10 ms·
“Irregardless” is part of a penumbra of unorthodox English words
- heinrich5991 6y agohttps://archive.is/0knTf https://archive.is/0knTf
- yakshaving_jgt 6y agoAs the article points out, irregardless is pretty uncommon. I'll be much more horrified when Merriam-Webster begins defining terrorism the way that the Americans often use it in common discourse, i.e., the attacker's acts were terrifying and the victims and community were terrorised, therefore he's a terrorist.
- gsk22 6y agoMaybe I'm just an ignorant American, but what is the issue with that definition? Lack of an explicit political goal?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- keiferski 6y agoIt’s a problem because it bases the definition on the feelings of the recipients and not on the actions of the perpetrators.
- ukj 6y agoBoth terrorists and freedom fighters act the same way. In the battlefield of narratives perspective matters.
- keiferski 6y agoSure, but I think this meme is actually not so clearly true in practice. Freedom fighters may engage in terrorist acts (see Algeria for example) but that doesn’t seem like a quality of “fighting for freedom”, merely a correlative practice.
- ukj 6y agoOK, but that's how language is broken. You can't define 'terrorism' in such a way so as to include all terrorists, and exclude all non-terrorists. This is the essentialist dream.
- keiferski 6y agoI’m not a linguist, but the main issue here seems to be the desire to make adjectives into nouns, as it’s easier for humans to conceptually understand. Instead of X is [noun], we could say X is Person who engaged in X [acts.]
- ukj 6y agoAnd you'll get no further than 'A terrorist is a person who engages in terrorism'. And then the debate is still exactly where we left off. Was that person engaging in X, or was he engaging in Y? X = Terrorism, Y = Freedom fighting The main issue is that your attitude towards the activity/person is encoded in the language you are using to describe it.
- keiferski 6y agoI don’t think this is accurate or a charitable interpretation of what I said. I am making a distinction between actions and nouns. I hold that it is not controversial to say certain actions are considered terroristic actions and certain actions are considered freedom fighting actions. Often, the same people engage in both, and combined with our tendency to want to assign people in noun classes (He is an X), this results in the perceived equivalence you are speaking about.
- 082349872349872 6y agoIsn't it an irregular conjugation? I am a freedom fighter. You are conducting asymmetric warfare. They are terrorists. By the author of I, Claudius: Truth-loving Persians do not dwell upon The trivial skirmish fought near Marathon. As for the Greek theatrical tradition Which represents that summer's expedition Not as a mere reconnaisance in force By three brigades of foot and one of horse (Their left flank covered by some obsolete Light craft detached from the main Persian fleet) But as a grandiose, ill-starred attempt To conquer Greece - they treat it with contempt; And only incidentally refute Major Greek claims, by stressing what repute The Persian monarch and the Persian nation Won by this salutary demonstration: Despite a strong defence and adverse weather All arms combined magnificently together.
- JohnStrangeII 6y agoNo, not according to a reasonable definition of terrorism. It's terrorism if a group is intentionally attacking civilians (non-combatants) for political goals. Freedom fighters may or may not be terrorists, depending on whether they intentionally attack civilians or only hit military targets. What it means to intentionally attack someone is regulated by the Doctrine of Double Effect, is based on distinguishing between side effects and intentional goals of an action. It's a tricky topic and there is leeway for interpretation, but It's not as if a definition in this area could or should never lead to controversies. Unfortunately, this definition is rarely used, because it doesn't match the political goals of states. First, it follows from the definition that there is widespread state terrorism. Second, countries that send military occupation forces to other countries have a vested interest to brand asymmetric warfare against their military as terrorism, but this is not covered by the definition.
- ukj 6y agoObviously you would think your definition is the “reasonable” one. Until you find yourself having to engage in terro^H^H^H^H^H freedom fighting to achieve your own political goals.
