12 ms·
UK Formally Abandons Europe’s Unified Patent Court
- orwin 6y agoI don't think this is a great timing. I also think the brexit was bad timing overall. UK's engineering/scientific corp is good with electronics and biomed especially, areas where patents are really important, and having a voice on unifying EU patent without a doubt would have helped them. They already need to import civil, construction and production engineers, and Brexit will probably end with a no Deal when the country is trying on giant infrastructures with a bit of central planning smell (and great job Corbyn&Friends on that by the way).
- cannabis_sam 6y agoYeah, let’s blame the guy who had no actually power (remember the tories were in charge), and was targeted by a smear campaign about anti-semitism, while the Tories erected and celebrated a statue of a nazi-sympathizer with both Theresa May and Boris Johnson in attendance.
- madaxe_again 6y agoShrug. Who even cares any more. The U.K. can abandon everything they want, and any business or person with a brain or eyes to see will abandon them. I did. I’m far from alone. What’s the U.K. going to do when there’s nothing left but idiots and seagulls? This also seems like a great opportunity to find any interesting U.K. patents you can, and steal them. What are they going to do, write a letter? They’re leaving all mutual enforcement agreements, too.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoWe will end up back in or closely aligned. The economic arguments are overwhelming. It's only a matter of time.
- pjc50 6y agoOnce the conservatives are out, and a sufficient period in the wilderness has been completed, we could return to a Norway position. However, that depends a lot on what happens in the intervening decade to failing intra-Europe states such as Hungary and Poland.
- black_puppydog 6y agoGood luck with the negotiations. I guess Albania and North Macedonia have a always had lot more goodwill on the EU side, ever since the idea of them joining the EU was floated, than the UK will ever have again.
- te_chris 6y agoNah, they'll want the budget contributions back. Also, as much as I think Brexit is a complete waste, it doesn't have to be a disaster either - although this govt. seems hellbent on making it one. By the time the UK comes to reconsider joining or similar, things will have moved.
- normalnorm 6y ago> Nah, they'll want the budget contributions back. Also: "The German car industry will demand it", "The EU needs the UK more than the UK needs the EU", etc. All of this has been falsified in the last four years. The integrity of the single market and of the European project is turning out to be much more valuable to EU member states than the highly rebated UK contributions.
- te_chris 6y agoAs I said, I'm on the side against brexit, but what you're saying is not true. The EU is struggling massively with this current budget round and the loss of the UK contribution seems to legitimately be causing problems. The shit about BMW's and Prosecco was just nationalist bollocks, but that doesn't mean that the loss of the UK budget contribution isn't real. Likely end outcome is EU budget struggles a bit for a few years, then UK rejoins as an associate or whatever new category they come up with.
- fwsgonzo 6y agoThat's a good point. Patents tend to be applied in several geographical areas though (although I'm no expert), but I suppose there's always a possibility that there are patents that only apply in the UK now.
- lloydatkinson 6y agoAs an English person, I care a great deal. I voted to remain.
- madaxe_again 6y agoLikewise, but that cause is lost. They’ll be leaving the UN Security Council in the next few years most likely, in the name of control and sovereignty. I’d get out while you can.
- arethuza 6y agoI can't see the UK voluntarily leaving the UN Security Council and as we usually act as the sidekick of the US I can't imagine they'd want the UK to leave either.
- corford 6y agoOn the other hand, I can see the other more powerful Security Council countries leaving and setting up something else (to which the UK, now a rather middling power, will not be invited).
- gadders 6y ago6th largest country by GDP out of 195 is a strange definition of "middling".
- manquer 6y agoIndia is 5th largest GDP and also a nuclear power, it is not a permanent member and does not have veto power on the SC. Germany/Japan are higher than both India and U.K. and still not part of council for obvious historical reasons. GDP and nuclear arsenal are just two aspects to power, lot more to it than just that. When France and UK became part initial members the SC. They were still colonial powers controlling a lot of the world, and won the war, they are no longer have that kind of strength or influence. If a new council were created in the somewhat near future it would be because power dynamics have shifted far enough that the current council is no longer useful, from the current members UK and France are most likely to ones for that shift and not enjoy similar rights. New powers at the table could be EU as a whole, India, Brazil perhaps Japan and Germany etc.
- Normal_gaussian 6y agoThe UK withdrew from a not yet complete project to unify existing patent systems. They are still party to the non-eu body of the EPO as explained here : https://www.epo.org/law-practice/legal-texts/official-journal/information-epo/archive/20200129.html https://www.epo.org/law-practice/legal-texts/official-journa...
- madaxe_again 6y agoRight, but they’ll inevitably leave the EPO too - I’d say this was the shot across the bows. It’s easy to predict - just consider what the worst, most self-destructive course of action available is, and voila, you know what the British government will do next.
- blibble 6y ago> Right, but they’ll inevitably leave the EPO too based on what? the government is pulling out of anything where the ECJ has jurisdiction, which you might not agree with, but is perfectly consistent with leaving the EU's institutional control the EPO is not under the control of the ECJ
- madaxe_again 6y agoThey left euratom, which has nothing to do with either the ECJ or EU. There’s precedent.
