7 ms·
I think the biggest disadvantage of a DIY degree is that there's no one requiring you to take classes that don't interest you. Thing is, when I was studying, I
by kstrauser 6y ago
I think the biggest disadvantage of a DIY degree is that there's no one requiring you to take classes that don't interest you. Thing is, when I was studying, I was grossly incorrect about 1) which classes I would come to enjoy, and 2) which subjects I would actually use every day at work. There were lots of things I studied only because someone was making me, but that I found to be incredibly fascinating or useful once I had learned a little about them.
That's the biggest thing I think someone would give up by not pursuing a traditional degree.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoIn my view, the two college topics everyone should take is Physics and Constitutional Law (or equivalent in another country). Both will literally radically change how you look at the world, and provide a foundational basis for conversation in nearly any field.
- aciswhat 6y agoI would add ethics to that list also.
- p1esk 6y agoYou can say the same thing about any single lower undergraduate subject.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoI took a class in Library Science. It didn't change my outlook on anything. It only confirmed my belief in the wastefulness of certain general ed requirements. Economic history didn't do much for me, either. (Now, granted, that could be eye-opening, for at least some people, if taught well and with solid content. But in my case, for that class... meh.)
- p1esk 6y agoIt didn't change my outlook on anything Someone can say this about any single lower undergraduate subject :) p.s. Library Science course would have been an eye-opening experience for me, given my fascination with books and libraries when I was a teenager.
- vonseel 6y agoI’m not sure how fascinating it gets beyond the Dewey Decimal system, lol. There’s probably some cool stuff with document preservation and archiving. But so much of library science seems outdated now that most information is on the internet. What they really need is a better system for internet research, the UIs those systems use last time I worked in a library on a project was terrible.
- agumonkey 6y agoshould we (could we) compress higher education ? I found a lot of redundancy by splitting things in modules. (uml, oop, sql felt like 3 sides of the same hypercoin, granted the first 2 may disappear from books soon). algorithmics and mathematics (and other topics) may be merged into one ? or maybe that would be pedagogically detrimental.. I feel that it would allow more time to spend on a concept since you don't have to see bits scattered in different courses.
- gizmo686 6y agoNo student learns everything that university teaches; there is simply not enough time. It would be ideal if each student received a perfectly customized curriculum; but that is simply not practical to do. Instead, universities have a modular system; where different students can mix and match modules to cover what they are interested in. Similarly, different majors can mix and match required module to cover the material that is nessasary for said majors. In the case of subjects with a very large number of students, it is possible to produce specialized modules, so you might have a university offer a separate probability-for-scientists and probability-for-mathematicians classes that it considers to be interchangable, but differs in how it covers the subject/what background it assumes.
- tsimionescu 6y agoI'm not sure how oop and sql would be the same thing - they are famously incompatible (object/relational impedance mismatch). UML is just a graphical notation, I would agree it doesn't make sense as a separate course. When you say algorithmics and mathematics, do you mean all of computer science and all of maths? Do you think a single course should cover, say, Dijkstra's algorithm and partial differential equations? Usually, each course already covers a wide array of concepts. I can't think of a single concept that was explored by different bits in different courses. The closest I can think of are 2 courses I had, one of which was focused on analytical solutions for linear algebra (matrices), and the other focused on numerical solutions to the same problems. Even then, the split did make sense, since they were focused on different concepts (mathematical objects, their properties and how to work with them in the first case, computation and more applied mathematics solutions for the second).
- 6y ago
- JSavageOne 6y agoCounterpoint: my 2 favorite classes in undergrad were both general education courses - "World Regions" (had a super charismatic professor so wouldn't necessarily recommend this course at any random university) and "Morality & Justice".
- DoofusOfDeath 6y agoDid you really mean "World Regions", or instead "World Religions"?
- gowld 6y agoHageography ;-)
- JSavageOne 6y agoYes "Regions". The course covered geopolitics, current events, etc. The course and professor were famous at the university. The course material itself was interesting because it covered current events in detail, but the real reason for the class's popularity was that the professor was incredibly entertaining. Attending a lecture was sort of like watching an episode of Stephen Colbert, except deeper with more focus on learning than just pure entertainment.
- mcguire 6y ago"Contemporary Moral Problems" with a professor who resembles Captain Kangaroo (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Captain_Kangaroo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Captain_Kangaroo).
