4 ms·
I disagree I think personal abuse is always wrong. You can deal with even the most extreme situations and even the worst people while still being respectful.
by chrisseaton 6y ago
I disagree I think personal abuse is always wrong.
You can deal with even the most extreme situations and even the worst people while still being respectful.
- pavel_lishin 6y agoYou can, but you ain't gotta. Not everyone deserves our respect, especially not those calling for ethnic cleansing.
- IgorPartola 6y agoHonest question: do you believe everyone deserves respect no matter what they do? I am all for keeping things civil as much as possible and keeping conversations polite. But to me respect is earned, not a given.
- chrisseaton 6y agoA basic standard of respect, yes. You can think someone isn't good at their job, or that they're mistaken, or that they make bad choices. But there's never any reason to resort to using personal abuse.
- IgorPartola 6y agoSo if you are in a building held hostage by a terrorist they deserve your basic respect? You’d never use violence or abuse against them? Or a mugger? Or a Nazi camp guard? Or a gay conversion therapist? Or a rapist who violated you? Or someone who falsely accused you of rape? Or someone who murdered someone you love?
- eplanit 6y agoMeh. When a person identifies with a stupid idea (i.e. "I'm a flat earther"), then the person is stupid along with the idea, and it's okay to say so (IMHO). It's good for evolution to give such "corrections".
- TeaDrunk 6y agoI think it’s possible to approach all situations respectfully but that the difficulty bound to do so varies depending on the parties and position being discussed. At some point and some edge cases it’s extremely unfair to expect polite responses. (Eg. Blaming a Black person for responding “fuck off” to a white person who says “lynching was good actually it keeps blacks in their place” is distinctly unfair to the black person as they are then expected to take and accept dehumanization and abusive language without responding as if they’ve been dehumanized or abused).
- bluecalm 6y agoInsulting someone is not abuse or at least shouldn't be. It's only abuse if you have power over someone and your insults cause them to experience social repercussions.