- JohnStrangeII 6y agoI agree, what you describe is what terrorists think. Obviously, at some point in their life they persuade themselves that their political goals justify the intentional killing of innocent civilians. They go at great lengths with these justifications precisely because they are so obviously flawed. Attempts to justify their actions involve a mix of denying the Doctrine of Double Effects, speaking of necessary sacrifices, and of portraying innocent victims as guilty collaborators.
- ukj 6y agoIt's exactly what you are doing right now. Denying the Doctrine of Double Effects. Attempting to justify your definition. Portraying freedom fighters as terrorists. Ultimately insisting that your perspective/definition is the 'correct' one. You've gone to great lengths with these justifications perhaps because they are so obviously flawed?
- yakshaving_jgt 6y agoThe issue is that terrorism is about advancing an ideology. That's the important part. It's not about how terrifying the act was, nor is it about the attacker's skin colour (as is rather depressingly hinted at in US discourse). Ted Bundy terrorised his community, but there was no political aim. He was a sociopath, but not a terrorist. Anders Behring Breivik terrorised his community, and he had an explicit and clear ideological aim. He's a sociopath, and a terrorist.
- gsk22 6y agoSo in other words, it's an antonym to "senseless violence": as long as the perpetrator has a known agenda (whether implicitly or explicitly stated), it's terrorism? Doesn't that also make things like war and police brutality terrorism? Growing up in the US post-9/11, the word terrorism itself was very political. It was weaponized by successive presidential administrations as a catch-all term for "any person or group the government doesn't like" and repeated endlessly on news broadcasts and in other popular media. Terrorism is our only "justification" for holding people like Ramzi bin al-Shibh without trial for nearly 20 years. The original meaning of the word was lost long ago in popular American discourse, and the state prefers it that way. We still see that today, as prominent American political figures label peaceful protesters terrorists. Anyways, thanks for helping me chew through this. I'd never considered the meaning of the word closely before.
- skissane 6y agoYes, “terrorism” has a political objective. Randomly killing people for non-political reasons, such as done by some mass shooters or serial killers, is not terrorism, even if in some cases it kills more people than many acts of terrorism do.
- darksaints 6y agoI suppose the word political could encompass this, but it should also be pointed out it is political in the sense of having an intended purpose for societal change. That goes beyond what most people consider politics. It could be religious, ethnocentric, ideological, philosophical, etc. Even the actions of the luddites could fall under terrorism.
- skissane 6y ago> it should also be pointed out it is political in the sense of having an intended purpose for societal change The Christchurch mosque shooting was very consciously political - the perpetrator published a manifesto, he pre-announced and live streamed his crime to an online political discussion community dominated by the far right, he was hoping to inspire copycats through which to change society (he hoped to trigger the genocide of the Muslim minority in Western societies). Compare that to the Sandy Hook Elementary shooting - in the later case, the perpetrator didn’t prepare a manifesto. His motivations appeared to be primarily personal. Like everyone, he had some political views which investigators pieced together from writings and communications he left behind, but he made no attempt to communicate a clear political justification for his monstrous act. Both shootings were horrific acts of evil. But only one was clearly intended as political. Only one was a clear case of terrorism
- darksaints 6y agoI'm in full agreement. I'm just saying that a lot of people have a very narrow definition of political, and can easily fall into the trap of seeing that definition being a left vs right thing, or whatever political lense they tend to bias towards. For example, while the Sandy Hook shooting was distinctly personal in motivation, the 2014 Isla Vista shooting looked very similar but was very political, and thus terroristic. It just happens that the political motivation was one not commonly viewed as being political.
- tech2 6y agoI think the difference is the intent. If the intent of the act is the death (or other outcome) of a group of individuals then the act would be mass murder. If however the intent of the act is to use these acts to cause terror (the deaths are merely a means to that end) then the act is terrorism. Terror has been a tool of a number of political groups over the years. An easy example would be when the IRA bombing campaign moved outside of London after the ring of steel was constructed. The destruction of property, or the deaths of individuals themselves in London weren't the aims, it was the threat/fear/terror that anyone could become a victim. The terror was a lever to force government response.
