15 ms·
You advocate a ________ approach to calendar reform (2013)
- isidor3 6y ago> having one or two days per year which are part of no month is stupid > having one or two days per year with no day of the week is asinine These don't sound like real reasons to me. If it costs having a 13th month with just a few days in it or a NO_DAY_OF_WEEK constant in my DAYS_OF_WEEK enum, I'd take it if it meant all of the weirdness was limited to a few days always located at the end of the year. Sounds like a convenient place to put leap seconds as well! While you're at it, make those days holidays for most people, so that when tech inevitably breaks due to the weirdness, those of us who get paged for such things can fix them in peace before the rest of the world starts back up a few days later.
- msla 6y ago> These don't sound like real reasons to me. They are if you have to write date-handling code or, worse, use the date-handling code of others. Date-handling code is hard enough without NULLs.
- ketzu 6y agoThis does not only concern code, but regulation, tradition, contracts etc. The mutual understanding of weeks, days, months of roughly equal lengths is baked into a lot of our things and it's not enough to change it in some header file/law to clean up the rest.
- twic 6y agoThe Romans at one point had a setup where a year was 38 8-day weeks plus a bunch of days over winter when nobody is up to much so there's no point having weeks. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nundinae https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nundinae
- kibwen 6y ago> your name for the thirteenth month is questionable In my plan for twelve 30-day months, I intended to call the leftover 5/6 days "Etcember", for et cetera. :P (This submission appears to be a riff on the classic "Programming Language Checklist": https://www.famicol.in/language_checklist.html https://www.famicol.in/language_checklist.html )
- LeoPanthera 6y agoWhich in turn is a riff on the "spam solutions" checklist: https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt
- pjscott 6y agoI remember seeing that posted often, back when email spam was a big problem, and it always bothered me. Whenever people were discussing possible fixes, someone would post that checklist -- and you could always find some way to apply the checklist, even if it was just by invoking the generic "Eternal arms race involved in all filtering approaches" objection. Every sophisticated person knew that the email spam problem was intractable. Your inbox would always be full of spam, and it was considered foolish to think otherwise. I haven't had much spam hit my inbox lately, though. So much for the checklist.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- new_realist 6y agoA time scheme in which sunrise is always at same time (skewing the clock by a few seconds or minutes every day at three a.m.) is likely a boon to human health. Smart watches and Alexa/Siri take care of time zone calculations. The fact that two dimensional time zones skew a bit more at the poles is a silly reason to dismiss the idea. The poles are weird for a bunch of other reasons and no time works there.
- gberger 6y agoAnalog watches would all be rendered useless.
- gizmo686 6y ago> coordinating geographically dispersed events would become nearly impossible > I shouldn't need to adjust my wristwatch every few miles > many clocks do not have line-of-sight to GPS satellites > you can't put a GPS chip in a mechanical clock > clocks on planes would literally run backwards There is a reason most timezone offset by hours. It is very convinient for everyone to agree on the time when ignoring the most significant digits. Otherwise, you end up having meetings start at 17 past the hour, and be much harder to mentally calculate the offset. You would also need to know the location of the other party much more presicily. At the moment, I know how to offset my schedule when planning a meeting with a customer in Texas.
- TylerE 6y agoIn fact, historically time WAS just set in each location, at local noon. This was done away with by the railroads because it made scheduling a complete nightmare. The first use of "Standard Time" was by the Great Western Railway in the UK. Even in a relatively small country like the UK - only about 100 miles wide in most places - that was still enough to shift "local" noon by about 15 minutes.
- dwighttk 6y agoDepending on which part of Texas. El Paso is in Mountain time.
- 6y ago
- irrational 6y agoIf the USA can’t convert to metric, despite passing laws to that affect, my belief that the world will adopt a new calendar system is less than non-existent.
- hinkley 6y agoI hate to scapegoat, but there are a bunch of odd things the US does because boomers like things the way they've always been. Why were a bunch of new Christmas songs written 60 years ago and barely a song a decade has been added to the repertoire since? George Michael is dead, and Mariah Carey seemed touch and go for a while, and those are pretty much the last two people to create a successful Christmas song (and the less said about Do They Know It's Christmas, the better)
- gizmo686 6y agoUS copyright terms: 1978+: Author's life + 70 years. 95 years if work-for-hire 1967-1977: 95 years 1924 - 1963: 28 years if never renewed. Maximum 95 years. Pre-1924 - All copywrights have expired
- munk-a 6y agoUS copyright terms: Pre-Mickey Mouse: Expired Post-Mickey Mouse: Copyrighted for eternity.
