5 ms·
Excerpts from the journalist's piece I think are worth quoting: > "The specter of “cancel culture” is a concept most often invoked to protect those in power, o
by lucideer 6y ago
Excerpts from the journalist's piece I think are worth quoting:
> "The specter of “cancel culture” is a concept most often invoked to protect those in power, often straight white men such as myself, from facing consequences for their actions, but I want no part in it. I’m not going to start a YouTube channel railing against the perceived dangers of PC culture. I believe I lost my job unfairly. At the same time, I firmly believe that people, especially those in power, should be held accountable for what they say and do."
> "There was no union at the Register. Had I been a union member, I believe I would have been able to more effectively advocate for myself."
These two paragraphs are almost a contradiction (saying "I’m not going to start a YouTube channel" but writing a blogpost railing against ununionised workers not being able to advocate for themselves), but it isn't quite a contradiction, and that nuance is exactly where I think the "line" is in this debate.
People's lives are ruined not because there's no authoritarian protection of "free" hate-speech, but rather because there's no individual-level protection of actual livelihoods.
- raxxorrax 6y agoDisagree. If we had a more enlightened culture, people wouldn't connect statements from individuals to companies they work for in the first place but that is not relevant. What this shows to me is that he has a clear image of an enemy. An image so hated that he didn't use his conscience while writing the article he got fired for. This is real prejudice and he hasn't worked through that. Otherwise he would not rail against those critical of cancel culture. Protecting people against twitter hysteria is not the work of unions. Additionally, free speech is very valuable and freedom doesn't come without costs. I do think he was fired unfairly, it would be nice if he could extend his judgement about himself to others.