- dgb23 6y agoI like this definition very much. However, would you for example include propaganda, which is specifically designed to spread fear? I always associated terrorism with physical violence.
- webmaven 6y ago> However, would you for example include propaganda, which is specifically designed to spread fear? I always associated terrorism with physical violence. Propaganda in the form of "$OUTGROUP are all murderers and rapists" is just fearmongering rather than terrorism, propaganda that threatens violence directly (eg. "Kill all $OUTGROUP") might be considered such, esp. if there is any reason to think that the propaganda is at all likely to be acted upon (so, if $OUTGROUP is "clowns" I don't think it would currently qualify, but "banksters" might).
- tech2 6y agoI think it's an interesting line, and depends on the propaganda. I imagine at some point lawyers would need to get involved to argue the minutiae. I can't say for sure and would really need decent examples.
- bzb3 6y agoWhy'd you bring politics to this post
- lightgreen 6y agoI’m also concerned MW already considers “homosexuality” offensive since a couple of months ago. It looks like MW starts supporting lefts redefinition of the language rather than providing a reference of the established language.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jimhefferon 6y ago> pretty uncommon Gee, I hear it a lot. Northern New England, US.
- ukj 6y agoLanguage evolves. Use and meaning of words changes over time. Logocentrists are surprised. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logocentrism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logocentrism
- twelvechairs 6y agoEnglish evolves because it is polycentric. Other languages are held back by formal regulators from evolving (e.g. Association of Spanish Language Academies, Académie française, Council for German Orthography, China's State Language Work Committee, etc.)
- 082349872349872 6y ago> “irregardless: a word that distinguishes people who do not care much about English usage from those who care terribly—and want the world to know it.” In other words, a sibboleth? Exercise for hackers: what are the minimal code sequences one can write to distinguish between various x86 versions? various python versions? etc.
- SamReidHughes 6y ago"Disregardless" still gets no respect.
- jasode 6y agoThe actress Jamie Lee Curtis complained about MW's addition of "irregardless" because she misunderstands the purpose of that dictionary: to document and describe actual language usage. Therefore, if "irregardless" is in wide common usage, it gets added as an entry. Dictionaries that are more descriptive than prescriptive: The Oxford English Dictionary and Merriam-Webster Dictionary. (e.g. "whatevs", "chillax", other slang, etc added to OED: https://www.google.com/search?q=newest+words+in+Oxford+English+Dictionary https://www.google.com/search?q=newest+words+in+Oxford+Engli...) A dictionary that is more prescriptive (more conservative and avoids adding new non-standard words): The American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_American_Heritage_Dictionary_of_the_English_Language https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_American_Heritage_Dictiona...) tldr: most people don't know the underlying rationale of dictionaries some Youtube links... deep link of Kory Stamper @ Merriam-Webster talking about adding nonstandard word "irregardless" to the dictionary: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLgn3geod9Q&feature=youtu.be&t=4m20s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLgn3geod9Q&feature=youtu.be... Anne Curzan (advisor role on Usage Panel) for American Heritage Dictionary explaining "what makes a word 'real'?": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6NU0DMjv0Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6NU0DMjv0Y [to downvoters: it would be helpful if you state what's incorrect in my post; I don't want to give out bad information. Thank you.]
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoI guess I'd just assume she had a prescriptive personality type and preferred the dictionary she happened to look at to have the same view of language.
- ukj 6y agoFun game to play with Linguistic prescriptivist (endearingly called Grammar Nazis) in 2020. Host your own dictionary and insist that theirs is wrong.
