8 ms·
They should recruit people on Reddit for this. A large number of them seem perfectly fine with this type of content. There are dedicated communities to all the
by MattGaiser 6y ago
They should recruit people on Reddit for this. A large number of them seem perfectly fine with this type of content.
There are dedicated communities to all these things.
I do not mean this as a hit against Reddit users. It is just that there are small pockets of people who are psychologically capable of tolerating this or even enjoy it. It seems more ethical to hire people from /r/watchpeopledie.
- dmalvarado 6y agoPerhaps. I would argue that there is some difference between seeing someone fall off a cliff and watching someone being tortured to death.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoThen they should run sidebar ads on the gore sites. The point is that there appears to be a subset of the population that is not traumatized by this stuff. We may as well give them an opportunity to put that difference to use. Edit: and saying things like "well clearly these people are already traumatized if they're seeking this out, it's not good for them, we shouldn't give these jobs to them" seems laughably paternalistic when the alternative is to traumatize more people by making them look at it instead.
- ceejayoz 6y agoHow do we know they're not traumatized by it? That they seek it out doesn't mean they're not messed up.
- filoleg 6y ago^this. I am not arguing one way or another, because I don't see strong evidence making me lean predominantly one way. But imo, it is at least just as possible that they are seeking out that kind of content voluntarily because they are already traumatized in the first place, so this is a coping mechanism. Maybe it helps dealing with that trauma. Maybe it makes the trauma worse. Maybe there was no trauma to begin with, and the person was seeking out that content simply due to morbid curiosity, but then it evolved into something else. Maybe there was no trauma to begin with and no trauma appeared after the exposure. Who knows. But just because there are communities on reddit with people seeking that kind of material and not going on crazy violent sprees doesn't mean that it doesn't negatively affect them. It could be the case, but we should probably look into that first before jumping to "obvious solution" claims. tl;dr: we gotta do more research and weigh pros and cons before simply declaring "we have an obvious solution, let's just hire all those gore content enthusiasts to moderate violent content, because they already do it on their own and don't seem to be going crazy in obvious ways due to it".
- munificent 6y agoThere is a subset of people who seek this stuff out, yes. Whether or not it is traumatic for them does not strictly follow from that. People come to their choices with all manner of existing problems and conflicts, and they don't always do things in their own best interest.
- matz1 6y agoThere are people that really like chocolate and some people that really hate chocolate. Human are so diverse. Is is really hard to believe that there are people that are not negatively affected by this ?
- three_seagrass 6y ago>Then they should run sidebar ads on the gore sites. That would do wonders for the Facebook brand.
- philwelch 6y agoHave a subcontracting company do the moderation and have them run the sidebar ads.
- three_seagrass 6y agoWhich is still linked to the brand - "Facebook pays $10 M to company that runs ads on gore and rape sites" Look at how much trouble they got in when it was revealed they were using Onavo (even before acquisition).
- philwelch 6y agoMeh, if that’s the worst PR they can get they’d be massively ahead of where they are now. Especially considering how massively the press narrative has turned against them overall.
- three_seagrass 6y agoBut that's my point - Facebook has a massive brand problem right now, and this would just be throwing more gas into the fire.
- philwelch 6y agoAt some point that stops being a factor. If the haters are going to hate no matter what, you actually get impunity because your actual actions stop making a difference either way.
- MattGaiser 6y agoThere were pockets where the video of the Jordanian pilot being burned to death by ISIS was popular. Same with the raw video of the New Zealand shooting. Obviously not everyone, but they are there.
- mFixman 6y agoMost importantly, there's a big difference between seeing someone being tortured to death and frequently seeing people being tortured to death every weekday.
- catalogia 6y agoAre moderators really meant to watch the whole video in cases like that? It seems to me like they could stop once the content of the video became apparent. Even just a fraction of a second of that sort of content could be scaring, but I think probably less scaring than watching several minutes of it... My basis for thinking this is I've seen videos like that before and clicked away quickly. It's disturbing, but I think I'm okay.
- kylecazar 6y agoI'd wonder if frequents in these subreddits are typically professional and healthy people to have on a team, though (honestly no idea, never been). It's a strange conundrum because ideally you want good people who are comfortable watching things good people rarely want to watch. Don't have much experience with this demographic -- maybe there are more sane, emotionally healthy people watching snuff films for fun than I instinctively expect.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoAs long as they have a pulse and can sit in the chair long enough to do the job they'll likely be fine. Content moderation farms, call centers and the like tend to optimize their internal processes such that they don't need to restrict their hiring to "professional and healthy people". There are plenty of people who are insane and unhealthy that can hack this sort of work.
- ceejayoz 6y agoDo you want "insane and unhealthy" people who voluntarily look at horrifying stuff deciding whether that stuff should be allowed on the platform, though? It'd be like having a jury pool made up of serial killers.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>Do you want "insane and unhealthy" people who voluntarily look at horrifying stuff deciding whether that stuff should be allowed on the platform, though? These kinds of bottom of the barrel places of employment tend to have their policies and procedures tuned to make sure employees do things the way the company wants them done. That's just the nature of doing an unskilled, non-laborious job for a BigCo. There will be automatic spot checks, audits, reviews, etc. It is no different than the cube farm on the next floor where they review images of documents that AI systems have flagged as possibly fraudulent. Such systems are likely in place already for their current moderators.
- 6y ago
- amelius 6y agoPerhaps we could use DL to "dehumanize" the content. For example, instead of showing one person torturing another person, a DL filter could turn the scene into two teddy bears torturing eachother.
