low need for consistency). Another example in the US is emergency phones on the highway - solar panels power those too, and have for a decade or more. The critical question is whether it can overcome those specific circumstances and be useful in developed electrical grids with strong needs for high power and consistency.
- Joe8Bit 6y agoI don't think that's true, for example renewables were responsible for ~50% of the energy generated in the UK in Q1 2020[0], and Germany claims it's ~40%[1] and Sweden claims it's ~55%[2]. These aren't perfect numbers, but they clearly demonstrate renewable energy is deployable at national grid scale. [0]: https://www.edie.net/news/10/Renewables-accounted-for-record-47--of-UK-generation-in-first-quarter-of-2020 https://www.edie.net/news/10/Renewables-accounted-for-record... [1]: https://www.cleanenergywire.org/factsheets/germanys-energy-consumption-and-power-mix-charts https://www.cleanenergywire.org/factsheets/germanys-energy-c... [2]: https://sweden.se/nature/energy-use-in-sweden/ https://sweden.se/nature/energy-use-in-sweden/
- Akronymus 6y agoThe only problem I have with that, is that renewables can mostly only be treated as a bonus. Trying to rely on them for baseline power means you have to put out a LOT more capacity than you'd need with fossils. IMO baseline being nuclear and the rest being mostly renewables (With HEAVY reliance on pumped storage power plants, as a sort of capacitor) is the way to go to minimize emissions.
- acomjean 6y agoWe have a solar array on the house. A lot of the Dc to AC solar inverters used in residential installs use the grid to match the frequency of the AC. The downside is with no grid power the solar system doesn’t work to power the house. There are systems that can but they’re more money.
- setgree 6y ago> For an upfront payment of $5,000 they can buy an array of solar panels and an electric pump. Once it is installed, there are virtually no running costs. I don't know much about solar panels, but I thought they broke down fairly frequently and required specialized tools and knowledge to repair? This article makes it sound like the panels are pretty reliable over time, which would be welcome news to me. 2) Drilling down 100M to groundwater -- does this require industrial equipment? I wonder how these farmers afford it, if so, or perhaps drilling 100M is much easier than I believe?
- zensavona 6y agoWhen I was growing up my family had a goat stud - we had one of these wells drilled and if I remember correctly it cost somewhere in the order of ~$50k AUD
- brohee 6y agoThe wells were already there I understand. Solar is just replacing diesel generators...
- setgree 6y agoFrom the article: > "It's just how opium poppy is farmed now," Mr Brittan tells me. "They drill down 100m (325ft) or so to the ground water, put in an electric pump and wire it up to a few panels and bingo, the water starts flowing." This suggests, to me, that the farmers dug the wells. But maybe they are a relic of soviet times? Point is, there is more to the story here w.r.t. existing capital, I think.
- dmurray 6y agoTFA says there is way more area being cultivated and more farmers in the existing area, which must also imply there are plenty more wells being drilled.
- kitten_mittens_ 6y agoMy parents’ exurb in Idaho features houses with wells down 100 meters or more. It costs about $10K USD to drill a well these days.
- EricE 6y ago"...water is effectively free..." yeah, until they deplete the groundwater. But until then it's good times! They should talk to farmers or more importantly, residents in central CA about how much fun it is to run out of groundwater. Good luck.
- nn3 6y agoIt's discussed at the end of the article. Water level is dropping at ~3m/year. One NGO estimates the boom will only last ~10 years before causing massive problems for everyone living there (not just the farmers). Ironically solar is the opposite of sustainable here. Diesel power would at least be more self limiting.
- kolbe 6y agoHumanity at its finest: depleting a potentially valuable resource forever so you can make more of a drug that ruins hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of lives a year.
- LockAndLol 6y agoInstead of demonizing them, think a little, inform yourself and try to understand why they are doing. Afghanistan was at the center of multiple proxy wars between America and Russia, all because of America feeling threatened by communism. The US then helped fundamentalists get into leader positions which further threw the country into disarray. Then to top it all off they started another beautiful war to look for Bin Laden. I haven't looked into it in a while, but maybe the US still isn't out of there because of a lacking exit strategy. Imagine living in a country that has continuously been in the crosshairs of foreign fundamentalist, political and capitalist interests for the better part of half a century. Do you really think they know or even care about the effects of their actions? Do you vote caring about Afghanistan? Are you outraged when another cultural site is destroyed by foreign or local terrorism? We have the luxury of lying back in a comfy bed with a roof above our heads, some form of stable income and not worrying that tomorrow a market square close by will be rubble. Our women can go to schools (and so can we) and we aren't at the mercy of crazy people who want to violently, actively overthrow our government.