- dhosek 6y agoDisney finally gave up that fight. Barring a last minute lobbying effort, Steamboat Willie will be in the public domain on 1 January 2023. Of course the trademarks on Mickey Mouse will be valid in perpetuity.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Barring a last minute lobbying effort, There's always a last-minute lobbying effort.
- annoyingnoob 6y ago> having one or two days per year which are part of no month is stupid There are some valid points in there but this kind of thing is not productive. No need to be rude.
- evan_ 6y agohow about we just do away with months altogether. One or two days per year that aren't in a month would be weird but 365ish days should be fine, right?
- annoyingnoob 6y agoI'm referring to the name calling. I'm not looking to change any dates or calendars. I found this approach of 'old man screaming at cloud' while name calling offensive. You don't need to be condescending to make a point - and that is my point. This person shared this rant and I gave feedback about the rant, not the subject of the rant.
- ddevault 6y agoNewcomers to qntm.org are advised to browse around a bit. There's some great stuff here. Here's one: https://qntm.org/responsibility https://qntm.org/responsibility
- qntmfred 6y agoqntm's work is indeed quite excellent and highly recommended (no relation)
- sdiupIGPWEfh 6y agoBrings back memories of reading "Fine Structure" while it was still a work in progress on Everything2. "Ed stories" was great too. Looks like there's a lot to catch up on. And then there's https://qntm.org/hatetris https://qntm.org/hatetris
- creade 6y agoThe Antimemetics Division series on SCP is great http://www.scp-wiki.net/antimemetics-division-hub http://www.scp-wiki.net/antimemetics-division-hub
- guerrilla 6y agoAm I supposed to be able to select an option?
- evan_ 6y agoThe premise is that this would be pasted in its entirety into a reply to a usenet or listserv post, with the text of the appropriate line- or lines- modified from "( )" to "(x)". The implication is that amateur calendarists, who do not fully grasp the enormity of the task, frequently post to this list with proposals for a new calendar. The regular contributors to this list see so many ill-conceived proposals that they have prepared a post with all of the common mistakes and oversights so they may shoot the theory down without having to type them all over again. In reality this list is prepared and posted as a joke for the members of the community and a deterrent to posting calendar proposals at all, at least those that do not consider all of these common errors ahead of time.
- zzo38computer 6y agoWhat is the newsgroup for writing calendar proposals?
- staycoolboy 6y agometric. all hail the kiloday.
- TMWNN 6y agoIn Vernor Vinges A Fire Upon the Deep (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Fire_Upon_the_Deep#Time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Fire_Upon_the_Deep#Time), the future human civilization uses [kilo|mega|giga]seconds as time units because nothing else makes sense in an environment where Earth is long gone and hibernating for years or decades between planetary visits is common. (Beyond being great novels, the above and its prequel, A Deepness in the Sky, have points of interest to Unix and Usenet users.)
- jaggederest 6y agoA year is 31.54 megaseconds, who needs months :)
- iso947 6y agoMonths are fine. Leap years are fine. It’s leap seconds that annoy me.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> Leap years are fine. It’s leap seconds that annoy me. The implementation of leap seconds is obviously worse than the implementation of leap years, though. (This might make more sense if leap seconds had come first...) In a leap year, February 28 is followed by February 29, a day that doesn't ordinarily exist. It has the same weight as any other day. If you had a dentist appointment on the 29th, then on March 3rd people will all happily admit that the 29th happened and you might have had a dentist appointment on that day. In a leap second, 23:59:59 is followed by 23:59:59 2, 23:59:59 Harder. Then, a few seconds later, everyone agrees to just pretend the whole thing never happened. The POSIX standard specifies that there are 86400 seconds in a day, and God forbid we deviate from the standard just because some days might -- but only in reality! -- have 86401 seconds.