- untog 6y ago> It is just that there are small pockets of people who are psychologically capable of tolerating this or even enjoy it. I wouldn't assume "watches this stuff" and "is psychologically capable of tolerating this stuff" are one and the same. Those people might be actively harming themselves by watching the content. That's one thing when they're volunteering to do so (though that's an interesting conversation in and of itself) but it's quite another when Facebook is paying them to do it.
- throwawaytime40 6y agoHonestly, this post speaks a lot of truth, at least in my experience. I use to be subbed to /r/watchpeopledie, really just out of morbid curiosity. One day I had an anxiety attack because I had a dream that I had a heart attack and suddenly I had a deep fear of randomly dying. All the random deaths on that sub started to really get to me, I even started to get depressed. It became harder and harder to watch content on it. Eventually I unsubbed from it and gradually bounced back to normal. I don't really regret it because it gave me a new perspective on life and how valuable it is. But I would be lying if I said it didn't fuck me up in a way.
- justanotheranon 6y agoI think the best counter to becoming desensitized or depressed is having an over arching sense of mission and identifying your work with a cause for good that is greater than yourself. take ER doctors. they daily witness human trauma far worse than viewing horror show videos and images. do you ever hear about ER docs who become depressed or mentally ill from being exposed to so much horrific human suffering? Doctors have a personal sense of doing good in the world through healing. They witness so much trauma that they become so desensitized that non doctors often criticize them for seeming so detached and for treating human bodies like mechanistic processes. But doctors have to be somewhat detached in order to do their jobs well.
- ksdale 6y agoQuick googling yields this - https://www.webmd.com/mental-health/news/20180508/doctors-suicide-rate-highest-of-any-profession#1 https://www.webmd.com/mental-health/news/20180508/doctors-su... It's not specifically about ER doctors. Anecdotally, I'm a lawyer, and they warned us in law school that lawyers have abnormally high rates of substance abuse and depression, and constant jokes to the contrary not withstanding, most lawyers believe they do good. Emotionally hard jobs are hard, even if they are indisputably good.
- three_seagrass 6y agoThese niche demographics are typically into it for the wrong reasons though, which includes fantasizing about the material (murder, rape, child pornography, etc.).
- victoriasun 6y agoBut are people like that people you want as your co-workers? Serious question, I don't mean this facetiously. I think is an extremely complex question and I wonder if introducing someone who is openly comfortable with gore is dangerous to the psychological health of the company. For example, at a previous company a co-worker publicly shared, without a trigger warning and in great detail, a very gorey thing he enjoyed watching to relax. Lots of people were extremely disturbed by this -- not disturbed by him, per se, but disturbed that he shared this without any kind of warning. I don't even resent him despite myself being pretty disturbed because what one considers normal is subjective, and if you regularly relax to this content you probably don't realise that this might not be anyone else's cup of tea. But it really makes me wonder -- what if the guy who sits next to me starts telling me that ISIS beheadings are relaxing to him?
- AdmiralAsshat 6y agoWell, I probably wouldn't invite him to my game night, but if it's his job to watch ISIS videos, it seems like he'd be well-suited, no? It seems like if you acknowledge that: a) Terrible job exists b) Terrible job is necessary You should also allow for a person to do terrible job without thinking that they must be a terrible person by extension. Otherwise you continue the well-trodden history of certain professions like hide-makers, executioners, or coroners being ostracized from society for doing the job we told them to do.
- victoriasun 6y agoI'm sorry if I implied that I think that people who would enjoy this work are bad people. I certainly don't feel this way; I mean, I myself have worked on a platform that plenty of Nazis use and i don't consider myself a Nazi, so it would be hypocritical of me to say as such. I agree that I wouldn't personally spend time with said person, but my question was less about personal social responsibilities outside of work. My example I pointed out happened at work, during normal work hours, in a social space where people have inherently less control over who they surround themselves with. This is the part of it all that is fuzzy to me, and I don't have a clear answer for.
- 6y ago
- inostia 6y agoThere are not hordes of people on Reddit watching intensely disturbing child pornography. The gore stuff maybe (although r/wpd was banned), but still I think any normal person, even the person who was occasionally on r/wpd, would be extremely traumatized by watching anything involving children. Which to be honest is probably a lot of the content discussed here, as sick as it is.
- MattGaiser 6y agoYou want the subscribers to r/wpd. The people who mod it or those who come and visit everyday. The entire point of this is to find those who deviate enough from normal to not be as impacted.
- totetsu 6y agoThey might be too young for the office...
- jfax 6y agoI was thinking more of 4chan moderators.
- tomatotomato37 6y agoBut we want these people to actually do their job
- ogurechny 6y agoThen let them do it for free.
- bagacrap 6y agoI think there's a good chance that if someone seems perfectly fine with this content, they've already got mental health issues.
- Traubenfuchs 6y agoI spent my youth on 4chan. I saw everything that's mentioned in the article and worse. Desensitization is certainly a thing. The first few times seeing those things were shocking and disturbing. Then it got exciting. Then it got boring. I don't actively look for that content, but never having left 4chan, I still sometimes stumble upon it and it causes no big reaction. I think I could totally do that content moderation job, I have to admit some morbid curiosity about what I would stumble upon exists in me. The only content that never stopped to disturb me was violence against animals. Talking with my "normie" friends about this I realized I am the odd one out. I wonder just how much consuming that content in my youth changed me.