- Aengeuad 6y agoYour post is pretty fair and I don't have an issue with it but I do have an argument (albeit not a very convincing one) for why somebody might take issue with a word like irregardless. I'm sure we've all experienced the frustration in an argument where somebody will point to a less comprehensive dictionary that doesn't document your particular or explicit usage of a term and use that to say you're wrong, but the opposite is occasionally true where people will take popular usage or a dictionary entry of a term that might be incorrect or used in a way that is incorrect and use that to justify their continued usage of the term. The former is frustrating because both parties may understand and come to terms with each other but one is shirking their responsibilities in an argument, the latter can be frustrating because there may be a genuine difficulty in communication until the common usage or dictionary is brought out to clear up the confusion. There's a strong case to be made that the purpose of a dictionary is to aid communication by describing the usage of words so I think it's clear that 'irregardless' deserves a mention although with a warning on usage, which seems to be the case here with Merriam-Webster describing it as non-standard and the OED going a step further and saying it's not correct. Language prescriptivists usually deserve the lectures on the usefulness of descriptive dictionaries that they get but I don't think that it's always useful to go to the extreme and celebrate confusing or commonly understood as incorrect usage of words despite some minor usage. The article brings up a good word that was changed over confusion which was inflammable becoming flammable as the 'in' suffix could be taken to meaning a negator and I don't think anybody really had an issue with this, although it does say that 'flammable' is malformed but I really don't see how.
- smitty1e 6y agoCaring about grammar may indicate one stands with the wide soup rim assists.
- daffy 6y agoThe author seems to claim that `irregardless' is all right and that caring about it is caring too much and vain. He compares it to other malformed words such as `television' and `flammable'. But there seems to be a significant difference between these and that. While recognizing the malformedness of these words require knowledge of Greek and Latin, recognizing that of `irregardless' is trivial for anyone who is proficient in current English: it is obviously a stupid word, and that makes it stupider.
- darksaints 6y agoBut that is exactly how language evolves. People say stupid shit often enough and it eventually stops sounding stupid. See also: ain't, firstly, cisgender, etc.
- thechao 6y agoPure conjecture on my part: irregardless is an intensifier of dismissal. It allows the word to start with a vowel. Since (American) English requires exhortations to start with a consonant, it forces the speaker to begin the sound with a glottal stop. Initial glottal stops are markers for interjective cursing, like “‘Asshole!”
- kazinator 6y agoThe conjecture is likely wrong. Some speakers simply reach for irregardless whenever they want to say "without regard" and are never heard using regardless.
- irthomasthomas 6y agoMy favorite/worst example of language evolution is the word factoid. Factoid literally meant a thing resembling a fact (i.e. a false fact) which is believed to be true after being repeated in print. Now, those same writers who where presumably spreading factoids, have inverted its meaning to be 'a minor, but true fact' [0]. [0] http://www.doctoryourself.com/hoffer_factoids.html http://www.doctoryourself.com/hoffer_factoids.html
- vbtemp 6y agoWould a more correct version of a minor, true fact be a _factino_? Kind of like a Plutino or Neutrino?
- daffy 6y agoFactule, perhaps, from the unattested but regular diminutive factulum.
- nafey 6y agoFactarrino if you really wanna go wild with it
- jwilk 6y agofactlet (like piglet)
- daffy 6y agoBut that would be mixing Latin and English, just as bad as television!
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agofactette then.
- Udik 6y agoTrivia?
- swiley 6y agoThe popularity of the word “irregardless” demonstrates a property of human thought and socialization that’s very important to most people here: that the majority of people (at least those that speak English) are perfectly happy copying other people’s behavior without asking why. More complex examples of this come from studies where people struggle to communicate the difference between Boolean operators (specifically OR and XOR.) My point is that this is a reminder of why we have software engineers and why cheap contractors, AI, and easier to use tooling (such as “graphical programming languages) haven’t been able to replace them: people think and speak too imprecisely to communicate even just software specifications correctly let alone implement them.
