15 ms·
The amount of narcissism these people (the Koch's, for example) have is just astounding. If you're a billionaire, what could possibly be a reasonable explanatio
by bmitc 6y ago
The amount of narcissism these people (the Koch's, for example) have is just astounding. If you're a billionaire, what could possibly be a reasonable explanation for why you even care about the post office? Why are these people so hell bent on hurting people to feed their own narcissism?
The USPS could be improved but struggles primarily due to active efforts to kill it off. But it's a wonderful idea of a service that definitely should exist and be improved. What's next to kill off? Libraries? Public schools? The USPS, libraries, public schools provide basically guaranteed service to anyone, anywhere. They're wonderful institutions. Are they perfect? No. But very few institutions are, and these provide a helpful service to people. We should focus on improving them instead of spending so much money to kill them.
I've learned that the USPS has free package pickup since someone is basically guaranteed to be in your neighborhood every day, which has been a wonderful service during this viral breakout. By having USPS pickup my small packages, it keeps me out of their stores away from other people and employees. I simply purchase a label online and schedule the free pickup, next day if it's a weekday. It's a minimum of $11 for UPS to come pickup your package at a residential address, even if they're already coming to your address for another delivery that same day.
- darawk 6y agoIt's ideological. They believe that the government should not be in the postal business. They probably believe that it's harmful to competition in various ways, and they are probably right in certain narrow contexts.
- bmitc 6y agoThe same argument of being harmful to competition could be extended to schools and libraries and <name a service>. It's just mind blowing why we should care about companies more than people. So what if it's harmful to competition? What merit does that have? (These aren't questions for you. They're rhetorical.)
- usaphp 6y agoProbably because your tax money go to support a “broken” business model in their opinion; without asking you if you want to pay for those services. Edit: I am not saying it’s a right thing to do, I am just trying to list a possible reason why billionaires might try to fight against it, per OP question
- flir 6y agoI get a say every time I vote.
- nickff 6y agoDo you think anyone is listening to what you have to say? This comes back to voice vs. exit, which was being discussed on HN yesterday.[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit,_Voice,_and_Loyalty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit,_Voice,_and_Loyalty
- flir 6y agoNot much, but that's why I support proportional representation, not turning the world into a Libertarian hellhole.
- jorblumesea 6y agoMore likely, it's because billionaires see $$$ to be made in divesting the government of a cheap public service. It's the same idea behind the privatization of everything the government does. Cheap, clean water? Why is the government giving this out for pennies when we could be making a killing? It's greed, simple as that. These people are corporatists that believe if there's money to be made, they should be allowed to regardless of the ethical consequences.
- coliveira 6y agoExactly, capitalists think in terms of opening new markets so why let people have for free something from which they can make a fortune? This way of thinking is like a cancer that grows on society.
- _emacsomancer_ 6y agoThe existence of billionaires is far more harmful to competition than government is.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoIf you’re a billionaire, it’s likely hard to understand why you’re the problem (as well as an economic system configured that allowed such wealth concentration).
- devilduck 6y agoIt is also hard to understand for the droves of people who wish they could become billionaires
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dungdang 6y agobut what about dictators in nuclear armed countries? an whatabout african armies in zimbabwe killing people? whatabout hitler? the existence of hitler was far more harmful than billionairs.
- BoysenberryPi 6y agoI don't understand what this Whataboutism has to do with the topic at hand.
- dungdang 6y agoexactly.
- brendoelfrendo 6y agoYou’re commenting like you won, but everyone else is just confused what your original point was.
- ouid 6y agoI dont think the problem with the Kochs is their tunnel vision.
- pryce 6y agoIdeological is close; If you are a billionaire, you didn't perform a billion dollars worth of labor; you got that way being the recipient of profits of significant fractions of entire industries based predominantly on other people's labor. If you make money this way, untapped resources don't necessarily look like untapped oil fields, instead they might look like entire industries that (with friendly legislators) can suddenly be opened up private profit (especially yours), or industries that can be captured into monopolies, or nations whose current economic situation can be exploited in ways that put large amounts of money into your pocket.
