22 ms·
Independently Poor: A Twist on FU Money – a.k.a. “FU, Money”
- forgotmypw17 6y agoFU Money, and FU Paperwork, is basically what I gradually came to live, after gradually unsubscribing from all of it. It's been an amazing experience, and yes, very freeing.
- rumanator 6y agoThe main problem with this blend of "liberating experiences" is that they are all fine and dandy when you're in your 20s and 30s. When health concerns start to kick in and your ability to generate income is hampered by the fact that you've decided to pay no attention to your career then that's where the consequences of your decisions start to catch up with you. It's like those hedonists who choose to spend their life up to their late 20s/early 30s chasing parties while either living off someone else or barely generating any income suddenly need to realize they are powerless to address their basic needs.
- forgotmypw17 6y agoYou speak of health concerns down the road, but I have concerns over the health of my soul right now. I do not want to get to old age and realize that I've just been doing pointless shit for money my whole life, just to stay safe, meanwhile building someone's stupid dream instead of my good dream. Where are those advertising campaigns I worked on so hard, putting in extra hours to hit the arbitrary deadlines? Gone, forever forgotten. Where is that loan lifecycle management application I put so much effort into? How has it helped the world? It hasn't. I helped someone else funnel money into financial instruments. When someone asks me what I did with my life, will I say that I helped a brand sell more product? That I did very thorough testing of ad delivery components to ensure that the tracking was reliable? That I helped increase conversions by 30% by optimizing the UI? I don't think getting more help with health issues down the road is a worthwhile tradeoff for all this. It sounds like fear-guided. Yet medical industry cannot help with most situations when body is already damaged. They can only help with symptoms, and often poorly. Having seen relatives through it, I would like to avoid it as much as possible. Many health issues are developed from not enough sleep, over-work, and over-stress. I believe that if I am careful, I can actually live longer AND better by not sacrificing my health for jobwork. I really like that quote by IIRC His Holiness the Dalai Lama, which goes like this: people trade their health for money, then try to use money to get their health back. I don't want to live that life. It's nice to have enough time for a party or two, it's unhealthy to not go to one occasionally, IMO.
- rumanator 6y ago> You speak of health concerns down the road, but I have concerns over the health of my soul right now. I do not want to get to old age and realize that I've just been doing pointless shit for money my whole life, just to stay safe, meanwhile building someone's stupid dream instead of my good dream. That's where the hedonism road leads you, but whose trip just takes you 20 to 30 years instead of 60 or 70 or 80. The ant and the grasshopper fable was written down by Aesop over 2 thousand years ago. This isn't new. Just because you come up with an excuse about "soul health" that doesn't mean that you aren't volunteering to enter a world of pain by neglecting your livelihood and ability to generate income. And please do realize you do have influence over your career. If you chose to work on uninspiring projects them... Don't, and instead search for projects that you feel are more rewarding. Demand for skilled developers is so high that anyone remotely competent has to fend off recruiters lining up to pay salaries that are way above any nation's median wage.
- distances 6y agoWhat's FU paperwork? Only relevant Google hit I see is pointing to this comment.
- Havoc 6y agoDon’t know what parent commenter meant but for me it’s multiple passport and qualifications that will fly anywhere. So when a country doesn’t work out I just go somewhere else.
- germinalphrase 6y agoIs your passport situation by luck of your birth or have you gone through the expense/hoop jumping of obtaining passports?
- Havoc 6y agoTwo by birth. Third is still six months to go for sufficient years. (Currently perma res which is functionally the same for now)
- forgotmypw17 6y agoI believe that it should not be necessary to fill out paperwork in order to exist. So I don't do it.
- distances 6y agoYou've then misunderstood what "FU money" means. It doesn't mean you disregard money, on the contrary. It means you have enough money to make the choices you're happy with. Most common case being you don't have to do work that makes you unhappy. I think this was laid out in the article well enough. In the same vein "FU paperwork" should mean you have powerful enough paperwork to disregard some annoyances in life. It does not mean you can skip doing paperwork.
