12 ms·
Kharkovchanka – Soviet Antarctic Cruisers [video]
- Torkel 6y agoHere's a twitter thread by a guy who built a nice model of one: https://twitter.com/PeterOlsson/status/1280940641472655367 https://twitter.com/PeterOlsson/status/1280940641472655367
- muro 6y agoThanks for sharing, very good scratch-build on display with the track extension and cabin build.
- dayofthedaleks 6y agoIt also shows interesting deep-nerd cross-pollination in the model building/military history/art scenes.
- jojobas 6y agoLater designs moved the engine outside to reduce noise. I'm not aware of any operational difficulties but I'd rather cope with noise than service a V12 diesel in -60C wind.
- mc32 6y agoYou can’t shut off the engine in that climate, if you do you would need a way to heat it up before restarting so, it’s redundant. In other words if you will anyway need a warmer environment [hangar, large building] to enable the engine to start, there is no point to “fixing it” in the cold as it will not turn over anyway.
- jojobas 6y agoBoth models have auxiliary heaters and later models have generators. There's no warmer environment for thousands of kilometers there, doesn't mean you can't change a belt or oil in the field.
- lstodd 6y agono one ever changes oil in a diesel in those conditions. a belt - maybe, if it breaks. otherwise one just does not shut down the engine, auxillary heaters or not.
- bserge 6y agoDo they even use belts? I imagine it's all internally chained, that way a diesel engine can last well over 100k miles... With oil change or at least top up, however. Mechanical pump/injectors don't even need electricity, just have fuel.
- izacus 6y agoThe documentary says that original expedition swapped a whole 600kg gearbox on a Kharkovchanka when one of them failed. Crew worked for 5 days at less than -50C. So they ceranly did change much more than just belts :)
- nuccy 6y agoWhile looking for more info on Kharkovhanka 2, I found a blog of a russian guy who actually lives on the Vostok station [1]. There is an additional engine+generator inside [2], which is used for heating of the interior, but probably can also be used to heat up the main engine. I was not aware of the fact that all the stations in Antarctic are on the ice actually, so they drift as time passes. There is a map of that [3]. Given the extremely low humidity, non-existing grounding (since the station is on the ice), when there is a blizzard or strong wind outside, snowflake rub themselves, and the station accumulates significant static charge which affects all the equipment. [1] https://pikabu.ru/@deratizator https://pikabu.ru/@deratizator (in russian, but google translate is capable of translating most of the text, except profanity words which appear occasionally to highlight the complexity of life in such climate conditions :) ) [2] https://pikabu.ru/story/kharkovchankaii_5499165 https://pikabu.ru/story/kharkovchankaii_5499165 (still in russian, same blog) [3] https://cs7.pikabu.ru/post_img/big/2017/12/11/7/1512993213138441238.jpg https://cs7.pikabu.ru/post_img/big/2017/12/11/7/151299321313...
- masklinn 6y agoThe pictures are pretty cool. It looks like the cabin of the kharkov II is significantly less insulated than the crew space? The hatch between the two looks as thick as the "external" doors (actual door and transmission hatch). I was also surprised to hear the windows are only double-paned in kharkov, and it doesn't look like model II is any better. Understandable but a bit sad to see how decayed they got, especially if they're still in somewhat active use.
- anonAndOn 6y ago>all the stations in Antarctic are on the ice actually Many of the ones on the peninsula are built on land with some open to visitors! [0]http://www.antarcticglaciers.org/antarctica-2/living-and-working/ http://www.antarcticglaciers.org/antarctica-2/living-and-wor...
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoTwo words: pony motor They've been used since forever to heat and start large engines. Depending on size the pony motor might even produce enough heat when idling to keep the crew cabin warm while you service the main engine. I still wouldn't want to share a box with an old soviet diesel though.
