5 ms·
The Problem with Solano County's Rail Plan
- Lammy 6y agoRemember to read "protecting the environment" as "protecting our segregation" when anyone opposes constructing housing or transportation of any kind. From the summary of the linked slides: > "Recommendations: Halt work on sites for Benicia and Vacaville-Fairfield. Develop plans which better serve the majority of residents along the Capitol Corridor Route" Now, I wonder what "the majority of residents" in Benicia might want? (or, might not want?) https://belonging.berkeley.edu/racial-segregation-san-francisco-bay-area https://belonging.berkeley.edu/racial-segregation-san-franci... "Rio Vista and Benicia are the two most segregated, and heavily white cities of Solano County."
- AbrahamParangi 6y agoNIMBYism is just Conservatism bereft of any kind of principles or values.
- golemiprague 6y agoI thought the bay area is very liberal? Japan which is a very conservative country, both in absolute terms and as a general philosophy, has very lax zoning rules and many trains running literally thorough people back yards. So I wouldn't say it is related.
- Lammy 6y agoThe Bay Area is many things to many different types of people. Unfortunately it is also very segregated: http://www.radicalcartography.net/index.html?bayarea http://www.radicalcartography.net/index.html?bayarea
- fountainofage 6y agoFrom what I've experienced, the majority of the Bay Area is very liberal up until the point it actually costs them something - then it quickly becomes a conservative paradise. People will shout and scream and boycott to make sure you can use whatever bathroom you choose. Or make sure that everyone respects your choice of pronouns. But ask those same people to build more housing and provide ample public transit? Ask those same people to close all private schools and force people to use public school lottery systems that mingle rich, middle-class, and poor? Absolutely never. They isolate into their communities and tell the folks trying to get in that their town is now full.
- FreakyT 6y agoYou’re definitely correct that NIMBYism is a form of conservatism (in the classic sense of the word), but what I find really interesting is how effectively NIMBYism crosses party lines. I’ve noticed both very liberal and very conservative people will both be anti-development, but their rationales will change. The conservative will raise objections around things like “neighborhood character” and “small businesses”, while liberals will raise objections around “the environment” or “displacing disadvantaged communities”. Either way, the resultant viewpoint is the same: everything is perfect the way it is right now and nothing should ever change.
- smnrchrds 6y agoIn support of your point, Margaret Atwood (the author of The Handmaid's Tale) is famously NIMBY [0]. [0] https://globalnews.ca/news/3707723/margaret-atwood-condo-controversy-in-toronto/ https://globalnews.ca/news/3707723/margaret-atwood-condo-con...
- dmitriid 6y agoOn the other hand the article calls "8-storey 16-unit building" a "modest condo development". I'm not NIMBY, and I would be opposed to that.
- ponker 6y agoWell then you are NIMBY, just for some things and not others, like every other person.
- CalRobert 6y agoOK, where should those people live instead?
- michaelt 6y agoWhen you're a NIMBY, depending on your political persuasion they might say: * I don't care, just not here * One of the housing developments in other towns, which I don't oppose * Working from home is the future, why do people need to move here anyway? * Further out, served by improved public transport infrastructure. * Homelessness is really more of a mental health services problem. So the real solution here is healthcare reform. * The problem is billion-dollar corporations all centralising in one place for no good reason. We should spread the jobs out. * Who says the population has to grow at all? Capitalism is the problem, the endless growth it demands isn't possible. * The solution is a bay-area-wide master plan to deliver an integrated response, addressing our current and future needs for jobs, homes, schools, equality, desegregation, mass transit, homeless and mental health services, and a response to the climate crisis. Needless to say, these are well beyond the power of someone building a few condos. But the NIMBY's alternative is only to assuage their conscience, so realism isn't important.
- desert_boi 6y agoPortland, OR is famous for hating both sprawl and density. NIMBYism is something all Americans can get behind.
- CalChris 6y agoThe Bay Area used to be dotted with military bases. Alameda NAS Concord Naval Weapons Station Fleet Industrial Supply Center Oakland Hamilton AFB Hunters Point Mare Island Moffett Field Oakland Army Base Oakland Naval Hospital Presidio Treasure Island In fact Silicon Valley used to be defense industry before it was silicon. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZTC_RxWN_xo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZTC_RxWN_xo Losing Travis would cost jobs but CA would eventually recover. Vallejo is finally recovering from Mare Island closing and losing that tax base. However, we pay for those jobs which get shipped elsewhere with CA taxes. Also, military jobs are less impacted by economic cycles and provide more stability to the local economy. Solano should fight hard to keep Travis but the article doesn't provide good news on that front.
- joe_the_user 6y agoThat misses the point that the problem is transit created as political footballs. That basically results in grand plans that end-up worthless. I used to live in Sonoma County. To fight congestion, they created the Smart Train. But through a similar process, the train wound-up a seldom running, expensive medium rail from nowhere to nowhere. Maybe there's a reason to not put trains where people generally good but you'd have to spell out what that is.
- season2episode3 6y agoThey made the mistake of trying to build that train through Marin. Good luck. Marin's home to some of the most regressive local politics imaginable.