- dclowd9901 6y agoI don’t know if this is tangential or completely related to this article, but at some point I realized the greatest thing I could have was the freedom to change everything about my life at any given moment. I realized that unless I had that freedom, I was never really free. Now, every choice I make is colored by question: if I make this choice, what choices do I lose? How can I make a choice that keeps me from losing any choices. The unexpected side benefit of this is that if I’m ever in doubt of what I’m doing with my life, I am free to consider changing things, and if I don’t, then I know that I am doing exactly what I want to do. It’s a way to contentment that is almost objective.
- konschubert 6y agoI don’t know. I’ve found it very liberating to commit to choices.
- cbanek 6y agoI really sympathize with this and feel this way too although sometimes I feel paralyzed by too much choice, and that can make it harder to make "big" decisions, like buying a house, etc.
- Ruphin 6y agoBy limiting yourself to choices that do not cause loss of choice in the future, are you still free to choose anything? You value this freedom so much that you limit the choices you can make significantly only to retain this freedom, but unless you "cash in" that freedom at some point to make a choice without restrictions (which will probably limit your freedom of choice in the future) you are living with a limited choice-space just the same.
- Joeboy 6y agoPoverty is shit. I recommend avoiding it if you can.
- rapnie 6y agoThe article though is not advocating to live in poverty, but rather to live with just the right amount of FU Money to be able to make free choices. After this threshold the perspective if one is rich of poor becomes one of mindset and not so much based on the superficial metric of one's net worth.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThank you. Yes, that's the point.
- arcsin 6y agoThis is fair if you think freedom is the most important thing. Having more money has real objective benefits and most people are fine with giving up some freedom to have those benefits.
- imheretolearn 6y agoI beg to differ. I'll say the article assumes you even have access to FU money, which is what the real poor live with everyday.
- granshaw 6y agoIt’s understandable why a regular member of society would feel that way - but as someone recently wanting to go the entrepreneurship route I have a different take I wish I could live on the bare minimum and not mind doing things like living off food stamps and clipping coupons, and had a partner in the same mindset. That would open up so many options and increase my runway so much! But as it is, I’ve never had to go through that and would never want to put my partner through that, so I have to make do with a higher minimum bar
- Joeboy 6y ago
- 2sk21 6y agoGood article - Everyone needs to learn the amount of money that they need to become independent. As the author says, it can be as little as a couple of dollars in some situations for some people. Learning about the concept of financial independence really made a big positive impact on my career as it allowed me to walk away from toxic work situations.
- jcun4128 6y agoI briefly experienced "freedom" for a few months where I just stopped paying my bills(no expenses). This was dumb later on eg. cc law suits/tanked credit score. But I had the ability to do so(friends/cheap housing/internet access). I learned how to build full stack websites, I was chasing the dream(high traffic ad-revenue based websites). Meanwhile was in the process of failing out of school/fear of how I would pay my student loans. It was great because I had no reason to do anything eg. get up by 9AM/pay a bill at this day. I could chase some rabbit hole and just keep going even if my sleep pattern was flipped. I could sleep 16 hrs straight. But yeah I'm going for FiRe I'm still broke af despite making a lot for my area. But I'm at least glad I am in this industry/aware of a lifestyle like that. edit: I would not advise screwing up your cc haha... it's too bad I didn't learn that till later/too late.