- brownbat 6y agoReminds me of this Outside/In episode about (possibly) the earliest adopters of solar in the US: http://outsideinradio.org/shows/2018/1/4/stoner-panels http://outsideinradio.org/shows/2018/1/4/stoner-panels
- hosh 6y agoI like solar and all, but I will say that just looking at the farming practices of these growers, this transformation will likely be shortlived (I am thinking in terms of generations, not in terms of seasons). Yes, the solar allows people to rapidly deploy solar to use as pumps, but those pumps are also depleting the aquifer. They are probably not putting anything back into the aquifer with practices such as rainwater harvesting (earthworks and improving infiltration, rather than rain barrels). In metro Phoenix, AZ (here in the States) we have been seeing something similar as the deep water have been drying up. Arizona is at the bottom of the water rights (from the Colorado river), and people’s solutions have been to install an electric pump to get at the water. With so many people draining off of the aquifer, people who have been depending on the water have been having difficulty with getting consistent water. Many of them are finding that they have to try to sell the property. What they have not been doing are things like, capturing the rain that does come to the region to irrigate crops or landscape; use of greywater; use of a composting toilet (which cleans waste with the carbon cycle rather than the hydrologic cycle), and otherwise conserve drinking and cooking water. Tuscon, AZ and Flagstaff, AZ have residents and public policies in place that does a much better job with this than Phoenix. With cheap solar added to the mix, what will happen is that it hastens the aquifer depletion. So those poppy farmers are not thinking with whole systems or thinking in the long term. On the other hand, if they were thinking in the long term, they probably would not be growing poppy as a cash crop in the first place. Perhaps small batches to make high quality anesthesia for local use, as part of of a more diverse crop. You don’t kill off your aquifer, and you don’t make something that will kill off your customers. You’d have nothing left. My conclusion is that that the market forces, while transformative, is also very limited and short-sighted, and there are better ways for humans to interact with each other.
- colinmhayes 6y agoCan't agree that the poppy farmers aren't thinking long term. Abusing the aquifer is the nash equilibrium. As soon as one person starts pumping everyone else has to too, because the water will be gone soon either way. This is a collaboration failure more than some sort of ignoring the long term for the short term.
- 6y ago
- DC-3 6y agoInteresting story, but the article reads like it was written to be used as an exercise for teaching English to 15 year olds.
- catsdanxe 6y agoWe need cia investment and us military troops to protect the fields.
- baybal2 6y agoIt can work the other way too: https://kmarp.com/home https://kmarp.com/home Solar powered aquifer recharge stations were close contenders for the project.
- aaron695 6y agoWow, that's a really interesting site. Aquifer recharge is an interesting topic that one doesn't hear much about. I guess Domesday dopamine chasers hate missing their rush.
- baybal2 6y agoThe company I once contracted for once bided for the project. When bids started to close on $100k, solar panels solidly lost to mains powered pumping stations, and the company bailed out of the tender. This is the problem with infrastructure tenders all around the world, even immediate operations cost is rarely considered to count against lowest upfront payment.
- phjesusthatguy3 6y ago*Some Afghan opium growers have switched to solar power. This is the free market in full effect. The market is actually larger than what you can fulfill yourself, why wouldn't you produce as much as possible?
- orbital-decay 6y agoWhile the opium growers' perspective is an interesting one, the conclusion is misleading. >The story of the revolution in Afghan heroin production shows us just how transformative solar power can be. Don't imagine this is some kind of benign "green" technology. Solar is getting so cheap that it is capable of changing the way we do things in fundamental ways and with consequences that can affect the entire world. It's not exactly solar that is transformative here, but the access to any electricity at all. It's not like they can use a normal power grid for heroin production, even if they had one there. Photovoltaic panels are more convenient for providing very small scale off-grid power than most other tech like thermal solar or diesel generators, thanks to being heavily subsidized by other people - that would be the more accurate conclusion.
- fennecfoxen 6y agoGrow ops in the US are also prone to use solar power for their grow lights, so that the Feds don’t hunt them down based on the power bill. This isn’t an endorsement of solar more generally, either.
- dharma1 6y agoIt sounds like a mess to be honest. More production of heroin for 10 years, then 1.5 million refugees because there is no ground water anymore
- toomuchtodo 6y agoYou’re going to get the refugees anyway due to government and public health failures [1] in the area (see: Afghanistan fertility rates, the level of female empowerment and education compared to elsewhere, and healthcare infrastructure). If you’re anti heroin production, get in there and pump that water faster than the farmers to deprive them of it. [1] https://eurasianet.org/afghanistan-population-boom-threatens-stabilization-chances https://eurasianet.org/afghanistan-population-boom-threatens...
- ornornor 6y agoI heard they’re being switched to meth because the cartels don’t buy poppies as much anymore and pay partly in amphetamine pills.
- learnstats2 6y agoSolar is presumably attractive to Afghan opium growers also because it's decentralised, not directly depending directly on another party to provide power.
- WrongThinkerNo5 6y agoDon't all plants grown with solar power?