- hinkley 6y agoBecoming a Class 2 stellar civilization so that we can alter the orbit and rotation of the earth to be exactly 365 days, 24 hours.
- Razengan 6y agoMust a calendar only represent the physical positions of heavenly bodies? What happens after we propagate to other planets? Why should there be only one calendar? Why can’t we have, say, a Social Calendar alongside a Astronomical Calendar? We could have a sane, logical calendar with even and regular divisions for determining working days, holidays, financial calculations and political durations etc. And there could be another calendar for the galactic rotation, orbital period, lunar cycle etc. that only people who need to care about such things would use (astronomers, farmers).
- Ruthalas 6y agoI tend to agree with the concept, but you'd probably have to address holidays that are season-specific. Perhaps 'Christmas is always in the third winter time-block', or something to that effect.
- Razengan 6y agoYes, “floating” holidays are already a thing, so some of them would just have to be tied to the astronomical calendar instead of the social calendar.
- rodgerd 6y ago() Your solution shows you don't understand hemispheres or seasons.
- Razengan 6y ago() Your solution shows you don't understand hemispheres or seasons. I don't. Who does?? When was the last time a city dweller needed to worry about where the Earth or moon was? Things we do need to know: • How many days in a row do I have to work • When do I get my next paycheck • When is X product coming out • How long do we have to put up with X politician • When should I plan a vacation • When will it get colder or warmer Except for maybe the last 2 questions, all of the above can be answered by a calendar that has nothing to do with astronomy whatsoever. Farmers and scientists can continue to use the astronomical calendar of their choice. Perhaps make one that is specifically designed for them, in maybe a S%.M% format, where S% is the percentage of Earth's solar orbital period we are currently at, and M% is the moon's orbit. For the rest of us ordinary folk, we would be fine with a "Human Calendar" that is simply a cycle of working days <-> weekends, with some holidays thrown in every N weeks. Say a 4/2 or 4/3 (work/rest) day week, 4 weeks in a Human Month, and an 8-10 day holiday every 3 such months. A Human Year could be the equivalent of 9 or 10 months of the current calendar, the average duration a new person takes from conception to birth. :)
- every 6y agoI've played this game twice: https://every.sdf.org/Geekish/sol13cal.txt https://every.sdf.org/Geekish/sol13cal.txt https://every.sdf.org/Geekish/lunasolcal.txt https://every.sdf.org/Geekish/lunasolcal.txt
- zzo38computer 6y agoI like the solar hijri calendar (not to be confused with the lunar hijri). Better than anno domini would be a anno mundi system, but to make a new scientific anno mundi system rather than the old way, due directly to the Earth going around the Sun, because that is how the year is considered, so to count years starting from that, too. For time keeping, use local time based on mean solar time, with no daylight saving time (I hate daylight saving time), with 12:00 being mean solar noon. Perhaps make half hour time zones. Continue using UTC with a "Z" suffix when you need to use the time that isn't local time (and if you do need to explicitly note local time, you can use a "J" suffix, or use the + and - and number of hours if you need to specify the timezone explicitly too). My idea for dealing with leap seconds in Unix time is to allow the number of nanoseconds to exceed one billion during a leap second; at all other times, the number of nanoseconds is less than one billion. Don't be over-civilization. My ideas do perhaps have some (maybe most, or even all) of the problems mentioned in that document, but nevertheless, this is my ideas.
- patrickthebold 6y agoI'm a big proponent of continuous time zones, so that noon drifts ever so slightly as position changes. Seems like a no-brainer to me.
- cecilpl2 6y agoDefinitely a no-brainer, I'd say.
- 0-_-0 6y agoAbsolutely. No brain whatsoever.
- defen 6y ago(x) I shouldn't need to adjust my wristwatch every few miles
- Arcorann 6y agoAlready addressed: https://qntm.org/continuous https://qntm.org/continuous Suffice to say, we stopped doing that in the 19th century for very good reasons.
- taveras 6y agoIf you are interested in calendar reform and enjoy world history, the French Revolutionary calendar is fascinating to read about. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Republican_calendar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Republican_calendar
- dhosek 6y agoI used to use a bastardized version of this on our team calendar on the whiteboard at work (just the month/year, ignoring the fact that French Republican months don't correspond neatly to Gregorian months). I was able to get away with it because the month/year were not really functional parts of the calendar. I doubt I could have gotten the team to fully adopt the French Republican calendar, although it would have been fun to try.
