7 ms·
“Designed by Apple in California. Assembled in India.”
by numpad0 6y ago
“Designed by Apple in California. Assembled in India.”
- mmastrac 6y ago"... Taxed in Ireland"
- bergstromm466 6y agoWith IP monpolized and enforced by the neo-colonial global North corporatocracy or empire, thanks to TRIPS [1] - "Meanwhile, the educational, information and intellectual commons have been plundered more than at any time in history. Thomas Jefferson, a founding father of the US Constitution, correctly said, ‘Ideas, in nature, cannot be made the subject of property.’ Sadly, that is precisely what has been done in the neo-liberal era. A globalised intellectual property rights system was immensely strengthened by TRIPS (Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights) passed through the World Trade Organisation in 1994, shaped by a few US multinationals, backed by the US and UK governments. This has facilitated the commercialisation, privatisation and colonisation of ideas. Since 1994, the annual filing of patents has more than tripled, with the global stock of patents close to 12 million, each giving monopolistic control of some idea for 20 years or more. Many patents result from publicly-funded research, diminishing the risk. But TRIPS allows corporations to receive monopolistic income for two decades, or use the patent to block others from producing something. Those claiming to believe in free markets should have opposed the trend, but reveal their class-based ideology by keeping quiet. There is evidence that the patent system hinders economic growth and innovation. It merely increases inequality and rentier capitalism." [1] https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/oureconomy/plunder-commons-compensate-commoners/ https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/oureconomy/plunder-commons-...
- beervirus 6y agoEvery (or almost every?) industrialized nation already had a patent system. The TRIPS agreement just standardized some aspects of those disparate systems across countries.
- bergstromm466 6y ago"Of all the forms of artificial property and legal privilege in existence, the one most indispensable to corporate power in today's economy is probably "intellectual property. A large portion of the price of most goods and services consists of embedded rents on “intellectual property.” Tom Peters, in The Tom Peters Seminar, argued that the cost of materials probably accounted for some $60 of the total price of his new Minolta camera, and that he paid “the rest, about $640, for its intellect....” He went on to celebrate the portion of economic value made up of “intellect” and “imagination.”33 Whether Peters' estimate is typical for the portion of the price of manufactured goods made up of rents on IP is doubtful. But in an economy with no property rights in software and product design, with competition unrestricted by "intellectual property" claims of any kind, whatever portion of a product's price was made up of rent on the ownership of designs or ideas—as opposed to labor and materials—would evaporate overnight. IP is a major legal support to oligopoly, since so many cartels were stabilized by the exchange or pooling of patents between the major players in various industries (e.g. G.E. And Westinghouse in home appliances, the Bell Patent Association as the basis for AT&T, RCA as a patent pooling arrangement for the major radio producers, etc.). If IP were abolished, there would be no legal barrier against many small companies producing competing modular components or accessories for the same platform, or even big companies producing modular components designed for interoperability with other companies products. That means that IP is an important legal bulwark not only for planned obsolescence, but also for a business model based on selling cheap platforms and then charging an enormous markup to a captive market for accessories. If you've ever remarked on how expensive toner cartridges or glucometer testing strips are, you can thank “intellectual property” for it. It's odd that the so-called “Free Trade Agreements” promoted by so many professed “free traders” focus so disproportionately on provisions for stricter enforcement of patents and copyrights. IP plays exactly the same protectionist role for global corporations that tariffs did for the old national industrial economies. Patents and copyrights are barriers, not to the movement of physical goods, but to the diffusion of technique and technology. The one, as much as the other, constitutes a monopoly of productive capability. “Intellectual property” enables the transnational corporation to benefit from the moral equivalent of tariff barriers, regardless of where it is situated. In so doing, it breaks the old link between geography and protectionism. With an American tariff on a particular kind of good, the corporations producing that good have a monopoly on it only within the American market. With the “tariff” provided by a patent on the industrial technique for producing that good, the same corporations have an identical monopoly in every single country in the world that adheres to the international patent regime. “Intellectual property,” just as much as the tariff, is a form of protectionism in that it restricts the right to produce a given good for a particular market area to a privileged class of firms." Source: http://c4ss.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/Political-Economy-of-Waste.pdf http://c4ss.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/Political-Economy... -- Your argument that patent systems already existed does nothing to critique the systems, or the dynamics of the systems, themselves. Instead of accepting things on face value or because an authority has made a claim, I am trying instead to find out the story of how it came to be. I am not arguing that we should not have any system at all. I strongly disagree however that the existing systems are as harmless as you make them out to be. When you say it "just standardized some aspects" it brushes under the rug any nuance of the underlying mechanics of these systems.