- hguant 6y agoI was a political philosophy major in college - it's interesting seeing how important being able to rigorously define what you're saying, and taking into account what your statements assume, is critically important for both engineering, and philosophy. ...also it turns out that dissecting a statement and pointing out the inconsistentsies is a great way to piss people off.
- posterboy 6y agoit's precisely the formal logic, albeit mostly in legal, that employs double negation to cover all bases, in case of doubt about the excluded middle, and importantly, to reverse liability of proof. You are not not an idiot. I didn't say you were one, but I will leave the proof to the opposite to somebody else. It might just be an intensifier, irregardless of the legalese, whenever it defaults to the law of excluded middle, that is, perhaps when the proof is not even considered relevant, whereas "regardless" implicitly connotes neglect. Regardless ofyou being an idiot. or Irregardless of you being perhaps an idiot. Alas, double negation tends to be not very stable in informal speach, e.g. any "some", not any "none", not not any: "some", "any" or "all". This involves type coercion from the gradual to the binary interpretation (and it's terribly difficult to make explicit, exactly not trivially simple at least).
- marcosdumay 6y ago> copying other people’s behavior without asking why Yielding to a shared meaning is the entire point of language.
- trynumber9 6y agoIf it makes you feel better it's not widely used: https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=regardless%2Cirregardless&year_start=1880&year_end=2019&corpus=26&smoothing=3# https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=regardless%2Ci...
- Emma_Goldman 6y agoIt's scarcely surprising that it's not used in print. Books are considered, written by those most proficient in English, read and re-read, and professionally proof-read. The extent of its use in ordinary conversation is something else entirely.
- Jedd 6y agoI recall my mum, it must have been in the 1980's, engaging in much eye-rolling and tut-tutting at our (Australia) then prime minister, Bob Hawke, using the word 'irregardless'. Bob was ostensibly quite charismatic, but no one could accuse him of being an especially thoughtful communicator. In retrospect it's fairly typical behaviour for less literate types to adopt a word that sounds sophisticated beyond their standard repertoire , and assume it's sufficiently cromulent for formal use. (A very recent thread on HN was around the use of the word 'decimate' as an alternative spelling for 'destroy', for similar reasons.) I think Boris Johnson is a profoundly bad force in the universe, but I do recall feeling the editing of one of his appearances on a UK TV show (Have I Got News For You) was patently unfair, as he was asserting that calling small four wheeled vehicles 'quad-bikes' was etymologically unsound. His point (I imagine - the broadcast did not include the justification) was that 'bike' is a corruption of bicycle, in turn rooted from 'bi', referring to the two wheels.
- Udik 6y ago> and assume it's sufficiently cromulent for formal use Ha! Good one. > the use of the word 'decimate' as an alternative spelling for 'destroy' An alternative spelling? I don't think so.
- Jedd 6y agoThe claim was made that common usage defines meaning (I don't entirely agree), and that the masses had spoken, as it were, and determined that decimate no longer has any notion of 1/10th of something being removed, but rather the word's meaning is now functionally identical to destroy or devastate (I don't agree with this either). My point is/was that if that claim is true, then the choice of which word to use is purely one of aesthetics rather than exercising any nuance of meaning or intent -- a regrettably poor evolution for a language.
- ergothus 6y ago> In retrospect it's fairly typical behaviour for less literate types to adopt a word that sounds sophisticated beyond their standard repertoire This seems an excessively negative take on it. How do we learn new words? Sure, we COULD look up the definitions, but (1) who bothers, and (2) we have plenty of evidence that definitions are so vague as to be useless. (I recall arguing with my high school english teacher about "moot", which we had as aa vocab word with a definition that didn't match my colloquial understanding). So as adults, as teens, tweens, and before, most of our language is learned from contextual usage. Which is a terrible way to maintain accuracy. When I get stumped with newer terminology, my friends that USE the new words are often at a loss to explain them (one spent 30 mins trying to explain "kappa") because they don't know a formal definition, they know it when they see it. We can be smug and superior about the "less literate" trying to be impressive, but honestly, that applies to all of us, we are just mocking those that get caught.
