6 ms·
He didn't get banned for saying the earth was not flat, he was banned for calling people morons and idiots. I'm as much opposed to flat earthers as any person
by jeroenhd 6y ago
He didn't get banned for saying the earth was not flat, he was banned for calling people morons and idiots.
I'm as much opposed to flat earthers as any person here, but calling people with questionable beliefs idiots and morons only serves to make you feel better about yourself.
You can explain the ridiculousness of flat earth conspiracy without resorting to insults and you won't get banned as easily.
- TulliusCicero 6y ago> He didn't get banned for saying the earth was flat, he was banned for calling people morons and idiots. No he didn't? > Long story short, I called a few people idiots and a few others morons. I got a warning about that, acknowledged it, and stopped referring to the people who believe the earth is flat as idiots and morons. > After my warning, I was an excellent Quora user. I was courteous, even to people who completely disregard science, and I watched my language. Don’t get me wrong — I still interacted with flat earthers and I still told them they were wrong. I just sought not to violate the Quora Policies and Guidelines as I did it. > But it seems as if my answers angered the flat earthers, no matter how courteous I was. Sounds like the banning came long after he ceased insulting people.
- CJefferson 6y agoThe thing he was banned for was linking to an article he wrote which claimed "... Team Flat Earth will be shown to be the moronic fools they indeed are". I mean, I agree that Team Flat Earth are moronic fools, but if you've agreed to be polite that isn't it.
- throwaway_pdp09 6y agoIf possible, I find it always worthwhile sitting down with people who hold odd views and try to understand them. Maybe not even directly (why the earth is flat) but the underlying reason (anti-science? ignorance? desire to be part of a special out-group?). Plain stupidity may not be the real story. Edit: sheer stupidity is not out of the question of course.
- BrandoElFollito 6y agoWhy do you think it is worthwhile? For your general culture/curiosity?
- throwaway_pdp09 6y agoUnderstanding other people. First, it's plain interesting to discover if they hold the view with some merit instead of stupidity[0]. Second, I guess it's polite to listen when you can, and my manners could do with some improving. Third and perhaps most compelling, the better you understand them the better you might be able to counter their arguments. Fourthly, in the rare event they actually can make a solid case case for their side, you may learn something important. [0] Yesterday (FYI I'm in the UK) there was a discussion in a shop by staff with a woman who didn't want to wear a face mask (they are compulsory starting today, yesterday they were not). She said they didn't help to protect you from covid so she didn't see why she should. I told her that was true but they weren't intended to protect you from viruses, they were to prevent infected people from spreading it to others. It was clear from her reaction she hadn't known this. Therefore she made up her mind without doing the least research. That's stupidity.
- BrandoElFollito 6y ago> Understanding other people I used to do that too - with religion. Then I stopped because I believe that there are fundamental differences between rational and irrational people. The volume is on the side of the irrational ones, so I gave up. I am better off avoiding these subjects now, as nobody ever convinced anybody. > Therefore she made up her mind without doing the least research. That's stupidity I am French and our news (following official governmental information) told us that masks are useless, then dangerous, then somehow useful, then life-saving. Someone who is not that interested in the subject may have heard one of these opinions. I am in the same boat when it comes to climate change and Brexit. There are zillions of opinions, but none of the ones I heard are clear cut. I have a PhD in physics so I love numbers and equations. I am also painfully rational and yet I hear that the climate is warming globally, but this doe snot mean that this is visible on the small scale of my city, and then that in average the temperature of seas is raising, but the sea during my vacation is still cold. And why it matters that +2° here or there makes a difference. Same for Brexit: this is an economic disaster, or a godsend - depending on whom you listen to. But nobody gives actual numbers. When I look at the EU budget, I see that the UK is a net payer. So UK leaving is bad for us, good for them. Except that it si not, because something. I am not an expert in climate and in economy. And I do not want to be. I am open to having a well bundled rational set of information (and consequences) - it is just that I do not see them. For things like Brexit or climate change, they should be stuffed into my eyes daily. When people start to wave hands instead of giving a few accurate and unbiased numbers, I conclude that they simply do not know, or are not sure. BTW, the best, understandable argument about climate change was given to me by, who else, xkcd: https://xkcd.com/1732/ https://xkcd.com/1732/, https://xkcd.com/1379/ https://xkcd.com/1379/ and a few others.
- dang 6y agoI can tell you from years of experience that people make up all kinds of stories about why they were banned. Often the stories are very convincing to third parties. That's not surprising, because they're designed to be. The thing to check is whether there are links to the original posts, which would allow readers to make up their own minds. If the "$site banned me for $outrageous-can-you-believe-it-reason" story is linkless, odds are that salient details have been omitted. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20readers%20own%20minds%20link&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- TulliusCicero 6y agoThat's a plausible explanation, but so is "enough people reported me that I got autobanned". For an equivalent, there are some subreddits that auto remove/lock threads if they get reported enough.
