3 ms·
I must have missed the part of my own comment where I suggested that the strange part of this was that those people were allowed onto a boat. The strange part
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
I must have missed the part of my own comment where I suggested that the strange part of this was that those people were allowed onto a boat.
The strange part is that they wanted to be there. If you can't swim, this is a self-evidently bad idea. People are still afraid of boats, just as people are afraid of airplanes. Those people are correct -- occupying a vehicle whose failure will instantly kill you is something you should be frightened of.
But since you mention requirements, I'll note that my parents would not allow me on a boat -- any boat -- before I could swim. Unlike the ability to fly, the ability to swim is not all that difficult to learn. And while it won't save you if you get dumped into the middle of the sea, it will save you if you get dumped twenty feet from shore.
- ghaff 6y agoYes, people should learn to swim if only for safety reasons. I went to a school that required you to pass a swim test (or take a swimming class) to graduate. I approve with whatever reasonable exceptions are appropriate. But it's not obvious to me that large boats should particularly be avoided if you have otherwise never learned to swim for whatever reasons. And it's not clear that being able to swim would necessarily save many of the people who have died in major ferry, etc. accidents.
- catalogia 6y ago> And it's not clear that being able to swim would necessarily save many of the people who have died in major ferry, etc. accidents. The ability to get off the ship and into the water seems like the trickiest bit to me, particularly if you're below deck sleeping when the accident occurs. Once you're in the water, I think the temperature of the water is likely the biggest factor. If the water is cold then you likely have minutes to survive no matter how strong a swimmer you are. If the water is warm, people could float for days before succumbing to the elements. The USS Indianapolis survivors were in the water for four days and were in pretty bad shape, but I think in the modern era a more timely rescue is likely.
- pantaloony 6y agoIt’s not clear to me that most of the drownings were related to inability to swim. If you dump a few hundred strong swimmers in water, unexpectedly and all very close together and panicking, then add that a bunch of them are kids (many of which may well hav been able to swim, ordinarily) then I’d expect a bunch of them to drown. Ever accidentally get in a little knot of people in the water? Makes it harder to swim. Now put some people under you and others trying to swim past you and wait where the hell is my ten-year-old and everyone’s screaming and tugging and pushing and your suit is wet and heavy... I don’t see how a large percentage of the passengers being unable to swim is necessary for a whole lot of them to drown. [edit] more to the point, do you believe crowd-crush deaths occur because those crushed foolishly never learned to walk?
- solarkraft 6y ago> If you can't swim, this is a self-evidently bad idea. Except it's not really. You'd generally trust these things to be safe and in reality they kind of are. Now much more than then, but even back then the risk was low enough for most people to take, I assume. The same thing (albeit with a lower risk) is true of planes today.