- nerfhammer 6y agoaccording to the labor theory of value google should be rewarded less than altavista depending on which performed more labor
- rudolph9 6y agoAlthough those are both search engines altvista produced drastically different results than google and the comparison of the results is generally subjective. The quality of the search result is what largely drew people to google (I was very young at the time please correct me if I’m mistaken). Regardless of which entity delivers a package the quality of the result can generally be objectively judged (cost, duration, package care, etc). Depending on the entity delivering search results of e.g the term “bear” the quality is highly subjective (e.g black bear wiki, Chicago bears, polar bear wiki, bear Halloween Costume amazon page, Berenstain Bears, etc). Not to mention the results are continuously changing. I’m not really familiar with labor theory but I’m inclined to think your analogy isn’t applicable to the discussion of privatizing USPS. Could you rephrase your comment in terms of sorting algorithms? Say a bubble sort would be rewarded more than a merge sort? Maybe that would better articulate your point??
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nerfhammer 6y ago
- rayiner 6y agoIt’s not just “they.” Postal privatization is common, and subsidies are closely watched: https://www.oecd.org/daf/competition/sectors/1920548.pdf https://www.oecd.org/daf/competition/sectors/1920548.pdf. The Danish post, for example, is a private company owned by a Swedish company, and subsidies are closely tracked.
- jahaja 6y agoOnce again, the privatization to form "Postnord" has been an utter failure and is a source of constant ridicule here in Sweden due to its newfound unreliability.
- beepboopbeep 6y agoYes but ideological means tt's a systemic crippling of government pillars in order to collapse the federal government or otherwise render it inept.
- sparkling 6y agoIts easy to point at a greedy billionaire who wants to ruin [insert public service here] so that he can squeeze out another dollar for himself. But have you considered that they _genuinely_ belive that minimal government and more privatization leads to overall better results? It might just be that they have good intensions, that they really wish for a better outcome for all. I don't share that view, but i do think that there is a fraction of hardcore liberterians that truly believe we'd be better of without many of the government-founded services such as libraries, schools etc. - and while i do not agree with that, those people are still entitled to their opinion and are allowed to lobby for it.
- aahhahahaaa 6y agoIf they wanted a better outcome for all then they wouldn't be billionaires, IMO. The fact that they exist is the sign of a problem that they're happy to exploit and automatically warrants suspicion about their motives.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- quickthrowman 6y ago> But have you considered that they _genuinely_ belive that minimal government and more privatization leads to overall better results? It might just be that they have good intensions, that they really wish for a better outcome for all. Yes, and that makes it even worse. They’re so out of touch with common people and so insulated from routine everyday life, their opinion shouldn’t count for anything. I don’t care if joe programmer on HN or Jeff the General Contractor at the bar are advocating for dismantling the post office because of libertarian ideology, because they have neither the power nor resources to affect change. I do care when insanely wealthy billionaires who are completely insulated from the rest of society argue for horseshit like this because they have power to change it, and it’s for ideological reasons. It’s pure narcissism to argue for a position that would negatively affect millions of people when the one arguing for change wouldn’t suffer one damn bit and in effect disregard everyone else’s suffering for their ideological bullshit position. The existence of billionaires combined with Citizens United is an actual problem, the post office is not.
- rayiner 6y ago> The amount of narcissism these people (the Koch's, for example) have is just astounding. If you're a billionaire, what could possibly be a reasonable explanation for why you even care about the post office? Why are these people so hell bent on hurting people to feed their own narcissism? Because they believe it’s bad for the public welfare. As you acknowledge, they have no other reason to care.
- woodruffw 6y agoSince the OP failed to mention the other reasons: ideological purity and profit motive come to mind. Edit: I failed to mention that the libertarian groups, at least in the US, are also a consistent reservoir and breeding ground for reactionaries. Another plausible explanation is that a lot of (ultra-wealthy) people have even worse politics, but launder their views through "free minds, free markets."