- masklinn 6y ago> They've been used since forever to heat and start large engines. Depending on size the pony motor might even produce enough heat when idling to keep the crew cabin warm while you service the main engine. The much larger problem is that the engine will have seized by the time you're done. In central siberia (oymyakon and friends) locals will keep the engine running from when they leave home (having possibly heated it up by starting a fire under the engine block to thaw it) to when they're back so it doesn't freeze solid. Even the gasoline will start coagulating at the temperatures involved.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoGasoline (I'm not a petroleum engineer so I make no claim about certain additives) is fine down to any earthly temperature. It was used extensively in 1930s antarctic expeditions for this reason. The pony motor can be heated with a gasoline blow torch (yes that's a thing) to start easily. Then it can heat the coolant (and through that coolant the oil and cylinder heads) of the main engine so that the main engine may start easily. Depending on the size of the pony motor it may even be able to provide cabin heat.
- Gibbon1 6y agoMy friend from Alaska took him about 20 years and his wife putting her foot down to give up on the white gas stove for that reason. Diesel trucks often have a diesel powered coolant heater and pump for that reason as well. Turn on the heater and you can shut down the engine knowing it'll start again. And so you still have cabin heat. See random sales website. https://www.webasto-comfort.com/en-us/heating-solutions/off-highway/coolant-heaters/ https://www.webasto-comfort.com/en-us/heating-solutions/off-...
- Torkel 6y agoThe video mentions that this was done because the people in the driver cabin became covered in diesel soot as the sealing between engine and cabin was not 100%.
- jojobas 6y agoYou don't typically see soot dispersed from under the hood of diesel trucks, that would mean leaky exhaust (a big no-no even with external engines). Sure they had their reasons.
- jhayward 6y agoA lot of diesel engines have a certain amount of blow-by, which is exhaust pressurizing the crankcase by bypassing e.g. the piston rings. This can leak out from valve rocker covers, etc.
- lstodd 6y agoYeah like the other comment said, they leak. Especially when it's a tank diesel, not designed for longevity at all. You have to keep in mind that those were just campers thrown on top of a T-55 tank chassis.
- jacques-noris 6y agoGerman Wikipedia says this was done to avoid overheating: "Since September 1975 the further developed Charkowtschanka-2 was built. One of the most important differences was the external cabin, which also facilitated access to the engine and transmission, which were mounted under a classic engine hood and avoided overheating problems."
- mikl 6y agoSuch an interesting machine.
- dayofthedaleks 6y agoI am highly impressed by the production values as well as the research quality here. Edited in an attic studio, facilitated by Google Translate. The YouTube auto transcription is brutally bad with Callum’s Scottish accent, though. Do uploaders have the ability to manually edit subtitles?
- bserge 6y agoI still wonder why many people think colonizing Mars is doable, when we can't even colonize Antarctica. I mean, weather might be slightly better, but the lack of breathable air, water and the distance from Earth far outweigh that. Neither Mars nor Antarctica offer anything of real use, even asteroid capture and mining seems like a more viable idea.
- daveslash 6y agoNot to mention Mars' lack of protective magnetic fields....
- Robotbeat 6y agoIt really is not that important. Solve the atmosphere problem, and the surface radiation levels would be plenty low enough. Additionally, even without a magnetic field, it’d take on the order of 100 million years for Mars to lose an atmosphere if it were terraformed. Earth, due to Sun increasing in temperature, may become uninhabitable in about ~250-500 million years without active measures as well.
- analbumcover 6y agoHumans will be long extinct in 500 million years. That's not really something we need be planning for.
- Robotbeat 6y agoBut our ancestors need not be. Also, that's something of a self-fulfilling prophecy. In order to be a long-lived civilization, species, or even biosphere, we must learn to think and plan far beyond one's own lifespan. Anyway, you're proving my original point about the (lack of a) "need" for a magnetic field. It isn't necessary (on any kind of reasonable timescale), provided you have sufficient atmosphere. On Earth as well, the atmosphere is much more important than the magnetic field for shielding us from space radiation. EDIT:Which isn't to say we couldn't build one. In fact, building a magnetic field for Mars (say, by many parallel superconducting cables around the equator) may be easier than making enough atmospheric pressure.
