4 ms·
I wouldn't count Intel out yet. They've been leapfrogged by AMD before, and then caught up. The cycle repeats. Also, do you remember the 90's? There was a prom
by icedchai 6y ago
I wouldn't count Intel out yet. They've been leapfrogged by AMD before, and then caught up. The cycle repeats.
Also, do you remember the 90's? There was a promising 64-bit CPU called the DEC Alpha. Windows once even had an Alpha version. We know how that turned out.
- sparker72678 6y agoARM 64 has a bit of a wider adoption that DEC Alpha ;) I really wish Intel was doing better, and I hope they come back, somehow. The chip world needs good competition.
- AmVess 6y agoThe problem with Intel is that they have been missing important deadlines by massive amounts of time. Their 10nm node was slated to arrive almost 5 years ago. It is still far from mature. TSMC is readying serial production of 5nm (equivalent to Intel 7nm) this year. I wouldn't plan on seeing a 7nm product from Intel in any volume until 2024, and I wouldn't place money on that as a bet.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- waheoo 6y agoSo? They have a runway, yes, but it's a freakin long one. They have a massive warchest and a crapload of market share that isn't going to go away overnight. Id put money on them already having a new operation crush well underway by this point.
- ArkVark 6y agoIntel has been hollowed out by contractors and H1B workers. I don't think the raw talent is there anymore. The company is just running on inertia. AdoreTV has a video on the topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=agxSclh27uo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=agxSclh27uo
- Throwawayaerlei 6y agoIn addition, many years of using stack ranking to fire 10% or sometimes more of its employees each year, which we know from other examples like Microsoft catastrophically damages a company in many ways, including loss of many of your best employees.
- wenc 6y agoI remember the DEC Alpha. Intel (and HP) countered with Itanium, which was a break from (i.e. incompatible with) the x86 architecture (IA64). It tanked. AMD created AMD64 which was x86 compatible. They released chips like the Athlon which were very popular. This turned out to be the winning strategy. In a strange twist, Intel was forced by the market to adopt the AMD64. It released it's own version, Intel64. Intel messed up there too in the 90s too. It wasn't until the Core CPU roadmap that Intel regained its lead. There seems to be a link -- Jim Keller [1] was involved in the design of DEC Alpha chips, and then moved to AMD to work on the K8 and then co-wrote the AMD64 instruction set. He also worked on Apple's chips and Tesla's HW. He recently just left Intel. What a career. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Keller_(engineer) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Keller_(engineer)
- burnte 6y ago> It released it's own version, Intel64. Well, they licensed AMD's and CALLED it their own.
- garmaine 6y agoIt was their own implementation.
- ivalm 6y agoWas it ever understood why Keller left intel recently?
- thu2111 6y agoNo. The announcement was the usual platitudes. We can infer from the unexpected and apparently sudden nature that there was some bust-up or dispute but nobody knows why. The interview with Fridman may offer a bit of insight. Keller is a firm believer in Moore's Law, that it'll continue for a long time yet. He believes you have to redesign things nearly from scratch on a regular basis, to benefit from this firm progress. Intel, meanwhile, is struggling with Moore's Law. First 10nm, now this. Backporting architectures to older nodes. It may be that Keller realised how deep the production issues went (perhaps he learned that 7nm was starting to fail too) and concluded he wasn't going to be able to achieve what he wanted to achieve when constrained by Intel's fabs.
- nl 6y agoBut Intel has better node processes in the 90s than DEC/Sun/AMD/HP, even when AMD had a better architecture compared to the Pentium 4. I think this is the first time they are behind on both process and chip architecture at the same time.
- btian 6y agoWasn't it because DEC Alpha targeted the workstation market while Intel disrupted them with PCs? The story is in "Innovator's Dilemma". Today Intel is facing the same problem DEC faced, that they make most of their money from workstations and datacenter hardware, while facing disruptive innovation that is ARM If Clayton Christensen is correct, then Intel is dead in the water
- gameswithgo 6y agocycles do bot always repeat
- rbanffy 6y agoTimes are different now. When Alpha launched, proprietary software was the de-facto standard. Windows ran on it, but Office didn't. Neither did a huge number of popular Windows desktop applications. Alpha was reduced to a limited role in servers where the lack of software wasn't an issue and performance was important enough companies procured hardware that would be harder to remission. Alpha lived on for a good couple years running OpenVMS and Tru84 proprietary enterprise OSs and, for some lucky people, Linux. Now most mission-critical software is one recompilation away from running on ARM. Or POWER, or RISC-V, or SPARC (for now). That AWS offers ARM-based servers is seen as a non-issue. I run the same workloads on x86, ARM and s390x and they all feel the same (except that z15 hardware is ridiculously fast). If tomorrow someone comes up with cloud servers based on RISC-V or MIPS that are competitive in price/performance with x86 and ARM, I see an easy migration path between these architectures. In terms of mobile, that's the same. If tomorrow someone releases an Android phone running on RISC-V instead of ARM, that'll be largely irrelevant to most software. On the desktop, Apple (and NeXT) have a couple extremely successful architecture changes under their belt. They should have no problem with this one. Porting was difficult enough that Itanium and Alpha never got much Windows software and, therefore, were relegated to small niches, with servers and single-purpose workstations. It seems Microsoft made it right this time and that porting Windows software to ARM is easy and seamless. We'll see what happens.