- CJefferson 6y agoIn particular, he admits he was originally insulting, but then was "polite". Turns out his definition of politeness (from his own blog post he linked to) is saying "... Team Flat Earth will be shown to be the moronic fools they indeed are". I personally agree Team Flat Earth are moronic fools, but I haven't promised to be polite to them.
- giantDinosaur 6y agoPoliteness doesn't mean you aren't insulting them. 'Moronic fools' is a fairly polite insult.
- TeaDrunk 6y agoIn this case he was already warned for calling people morons, then he called people moronic fools. Surprised pikachu face?
- giantDinosaur 6y agoI find it far more insulting, despite being perfectly polite, for people to insist the Earth is flat, than for someone to dismiss them with what is, essentially, an accurate descriptor. I am utterly insulted at the waste of intellectual space and the energy expended in these useless debates when people who lived two thousand years ago had pretty much settled it.
- pcmaffey 6y agoI believe flat earthers are intentionally weaponizing their ignorance as an act of rebellion. So yes in that case it is meant to be insulting, just nit anything to take personal.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- m1117 6y agoMoronic fools deserve some respect!
- jbob2000 6y agoWe're in strange times if you can't call a flat-earther an idiot and a moron. What's next, I can't call a Nazi a piece of shit? There are objectively correct times to use insults, this is definitely one of them.
- chrisseaton 6y agoI disagree I think personal abuse is always wrong. You can deal with even the most extreme situations and even the worst people while still being respectful.
- pavel_lishin 6y agoYou can, but you ain't gotta. Not everyone deserves our respect, especially not those calling for ethnic cleansing.
- IgorPartola 6y agoHonest question: do you believe everyone deserves respect no matter what they do? I am all for keeping things civil as much as possible and keeping conversations polite. But to me respect is earned, not a given.
- chrisseaton 6y agoA basic standard of respect, yes. You can think someone isn't good at their job, or that they're mistaken, or that they make bad choices. But there's never any reason to resort to using personal abuse.
- IgorPartola 6y agoSo if you are in a building held hostage by a terrorist they deserve your basic respect? You’d never use violence or abuse against them? Or a mugger? Or a Nazi camp guard? Or a gay conversion therapist? Or a rapist who violated you? Or someone who falsely accused you of rape? Or someone who murdered someone you love?
- 6y ago
- raverbashing 6y agoI disagree Being too sensitive with morons is what's causing the most trouble in this pandemic. Because apparently some snowflakes can't put on a mask without fainting and help stop the spread of the disease. Because they can't do anything to help and act mostly in ways that are completely self-centered. So no, let's start calling things for what they are and act accordingly. People know the Earth is not flat since 2000BC, period.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoI don't think that calling mask skeptics morons or any other forms of ungentleness are likely to help. I can't think of any instances where large minorities have been convinced of their wrongs by mean talk from the majority. What would actually help is a commencement of sensible policy at the top. Another thing that would help is an enforcement scheme with teeth. It is incorrect to pass laws about important topics then decline to enforce them rigorously. But I think insults are not on the list of helpful things.
- pcmaffey 6y agoShame has been used to police human behavior throughout history. See: all religions.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoI do not dispute this. I think shame works in small communities, but not over the internet.
- gus_massa 6y agoIt is usually shame with the implicit threat of ostracism with the implicit threat of burning the witch at the stake.
- castlecrasher2 6y agoWhen were you ever convinced you were wrong because you were called an idiot by someone who disagreed with you? It simply breeds resentment.
- scarface74 6y agoThey are idiots. Why tip toe around and try to spare someone’s feelings who express statements that are provably false and should be known by someone who has enough of an education to read? It’s not like a difference of opinion between supply side and demand side economics.
- jeroenhd 6y agoNobody will listen to you if you call people morons, no matter how dumb they act. If you want to convince people not to believe these conspiracy theories, you need to come across as intelligent. You can call their theories moronic and idiotic (with some proper scientific backup), but when you call people that, you only reduce your credibility.
- minikites 6y agoAnd how well does it work when we're nice to them? How many people can be reasoned away from an unreasonable belief?
- luckylion 6y ago> And how well does it work when we're nice to them? Very. But people who call them idiots don't want to convince them, they want to ridicule them to signal their own superiority to other people who also know the earth isn't flat. It's like teenagers bullying younger kids to show off. They don't want to teach those younger kids how to do $whatever, they just want to laugh because they're so great in comparison. If you approach them with empathy instead of insults, you'll usually find them to have specific reasons for their beliefs (a general and deep seated mistrust for "the system" is what I've encountered the most), but aren't actually attached to them that much. It's more of a "fuck you" to everybody who is part of the system that they feel mistreated by, like a rebellious teenager. What might also happen if you approach them with empathy of course, is that people like the person that wrote this article, will make fun of you and call you an idiot for engaging with idiots instead of calling them idiots like you should in his mind.
- scarface74 6y ago