- mcguire 6y agoWas Library Science required, or was it a general requirement that you picked Library Science for? (Having a hard time seeing Library Science as a specific requirement.)
- charlesdaniels 6y agoFWIW I completed my undergraduate degree in 2019, and I was required to take library science specifically. It was a half-semester course that taught students how to use the library. I guess the value is it means the students have no excuse to not know how to find library resources, but I feel like most people in the class were generally familiar with the idea of a library and how to use it.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoThis sounds somewhat similar to other "college success" first year courses that are more about how to do research papers than anything else. A proper introduction to Library Science is about how to run a library...
- p1esk 6y agoGood point. It would be an utter disappointment for me to take this class only to sit through explanations on how to find a book in a library (something I was able to do when I was 8).
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoIt filled a general ed slot, I think. Or else I just wanted a super-easy class. It wasn't required. And yes, it really was "how to use a card catalog". (Hey, I'm old. It really was cards.)
- alexbanks 6y agoIf you go into something with a set of beliefs and are only looking to confirm them, you probably won't gain anything.
- frogpelt 6y agoI could say it about Macroeconomics and English 102 but only because I had awesome teachers. I can say that one of my Calculus classes and my other English classes made me want to quit school. The teachers were horrible; either arrogant and condescending or incompetent at teaching (which made us a bad pair because I was an incompetent student at times).
- Aaronstotle 6y agoI think Ethics/Ethical Theory class from a philosophy department should be added as well.
- grandmczeb 6y agoWhy? The engineering department version of ethics was a required class at my undergrad and it was a total waste of time.
- mcguire 6y agoHenry Petroski claims that engineering ethics was founded on the principle that an engineer should not compete with another engineer on the basis of price. A good philosophical ethics class is mostly uncomfortable...
- mnemonicsloth 6y agoAdam Smith: > People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices.
- woolcap 6y agoI found an Anthropology class very eye-opening, helpful to become aware of one's own ethnocentrism. I'd echo the vote for Physics.
- LudwigNagasena 6y agoCan you explain why you think so? I feel it would be a complete waste of time for me to study anything like this in college. And it seems it is an absolutely inadequate foundation for “conversation in nearly any field”.
- rovr138 6y agoThe course I think everyone should take is a logic course. Our philosophy department gave one and it was amazing. They went over fallacies, truth tables, tautology, and other things. I took that with a great professor that wanted you to learn and be able to make strong arguments. You had to be able to break apart anything thrown at you and call out what it was. Everyone would be able to see how others are trying to take advantage. The other is also doable. How to phrase things in a way to get what you want. I think he’d approve...
- PacketPaul 6y agoI think everyone should take statistics and probability. Same reason, to change your world view.
- p1esk 6y agoQuoting the very first sentence: “DIY” CS degree: take the same courses you would at your own school
- Jtsummers 6y agoMy question is: Are those courses actually available in MOOCs? Is the feedback sufficient from the MOOCs for the more technically difficult courses? I cannot imagine taking, for the first time, a course like CS Theory, but maybe a follow-on course, as a MOOC. So much of what we learned was because of feedback during the semester and tailoring to our level by the professor. If you're talking about an online course with 20-40 participants in a cohort with a dedicated instructor/professor, then it could've worked online. But most MOOCs are not set up that way (from what I've participated in). On top of that, lacking discipline, I can't imagine anyone in that class but 3 of us choosing to take it voluntarily if alternatives had been provided.
- legerdemain 6y agoI think computer science is the university subject with the best availability of publicly available online courses. Available courses range across the entire undergraduate curriculum from distributed systems to operating systems to cryptography. The number of different courses available within each area varies a lot, and some only have 1-2 options, but at least they are available. The situation is much more stark in other subjects, such as mathematics. Many upper-division courses aren't available, so the best you can do is find a book for self-guided study.
