6 ms·
For reference from the UAV industry. The very best lithium ion batteries are about 250Wh/kg but limited in the instantaneous amperage they can put out. High amp
by walrus01 6y ago
For reference from the UAV industry. The very best lithium ion batteries are about 250Wh/kg but limited in the instantaneous amperage they can put out. High amperage capable batteries are more like 170Wh/kg.
UAV compressed hydrogen tank systems with fuel cells in the 800-1600W range, the full system with tank, fuel cell and a small buffer battery works out to between 800-1200Wh/kg depending on size. Some guys in south Korea recently hovered a large hexacopter for 10.5 hours. The systems I've seen are typically configured for an output voltage equivalent to the float voltage of a 12S lipo.
Diesel fuel, jet a, avgas and other fuels are a whole magnitude more dense in Wh/kg stored than the above-mentioned hydrogen system.
- dthakur 6y agoCould you kindly provide a link for the hovering hexacopter please? Thanks.
- culturestate 6y agoI assume they're referring to https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_U_dHZZ3vxQ&feature=emb_title https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_U_dHZZ3vxQ&feature=emb_titl...
- walrus01 6y agoThat one and also Doosan. https://www.youtube.com/c/DoosanMobilityInnovation https://www.youtube.com/c/DoosanMobilityInnovation There is more than one south Korean company working on combined packages of lightweight hydrogen tanks and fuel cell power systems. And several American companies.
- Retric 6y agoHydrogen becomes significantly more efficient as you scale the tank. Don’t forget many rockets use Hydrogen over Jet-A and they really care about weight.
- mhandley 6y agoRockets use liquid hydrogen, which is a pain to work with, but not too bad if you can fuel up and launch relatively quickly before too much boils off. The real reason rockets use hydrogen is because Hydrogen and Oxygen gives the highest specific impulse of any chemical rocket. You really don't care about specific impulse in a jet aircraft, and you really don't want the fuel boiling off before the end of your 12-hour flight. Also, if you're thinking of pressurized gaseous hydrogen instead of liquid hydrogen, then the tanks get really heavy because high pressure tanks don't scale well (unlike low pressure liquid tanks which do). Hoop stress is proportional to diameter, which means tank wall thickness needs to grow with diameter too. https://www.engineersedge.com/material_science/hoop-stress.htm https://www.engineersedge.com/material_science/hoop-stress.h...
- Retric 6y agoBoiling off is a function of surface area which means it scales really well with volume. Rockets have issues because they don’t want to bleed off hydrogen on a launch pad or use significant insulation, but aircraft can just feet that to the APU or engines in flight. You will want to drain hydrogen for maintenance etc, but that’s not a significant issue.
- sandworm101 6y agoSome rockets, and generally on lower-thrust high efficiency upper stages. Hydrogen has a low energy density in terms of volume. It requires larger tanks and so is rarely used to get off the pad.
- Symmetry 6y agoThe rockets that use it in the first stage all get most of their initial thrust from solid strap on boosters too.
- philipkglass 6y agoThe Delta IV heavy uses hydrogen/oxygen exclusively, without any solid boosters: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta_IV_Heavy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta_IV_Heavy It is a very expensive vehicle though.
- 5ersi 6y agoActually liquid H2 has energy density of 39 kWh/kg, where common CH fuels are around 12-13 kWh/kg. So about 3x more energy per kg then conventional fuels.
- jcranmer 6y agoNote that H₂ boils around 20-30K (depending on pressure). Once you take into account the weight of the insulated tanks, liquid H₂ is going to have much worse energy density.
- gsnedders 6y agoLiquid storage I believe typically gets up to about 20wt%, so you're talking around 7.8kWh/kg. Compressed storage is around 6–10wt%, so up to 3.9kWh/kg.
- cheerlessbog 6y agoThat's without the weight of the storage and potentially fuel cell surely.
- formerly_proven 6y agoYes, but that's without the container, which is very heavy for the hydrogen, while a plastic bag is already good enough for fossil fuels.
- elmo2you 6y agoAside from the (obvious) energy density downside of hydrogen as a fuel, there is another substantial problem. Hydrogen is challenging/expensive to store/contain. Kind of the direct result of it being the smallest atom we have. Even more important: when it reacts uncontrolled, in particular with oxygen, it does so at a truly frightening speed. Once it goes, good luck doing anything about it. The fact that this is almost never mentioned in every yet-another-hydrogen-is-going-to-be-our-future-next-year piece, always makes me wonder if that's the result of not-so-honest entrepreneurs trying to lure investors, or that none of these jokers ever talked to any experienced chemist. This is no attempt to spread FUD regarding hydrogen. It sincerely worries (if not frightens) me, how so many initiatives appear to completely ignore that any volume of hydrogen that is sufficient to power something that can transport humans or cargo, is pretty much inherently a catastrophic disaster in the making. That is, if such a system would ever fail in a way that makes the stored hydrogen react uncontrolled. Every widely utilized technology is bound to fails, even if only in edge cases, and of course: extra safety margins/features can be added to limit the effects of failures. But with hydrogen that might be a hell of a lot more expensive and/or difficult than most would realize. So, the way I see this is that we either end up very cost ineffective solutions, or ones that will be far more dangerous than many would ever realize. That is, until something goes terribly wrong, and everyone realizes they have been ignorant and maybe even intentionally fooled by people trying to make money. Reminds me a bit of self-driving cars.
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoIf your fuel tank catches on fire you have similar problems, so I don't think these problems with hydrogen are insurmountable.
- dehrmann 6y agoIf you had a hydrogen tank in a plane, would you be better off using it as a fuel in a jet engine or using it to power motors with a fuel cell?
- jonsen 6y ago“Hydrogen needs a bit more work” for use in gas turbines, but it is something Rolls-Royce is examining, along with electric.
- benhurmarcel 6y agoBoth are being researched. The answer to that isn’t clear-cut.
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoWhat about liquid hydrogen, which is much denser than compressed one? Not an option for UAV?
- rstuart4133 6y ago> UAV compressed hydrogen tank systems with fuel cells in the 800-1600W range They didn't say how they would be using the hydrogen. I haven't been able to find it again, I did read about an article about a long endurance (days), high flying plane. It was powered by hydrogen. It burnt it. As I recall it was in an ICE, but at 50% efficiency using it as jet engine fuel isn't such a bad idea. It has an energy density of 120 MJ/kg, 3 times as much as normal fuels so it makes sense either way, if you can contain it. In other news, the country where I live (Australia, 6th largest exporter in 2019) is contemplating exporting hydrogen. Why? Because if renewable power continues on its current price trend it will be cheaper to produce hydrogen than it is to mine the natural gas we currently export. Again, I presume no fancy technology - it will be burnt just like the natural gas is.