- imheretolearn 6y ago>> At one time while I was homeless, relatives helped me deal with some of my financial drama >> I was able to resist such pressures and make decisions for myself, including moving my bank account at a later date on terms that made more sense for me, because I had some maneuvering room in the form of food stamps and knowing where I could get a free meal or free clothes. Food stamps didn't cover some essential nonfood items that we needed and couldn't get from a homeless services center, specifically peroxide and plastic cups, but we made more of an effort to get better at finding change on the street and we used that to buy those essentials at some local "dollar" store. This article is a good example of a "First World Problem". Before jumping to conclusions, let me explain. There is world of a difference between being homeless in a first world country and a third world country. This article completely discounts that. Food stamps, bank accounts are something 'poor' can only find in first world countries. >> Join reward programs, clip coupons, etc. >> Check Reddit for pertinent subreddits for meeting your needs cheaply. To access Reddit you first need a device AND an internet connection AND you need to be literate. >> Ultimately, I concluded that being able to choose wasn't really about money per se but was about maneuvering room. Yes, having sufficient resources helps, but making choices in life and exercising free will is not directly related to how much or how little money a person has. It helps if you have some confidence you won't starve or otherwise experience catastrophe, but that isn't about money per se. It completely discounts any family members that may be disabled and maybe completely reliant on you for making ends meet. Have you ever seen a slum?(if not, then you probably won't get the point). This doesn't even touch the surface of what real problems most of the world in poor countries face. I don't blame the author for she has probably not been to a third world country but I do not agree with the above points.
- olcor 6y agoThis so much. It felt so weird that this person was talking about poverty and blogging/reading on the internet at the same time. Few poor people in the third world would know what blogging even is, forget about even wasting precious resources like time, money for a smartphone and an internet connection just to read/write some ideas which few are ever going to read and you won’t be making anything out of. This feels like being written by a person who knows that she’s writing for people who like to think about the idea of poverty living, but haven’t experienced it much first or even second-hand, only knowing about it from the news or glossy donation pamphlets.
- cryptica 6y agoI feel like being poor has lost a lot of its negative stigma. These days I find myself casually letting people know that I'm poor in order to get more favorable treatment. There are so many highly skilled poor people these days that there is not so much stigma around it. Being poor is basically a natural state for the vast majority of people in their 20s to 40s. My ex-colleagues often discuss how little money they have and how hard they struggle to find jobs. This is a totally normal conversation.
- Joeboy 6y agoIt's always been a totally normal conversation, at least where I live (the UK), for the last few decades. I had a colleague who complained that he couldn't reasonably be expected to live on his pitiful salary, which turned out to be £80k (about $120k, adjusted for inflation). Poverty oneupmanship from 1967: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKHFZBUTA4k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKHFZBUTA4k
- 082349872349872 6y agoWhen I was living in the US, I used to enjoy hearing people talk about "being rich." (To understand this circumlocution, the reader must understand that they're all "middle class" over there.) The most egregious instance was when I was talking with someone in a VIP tent, watching her pro jumping her horse over fences in a competition. She'd made some kind of comment about how she was different from the people she had just been talking about, "because they have money." When I asked what she would do if she had money, she replied that she wasn't sure, but maybe she would "get a jet."
- 10xPerson 6y ago>"watching her pro jumping her horse over fences in a competition." I have a hard time understanding this sentence
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kanobo 6y agoWhen life gives you lemons, do everything you can to sell them at a profit so you don't have to touch those nasty yellow fruits ever again. Congrats to the author for gaining independence and forging her path out.
- arcsin 6y agoComing at it from a different perspective, I did something similar to this by saving money on a US salary and then moving to a low cost of living country. I spent years at a time not working or even thinking about how to make money. I think almost everyone has felt the pain of financial and social obligation, but very few people have experience a total lack of such obligations for years at a time which leads to things like fantasizing about FU money. I can tell you that for me personally I don't think it was ideal. Yes, at first the freedom is exhilarating, but it doesn't last forever. There were two big problems. One is that you feel disconnected from society. This is hard to explain but being outside of normal social structures you lose a sense of context and meaning to your actions. Second is that when you don't have any social or financial pressures it's hard to avoid the path of least resistance. It's very easy to fall into bad habits, just watching youtube, reading reddit, bad diet, etc. I would assess myself as someone who would be less susceptible to these problems. I consider myself a fairly self-motivated person and definitely an introvert. But after several years it starts to weigh on you. Today I work in an office. There are often times when it's hard and I have to deal with things I don't want to. But I still think it's better than when I wasn't working. I think if I never had the experience of not working I would probably only see the downsides of office life as the upside is quite abstract and hard for me to articulate. I don't think this is something unique to me, I think it's human nature to want social structure and this naturally comes with social obligations. But for most people not being constrained to social structures was never an option anyway so they underestimate how much it affects their happiness.