- tptacek 6y agoHow is privatizing the Post Office "reactionary"? The origins of the USPS are in a pre-Revolutionary grant from the British Crown. It's always been a public service. And what is "worse politics" but a begging of the question? Ok, privatizing the Post Office is worse than keeping it public; I agree. The question is why they believe that.
- woodruffw 6y ago> How is privatizing the Post Office "reactionary"? The origins of the USPS are in a pre-Revolutionary grant from the British Crown. It's always been a public service. It isn't; the reactionary comment is a more general one about the relationship between self-labeled libertarians and political positions that are disguisable within the libertarian framework. Being anti-postage and anti-national ID for disenfranchisement purposes are good examples of this; reactionary groups encourage normalizing these views under the auspices of libertarianism. "Worse politics" is in that context; wealthy people have a (correctly!) estimated interest in lots of political positions that less monied people find unpalatable (cf. voter suppression, maintaining systems of wealth and power that stem from racism). (Right-)libertarianism provides a ideological veneer for these positions.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> The USPS, libraries, public schools provide basically guaranteed service to anyone, anywhere. Libraries are a public service. They're free. The people who use them don't have to pay anything for it, which is a boon to those who otherwise couldn't afford it. It's basically a public subsidy for access to books. The postal service is a business. There isn't supposed to be any subsidy, you pay for it through postage, and they're not doing anything that UPS or FedEx couldn't do just as well. Public libraries don't need a law prohibiting private libraries to keep everyone from abandoning them, but the USPS needs a government monopoly on carrying letters? If the post office was so great then they shouldn't need that -- but then they'd likely fail, because private competitors would do it better and people would stop using USPS. It's the same thing with public schools. The benefit is that the government pays for them, so no one can say they can't afford to send their kids to school. But that doesn't require the subsidy to go only to schools operated by the government. Give the parents education vouchers and let them choose their school. If the public schools are so great then they'll choose them anyway. The opposition to this comes from people knowing full well that they're not.
- DubiousPusher 6y agoThe reason for public involvement in the postal service is to ensure parcel and letter carrying to all. I have many friends in rural Montana who would not have parcel or letter service if a strictly profit oriented company were the only delivery service. Or the price of delivery would be so exorbitant as to be prohibitive. UPS and FedEx only offer delivery to these locations because they see it as a required feature to remain competitive with USPS.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> UPS and FedEx only offer delivery to these locations because they see it as a required feature to remain competitive with USPS. If it isn't profitable to offer delivery there then they would have no reason to compete for it even now, and if it is then they would do it regardless. But more to the point, it's possible that in a competitive market there would be different optimal solutions. In a very rural area, rather than sending a mail truck on a fifty mile trek through the wilderness to deliver one parcel, everyone in the area might have a mailbox in the town center and pick up their mail whenever they go into town, because that would be cheaper by enough that people would choose it over the more inefficient/expensive alternative. You can't justify the entire USPS just to avoid that sort of increase in efficiency.
- coliveira 6y agoThese people are moved by blind ideology, they operate like religious fanatics. The Kochs simply do not believe that any socially owned service should exist. This kind of people are a danger for everyone. And you must be sure that the USPS is not the last target. Public schools, libraries, everything is in their crosshairs.
- cgh 6y agoIt's also likely because they are trying to suppress mail-in ballots. These are overwhelmingly used by people who can't get to a polling station because eg it is too far away and they don't own a car - in other words, they are poor.
- cheez 6y agoIndia has a better solution: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-india-election-lone-voter/indian-officials-travel-deep-into-jungle-to-allow-one-temple-priest-to-vote-idUSKCN1RZ1U7 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-india-election-lone-voter...