- 082349872349872 6y agoI'm trying to imagine the hacker equivalent of the republican calendar's Wheezy, Sneezy and Freezy; Slippy, Drippy and Nippy; Showery, Flowery and Bowery; Hoppy, Croppy and Poppy. Maybe one season would have months named CacheInvalidation, NamingThings, and OffByOne? More seriously, what's wrong with Year-Week-Day? (I propose this having been in an industry where I regularly received swag calendars marked with week numbers, YMMV.)
- msla 6y agoYour next Death March might have lead to a Thermidorian Reaction.
- avs733 6y agoI'm surprised to see no mention in here of the international fixed calendar [0](sometimes called the 'Kodak calendar'). Kodak adopted it in part because Georgia Eastman (founder) was a big proponant, but also because for corporate scheduling the regularity made things like maintenance and long run chemical/manufacturing processes simpler to plan. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Fixed_Calendar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Fixed_Calendar
- fellowniusmonk 6y agoThe disadvantages listed are pretty are pretty much nothing.
- Arcorann 6y ago(2013) Previous discussion (the only substantial one at any rate): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11193152 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11193152 The main problem with calendar reform as I see it is that network effects and lock-in mean that unless everyone changes at once it'll never stick. I've long felt that the optimal time for calendar reform was several decades ago -- with increasing computerisation the cost of switching has gone up over time, much faster than any potential benefits.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- efitz 6y agoI advocate a solution similar to proposals floated years ago on alt.pave.the.earth on UseNet. 1. Disintegrate the moon, anyone who has ever advocated for lunar calendars, and anyone who fails to convincingly support this Plan(tm), converting their mass to energy that we can use for productive purposes such as orbital adjustments. 2. Adjust the rotational period of the earth to an aesthetically pleasing multiple of the length of the solar year. Adjust the axial tilt and orbital eccentricity of the earth to eliminate "seasons". 3. Adjust the definitions of time units to aesthetically pleasing multiples of the now-constant solar year and rotational day. Problem solved.
- markrages 6y agoalt.chrome.the.moon forever!
- helsinkiandrew 6y ago> Adjust the axial tilt and orbital eccentricity of the earth to eliminate "seasons". So you’re the guy who wants to kill summer?
- swsieber 6y agoNo, summer will be alive and well in Phoenix, AZ.
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoBut not in Helsinki, Finland if the planet is tilted :-)
- jacobush 6y agoWouldn’t it become tidally locked eventually and thus “hell”?
- kazagistar 6y agoIf we had the ability to make orbital adjustments, I feel like we would have the ability to make rotational adjustments as well to counteract tidal locking.
- nl 6y agoMy favorite calendar disaster was the Swedish calendar[1] between 1700 and 1753. They had a somewhat (?) reasonable plan: In November 1699, the Government of Sweden decided that, rather than adopt the Gregorian calendar outright, it would gradually approach it over a 40-year period. The plan was to skip all leap days in the period 1700 to 1740. Every fourth year, the gap between the Swedish calendar and the Gregorian would reduce by one day, until they finally lined up in 1740. In the meantime, this calendar would not be in line with either of the major alternative calendars and the differences would change every four years. Then war started and they stopped, after starting the process, so they were on their own calendar that no one else in the world used. Then the king decided it was a bad idea, so reverted to the Julian calendar. Then they decided to jump to the Gregorian outright. There's a bunch of other details, like Easter being calculated by one calendar but Easter Sunday by the other. Oh yeah, and they had February 30 one year[2] (which was Feb 29 in a Julian calendar or March 11 Gregorian). And in 1753 they finally sorted it all out by skipping all the days between February 17 and March 1. Good luck writing billing software for that. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_calendar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swedish_calendar [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_non-standard_dates#Swedish_calendar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_non-standard_dates#Swe...
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> Good luck writing billing software for that. How often do you need to bill someone for events that took place 300 years ago?
- nl 6y agoIt's a joke. As is the story it is posted on. Enjoy.