- WilTimSon 6y agoWell, there's always a healthy option in the middle. I'm not exactly up to speed on what the pay is like in the USA (which is where I presume most of the users here hail from), but getting at least $3-4k is enough to work remotely from some place like Thailand or a small European country. You still get the benefit of a traditional-ish social life, where you "go" to work every day, talk to people and then have some time to go out. Except that salary that would get you a passable living in London, Seattle or whatever other expensive city you inhabit, could get you much farther in a poorer country. I do realise that this only applies to those who CAN work remotely but that seems to be a large chunk of the userbase for HN.
- draw_down 6y ago“I’ve been rich and I’ve been poor. And, believe me, rich is better.”
- 082349872349872 6y agoAlexander: Greetings, I am Alexander of Macedon. If you be the philosopher they call the Dawg, let me know your wish, and I shall grant it. Diogenes: Before your shadow fell on me, I had been lying in the sun. Step aside a pēchys or two, and I'll resume. In The Dispossessed, the anarchist Shevek is surprised to find that his political polar opposite, Atro, has a kindred soul: > "In some ways he was totally incomprehensible to Shevek — an enigma: the aristocrat. And yet his genuine contempt for both money and power made Shevek feel closer to him than to anyone else he had met on Urras." more Διογένης: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23822425 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23822425
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoIs that you, amanfrommars? https://forums.theregister.com/post/search/?q=amanfrommars https://forums.theregister.com/post/search/?q=amanfrommars
- 082349872349872 6y agoWhich reference to "FU, money" wants expansion? Ἀλέξανδρος/Διογένης or Shevek/Atro (or even Διογένης/Ἀρίστιππος)? Your most Obedient ſervant, who Wiſhes only to Explicate ſhould the Topick of my prior Converſation have been altogether Unclear, /s/ 082349872349872
- puranjay 6y agoI'm 31 and have never had a job. I started freelancing when I was 18 - more by necessity than by choice - and continued doing that throughout my six years of college. There is something to be said about having "unordinary" experiences - it cuts you off from your peer group. My part-time freelancing through college meant that I was often too busy to do the things college kids do - party, join bands, etc. Later, when I started freelancing full-time, my friends would talk about their bosses, applying for jobs, building up careers, etc. and I would just nod my head and attempt to understand but I couldn't. I've never had bosses - or even bad clients - and my idea of career has basically evolved into a series of gradually better/bigger gigs and projects. I'm very independent person and can get by perfectly fine being completely alone. But I imagine that someone more extroverted and social than me would have felt a little too alienated living a life so different than their peer group. When the pandemic struck earlier this year, a couple of my key clients dropped their budgets or held off on decision making. So I took that time as a "break". This devolved into eating too much, working out too little, and sleeping at odd hours - all great stuff for a week or two, but extremely grating after a month. It's a romantic idea - a life without boundaries or bosses - but it's not something everyone is cut out for, nor is it something I would recommend everyone to follow.
- nsl73 6y agoIf a job is the only thing holding your diet, habits, and exercise in place what will happen when you retire?
- mark_l_watson 6y agoI can't answer for the parent comment, but after working just when I wanted to for 20 years (onsite at Google and Capital One were the only exceptions in a 20 year period), I finally decided to really retire March 2019 (except I still write). My diet is even better now because I have time to cook real meals following a hybrid of Dr. Fuhrman/macrobiotic diets. I bought weights, and hike/walk an average of 90 minutes a day, and except for worrying occasionally about how family and friends are doing with covid-19, life is peaceful and fun. One thing that I think is vital is having goals. For me that is spiritual development and studying specific tech, programming languages, etc. I have been an artificial intelligence practitioner since the 1980s but I have very little experience with probabilistic programming, graph models, etc. My goal for the next year is kicking my knowledge up a few levels. These are the only goals I have, and that is enough for me.