- api 6y agoTrue, but find me a member of the Fortune 500 that does not do this kind of thing.
- BbzzbB 6y agoNot sure why you're getting downvoted. It's true that it doesn't make it any less immoral, but at the end of the day companies will seek to lower their costs, after all it is their mission, hence this (major) problem is political and shouldn't depend on corporations good will.
- giarc 6y agoGovernments have to close this loophole. A CEO is going to be quickly ousted if they suggest not taking advantage of the well known tactic. For one it means less money in the pockets of shareholders but also reduces the ability to compete if all other companies are paying little to no tax. Until governments step in, nothing will change.
- api 6y agoThis is the nature of regulation in general. Without it anyone who does shady stuff gains a massive advantage.
- sneak 6y agoPaying the minimum in tax allowed by law to reserve the maximum amount of money possible for pursuing your own social or charitable goals is not immoral. The government is not a charity (indeed, Apple HQ’s government uses some fraction of their tax revenues to conduct mass murder) and to argue that anyone is immoral for not paying more tax than is specified by the law is an argument against the rule of law in society. If you don’t like the laws, take it up with your lawmakers, or with the concept of representative government or democracy in general, NOT those who explicitly comply with the law, and indeed spend millions on staff (and their payroll taxes) to ensure that they do.
- 6y ago
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoOr even "... barely taxed in Ireland"
- valuearb 6y agoApple pays taxes in every country it does business in. The remaining profits it keeps in Ireland because of the low tax rate, otherwise if returned to the US it would be taxed again. US international corporate taxation works like this if you repatriate profits to dividend to shareholders: 1) First pay taxes on profits in each country the profits were made. 2) Out of the remainder pay state corporate income tax in the US state you are headquartered in. 3) out of remainder pay federal corporate income tax. 4) out of remainder shareholder pays state income tax. 5) out of remainder shareholder pays federal dividend tax. Typically the shareholder is able to keep about 30-40% of their share of the original profits after they go through the five layers of taxation.
- DSingularity 6y agoSeriously? 30-40? Is that accurate!?
- Terretta 6y agoLess if you include sticker price then deduct VAT.
- valuearb 6y agoFollowing is roughly accurate from memory. Worldwide, Corporate tax rates by country range between 5-55%, but typically are between 20-30%. US Corporate tax rate is now 20%. State corporate tax rates range from zero (NV) to 10%. State income tax rates range from zero to 11%. Federal dividend rates range from 15-20%. Using the the best case scenario (no state income or corporate tax, foreign corporate tax of 5%) gives a total effective tax rate of 35%. Using more typical rates (8% state income/corporate, 25% foreign) produces a total tax rate of 58%. So looks like I was pessimistic, probably because my from memory numbers didn’t include Trump tax cut. But a worst case scenario (France 35%, CA 9%, Dividend 20%) still produces a 65% total effective tax rate.
- stingrae 6y agoIsn't this only for revenue generated in the European Union?
- the_h1b1 6y ago“Designed by American Apple in California. Assembled by Taiwanese Foxconn in India.”
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Shivetya 6y agoApple truly needs to get out of China, the amount of virtue signalling they do comes up sour considering their current manufacturing being heavily based in China. Look, I am all for corporations playing the good guy and standing up for what is right but you don't get a Get Out of Jail Free card with just a message, actions speak louder. This could be more along the lines of alarmist chatter but should the US get a new President China's best opportunity to act on some of its threats to Hong Kong and Taiwan is after February 2021. Guarantee they took the lesson to heart about how Crimea and Ukraine were handled with effectively little more than hash tag diplomacy.
- dan-robertson 6y agoI don’t think the dependence for manufacturing is sufficient to explain all the pressure Apple faces in China. Even if they were to move all manufacturing (not just final assembly) out of China they would still want to sell iPhones to the Chinese. The cynic in me would suppose that the move is merely in case there is a backlash against anything “made in China” by western consumers/governments, but maybe Apple really are trying to reduce dependence on China or just cut costs. In China I expect Apple to be just as craven as ever.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoApple USA and Apple China are, in a sense, different companies, even if they're owned by the same shareholders. If they're manufacturing for the USA market in China, it gives China leverage over Apple USA and not just Apple China.
- throw776432 6y agoIf that’s your reason, then Apple would need to move to Switzerland. India has its own atrocities with Kashmir, Pakistan, recently Nepal, and their discriminatory Citizensip policy.
- saagarjha 6y agoSome of their products already say "Vietnam" on them, particularly accessories.