- peterburkimsher 6y agoObligatory link to Falsehoods programmers believe about time: https://infiniteundo.com/post/25326999628/falsehoods-programmers-believe-about-time https://infiniteundo.com/post/25326999628/falsehoods-program...
- sixstringtheory 6y agoI like the solutions that have extra days that don’t fit anywhere else. Those should just be legally recognized paid holidays.
- tom_mellior 6y ago> ( ) by that logic, 2000 was the final year of the Nineties <rant> I'm annoyed by this argument, which came up again at the start of this year in dumb Twitter discussions about whether 2020 marks the beginning of a new decade. 2000 was not the final year of the Nineties. 2000 was the final year of the second millennium, and of the 20th century, and of the tenth decade of the 20th century. The Nineties were the years 1990-1999, the tenth decade of the 20th century were the years 1991-2000. These are different ranges, but we also use different terms to refer to them. There is no logical problem. There is only a problem with the assumption that these different terms "should" refer to the same concept. So did 2020 mark the beginning of a new decade? Yes, it marked the beginning of the decade we might call the Twenty-Twenties. It did not mark the beginning of the third decade of the 21st century; that will be 2021. </rant>
- kstenerud 6y agoAnd yet people will say that 2000 is the beginning of the millenium, and 2020 is the beginning of a decade, because colloquially it's easier and understandable. And no amount of begging, pleading, or berating will change that (although it might get you punched in the face). That pope Gregory XIII neglected to include a year 0 in his calendar doesn't have to condemn us to suffer the mental gymnastics in our daily lives.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> 2020 is the beginning of a decade, because colloquially it's easier and understandable But 2020 is technically the start of a decade, not just informally.
- dTal 6y agoWell, technically every day is the start of a decade.
- chrisseaton 6y agoNo that's what it informally means. Technically, decades start on the first day of a ...0 year, so not all days are the start of a decade.
- bhaak 6y ago> ( ) planetary-scale engineering is impractical I find your lack of vision disturbing. Given that we likely need planetary-scale engineering anyway in the next 50-100 years, getting a few asteroids to nudge the earth’s orbit a bit over a long period of time isn’t that much of a stretch. With asteroid mining it might even pay for itself. Note: I didn’t do any calculations but over millions of years we’ll need to stabilize earth’s orbit anyway, otherwise our calendars will get out of sync even more. Of course we’ll have to deal with the inaccuracies of the Gregorian calendar rather soon, in 7000 to 8000 years.
- jerf 6y ago"I find your lack of vision disturbing." Author does not lack vision: https://qntm.org/destroy https://qntm.org/destroy
- legulere 6y agoI really like the discordian calendar as it replaces chaotic months with regular 73 day long seasons, which are based on numerology. The only thing that was overlooked was the beginning of the year. The day which is the first of the year is pretty arbitrary as well, using the day of winter solstice would make much more sense. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discordian_calendar https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discordian_calendar
- opk 6y agoThe winter solstice isn't even a precise thing. It can be a different day depending on whether you're going by sunset or sunrise for example.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- twic 6y ago> ( ) civil time and solar time have to remain in synch to better than a second No, they don't. Proof of this is that they already aren't: there is a band no more than 15 arcseconds wide in each timezone where it is true, and everywhere outside that, civil time does not correspond to solar time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kwhitefoot 6y agoWhat is the problem for which calendar reform is a solution?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mbar84 6y agoI recently learned that the rate of rotation of the earth depends on how much water vapor is in the atmosphere. I suggest we use this information to turn the earth into a precision time keeping instrument. Instead of regularly adding/removing leap seconds every so often, we geoengineer the atmosphere to increase/decrease the rate of rotation of the earth, so that it on average rotates exactly 86400 SI-Seconds per day.
- geogra4 6y agoToo bad we never seriously adopted the French Republican calendar There's a twitter account that posts wonderful artwork along with the republican day of the week. https://twitter.com/sansculotides https://twitter.com/sansculotides
- egypturnash 6y ago> ( ) having one or two days per year which are part of no month is stupid Are you calling the Ancient Egyptians stupid? I think you are. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egyptian_calendar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egyptian_calendar And the Aztecs. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nēmontēmi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nēmontēmi
- kthejoker2 6y agoTo the author, if he's reading this: Hey Sam512, it's kthejoker from E2, hope you're well!