15 ms·
This appears to be a surprisingly level-headed government initiative. The amount is enough to do something but not so much as to be a colossal boondoggle. It's
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
This appears to be a surprisingly level-headed government initiative. The amount is enough to do something but not so much as to be a colossal boondoggle. It's the sort of fundamental research which private industry tends to under-produce because it's hard for any given company to recoup the full value of the R&D, but the target area is something with potential downstream practical implications.
> bipartisan
Also by coincidence (?) the first time I've seen that word used recently in a context that wasn't preceded by the words lack of or similar.
- adventured 6y agoI agree. It'd be concerning if they launched with some obscene $1 billion type financial tag with it. If or when it makes sense, they can always increase funding for these three centers and or to build additional centers. Which is exactly what I'd expect in the coming years.
- elliotec 6y agoI dunno. This seems worthy of a lot more funding than a dog walking app that raised $361 million https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/wag https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/wag
- rlt 6y agoFortunately I don’t think the US government invested in Wag. Not surprisingly, the bulk of that was from SoftBank’s Vision Fund: https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/SoftBank2/SoftBank-suffers-another-writedown-after-Wag-stake-sale https://asia.nikkei.com/Business/SoftBank2/SoftBank-suffers-...
- adventured 6y agoWhy is it worthy of a lot more than $361 million in initial funding? Your premise is that it'll stop at $75 million in funding. I'd bet against that premise. The US Government has a tendency to start its programs small and expand them considerably over time. Besides, the US simultaneously has several of the world's largest companies pouring resources into quantum computing (Google, IBM, Microsoft, Amazon, Honeywell, Lockheed, Intel, et al.). It's not as though $75 million is the extent of US investment into the space.
- DevKoala 6y agoThat's a SoftBank valuation. Those were inflated.
- godelski 6y agoI disagree. I'd be completely find with a $1bn financial tag with it. That's not going to be $1bn for a year but spread over something like 5-10 years. If this is a strategic technology, it is highly beneficial for the government to invest in it. They'll make the money back once the technology becomes widespread. And I mean, look at the last paragraph > ... the NSF that would be given $100 billion over five years to invest in American research and technology issues, including quantum computing. Which seems low when you consider that we spent $430 bn on the F35 and lifetime expected cost is 1.5tn for more acquisition and maintenance. Governments work with larger amounts of money and when you look at science (arguably the best way to get ahead in military) it is pennies (CERN was funded internationally and only cost around $20bn over 10 years and $1bn/yr for operation). I mean the largest super computers cost only a couple hundred million, which means if Google or Facebook wanted to, they could compete.
- rubber_duck 6y ago>It's the sort of fundamental research which private industry tends to under-produce because it's hard for any given company to recoup the full value of the R&D, but the target area is something with potential downstream practical implications. Quantum computing ? I've seen just a few months ago some article about a single start-up raising >200M ?
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThere is a difference between doing fundamental research and bringing a product to market. We know enough about quantum computers to be able to build some of them in limited ways which are commercially useful in very specific domains, so then companies can get investment to do that. But we still don't really understand all of the fundamentals, and it's always hard to raise investment for fundamental research. Suppose you could prove that building a quantum computer that can run Shor's Algorithm on interestingly large numbers is impossible. Knowing that would be of immense value. People could stop wasting time trying to create it or defend against it. But how would anybody commercialize that information? Who has the incentive to fund that research?
- hannob 6y ago> We know enough about quantum computers to be able to build some of them in limited ways which are commercially useful in very specific domains In which way are quantum computers commercially useful?
- SV_BubbleTime 6y ago> In which way are quantum computers commercially useful? VC Bait seems like a natural fit. Just say you are making a quantum computer that predicts global warming trends using blockchain. Might want to buy a wheel barrel for all your money you’ll be leaving that meeting with.
- mr__y 6y agoYou forgot about supporting 5G
- kitteh 6y agoAdvisors make these recommendations. Say the right words about the US falling behind China or national security risk and no one wants to be the person on record who said no to this.
- krapp 6y ago>Say the right words about the US falling behind China or national security risk and no one wants to be the person on record who said no to this. Or just say Obama wouldn't have the guts to do it[0]. [0]https://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/trump-launched-yemen-raid-told-obama-wouldn-article-1.2966736 https://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/trump-launched-yem...
- jonny_eh 6y agoThose only helps get one side on board.
- trekrich 6y agoso close to admitting trump has done something decent!
- saiya-jin 6y agoIs this coming from him directly? I would be really surprised, he has plenty of advisors for that. What comes out of him directly is more visible on ie twitter, different story
- trekrich 6y agoYou dont really know what directlys come from him though. His twitter account and all the stuff he says is just a smoke screen to keep everyone outraged. Who knows what he is really doing in the background.
- whoiskevin 6y agoOh please. As many have said stop pretending that he is playing chess when he is sitting there eating the pieces like a toddler.
- dimillian 6y agolol.
- roenxi 6y agoBetter or worse, little of what the executive does is really because of the president directly. The president chooses the sort of people to put in positions of power then the whole ship largely sorts itself out. But the president gets to be responsible for everything because they are nominally in charge, and people keep pretending they are superheros with all sorts of ability to personally oversee how the US operates. We can certainly say that if Trump didn't want quantum computing research to happen his administration wouldn't be doing it. So if it does, he has de facto supported it. Even if by inaction.
- inscionent 6y agoThis is implementation of a law passed by congress in 2018.
- loudtieblahblah 6y ago>preceded by the words lack of or similar. Eh, bipartisan stuff still happens. Look at the military industrial complex. Expanding executive power, expanding the surveillance state. Pro wall street regulation repeal. Usually its to screw us
- hajile 6y agoWhile the media paints a different picture, bills sanctioning and restricting China have also been getting through which also means bi-partisan support despite the election rhetoric.
- YinglingLight 6y agoOne does not simply get into $26T in debt without a whole lot of agreement from both sides of the aisle. To view any side as pure is to be a pawn in the overton window.
- fearingreprisal 6y agoWhy was this comment killed? It was just about the only sane comment in this thread.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoI'm not sure what the mechanism is (i.e. karma threshold or moderation) but it looks like all the account's comments are dead by default and have been for a very long time.
- rescripting 6y agoViewed through that lens perhaps this initiative is to help push quantum computing to a place where it can break modern encryption.
- ta17711771 6y agoCynical me figured there wasn't much other purpose for those approving funding.
- ilrwbwrkhv 6y agoWonder if Peter Thiel had a hand in it.