5 ms·
Yup. This is why I actually agree with Zuckerberg on his “no censorship” approach. He’s smart enough to recognize that taking on the burden of what should be
by refurb 6y ago
Yup. This is why I actually agree with Zuckerberg on his “no censorship” approach.
He’s smart enough to recognize that taking on the burden of what should be censored and what shouldn’t is a quagmire he’d prefer to avoid. No matter how “good” your filters are, you’re going to piss off a massive group of customers, despite all the effort.
It’s just a massive time sink with little to no benefit.
“The only way to win is to not play at all.”
- pjc50 6y ago> I actually agree with Zuckerberg on his “no censorship” approach. But this is a complete nonsense! Facebook cheerfully and aggressively censors anything sexual, far over and above local concerns of legality. Even before FOSTA/SESTA. (example list from 2018 of censored FB content rules: https://www.cnbc.com/2018/04/24/facebook-content-that-gets-you-banned-according-to-community-standards.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/04/24/facebook-content-that-gets-y... )
- s1artibartfast 6y agoThe grey area and room for debate is much greater for truth than nudity and sexuality. zuckerbergs policy preference was no censorship of fake news, not no censorship whatsoever.
- vkou 6y ago> The grey area and room for debate is much greater for truth than nudity and sexuality. That's your subjective opinion. Different cultures will significantly disagree with you (and with the Zuck) on what the gray area for nudity and sexuality is.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoDifferent cultures may disagree on what the policy should be, but Zuckerberg has the ability to create nudity rules that are objective, whether you agree with them or not. For example, FB can make a policy that says no exposed nipples for females. There may be different opinions on the value of such a policy, but not the execution/implementation. This is much more difficult for a policy stating that content must not be "misleading". Fact checking is much more problematic, because there can be support for either interpretation, nuance, as well as scientific uncertainty.
- AlexandrB 6y agoThe problem in the linked article doesn't seem to be that the rules were ambiguous. Instead it seems as though they were perfectly clear but overruled by leadership because of external pressure. Plus there's this: > Last week, however, ProPublica reported that explicit misinformation about voting remains rampant on the platform. Voting misinformation is not ambiguous in the way you describe, yet Facebook doesn't care.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI think we would have to discuss the examples given by propublica[1]. Almost everything I saw was a matter of opinion. "Your democracy, your freedom is being stripped away from you, and if you allow that then everything this country stood for, fought for, bled for is all in vain" "the democratic party wants to rig our elections by forcing all voters to vote by mail. Vote by mail WILL lead to fraud" "“Flooding the nation with ballots that can be stolen, sold, discarded, and forged—THAT’s the path to Leftist victory in November.” “You think coronavirus is a crisis, wait till you see the voter fraud epidemic we have here in California. And mark my words it’s heading to your state like a diseased bat out of hell.” “If you mail in your vote, your vote will be in Barack Obama’s fireplace.” [1] https://www.propublica.org/article/outright-lies-voting-misinformation-flourishes-on-facebook https://www.propublica.org/article/outright-lies-voting-misi...
- filoeleven 6y ago> For example, FB can make a policy that says no exposed nipples for females. There may be different opinions on the value of such a policy, but not the execution/implementation. Your policy is still ill-defined, though. Do you mean ALL female nipples, or just human ones? Does the ban extend to babies? Who’s going to police that, and how? Radiolab did an episode on all kinds of Facebook rules, covering the nipple conundrum as part of it. There’s very little that is straightforward about implementing any of them. https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/articles/post-no-evil https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/articles/post-...
- 6y ago
- Traster 6y agoAnd of course that doesn't even get into the fact that Facebook isn't about whether you can post something, it's about how algorithms choose to share what you post with others. They can tweak things so your post shows up at the top of everyone's feed, or no one's at all.
- Barrin92 6y agonot just anything sexual, but mere nudity on social media platforms seems to be controversial. I remember the "female presenting nipples" debacle on Tumblr including pictures of breast-feeding mothers. "no censorship" apparently means, "don't anger American conservatives", not "everyone can speak and share".
- Nasrudith 6y agoIt is probably pragmatic/conventional wisdom that it will kill mainstream adoption if they are openly linked to it. It is deeply stupid but I can't say it is incorrect. Now they have a point with FOSTA - it was already risky when they don't know if a naked body is 18 or 17. To be blunt stupid inputs be they customer norms or laws get stupid results - it is how systems work.
- smt88 6y agoI think it's fine for Facebook to opt out of fact-checking, as long as they also opt out of algorithmic syndication of content. If my feed is going to have posts shared by others (even non-friends) or, worse, op-eds in it, then FB is vouching for whatever I see. If they share a link with 50 million people, they're certainly responsible for the consequences. Worse is the ad side, where Facebook wants to continue to profit from well-funded wars against science while still claiming to be neutral. If you get paid to broadcast a message and then broadcast it, you are not neutral.
- pjc50 6y agoBingo. You can make an argument that your posts are your free speech. But "What Facebook chooses to put on your feed" is Facebook's speech.
- forgotmyhnacc 6y agoHow does this argument apply to Google? When you search something e.g. is climate change real, Google ranks the results algorithmically. If Google doesn't do fact checking, are they liable for false statements?
- Nasrudith 6y agoIt applies just as much because it is a fundamentally technically illiterate argument. It already ignores that the whole point of the algorithim is to prioritize. In this case just as much means "none" for both because it is asking for an outright contradiction to - provide prioritization without any bias. Or bias without bias. Nonsensical stupidity. The mobster with a cudgel making vague threats rhetoric is just another form of the stupid and wrong meme of service and platform being mutually excluse. I personally try to do my part by stomping on this dumb sentiment like a cockroach whenever it pops up.
- AlexandrB 6y agoI disagree. The "algorithm" is fundamentally an optimization problem and companies get to choose what the fitness function for each algorithm is. Facebook chooses "engagement". This is not an accident nor some fundamental property of math. It's a product decision made by a human. One that can be changed. And there is a fundamental difference between Google's algorithm and Facebook's: control. Google requires user input through search, Facebook decides what shows up when you open the app/site based on an algorithmic feed. In one case the user has some idea that what they're doing is interacting with an algorithm and they can change their search terms if they're not satisfied with the results, in the other the algorithm is in the background making decisions without making itself obvious.
- jeromegv 6y agoBut he already plays by having an algo that suggest you articles/news/groups to join. It would be one thing if it was just a dump of what your friends post and nothing else. But the moment you "suggest" content to people, you take an editorial stance. If you take an editorial stance and start pushing an article to millions of people, then you have a responsibility. You can't have it both ways. This isn't a phone company.
- johndavidback 6y ago> It’s just a massive time sink with little to no benefit. There is arguably a large social benefit to preventing widespread misinformation being disseminated. Perhaps no great business benefit - indeed it is likely a massive expense. But someone somewhere is paying that cost, however it manifests.
- shadowgovt 6y agoI'm sure he'd prefer to avoid it, but Facebook has become influential enough in people's day-to-day information consumption that at this point, doing nothing is itself a stance in favor of the well-funded and well-connected.
- duskwuff 6y ago> Yup. This is why I actually agree with Zuckerberg on his “no censorship” approach. The Rohingya massacre in Myanmar begs to differ. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebook-genocide.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebo...