8 ms·
> If I want to avoid this sort of thing, I'm thinking / hoping it's sufficient to simply avoid headphones that require an app. Or just get one with a good old
by josteink 6y ago
> If I want to avoid this sort of thing, I'm thinking / hoping it's sufficient to simply avoid headphones that require an app.
Or just get one with a good old 3.5mm jack.
Beyer Dynamic, AKG and Shure have several options much cheaper than these Bose or Sony headsets which still give you at least 10x the audio-performance.
For headsets, if you care about usability, portability, longevity and performance, wired is still the no-brainer choice.
- p1esk 6y agoGood luck with this if you want state of the art in noise canceling
- josteink 6y agoI’ve had the best heat headphones Bose has to offer in the Quiet Comfort series and to me this “state of the art noise cancellation” sounds like artefact- and distortion-inducing noise. I’ve returned them and replaced them with much better, naturally damping, closed head-phones. And the audio is so much better, at a fraction of the cost. Noise cancellation in the hifi-space is just snake oil, and I’m not having it.
- andrewflnr 6y agoDoes... does anyone actually think noise-cancelling is for increasing audio quality? I always thought it was just for handling obnoxiously noisy environments, like airplanes, screaming children, etc.
- mandelbrotwurst 6y agoNo one who's thinking through how it works, which is by picking up the ambient noise and then modifying the output to include the inverse on top of whatever you're listening to.
- _delirium 6y agoAside, but noise cancelling (at least what's currently on the market) doesn't really do much for screaming children. It only handles relatively constant noise well, ideally low/mid-frequency constant noise. Great at silencing stuff like airplane engines, wind, HVAC hum, freeway rumble, etc. But not very effective for people talking, crying babies, car horns, ambulance sirens, slamming doors, etc.
- andrewflnr 6y agoInteresting. I thought there was at least good noise cancelling for shooting/hunting.
- josteink 6y agoThat’s an entirely different kind of noise cancellation than you find in most “regular” headsets. It just blocks/reverses sudden sharp, loud noises (shots). It will let normal speech and such (and pretty much everything else) right through.
- josteink 6y ago> Does... does anyone actually think noise-cancelling is for increasing audio quality? No, but noise cancelling headsets are often sold as premium headsets, with the obvious implication that they are to have high sound-quality. And quite often, they don’t.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- barrkel 6y agoNoise cancelling works quite well on planes. It's not for hi-fi. Livable-fi in combination with noise cancellation is a bonus. The headphones are for noise cancellation, not hi-fi. (These cans are usually not too bad with noise cancellation turned off. But when you turn it on, it's because noise cancellation is what you want.)
- taneq 6y agoI have a pair of Bose QC20s which are (or were, when I bought them) state of the art for noise canceling, and have a 3.5mm headphone jack. No app required and they even work as normal wired headphones if the battery goes flat.
- paultopia 6y agoThis is a good point. Last I looked at the reviews, those were still state of the art for noise cancelling, if only because wired in-ears also have nice sound isolation. I should dust mine off...
- vladvasiliu 6y agoSame with the Sony WH1000 xm3. The only thing missing when working wired is the microphone, but I basically never use that anyway. The problem with the wire, at least the provided one, is that it's pretty stiff so it picks up a lot of noise and the plug doesn't lock to the headphone side so I'm not sure how well it would hold during prolonged usage. But the plug is standard, so at least the cable can be changed easily.
- flukus 6y agoHave there been large advances in noise cancelling since 3.5mm jacks started to disappear?
- kkapelon 6y agoMaybe not. But if you want to buy headphones today with NC, most of them will be wireless.
- mandelbrotwurst 6y agoI use both wired and wireless. Each has its own tradeoffs.
- bosie 6y agousability and portability are what makes BT headphones great. Which BD or Shure gives me 10x the audio-performance while still being able to be used without cables (optionally)?
- josteink 6y agoBy portability I mean it can be used anywhere, with any equipment. There’s still lots of places you won’t find Bluetooth, but there’s very few places you won’t find a connector for a 3.5mm jack.
- Florin_Andrei 6y ago> Beyer Dynamic, AKG and Shure have several options much cheaper than these Bose or Sony headsets which still give you at least 10x the audio-performance. It's complicated. The lowest level opinion is "Bose and Beats are awesome, soooo much bass!!!" That's the typical consumer. The level above that is what you said. That's sometimes called mid-fi. At least these things don't have major flaws anymore. The next level is companies and products specifically focused on high performance - Stax, Audeze, Sennheiser, Etymotic, etc and their best models. That's the "audiophile" level (and here truth is mixed with a lot of bullshit also - stay away from head-fi.org, it's a cesspool of pseudoscience). And the level above that is when you realize imperfections in headphones can be corrected via DSPs, for the most part. I have the Sony noise cancelling flagship model. By default, it's deeply flawed. It's tuned to the taste of the average consumer at Walmart ("moar basssss!!!"). But apply the oratory1990 corrections (from Reddit) and they sound like some nearly-flawless high end devices. The corrections are based on precise lab measurements of the headphones, and basically revert some of their flaws via digital processing. The future is DSP.
- rorykoehler 6y agoThanks for the tip. I also have the Sonys. Anyone who thinks they sound great needs a hearing test. Not a patch on my 2 favourites, Sennheiser HD-25 (or any €100+ Sennheiser for that matter) and Beyer Dynamic DT-990 Pro (great home listening and mixing headphone). Even after tuning the Sonys to correct their flaws they still sound tiring. Will check out the settings you recommend.
- Florin_Andrei 6y agoThe DT-990 are not bad. The treble is a little overemphasized. The easy bass is also a bit emphasized, but then they give up on the deep bass (start dropping below 50 Hz). Still good headphones, two classes above the uncorrected Sony NC. With proper corrections based on objective measurements, any headphones can sound neutral and balanced.
- rorykoehler 6y ago