- p1esk 6y agoI'm pretty sure I'd be much better off had I taken my first course in CS Theory on Udacity [1] or Coursera [2] rather than at UCSB where it was extremely confusing and/or boring. [1] https://classroom.udacity.com/courses/cs313 https://classroom.udacity.com/courses/cs313 [2] https://www.coursera.org/learn/cs-algorithms-theory-machines https://www.coursera.org/learn/cs-algorithms-theory-machines
- elliekelly 6y agoIn a few weeks I'll have completed every MIT course required to earn an undergrad EECS degree minus the physical education credits. It took me about two years. Some of the courses on their OpenCourseware[1] were a bit out of date and I supplemented the MIT courses with a few additional courses from Harvard (I'd read on HN that CS50[2] was worthwhile and was not disappointed) and Stanford[3]. I did not spend even one penny. Then again, I also won't get that very expensive piece of paper we call a "degree" so it's definitely a tradeoff. I'd already paid for several expensive pieces of paper so it didn't seem necessary to me but I can definitely appreciate that having at least one matters. MOOCs give you the same knowledge but they really don't at all give you the same credentials. It's silly but it's reality. Most of the more popular courses have discord or slack where you can work with other participants. A lot of the CS courses have automated the grading of problem sets. CS50 uses GitHub to submit and grade assignments, for example. There were a lot of frustrating moments for sure but I definitely spent a lot more time with the material and learned a lot more than I would have if I had been given more "support" like you get in a typical classroom. There's definitely a tradeoff. It worked great for me but I had a genuine interest in the topics. I'm also 32. I don't think for a second I could have managed to get as much out of MOOCs as an 18-22 year old. A minor complaint given that the superb education cost me exactly $0.00 but there are a lot of really good free courses available but you have to hunt for them. For example Paul Hegarty teaches a really great introductory course on developing for iOS with Swift and it's freely available to everyone but it's not listed on Standford's online catalog and the iTunesU version is woefully outdated. The latest version[4] is available on YouTube and even has a dedicated website. I can't even remember how I found the newer course. I also stumbled across "The Ethics of Technological Disruption"[5] by looking at Stanford's YouTube channel playlists. Like the Swift course, it wasn't listed in the university's catalog of free courses. All that is to say, it's entirely possible, if you're willing to put in the effort not only once you're in the class, but sometimes just to get there as well. [1] https://ocw.mit.edu/index.htm https://ocw.mit.edu/index.htm [2] https://cs50.harvard.edu/x/2020/ https://cs50.harvard.edu/x/2020/ [3] https://online.stanford.edu/search-catalog?free_or_paid%5Bfree%5D=free&type=All https://online.stanford.edu/search-catalog?free_or_paid%5Bfr... [4] https://cs193p.sites.stanford.edu https://cs193p.sites.stanford.edu [5] https://techethics.stanford.edu https://techethics.stanford.edu
- Ologn 6y ago> 1) which classes I would come to enjoy, and 2) which subjects I would actually use every day at work. Another thing that is easy to misgauge - how much work it takes to understand a topic. All told, across several classes, I probably spent a full semester studying mutual exclusion, critical sections, deadlock and so forth. I would not have known it would take several months of study to start getting a handle on that topic - although I see it all the time when debugging an error (created by myself or others) which turns out to be code that has a race condition.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- JSavageOne 6y agoWhich classes ended up being useful to your work that you didn't expect?
- kstrauser 6y ago* Truth tables and Karnaugh maps blew my mind, as did the rest of Boolean math. I loved finding a way to formally think about things I'd vaguely and unrigorously thought about before, and the notion of mathematics without numbers opened my eyes. * I loved political science and sociology classes. I would not have predicted that. * I use my physics classes all the time, but never in ways I would have anticipated. "Hey, I wonder how high we are. Here's a rock we can toss down into that pond. Get your stopwatch!" * I very rarely find myself working with finite state machines, but when I do, it's nice to feel comfortable reasoning about them. * Big-O notation? All the freaking time. That's an enormously powerful tool for thinking about how systems will scale with the number of users, for instance.
- chadcmulligan 6y ago> Truth tables and Karnaugh maps blew my mind, as did the rest of Boolean math Indeed, DeMorgans law is something I use regularly, but many devs don't know it (^A.^B) = ^(A+B) ^A + ^B = ^A.^B
- kstrauser 6y agoThat's an incredibly powerful simplification in the right places. It's so satisfying when you can remove a bunch of "not"s from code and get something that's mathematically identical but a whole lot easier to read. Heh! I also used it recently (and successfully) to argue with a particular vendor whose query language did not respect that transformation. I re-wrote a "not A and not B" expression to "not (A or B)", and the query broke. It was nice to be able to point them to the Wikipedia article and say "no, if your query language doesn't treat those as identical, then it's a bug and would you please fix it now?"