- joe_the_user 6y agoThe mistake of thinking they could go halfway through Marin and extend it later. And the mistake of having the train use a single track for half it's length (once an hour service at most, any time of day).
- Stratoscope 6y agoMore airbases and airfields: Crissy Field Half Moon Bay Airport Watsonville Airport If we venture a bit farther south: Hollister 12th Naval District Target No. 5 [1] [2] Salinas Army Air Base [1] http://www.militarymuseum.org/NAS-Hollister-History.pdf http://www.militarymuseum.org/NAS-Hollister-History.pdf [2] https://goo.gl/maps/HEpQV6QZp7B6jHi98 https://goo.gl/maps/HEpQV6QZp7B6jHi98 (The runway is Lightning Tree Ranch, a private airstrip now used for drone testing. The bombing range is the deserted area to its south.)
- Felz 6y agoI live in Benicia and I think the alternate plan is slightly disingenuous in removing Vallejo as a consideration for the Benicia stop. Much of Vallejo is only 20 minutes away from the rail line.
- google234123 6y agoI'm not surprised to hear that bay area politicians would be happy to rid themselves of something "unpleasant" like a military base. Also, I wish we would give up all the grandiose and expensive plans for trains as a means of public transportation in the US. This pandemic has just added another reason why they are not viable here.
- IAmEveryone 6y agoBerlin, New York, London, and Tokyo, and dozens more show that it’s perfectly possible to get the virus under control even in places where public transport is popular.
- corty 6y agoBy getting ridership down to 5-20% of normal levels. Which is a level where public transport is unsustainable, both from a monetary and from an environmental standpoint.
- Cerium 6y agoTo get a handle on what 5 to 20% means in the context of Japan, I did some searching around. It turns out that the Tokyo Metro and BART have similar amount of track (121.2 miles vs 131 miles), though the Tokyo Metro has many more stations. If the Tokyo Metro was operating at 5 to 20% or normal, it is still exceeding BART's daily ridership.
- skizziepop 6y ago"Tokyo Metro" is one of several metro networks in greater Tokyo. 121 miles only represents the sum total of a single subway system
- pas 6y agoWhat's the argument here? The decreased mobility affects roads and airports too, should we tear them up ASAP?
- niftich 6y agoThe traffic in the Greater Bay Area is so bad, the effect of chokepoints so profound, and the geographic concentration of jobs is so strong, that the Park-and-Ride model actually works there, and isn't just wishful thinking. This means that the exact placement of stations in the exurbs is much less relevant. The viability of P+R makes the Benicia station worthwhile to pursue, despite the challenging site. It's clear that transit-oriented development won't happen there, but in terms of transportation geography, it's a chokepoint at the Solano side of one of the few crossings of the Strait. The newly-opened Travis station is as close to the base as they could've cheaply made it, being completely greenfield and not clashing with any existing land use. If the base really wanted to, they could arrange a traffic-avoiding shuttle between the station and the base, through a new, dedicated northwest gate. But it's worth remembering that any threat Travis makes about encroachment is likely tough talk to keep the neighboring towns from getting too clever, because Travis encroaches just as well on itself: half of the base is housing, there's elementary schools... I admire the author's passion: I'm the same way, poring over GIS and aerial photos, reading draft plans, EIS documents, and public comments. But the author perhaps overestimates the county's appetite for well-placed rail stations next to which a higher density of construction becomes worthwhile. Just look at the Suisun-Fairfield station, which is nearly as well-placed as the one in Davis. If a midrange suburban hotel, a two-story office building, some offramps, and some underutilized public space the most the two cities can offer for this key gateway, what hope is there for a site where Vacaville's sprawl gives way to farms on its eastern edge?
- three_seagrass 6y agoTragedy of the commons in action
- supernova87a 6y agoIt's an admirable effort and I'm glad the author is concerned about such issues -- we need such concerned citizens. I hope she applies her local enthusiasm to wherever she is now. I think the presentation could use some help though, for the idea to come through clearly (I don't know enough locally to comment on the merits): 1) The webpage and title purport to tell the story about what should be done, but it's filled with tangential information not relevant to the issue. It took me about 3 casual readings to realize there were conclusions about the alternative plan that should be pursued, written on the page. And I didn't realize what this page was for, until I clicked the PPT link -- which is relatively hidden amongst text despite it leading to the primary document of substance. 2) The document itself (PPT -- unfortunate vertical format and page/text layout I have to say) is also not clear about the disadvantages of the current route, and advantages of the proposed route. Despite being so short, it rambles. It really needs some summary bullet points and maybe a table for someone to quickly grasp what the proposal is. 3) Visually, the map differences between the existing planned route and the proposed alternative are not at all clear -- the maps look almost identical to my quick glance at this scale. If some of the conclusions are that the stations are poorly located, the point is to show some of the locations in detail and the alternative location in clear comparison. It's almost without point to enlarge the maps so much, yet not point out what is distinguishing about the original versus the proposed route alternatives. Overall, given that county/city authorities signed off on the project, and that this reads as someone's interesting but casual idea, I can only (as a uninformed observer citizen) assume that forces at play have made their decision, and an effort like this, unless professionalized and given some real attention, are probably too late (see other comments below on why). But if there is opportunity to make change, I wish the author (or others interested) good luck in going after it!