- manquer 6y agoIt works in India because elections are federally managed , and poll workers are federal employees who have to do the duty . In US the rules are per state and complicated also while mostly paid poll workers are really volunteering for the job . The second part surprises me all the time , US May have lesser polling booths if they have lesser people volunteer to be poll workers . Despite collecting so much tax and have so many government employees , Election Day in the US depends on so much on volunteers Election Day is also not a national holiday . I am sure the country can afford a single day off every 2/4 years so people can vote . You don’t even need an extra holiday, Keep it on 4th July if you have to, what better to celebrate independence than casting your vote ? Free and fair elections is the foundation of democracy, with all the gerrymandering , ID rules , mail-in ballot issues, voter suppression I am not sure how free and fair US elections truly are and how much of the population they truly are represented
- cheez 6y agoStates are there to implement federal guidelines as well as their own. Nothing stops the US federal government from passing a constitutional amendment or a law that forces this type of setup. Aside from the corruption you mentioned lol
- 6y ago
- isthispermanent 6y agoThe idea that it’s purely narcissistic is without merit. Privatization is about fostering competition to ensure better products are created. Just because the USPS works as is does not mean it couldn’t be better. This is a classic “I like things the way they are” problem. Where the other possibilities are unknown and inexperienced and so are not given equal weight to a decision. I don’t particularly care whether the postal service is privatized or not. But the more we keep failing at things like public schools the more I’m inclined to align with privatization. Everything can be regulated to a degree that requires basic service levels. But you can’t fake incentive. What is the USPS incentive to do better?
- faitswulff 6y agoWhat is private industry's incentive to do better?
- missedthecue 6y agoIf you don't produce desirable results for your customer you go out of business?
- faitswulff 6y agoAnd if the businesses in question are rent-seeking oligopolies?
- missedthecue 6y agoThey aren't in any case. Total red herring
- conception 6y agoPublic schooling has had a tremendous positive effect on the US and countries world wide. If it is failing, which it is not, it is for the same political reasons as the USPS is “failing”, which it is not.
- linuxftw 6y ago> What's next to kill off? Libraries? Public schools? I would vote for this. Whatever we spend on public libraries, that money could be used to bring every residence land-line high-speed internet access. I would also defund all public schools. Charter schools seem to be the future, but the legion of bureaucrats don't want to let go of their communist indoctrination pipeline. As a tax payer, I don't want to subsidize people sending letters or packages. Much of the back haul and distribution has already been contracted out anyway. > It's a minimum of $11 for UPS to come pickup your package at a residential address Yeah, that's the real cost of that service. The fact that it's free for the USPS doing it means you're using other people's money.
- harimau777 6y agoA problem with this strategy is that libraries are often used by the homeless in order to study and apply for jobs. Librarians also provide expertise in sourcing knowledge that isn't available online; particularly with the way that Google search has evolved. Larger libraries also provide archivist roles and even small libraries may serve to archive local news and history.
- linuxftw 6y agoEverything is a cost/benefit analysis. Do libraries provide some services that home internet can't? Yes. Does that make them overall a better investment? No. There's already unemployment agencies. Maybe they can setup computers to assist the homeless. Or you know, the homeless shelter could have a computer for job searching.
- harimau777 6y agoCertainly it would be possible to re-create the services provided by libraries elsewhere; but at that point haven't we just re-created the library?
- antiutopian 6y agoIt's their class interest, which drives them to view the world in a certain way. So as others are saying, it's ideological. But that ideology isn't a coincidence, it comes from justifying the sort of "work" that they do, day in and day out.
- yingw787 6y agoI think the wealthier you are, the fewer "real" problems you have, so sometimes you end up making up problems or creating problems for yourself to chew on. I think the happiest rich people have a "wall" to push against and a "chair" to sit in when they're tired. Bill Gates has the health policy stuff to work on during the day, and his family to come back to in the evening. Jeff Bezos has Amazon to run, Elon Musk and Jack Dorsey have their companies and people to be around, average people have a job. If you don't have that "thing" to chew on, if you just sit in on a board meeting and sip cocktails on a beach, it's easy to become lonely and feel like life is meaningless. You become like Notch and end up in a depressive spiral where you simultaneously have everything and nothing. Not a psychologist or anything, just an interesting observation. No man is an island. Until he is, then he's Robinson Crusoe.