- blibble 6y ago> They left euratom, which has nothing to do with either the ECJ or EU. There’s precedent. afraid not: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-uk-leaves-the-eu-40571853 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-uk-leaves-the-eu-4057... > The UK joined Euratom when it joined the EEC in 1973. It is a separate legal entity from the EU, but is tied up with its laws and institutions, and subject to the jurisdiction of the European Court of Justice (ECJ). you may want to revisit essentially everything you've posted here, because most of it is just flat out wrong
- peteretep 6y ago> any business or person with a brain or eyes to see will abandon them. I did. I’m far from alone. What’s the U.K. going to do when there’s nothing left but idiots and seagulls? Right! Apart from being the 6th largest economy, a nuclear power, a permanent member of the security council, a member of FVEY, the home of two of the best universities in the world, home to London, being a cultural powerhouse for several centuries, home to one of the most established and trusted legal systems in the world, and printer of the pound sterling, the UK is basically completely irrelevant now. ... Brexit is a shit-show and probably a bad idea, but perhaps let’s keep the hyperbole to a minimum, eh?
- arethuza 6y agoWe are a bit of a second-rate nuclear power though - we are completely dependent on the US for delivery systems (Trident missiles) and, apparently, for the design of warheads. If the US decided it didn't want the UK to be a nuclear power then I don't think we'd be able to maintain the capability for very long.
- peteretep 6y agoBritain was the third nuclear power, can’t imagine they just threw the plans away... Also the French are managing to maintain theirs independently just fine.
- arethuza 6y agoI don't think a 1960's weapon design (if we ever really had them - there is some debate as to whether the UK conned the US into giving us proper multi-stage weapon designs) is going be that useful on a Trident missile.
- ck425 6y ago> two of the best universities in the world There's more than just two! Admittedly only Oxbridge are consistently top 10 but there are a disproportionate number of other UK unis in the top 200.
- 127 6y agoIt's really a shame for all the small business in the UK what's happening right now. I'm really going to miss them. Lots of hard working people building cool things.
- throwaway122kk 6y agoFrom Ireland, been looking at shenanigans in UK for last 4 years while scratching my head at the madness which seems to have taken over. Almost daily get contacts on linkedin for jobs both relocation and remote in UK (London and Belfast) and each time I politely point out to the recruiter that (beside the already lower salaries which have not kept up with fall in pounds value) it would not be a wise move to attach one to UK at this time due to all the uncertainty, also there has been a rush of companies setting up here opening up many opportunities while remaining in Europe.
- secondcoming 6y agoLondon's different. If the world economy falls apart I'd rather be in London than Dublin for job seeking purposes.
- throwaway122kk 6y agoI would have agreed with you up to few years ago, but now Dublin has a vibrant jobs market in tech with salaries that are equal to higher than London with a less crazy (tho still crazy) cost of living. Like I said the fall of pound has been spectacular in last 4-5 years. * Engineer Dublin 2015 - €100K ~£70K * Engineer Dublin 2020 - €125K ~£112K (5K eur increases per year) * Engineer London 2015 - £70K ~€100K * Engineer London 2020 - £95K ~€105K (5K gbp increases per year) Both engineers start at same pay 5 years ago, both of them think they are moving up in the world with reasonable pay increases per year. One of them is being screwed by falling value of pound against just about every major currency due to Brexit and all the uncertainty.
- OJFord 6y agoIt's only 'being screwed' (or just an unfortunate decision on your part) if your participation in Euro economy is weighted high enough vs. the local economy. i.e. the same increase looks better if you live in London than if you work remotely from Dublin. But.. I don't think it's surprising that London salaries aren't optimised for remote workers in Dublin? (This may well change of course! Will be interesting to see what happens if remote work gets significantly more widespread.)
- trekrich 6y agoyou cannot be half in, or half out. They wont let us pick and choose. I voted leave, so we are all the way out. Or we are all the way in.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoThere are plenty of options that are half in/half out. Any of them would be more appropriate than what we are heading towards given how close the vote was.
- LatteLazy 6y agoNone of the half & half options are as good as membership (by design). So Brexiteers won't accept them because they would mean admitting they were wrong. They'll insist on being completely "out", then when we have nothing it will be everyone else's fault for "picking on us" by not letting us have whatever we want. You can't argue with them. They're all suffering a group hallucination...
- Dormeno 6y ago> You can't argue with them. They're all suffering a group hallucination... What's better, the EU or rest of world? When you look at GDP growth, markets, trade... Rest of the world looks a lot better than EU nationalism/protectionism. The choice provided for every half-in option is to give up the rest of the world in that matter, but it turns out, that the EU in seemingly every comparison always comes short compared to the rest of the world.
- LatteLazy 6y agoThis is exactly what I am talking about when I said "you can't argue with them". The EU is how we negotiate with the rest of the world. When we leave, we don't just lose access to the EU, we lose access to 72 other countries with EU trade deals. And that's without actually examining the Brexiteer position: If we can't accept EU membership rules in exchange for EU market access, why would we be able to accept any other trade-for-sovereignty deal? Everyone else wants more sovereignty for less trade. The Brexiteer position is crazy and doesn't match reality. More reality won't persuade them. All they have is weird slogans like "What's better, the EU or rest of world?" and when you explain why it's nonsense, they stick to it because it sounds good and who needs inconvenient truths? EU trade deals: https://fullfact.org/election-2019/ask-fullfact-trade-deals/ https://fullfact.org/election-2019/ask-fullfact-trade-deals/
- Traster 6y agoI would love to understand from anyone, what it is about the European patent system that we're unhappy with and leaving, and what we're doing to overcome the chilling effect on innovation in the UK.
- econcon 6y agoUK is a rich country. They can get higher productivity by simply hiring laborers from Europe and not giving them same standards of work and life which EU demands from member states. That's enough for UK manufacturing to bounce back again.