4 ms·
> it might have taken until 2013 for someone to measure its g force To be fair, measuring this sort of thing was pretty hard in the past, when cheap miniaturiz
by toyg 6y ago
> it might have taken until 2013 for someone to measure its g force
To be fair, measuring this sort of thing was pretty hard in the past, when cheap miniaturized sensors and memory didn't exist.
I expect we will see more and more activities being re-evaluated now that tech is easily wearable.
- amelius 6y agoYou could do it with a weight on a spring, and a little pen attached to the weight.
- ChrisLomont 6y agoThat won’t handle the number of degrees of freedom a bobsled uses.
- EthanHeilman 6y agoJust thinking this through, wouldn't three weights on springs get you all the data? Or some sort of membrane containing a liquid than ruptures when a particular amount of force is felt in any direction?
- amelius 6y agoThe problem with three axes is that the registration of the largest deviation by the pen happens for the axes independently.
- VLM 6y agoYet its still valid data in that its trivial to calculate the theoretical maximum peak accel based on the possibly independent peak accels of the individual axes. If in theory the max peak acceleration could never exceed 2 G then there's no point in continuing the study. If the theoretical max peak accel could be 57 G then there's a point in continuing the study. The whole problem is irrelevant anyway. The problem isn't one individual sled journey, the problem is thousands of competitors taking thousands of rides over many years, so "tens of millions". They are competitive with each other having small std deviations in performance so each sled ride is roughly the same. Tiny reliable cameras have been a thing for a century as have mechanical timers. Simply bolt a half pound telemetry package to every sled that snaps a single random point of data via camera or some weird linkage to clutches and springs. Then run a data analysis and make statistical predictions. You wouldn't even need a 1960s mainframe to run the statistical analysis. This would have been something near BAU for mid-century aeronautical engineers, for example. I'm sure something similar was implemented during the test program for the F-86 or maybe P-51.
- ChrisLomont 6y agoPeak is not enough - you need to know time impulse. A 10G accel over 1 sec has much different effect than a 10G over a nanosecond. And the measuring devices must also handle this nuance. A liquid has inertia, so won't register quick impulses, and the things it measures might not be relevant to what bio systems are interested in.
- amelius 6y agoTrue. How about suspending a little metal bullet in a gel, chosen such that the bullet will break through the gel if the G-force is more than a certain threshold. This will give a good indication if the forces are within an acceptable range.
- m463 6y agoReminds me of shockwatch for packages.
- ChrisLomont 6y agoThis kid of stuff is incredibly hard to use for accurate results. Gels (and all materials) are not perfect in any sense, and you'd need significant effort modeling any material you used - viscosity under all sorts of motions (since nothing is nicely linear), the gel itself is sloshing, compressing, has different lag times... It's possible in theory, but in practice would not be useful. Look at what planes (Air Force has lots of R&D) did for the past century to see the state of the art at each point and the methods used.
- tzs 6y agoCould you do it photographically? If you can photograph the head movements at a high enough frame rate, you should be able to calculate the acceleration that produced those movements.
- simonh 6y agoIt's about pressure and load, not movement. Also the sleds vibrate and shake enormously. Any method of measuring this has to be extremely precise, and also extremely responsive to changes over extremely short time frames to capture every vibration and shake in many different axes of freedom simultaneously. Before modern motion sensors I just don't think there was any way to do it. Even if motion was enough, which I'm sure it isn't, film only captures a flat image from a fixed point, or the camera is moving itself so you have to compensate for that. Springs and wires suggested by others have way too much hysteresis to cope with the extremely rapid vibrations and changes in orientation.
- yk 6y agoWhen you are looking for something like 80g (as is the maximum of the graph), then the head would move something like 4 cm between two frames, which suggests to me, that you probably want to have a lot more than 100 fps, since you want to get a good handle on the highest accelerations. On the other end of the scale, the positional error from the camera sensor is something like width of frame / horizontal resolution which should give you something in the mm range, and it seems possible to get head tracking in the same order of resolution, which should limit your acceleration measurement for low acceleration. Overall, probably doable but you are replacing a 30c accelerometer with a multi year research project.