- alasdair_ 6y agoThe problem with certain types of libertarians (which the Koch brothers believe(d) they are) is that they overdo the market fundamentalism to the point of turning it into religion. At that point, anything that is not "of the market" turns into a religious war, with all the stupidity of all religious wars. Markets are phenomenal things for the majority of goods and terrible things for a few goods (like common defence, the judiciary and pollution control). The post office is in the latter case - some people need to subsidize the system in order for (say) rural deliveries to take place. The benefit of having a single universal system is important in a world where an enormous amount of things that are necessary to a functioning society (say, jury summons, or voting pamphlets or other government paperwork) need to be accessible to every single citizen in the democracy. Eventually the Internet can replace most of these things, but then the government of a democracy needs to ensure that literally every citizen has free and reasonable access to the internet without meaningful burden, lest it disenfranchise the poor and the rural. Oddly, the whole "defund the post office" thing seems to be mostly a Republican issue. I say oddly, because the Democratic base tend to be from more densely populated states and from larger cities in those states. These people are least likely to be affected by a lack of post office as commercial delivery services can supply the majority of their mailing needs in a pinch. The people most affected are people in large states like Texas, especially those outside of the cities, where it's less economical to deliver to. Not to mention all of the other federal services that post office provide that would ultimately go away if the post office did. Things like passport processing, for example. Honestly, I'm still kind of amazed at how people can be convinced to so consistently call for things that are against their own interests in the name of some abstract idea like "religion!" or "the market!.
- gibsonf1 6y agoWhat a silly idea, that a free market would be better and more efficient delivering mail than the government which loses billions a year? Fedex delivers anywhere you want - I'm sure they would love to deliver mail too with their network as would UPS etc. and you know how reliable they are as opposed to USPS.
- boogies 6y ago> these provide a helpful service to people To the people that run marketing and political campaigns, and utility companies. Over 95% of all mail is not personal correspondence. ~50% is advertisements. The UPS price probably reflects the fact it’s only allowed to compete with the USPS on an rigged, uneven playing field, through a legal loophole for “extremely urgent letters”. And I wouldn't mind “killing” my local public library (despite spending hours playing Minecraft and Roblox there in my youth) in favor of the Internet Archive et al.¹, and public schools in favor of private schools that prioritize customer satisfaction over union agreements². And deunionize the police while we're at it: many of the violent acts and actual human killings BLM and others protest were perpetrated by repeat offenders kept in the force because of unions. After unionizing, police are 40% more likely to use violence.³ Camden, New Jersey fired their entire police force, hired a new union-less one, and decreased there murder rate while saving money that could then be spent on libraries, schools, etc. Private police have successfully served many communities.⁴ 1: Edit: My area has private little lending libraries the size of large newspaper dispensers scattered around it, which work great because the area's dense and walkable; other less dense areas have libraries on wheels in the form of trucks and vans. 2: One of my favorite high school teachers was fired for lack of seniority because of union rules, and private and charter schools seem better by every measure I know of. 3: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/Papers.cfm?abstract_id=3095217 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/Papers.cfm?abstract_id=3095217 4: https://reason.com/video/dont-abolish-the-police-privatize-them/ https://reason.com/video/dont-abolish-the-police-privatize-t....
- dboreham 6y agoIt'll be the same thing that drives people to bang on about code reviews and tabs vs spaces and camel vs underscore and semicolons in a language that defines their use then says they're optional. Mostly.
- heimatau 6y agoLibraries are mostly funded by cities/states (harder to defund). Same goes for public schools. But...make no mistake, there is a power struggle going on. It can be seen with the reduction to these functions to expand the police departments.