8 ms·
Dam built by robots? Japan's Obayashi tests it out
- sriku 6y ago> "By transferring expert techniques to machines, we're able to analyze what was once implicit knowledge," said Akira Naito, head of Obayashi's dam technology unit. That's intriguing and reminded me of the following Perlis quote - > The only constructive theory connecting neuroscience and psychology will arise from the study of software.
- knolax 6y ago> The only constructive theory connecting neuroscience and psychology will arise from the study of software. Anyone who actually believes this has a poor understanding of computers, humans, or both.
- garmaine 6y agoI think you’ve misunderstood what “constructive" means in this context.
- jacobush 6y agoYeah, but it also brings me to that you don't have to agree with Perlis's quote. But IMHO we know too little at this point in time to say it's an unreasonable idea. We know far more about programs than about biology, but the gap between software and neuroscience is huge and we probably don't know as much about software as we think we do, either.
- MayeulC 6y agoRegarding the first quote: in any case, I think it's probably a good idea to encode this implicit knowledge somewhere. A bit like code is the best kind of specification. Code can be studied and improved gradually. Since it guarantees repeatable results, you can try tweaking parameters and measuring the outcome, to achieve even better result. It's a bit like taking the highest-skilled workers, merging their knowledge, and extending their lifespan indefinitely so that they can continuously improve. The only disadvantage I can see is that you're skewing the playing field in favor of those who have access to the most data, and by reducing the workforce size, make it difficult for someone else to obtain the same data. At the end, a skilled worker can leave a company and make its own, or join a rival one. An algorithm can't do that, further entrenching a select few companies'positions, thus locking knowledge away from humankind. Companies probably contribute to the loss of information over time (see lost knowledge: Roman cement, massive bronze castings, etc), as free-flowing information is against their interests, in most cases.
- jacobush 6y ago> Companies probably contribute to the loss of information over time I agree with what else you said, but I see much of the opposite process in corporations actually. I have worked in a couple of very large corporations and what I have seen is less of information hiding (and "not invented here") and more of cooperation through partnerships, open source software and standardisation of processes.
- MayeulC 6y agoOf course, it isn't all bad or good, and I was just writing down my train of thought. Corporations also contribute to maintaining that information: by grouping together individuals skilled in the same domain, they can foster the exchange of ideas, and by training new employees, they perpetuate those skills. Patents are another mechanism that forces them to contribute back to society. Once you start training algorithms instead of people, though, you attach that knowledge to the company, and it may not leave. In my experience, open source software and standards are the exception rather than the norm.
- jacobush 6y agoFair point, I didn't think that deeply about trade secrets. I guess it could be even more hidden with various forms of machine learning, even the engineers themselves possibly couldn't explain how or why it worked when they left the building.
- czrnb 6y agoWhile I mostly agree with your comment, I would like to point out that a company may have a lifespan much greater than that of a skilled worksman (which may or may not have transferred his "specific" knowledge to any co-worker and/or apprentice). A company, simply because of the stream of new people that will have to be trained, need to have that knowledge passed down at some point, and having it laid down in writing or any non perishable medium is the safest way to do so. I'd like to add a little context around the quote [0], because I do think it makes another issue very apparent: > Building a dam requires knowledge and skill developed through years of experience. Obayashi's automated system is expected to be a game-changer in dam construction, as well as in other applications. > "By transferring expert techniques to machines, we're able to analyze what was once implicit knowledge," said Akira Naito, head of Obayashi's dam technology unit. > Every process for constructing the 334-meter-wide dam will involve some form of automation. That includes the initial work of establishing the foundation, and pouring concrete to form the body. Implicit knowledge here refers to dam builders' workmanship and experience. It is an empirically constructed knowledge which is "stored" in the worksman's mind as instincts, concepts, know-how... While these may "be analyzed" and re-used for automation purposes, I have very strong doubts whether such implicit knowledge may even be truly understood and translated (be it in code or any other media) if there is such a precise goal. Specifically because the knowledge is implicit and applies situationally, one may never be able to grasp it all without some kind of very complex knowledge transfer set-up that could cover a broad range of situations, allowing all of the patterns to emerge and be identified. Enough knowledge may be gathered that a company could successfully apply it to dam building by machines. But as automation replaces dam builders, chances are that the portion of the extracted knowledge which is not necessary to the company will join the expertise which did not transfer from the workmans' minds to the company to lay forever in the land of lost knowledge (...until it is found again through experience). The rest will most likely be preserved "forever" through more or less obscure patents and "hard", explicit knowledge in the company's hands. [0] https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Engineering-Construction/Dam-built-by-robots-Japan-s-Obayashi-tests-it-out https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/Engineering-Construction/Da...