- 0ld 6y agoa wonder what on earth made the guy pronounce kh as ch
- 0ld 6y agoi was also completely puzzled what the hell "yearny" (or something) meant until i saw мирный on the map god, is it that hard to check up at least the approximate pronunciation of things and places when you are making a video like that?
- cpursley 6y agoI've been studying Russian for several years. The pronunciation of certain letters and letter combinations can be difficult; give people a break. Or at least correct them in a helpful way.
- woobar 6y agoAuthor commented on this: "...the worst thing was (and this is my fault) I consulted with someone who taught me how to pronounce it, but then I sort of reverted back to the wrong pronunciation while I recorded and I’m ashamed to say it was 3am and I just didn’t want to record for the 10th time . I figured if people understood that it was an honest mistake and not me being lazy they might forgive me! Next time I’ll be taking much better care!"
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zoomablemind 6y agoCaptivating documentary. Thanks to the author. Also thanks for staying consistent with pronunciation too. Surprised it would bother the Russian speakers so much at all. Oh, well, the designers back in Ukrainian SSR would not dare to name it in Ukrainian manner either. There seems to be some unintended irony in the naming. There was a popular sedan car Moskvitch [1] (masculine for Moscow resident), and Zaporozhets [2] (masc. for resident of Zaporizhia in Russian). Both of these cities had resp. car factories. However, Kharkiv, had none, instead it had a tractor and tank factory... The product is literally out of the league, so is the name Kharkovchanka (fem. for resident of Kharkiv in Russian) I'd guess the choice of masculine for a car name is in line with masc. for 'automobile' in Russian. Meanwhile, the feminine in this case is, perhaps, for fem. 'machine' in Russian. Just a guess. [1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moskvitch_402 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moskvitch_402 [2]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZAZ_Zaporozhets https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZAZ_Zaporozhets
- noir_lord 6y agoIf you like this stuff check https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=9Mdi_Fh9_Ag https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=9Mdi_Fh9_Ag they most informative and dryly hilarious historian I know is Drachinifel. His stuff is beautifully researched and you can tell it's his passion. I posted that one on HN a while back but it didn't go anywhere. I've listened to it several times entirely because it reminds me of dysfunctional companies so much.
- francis_t_catte 6y agoHahahah, oh man, one of Drach's best. Highly recommend his episode on what to do if your ship is sinking/exploding/disagreeable too: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rbX8rJMI9GM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rbX8rJMI9GM btw, did anyone else see Japanese torpedo boats???
- noir_lord 6y agoOnly in the North Sea. Fun fact, the trawlers they fired on where from my home town and there is a statue to the ones killed not a mile from where I was born, it’s a small world in many ways. The resulting war would have likely changed Europe as well, in 1904 the U.K. was still the pre-eminent global naval power but a dreadnought isn’t a lot of use on the steppes.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoMaybe I'm crazy but wondering if your engine is gonna overheat, field modifying tracks and swapping a gearbox in the middle of nowhere in -40 weather sounds like a fun time.
- amoitnga 6y agoI'm not quite sure why apparently accepted english name for the town is Kharkiv, and author wrongly (understandably) pronounces it as Charkovchanka. Yeah, it's hard - no biggie. just wanted to let those of you who interested to know how to pronounce it is: first 3 characters are same as in word 'harvest' and rest almost the way author pronounces it - kovchanka, so har-kov-chanka only r has to be softer. It just sounds so much better try russian sound -> https://translate.google.com/?rlz=1C5CHFA_enUS806US806&um=1&ie=UTF-8&hl=en&client=tw-ob#auto/ru/harkov-chanka https://translate.google.com/?rlz=1C5CHFA_enUS806US806&um=1&...