- krisroadruck 6y ago"independent" + "alimony" = nope.
- hcta 6y agoThe buymeacoffee link on https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/ https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/ is broken - it points at https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/2020/01/buymeacoff.ee/DoreenMichele https://streetlifesolutions.blogspot.com/2020/01/buymeacoff.... which 404s.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThank you. I've updated it.
- Kye 6y agoRelated: how has your experience with buymeacoffee been? I used Ko-fi for a long time, but BMC keeps popping up.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI actually mostly stopped using it because it wasn't getting results for me. I removed it from most of my sites and this link got overlooked.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThough I will add that it occurs to me that if I was using a broken link across most of my sites, that could explain the poor performance. Duh.
- Kye 6y agoMy experience with various donation-themed money collectors is they don't go far without active promotion. The problem I had with Ko-fi is they run right through to your PayPal account, and PayPal likes to flag payments through Ko-fi as requiring shipping. After a while I had to manually set "doesn't need shipping info" on every one, and it wouldn't release the funds for weeks. It's easy to get people to send by PayPal because PayPal is easy, but Stripe requires getting a card out. Donations cratered the moment I turned PayPal off. As much as Patreon frustrates me for a long list of reasons, it's low-pain on both ends since it handles the link between payment and your bank account. The numbers are smaller, but people stick around and don't expect anything extra from you. Even if they pick a benefit-having tier. I made an account on Buy Me A Coffee, but it seemed like a less refined Ko-fi and I wasn't sure if I missed something.
- Joeboy 6y ago> I also really like the scene in Titanic where the rich guy tries to buy his way into a lifeboat and gets told his money won't be worth anything at the bottom of the ocean. In reality of course, first class passengers were more than twice as likely to survive as third class ones.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoIn reality of course, first class passengers were more than twice as likely to survive as third class ones. I'm reasonably sure that's because the gates to third class were locked to keep them off the decks and not because first class passengers were successfully bribing staff to let them onto the life boats. So, for me, it doesn't diminish the power of the scene. The original piece that this was based upon was written at a time when my bank account was locked up for a month by creditors. I was homeless in downtown San Diego, surrounded by modern wealth, and the only cash I had access to was change found on the street and sidewalk as I walked around during the day. A similar vignette would be a story I remember reading about a plane crash where they ended up burning large quantities of cash to try to avoid freezing to death in the snow-covered mountains. I was enduring something extreme. It was a tremendous head fuck and I was doing my best to wrap my mind around it. It wasn't easy to come up with similar examples from literature to which other people might relate at all and people tend to think I'm exaggerating when I talk about the facts of my life. They think I'm being a drama queen to state things that happen to be true for me and try to convey what it's like to experience it. I remember being in a women's day shelter and someone else who was homeless was waving about a five dollar bill and I had no money and no means to get any money and I don't know how to describe how bizarre that was that even other homeless people were so much more comfortably well off than I was that they didn't feel some need to hide that five dollar bill and protect it from the other poor people around them. And it's like "Just how can anyone in the US be so extremely cut off from money like that in the midst of so much wealth?" But there I was. And I'm not the only person who is invisibly cut out. Plenty of people can walk past the table where America lays a feast for some, but not others, and they aren't invited to partake and if they touch it they will go to jail for theft. A lot of those other people are People of Color and they serve the feast, but aren't allowed to eat any of it. The barriers that keep people out are weird and "magical" in that they are invisible and intangible in certain important ways and they run deep. And all these years later, I still don't know how to speak of it effectively as is clearly demonstrated by the numerous scoffing comments in this very discussion.