- gowld 6y ago^A + ^B = ^(A.B)
- throwawaygh 6y agoThese articles are essentially an instance of the fallacy that all labor is equivalent. If you are self-motivated and intelligent enough to learn the equivalent of a CS degree on your own, then the upper bound on your career trajectory is often significantly higher than "senior software engineer". So even if you can self-learn, the article is still bad advice. Better advice would be "if you can learn this on your own, maybe aim higher than code monkey jobs". Go ahead and major in CS because it'll be easy and enjoyable and a good fallback. But also pick up a second major in pre-med/pre-law/econ/finance/engineering/etc. Or get involved in research projects, etc. So, yes, this is bad advice for weak students. But it's also often bad advice for strong students, who should be aiming high.
- octaveguin 6y agoThat's not true. Many people can self-learn. Those same people often cannot perform well in school because school is rigid and authoritarian. I'm definitely one of them and my career refutes your idea quite heavily. I'm absolutely not the only one. Doubling down on debt and the system with another advanced degree is dangerous advice. If you cannot self-learn, you find out relatively fast and with little cost. Not true for the above advice.
- throwawaygh 6y ago> Many people can self-learn. Those same people often cannot perform well in school because school is rigid and authoritarian. So... labor isn't uniform? > Doubling down on debt and the system with another advanced degree is anti-advice. Becoming a medical doctor is anti-advice? Is attending Harvard Law or Stanford's CS PhD program also anti-advice? I know this is a tech forum, but jeeze. The lack of appreciation for the world of fulfilling career choices outside pounding out code and managing people who pound out code is a bit concerning. I guess there's a small population of people who aren't good at school but can self-learn how to program. I agree that for those people a DIY CS degree is good advice. However, I also think that there's a substantial intersection between people who would get bored doing generic software dev and people who can self-learn CS.
- unishark 6y ago
- an_opabinia 6y agoWhen was the last time you worked with many CS students versus amateur developers and could really compare? These are shallow takes because they're always reflections on personal experience and not really a view of others. Or when it is about others, it's extremely shallow - this article's take is "is salary times expected employment probability minus degree cost positive" which is basically saying nothing at all. MOOCs like EdX and Coursera have deeply harmed CS degree quality. The most striking evidence for this isn't the crummy completion rate or as you're eluding to, lack of coercion or whatever. It's that in my experience with Harvard and Stanford interns, whose curriculum these MOOCs copy, the quality of the student declines with the number of years they have spent in their institution's CS program. In other words, freshmen and sophomores outperform seniors and just-recent grads! This is crazy, how could that be? By putting everything on rails. In MOOC CS50x and CS50, as long as you follow all the steps in the videos, you will complete the course with an A+. After the first few problem sets you're conditioned that if you're thinking too much you're doing something wrong because it's supposed to be on rails, it's supposed to be easy enough that you can just complete it by reviewing or copying. There is no space in that class for thinking, you should not be puzzle solving, the things that look like puzzle solving only look that way, they are not actual puzzle solving. It is an amusement park ride for entitled and mediocre people disguised as an elite university course. This makes sense for what the goals are. It's not really about education. It's about the psychic pleasure of feeling like you learned something challenging. It's about preparing someone for a corporate gig, where in reality it is really bad if a junior person is doing any thinking - they really should be going out there and cramming, copying something or asking someone for the right answers! David Malan and Andrew Ng gave people want they wanted, that is capitalism, that is okay, it just isn't necessarily education. How is performance defined? What am I asking these students to do? Something original. Like at the end of the day you want people to sit in front of computer and solve an original weird problem, MOOCs will unprepare them for that.
- throwawaygh 6y ago> When was the last time you worked with many CS students versus amateur developers and could really compare? I work in a very technical area where you need to have taken a PDEs course to even understand what's going on. The only amateur developers who can even carry on a conversation about the work have math or engineering phds. > There is no space in that class for thinking, you should not be puzzle solving, the things that look like puzzle solving only look that way, they are not actual puzzle solving. It is an amusement park ride for entitled and mediocre people disguised as an elite university course. Being a generic software developer cog in a giant corp sounds soul-crushing. I think smart students who have the drive and intelligence to learn CS on their own should seriously consider if that's the type of job they want.
- devwastaken 6y agoThat's how higher education suppresses those in poverty further. That time and money not related to the direct earning of income is only achievable by those already well off. All of the 'extra classes' that are important can be combined into dedicated courses that have significantly more relevance to the job market.