- daffy 6y agoI wonder, are there any statistics on descriptivist and prescriptivist attitudes in various groups? Or any recent defenses of prescriptivism?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 6y agoMerriam-Webster labels the word as "nonstandard" and recommends that regardless be used, all the while assuring readers that "irregardless" is indeed a word that has been in use by English speakers for "well over 200 years" and by "a large number of people across a wide geographic range and with a consistent meaning". And, note, that same dictionary makes no disparaging remarks about the abuse of "literally" as a generic intensifier; it simply cites that usage as one of the meanings. The abuse of "literally" is more recent than "irregardless". That tells you that "irregardless" is quite the lexical pariah. A major dictionary like Merriam is not able to wholeheartedly accept it in spite of the word's age and stability.
- NoSorryCannot 6y agoOne of the chief functions of a mainstream dictionary is to guide users on usage. Irregardless of the principles possessed by Merriam-Webster's editors, they still have to warn readers when a usage will be conspicuous. Chumming the water for pedants can only be a distraction.
- mjburgess 6y ago> The abuse of "literally" is more recent than "irregardless". It certainly is not. The complaints are recent. This usage is hundreds of years old. https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/misuse-of-literally https://www.merriam-webster.com/words-at-play/misuse-of-lite...
- kazinator 6y agoI strongly suspect that a new class of abuse is recent. literally is actually reasonable as an intensifer for a figurative situation. I.e. the speaker is asking you to forget that you're just using an extreme figure of speech for a situation that is actually mild, but instead imagine it literally happening. I.e. the situation I'm describing is in fact so intense, that please pay attention to the figure of speech, since it is utterly fitting. What we have now is literally just being applied randomly where there is no figure of speech, or not even a plausible figure of speech, as in: > I literally just moved here from New York last week; do you know where I can get a decent bagel? Here, "literally" doesn't inform us that a plausible metaphor is actual ("moved here from New York" is not a common figure of speech with a special meaning, and is vanishingly unlikely to be interpreted as such), and doesn't ask us to get a more intense sense of a metaphor by imagining it as actually happening: the move actually happened, that's all. The word is just a morsel of pure verbiage.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y ago"Dethaw" - to unfreeze something prior to cooking. It's something my ex imprinted on my kids. The court was quick to give me custody, once I brought that up.
- WarOnPrivacy 6y agoI feel the evolution of language reflects important details about the culture wielding it. I think a strong example is the word 'cult'. It once referred to a small sect or faith - and that's all. Leaders of established sects so often demonized small, competing faiths that cult became redefined to refer to evil and dangerous groups of worshipers. Notably, no other word ever emerged to take it's place. I really wanted a tool to evidence how changes in language reflected changes in society's beliefs. I figured an authoritarian source of English definitions would be that tool but there isn't any such thing.* In the end I had to adopt the more difficult approach of finding examples that my audience could relate with. * (For a time I believed that the Oxford English Dictionary was that source, due to the 60-odd years between the 1st and 2nd editions. I didn't realize tho that supplements were added on an ongoing basis.)
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/0knTf https://archive.is/0knTf
- throw7 6y agopaywall (didn't read). I had a co-worker who used to use irregardless. I didn't say anything. My own personal pet-peeve is the phrase "that begs the question...", and then the speaker raises a question. No. That's not begging the question. sigh. At this point in "post post-modernism"? I guess my line in the sand is pronunciation of proper nouns. Cue the "gif" vs "jif" debate.
- wdr1 6y agoIts ironic how upset people get over the use of "irregardless."
- cafard 6y ago"""(It's regardless, Caroline, not irregardless," Lorena said gently. Caroline huffily replied that regardless was a footless, weak word and got you nowhere, that on the other hand you threw in the word irregardless and won any argument hands down.""" Dawn Powell, The Locusts Have No King