- fxtentacle 6y agoThanks to covid, I have experienced how it must be to not have fu money. I'm not entirely sure why, but many companies are now hoping to take advantage of the rise in unemployment by trying to lock in highly skilled workers at a low salary. The way those job offers were presented, it seemed like they were feeling like my savior in a shining armor for offering job openings in these challenging times. But they were asking for lots of experience, unpaid overtime, yet offered less than what I currently make for part-time. Their main argumentation point was that it's better to be underpaid than to be unemployed. I assume that that's how most people who don't have fu money are treated, because they are not in a situation that allows them to negotiate. But of course, accepting such an offer might prevent you from accumulating a safety deposit in the future. Maybe the best way is to go with Aladdin: If you don't have anything, act like you own everything.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoJust take whatever job you can o pay your bills and jump ship when the pandemic is over and you can find a better paying job.
- mdavis6890 6y agoMore generally - take the best job you can, then keep looking and take a better job when you find one. Hopefully you'll end up looking a long time before you find a better one (meaning that your current job is relatively great). I think this applies always, regardless of the pandemic.
- toto444 6y ago"I'm not entirely sure why" That is what people usually call the law of supply and demand. Your salary is not a function of your skill but of how rare they are on the market relative to the number of job opening.
- fxtentacle 6y agoJudging from the number of offers I got in recent weeks, it seems the number of job openings currently is higher than before. Shouldn't that drive up prices?
- dpwr 6y agoThanks for writing an important piece. I had shit hit the fan before and wound up in being a begger that thought they could not choose and getting burned and being a begger that made hard choices and sacrifice for a long term goal. There is a lot we can do without to end vicious cycles of being vulnerable and being preyed upon. I completely agree with your comment of clarification that you to sort your shit truly out you must be choosey
- WhyIsItLikeThis 6y agoThis woman was getting alimony. This country is so broken. She was not poor or homeless unless she wanted to call herself that. Woman in the US are a privileged class and they often use that privilege to gain more power and sympathy. This story is a joke, this country is fucked.
- k__ 6y agoVery important points for a good life. The steps I took to become more happy with my life: 1. Lower my expenses 2. Work from home 3. Work on things I like 4. Work when I want I'm not rich, but I feel I can do what I want, when I want it.
- bane 6y agoMy wife and I have probably hit a point where if we really wanted to we could cash in and probably just go the grid for the rest of our lives. We're not rich, but we've put together a plan where it would be possible to do this if either of us ever really said "fuck it". The anxiety really comes when we start thinking about old age. Where dipping back into the workforce if we needed to is not really possible and unexpected expenses are likely. So I guess it's keeping to the grind to build as much of a safety net for those days as we can until we really decide to pull the trigger. We both know enough people who are "independently poor" and seem to make it day to day without too much fuss in the short term. But almost all those same people we know end up in catastrophic financial emergencies over the longer term due to unexpected expenses they can't surge their finances to meet. For us it just means we don't put as much away for retirement for a paycheck. For them we've seen evictions, garnished wages, divorce, ruined credit, bankruptcy, and so on. It's a vicious cycle that starts with being relatively expensive and ends up being ruinous.
- granshaw 6y agoSounds like old age medical expenses is the biggest fear - have you all considered emigrating to a country with govt provides healthcare to address that possibility?
- bane 6y agoYes. We plan on retiring outside of the U.S. primarily due to the medical nonsense making our expected cost of living much lower in old age.
- nemetroid 6y agoDo you plan on living and paying taxes for a substantial amount of time in your target country?
- justnotworthit 6y agoHow would they retire in a country without following its immigration laws? You're tattle telling on behalf of no one.
- 80mph 6y ago>>In other words, I had a degree of independence and agency that you normally only see in the Jet Set -- people who get called independently wealthy -- or comfortably well-off retirees. I had more control over my time and my life than your typical working stiff. No offense, but I would not attribute any sense of freedom or higher degree of control in one's life to receiving alimony. What happens if/when the ex-spouse prematurely dies or has their bank account hacked?