- techie128 6y agoWhile technologically cool, I think Japan could benefit from young immigrants from different parts of the world to solve their human capital problem. This benefits everybody.
- fearingreprisal 6y agoI absolutely disagree. The robots pose none of the challenges that immigrants from different parts of the world bring with them, while fulfilling the same labour force requirement. In my opinion, the robots are a better investment all over.
- totetsu 6y agoI'm sure robots can also be made to keep up the life of society and culture on the weekend too.
- baybal2 6y agoWhy do you disagree? What are the "challenges" you suggest?
- fearingreprisal 6y agoI support Japan's right to keep their distinctly Japanese culture and way of life intact indefinitely. I live in one of the more multicultural cities in the Western world. I have seen little evidence to suggest that even second and third generation immigrants assimilate into the host culture to a more than superficial degree. I have seen plenty of evidence to the contrary, which I will not list here due to the risk of this being mistaken as malice on my behalf. I harbour no malice towards other ethnicities or nationalities. The recent wave of immigration, including a large influx of refugees from the Middle East and North Africa, to Western Europe has demonstrated many of the challenges I speak of. There have been numerous interviews, news features and articles which have demonstrated that the new immigrants are largely ambivalent, often outright hostile towards the Western culture and way of life. An objective look at America's present situation without any prejudice could very well prompt an outsider to take the view that the experiment of multiculturalism in the West is not working, or at least not working well. The American left and right wing ostensibly seem to agree on this fact, based upon their media. Continuing the very generous American example, African-Americans have largely not assimilated into the wider American culture since their emancipation. From my outsider perspective, it appears that they constitute their own distinct culture. Their own media portrays them as suspicious, if not again outright hostile, or at best ambivalent towards the wider White American society. If Japan were to look objectively on at the Western world undergoing these challenges, why would they come to the conclusion that they would benefit from multiculturalism, when the abundance of evidence points to the contrary? Would they presume to think that they could make this experiment work, when it hasn't worked demonstrably well anywhere else?
- ipiz0618 6y agoTo me, Japan is the country with the most creative use of "AI". Maybe there is something to do with their perfectionism. Rather than focusing on only software, they worked on transferring precise designs to hardware. A while ago there was an article on HN on how Sony automated most of PS4's manufacturing and made the production extremely efficient. It's almost like the continuation of Japanese craftsmanship in robot form. It's beautiful and really illustrates how the Japanese tradition is transferred to modern machinery.
- harpratap 6y agoThere are drawbacks too, usually such solutions are very Japan centric and hard to port to other countries, leading to Galapagos syndrome. One example is bullet trains - my most favorite form of transportation but sadly only few countries can adopt it with success similar to Japan. Second is Osaifu-Ketai - I think this the best NFC based payment system in the world, extremely fast and almost no learning curve. But it took way too long to modernize it and put it inside smartphones. Is very inflexible. Licensing is too expensive so won't be ever globally opted, so we ended up with much inferior QR codes and slow NFC systems.
- aikinai 6y agoFor your second point, I think you meant FeliCa. Osaifu-keitai is the name of the integration with phones, but FeliCa is the name of the far superior NFC standard that never took off outside Japan.
- harpratap 6y agofelica did see usage as university cards but when I say "Osaifu Ketai" I mean the entire business model surrounding it too. Only Hong Kong successfully implemented it.
- aikinai 6y agoOh, if you mean the model and not the technology, Apple Pay has already accomplished far more than osaifu-keitai could ever hope to.
- toss1 6y ago>>"The companies also hope that new technology could dispel negative stereotypes of the industry among younger generations, encouraging more people to work in construction." Excellent - integrate high technology and make it cool - all kinds of nice second-order effects
- 24gttghh 6y agoWhere exactly is this dam under construction? "Mie Prefecture" is pretty big, and there are a lot of rivers...
- rasz 6y ago"The construction site in Japan where Obayashi is building a dam almost exclusively with automated equipment" under a photo with at least 10 people.
- ellendares 6y agoSky Rent a Car helps to add attention and glamour to the magical moment with our wedding rental cars. We have almost all brands of exotic cars like BMW, Audi, Rolls Royce for wedding and reception functions. We also aid decorating the wedding cars as per your desire. Our wedding car rental packages are too reasonable and you can save a bundle. We are unmatched in selection of wedding cars both in their range and price. Reach us to make your day wonderful. https://skyrentacar.in/rental-cars/ https://skyrentacar.in/rental-cars/